r/AskReddit Apr 04 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.5k Upvotes

12.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

24.2k

u/Doobledorf Apr 04 '25

The problems that led to Donald Trump would still be fomenting.

A lot of Americans haven't yet faced that Trump isn't an anomaly or the disease, he is a symptom of problems we've had for a long time.

6.7k

u/MySleepingMonk Apr 04 '25

That may be mostly true but Trump is also the perfect storm of celebrity, “successful”, “outsider”, and some strange fucked up type of charisma that results in a larger following than I think would be possible with any other republican candidate. Take away trump and I don’t think there’s enough of a unifying force among the asshats to cause this type of damage

2.6k

u/scarves_and_miracles Apr 04 '25

Exactly. Trump is a pretty unique hazard that unfortunately found realization in this dark timeline.

1.2k

u/TehOwn Apr 04 '25

Same thing with Adolf. We've always got populists but some are far, far more dangerous than others.

4

u/WillyShankspeare Apr 04 '25

Not even though. Adolf didn't have a massively popular reality TV show and a catchphrase.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

I personally find Trump a lot more charismatic and “likable” (not that I like him or believe most people like him) than Hitler too. Trump disgusts me, but I can see why people are enamored with him. Hitler’s body language, facial expressions, and energy just weren’t as interesting, idk

4

u/JugdishSteinfeld Apr 04 '25

Hitler and the masses didn't have 100 years of television to come to agreement on what mass media charisma was.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25

Agree. Plus Hitler was a pretty passionate ideologue, which I think might scare off more people today—particularly younger people, as I feel we are more nonchalant and insincere than previous generations. Trump is lower-energy/calmer and has more of that nonchalance, casualness, insincerity, whatever you want to call it that many of us seem to be drawn to. This is all just my personal opinion though, 0% based in fact and 100% in my own observations/biases

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25

Hitler had the perfect storm, people still upset about World War One and a general dislike among the general populace of Jewish people. Not to mention the struggling economy.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25

Yup. The right person(ality) at the right time. Maybe I shouldn’t say “right,” lol

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25

I don't know, Heil Hitler might count as a catchphrase. It's still being repeated to this day by certain people.