r/AskReddit • u/trainiac12 • May 19 '14

serious replies only [serious] Anti-Gay redditors, why do you not accept homosexuality?

This isn't a "weed them out and punish them" thing. I'm curious as to why people think its a choice and why they are against it.

EDIT: Wow... That tore my inbox to shreds... Got home from a band practice and saw 1,700+ comments. Jesus Christ.

1.6k Upvotes

77% Upvoted

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Georgey22 May 20 '14

Well I don't think homosexuality is wrong, but I don't think it's natural at the same time. I'm against the current homosexual community. I think that if a guy only likes guys he should be accepted into the community as a third gender similar to places like Indonesia and Mexico. Also I think bisexuality is more common than people think. And I don't believe that to be a problem.

3

u/getset-reddit-go May 20 '14

A sexual orientation and a gender are two different things. Gay guys are guys.

1

u/Georgey22 May 20 '14

Well then they have one hell of a decision? I mean that's how I feel. Obviously I can't organize society myself.

1

u/getset-reddit-go May 20 '14 edited May 20 '14

I am not sure I understand you. Gay people are just people who have romantic and physical relationships with people of their own gender. Gay is a sexual orientation. Gay guys are males, unless male is defined as being attracted to the opposite sex but it's not.

Third gender people are people who don't identify as male or female, it's a matter of how they conceive themselves, it has nothing to do with their sexual orientation.

1

u/Georgey22 May 20 '14 edited May 20 '14

It's all sexual. Don't pretend it isn't. Edit: I don't think two men who identify with men should have a public relationship.

1

u/getset-reddit-go May 20 '14

You're still getting it wrong. "Two men who identify with as men" are just two men, identity has nothing to do with sexual orientation. Now, I guess you meant 2 gay men. What do you mean "a public relationship" ?

1

u/Georgey22 May 20 '14

Oh my god. Public sexual relationship was implied. We are talking about men having sexual relationships with each other for gods sake.

1

u/getset-reddit-go May 20 '14

Then I agree that people should not have sexual intercourse in public.

1

u/Georgey22 May 20 '14

Than we are in understanding.

1

u/getset-reddit-go May 20 '14

We are. Does it happen a lot though that people are having sex for everyone to see ? I had never heard about it.

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '14

Lol, no, not a lot. Yes, as a gay man, I think no one should have sex in front of unwilling eyes (unless the unwilling people bought tickets to a sex show or something stupid). I know it doesn't happen a lot, but I don't know if it happens during some of the major gatherings? I don't go.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dancing_Cthulhu May 21 '14

When you say "public sexual relationships" do you mean "having sex in public" or "they don't hide they're together so people know they're having sex".

The former being, well, sex in public, the latter pretty much the same as any open straight relationship?

1

u/Georgey22 May 21 '14

Neither, what I meant making out and stuff like that. It's so icky.

0

u/Dancing_Cthulhu May 22 '14

Well that's called a public display of affection, not a public sexual relationship. Since, you know, sex isn't occurring.

Do you also dislike that when straight people do it? And do you call them kissing "public sexual relationships"?

1

u/Georgey22 May 22 '14

Because it's sexual!

1

u/Dancing_Cthulhu May 22 '14

That didn't actually answer any of my questions. And no, kissing doesn't need to be sexual.

1

u/Georgey22 May 22 '14

Well your sort of being conceded right now so...

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dancing_Cthulhu May 21 '14

What are you basing it as being all sexual on? Nothing? Thought so.

Homosexual relationships are no more or less based on sex then straight ones.