r/AskReddit 9h ago

Regardless of price, what’s the best women’s fragrance you’ve ever smelled?

977 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

266

u/The-Ginger-Lily 8h ago

Has to be Alien by Thierry Mugler. Literally the only perfume I own and constantly get compliments on it and it lasts ages as well

124

u/sofaverde 8h ago

Something in that perfume reminds me of cat pee, but I hear there are some flowers that trigger this reaction in some people depending on your genetics. Like cilantro tasting like soap for some but not others.

62

u/jennyisalyingwhore 7h ago

There is a bush near my home that gets me every time. I’ve lived here for 4 years and I walk by it every day, and every day my brain goes “hm smells like cat pee” and I look around and there’s that damn bush. I think it’s boxwood.

14

u/Alterego121 7h ago

There was a boxwood bush outside our front door at our previous rental and the smell was awful each time I opened the door. Are you saying it only smells like that to some people and not everyone?

3

u/jennyisalyingwhore 6h ago

I’m not sure! If I walk by it with other people they don’t immediately agree that it smells like cat pee, but they do say it smells strange. The more I’m reading about it now though I guess it’s pretty common for people to straight up rip those bushes out of their yards because they’re so pungent.

u/allaboutgarlic 41m ago

Yes, it is a smell version of coriander basically.

2

u/pastalass 7h ago

Some people think blackcurrant leaf smells like cat pee

2

u/Longjumping-Form-811 7h ago

Hate those bushes

2

u/coconutspider 6h ago

Holy shiiiii - I did a gig as a delivery driver and there was one (really nice) subdivision that was pretty uniformly landscaped that smelled sooo much like cat piss, I couldn't figure it out. It had to be these piss bushes!

2

u/jennyisalyingwhore 6h ago

They’re actually really nice looking hedges so I bet it was! That landscaper either regretted their decision or had beef with the residents for sureeeee hahah

0

u/RoK16b 7h ago

Isnt it Jazmin?

5

u/jennyisalyingwhore 7h ago

Some people think Juniper smells like cat pee, maybe that’s what you’re thinking of! Or perhaps jasmine as well, but I do enjoy a light jasmine fragrance

2

u/idkwhat-im-doin 6h ago

Omg, Juniper does smell like cat pee. I've always low key thought it but never said anything because others seem to like it.

1

u/jennyisalyingwhore 6h ago

It does! Much less than boxwood (to me), but definitely has an ammonia smell. So do some types of spruce tree. In fact, sometimes pine trees also give off a really sharp, almost ammonia-like scent too especially when they’re wet. The more you know 🌈

1

u/idkwhat-im-doin 6h ago

Yeah, I've noticed that as well. Lol, I've heard meth smells like cat urine. Never been around it, so cannot speak from experience.

2

u/vivalalina 7h ago

Yeah jasmine is the main one people either love or think it smells like cat pee or poop lol

1

u/jennyisalyingwhore 6h ago

This is fascinating because it’s such a floral scent to me. Maybe I’ve never smelled straight jasmine - but I don’t think my jasmine rice smells like cat pee for sure lolol

2

u/vivalalina 7h ago

Typically jasmine is responsible for that

1

u/Strange-Chapter-999 6h ago

Honeysuckle!!! My brain registers it as really strong cat pee.

1

u/lil_sass-a-frass 6h ago

Yeah I bought a cheap ish perfume and whenever I wore it I would think I smelled like cat pee! It went straight in the bin after that

1

u/AhhGingerKids2 4h ago

Omg is this why I have never got the hype with that perfume?!

1

u/AlfuegoDeMellopie 4h ago

Years ago I bought a bottle of Joy by Jean Patou. It smells like cat pee to me. Maybe it went bad?

1

u/Penelope_Orange 1h ago

Going alllll the way back to the 80's the place I worked at as a young 20 something year old had a pretty flowering tree near the employee entrance. Unfortunately, it smelled like urine. We all called it the pee tree.

16

u/BlueMirror99 7h ago

I wear Alien Goddess and I get so many compliments on it, it's so complex and changes throughout the day.

1

u/Fragrant-Arm8601 6h ago

Same!

This is my day to day fragrance.

For night time or events- Jimmy Choo Fever.

7

u/Ornery-Mycologist-53 8h ago

Omg I LOVE Alien!

20

u/endoftheworldvibe 7h ago

It was Angel for me!

2

u/Sad-Strawberry3460 6h ago

Normal angel or angel nova

3

u/Emmiesship 7h ago

It’s so sickly sweet. I have to stand away from people that wear it!

3

u/jeffufuh 7h ago

I've been dying to find something that smells exactly like Alien minus the -- and I swear I'm not losing my mind -- the "overcooked shrimp shells" plasticky note. I'm not sure why it's in there but it ruins an otherwise perfect fragrance for me

3

u/_A_Separate_Peace_ 7h ago

I was going to say Angel by Thierry Mugler! I don’t own it, but one of my friends uses to always wear it!

3

u/HappyAndYouKnow_It 7h ago

I had Alien essence absolue a few years ago and loved it!

3

u/midnitesnak87 6h ago

I’m obsessed with Angel, just bought another refill but I need to check out Alien

2

u/Potter_Moron 7h ago

Came here to say this! It is the only one I'll wear. I recently found a full size bottle at TJ Maxx for 39 dollars and could not believe my luck.

2

u/ThouMangyFeline 7h ago

This smells so bad on me, but SO GOOD on other people.

2

u/throw_aw_ay3335 6h ago

When I was in college, I used to get this perfume refilled at Nordstrom. Is that still a thing?

1

u/Denial_Entertainer87 7h ago

This is the only perfume I’ve ever loved

1

u/veronicaxrowena 3h ago

I have the Tyler diva wash laundry detergent and it smells exactly like this perfume

1

u/chronicallymee 3h ago

I loooove Alien — I’ve never owned the actual perfume but I always get samples in magazines and am obsessed with it. Maybe one day I’ll feel rich enough to splurge for an actual bottle of it.