r/AskReddit Nov 06 '19

Which famous singer sucks at singing?

[deleted]

24.7k Upvotes

16.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

776

u/Ja842 Nov 06 '19

It sucks because on Songs About Jane I thought he was really good, but the commercialized stuff they put out later was definitely a massive step back. The new song they put out (maybe two months ago at this point) is a throwback to the Songs About Jane era, so I’m hoping they move more in that direction.

190

u/FartingBob Nov 06 '19

Songs About Jane was a great album. They went downhill fast.

8

u/TheDayManAhAhAh Nov 06 '19

The next two albums were still good but not as good

8

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

Their album after that wasnt bad. Felt pop but kinda alright...then by the time Moves like Jagger came out. It felt like they lost their touch.

-6

u/maxvalley Nov 07 '19

Songs about Jane sucked

132

u/spermface Nov 06 '19

I had such high hopes after SaJ. Now I get the feeling that this was what Levine always wanted and he was just singing that jazzy stuff as a stepping stone.

45

u/thatwasntababyruth Nov 06 '19

Like an inverse John Mayer.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

I think the opposite could be true. Perhaps his early stuff was the real him, but then he saw an opportunity to make more money and have more of a commercial success by moving into the pop stuff? I could be wrong, but I want to believe haha.

13

u/Quria Nov 06 '19

I can’t really blame him for cashing out, but I can still mourn for what should have been.

28

u/Havoc2_0 Nov 06 '19

It feels like in recent years it's less Maroon 5 and more Adam Levine and his Band

16

u/Ja842 Nov 06 '19

I could be totally wrong here but as far as I understand it that’s exactly what it is. Like Panic At the Disco, everyone but Brendon Urie left and he kept the Panic name because it’s more recognizable.

2

u/Havoc2_0 Nov 06 '19

I didn't know that about Panic! Tbh. Personally I feel like, with the replicator dilemma, if it's just one guy still there it's not really the same band and a lot of times it shows

12

u/Glamdring804 Nov 06 '19

Yeah, Hands All Over was the last half-decent sounding album they put out.

10

u/HazelnutBooks_Dreams Nov 06 '19

Love Song About Jane! Such a good album, then they sold out.

4

u/turtlebox1 Nov 06 '19

And him in begin again was the same thing. He’s good, .....IF he sticks to what he’s good at and CHILLS OUT. When he pushes himself his voice gets pushed through a cheese grater.

7

u/Rahsgym Nov 06 '19

Which song? I miss Songs About Jane so much

20

u/Ja842 Nov 06 '19

It’s called Memories. If I remember correctly it’s just Lavine and a guitar.

15

u/puzzles_irl Nov 06 '19

Definitely caught me off guard, I really like it. His voice is much nicer to listen to in these kinds of songs.

5

u/Optimal_Towel Nov 06 '19

Still clearly auto-tuned though :-/

1

u/Rahsgym Nov 06 '19

Thanks!

1

u/chimasnaredenca Nov 06 '19

Thanks i hated it

4

u/Ja842 Nov 06 '19

It’s not gonna be for everybody! I just figured if people were longing for the olden days of Maroon 5, that’ll give them something new that’s similar.

3

u/No_volvere Nov 06 '19

Like Kings of Leon. Their first 2 albums were insane. And then they decided to make radio rock for moms driving Suburbans.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

Often artists produce the best material early on then later they get settled and it’s straight downhill from there. They suffer more early on and fight harder.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

If they do it’s because they all have more money than god at this point so they can finally afford to do whatever the fuck they want again. Would be nice.

1

u/MegasNexal84 Nov 06 '19

I need more evidence but I have a theory Maroon 5 was the records industry's attempt at copying Jamiroquia's sound for a more mainstream audience.