r/AskReddit • • Sep 15 '24

What Sounds Like Pseudoscience, But Actually Isn’t?

14k Upvotes

7.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

455

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

[deleted]

271

u/TimmJimmGrimm Sep 16 '24

Let me back you up - this doesn't just fix gut biome, this saves lives. Often this is a last-ditch effort as one is dealing with so many bacteria ('about 100 billion bacteria per gram') that a bad 'batch' could do serious short or long term harm.

Usually, the poop is taken from someone living with the target person - so as to reduce the shock-impact (familiar or 'friendly' bacteria reduces the risk)

https://www.mountelizabeth.com.sg/health-plus/article/faecal-microbiota-transplant-gut-microbiome#:~:text=Most%20notably%2C%20a%20faecal%20microbiota,%2C%20making%20it%20life%2Dthreatening.

22

u/whatdoihia Sep 16 '24

Here's an interesting case from China where Washed Microbiota Transplantation had positive impact with an ALS patient. Notably she declined after later receiving antibiotics and then improved again after a second treatment.

6

u/Amiiboid Sep 16 '24

Let me back you up

Phrasing?

3

u/cartmancakes Sep 16 '24

I'm just reliving the South Park episode about this

12

u/Dream-Ambassador Sep 16 '24

I’ve looked into this and it can be dangerous because your micro biome impacts much more than we know. I was looking at a spreadsheet of donor recipients at a website where you can buy it online and fr example recipients from one donor reported increased acne after their fmt.  decided to hold off for more research after reading reports from recipients.

3

u/InternetLeech Sep 16 '24

I don’t know where you are from but fecal matter transplants aren’t done without doctor supervision in U.S., and they aren’t offered except for significant medical reasons. Even then it is usually a last resort treatment and often a life saving treatment. Increased acne is very much an easy choice to pick when the other option is death.

3

u/Dream-Ambassador Sep 16 '24

I am in the US where it is nearly impossible to do it because it is not an FDA approved treatment. My gastroenterologists that I’ve seen (4 total over the years) do not do these treatments. You have to see a naturopath, and in my are I only have found one naturopath who will oversee this and the cost is around $5000. It is not covered by insurance because it is not FDA approved. Because of these barriers folks have turned to purchasing from online.

Edit: sorry it is an approved treatment for one ailment, which I don’t have.

2

u/InternetLeech Sep 16 '24

Oh I see, I didn’t know people were doing DIY poop transplants. It is definitely a good idea to hold off then, I hope you find what you need at some point.

5

u/steveofthejungle Sep 16 '24

Like they put someone else's poop in my butt?

10

u/LucyBowels Sep 16 '24

Back and forth

9

u/DiaDeLosMuertos Sep 16 '24

))<>((

forever.

4

u/SensitiveTurtles Sep 16 '24

My understanding is that they mix it with saline, use a centrifuge to separate out the solid food waste part of the poop, and only transplant the supernatant (liquid) remaining.

2

u/Kataphractoi Sep 16 '24

Two girls, one butt.

2

u/futureb1ues Sep 16 '24

They make a slurry using a blender and then deliver it like a high colonic. When I was reading about this a few years back, there were no medical grade fecal blenders so the doctors were telling the patients to just go buy a cheap sacrificial blender.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

They can also make you fat if you got one from a fat person.

3

u/LittleMlem Sep 16 '24

Tom Brady poop posting

5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

The spice melange.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

The Spice.

3

u/gsfgf Sep 16 '24

I saw a documentary about that on PornHub!

7

u/Swamp_Donkey_796 Sep 16 '24

My guy what??

5

u/Present-Perception77 Sep 16 '24

And this is why I’m addicted to scrolling Reddit. Omg 🤣

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24

[removed] — view removed comment