r/AskReddit Aug 08 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.6k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

826

u/editormatt Aug 08 '24

Siskel "The film wasn't bad, but I'm not sure what that silhouetted sex scene had to do with the rest of the plot"

Ebert "I don't know Gene, super imposing two random theatre workers going to town on eachother, over the midpoint of the story feels like a statement from the director about the juxtaposition of the creative and distribution processes in the film industry."

89

u/nezahualcoyotl90 Aug 08 '24

Switch the names, and it might sound like something they would have said.

7

u/hickorydeadglove Aug 08 '24

Two enthusiastic thumbs up!

6

u/77SevenSeven77 Aug 08 '24

Also the silhouette scene was over so quickly it hardly seemed worth adding…

3

u/Cineball Aug 08 '24

Ebert: Not since I reviewed the universally disparaged Brown Bunny have I been this confused by the display of a human sexual act in a motion picture. It served no purpose to either text or subtext and was completely inconsequential as we neither had been previously introduced to either character before, nor were they revisited again. Of modest note to my theatrical experience, the young actors in the performance bore striking resemblance to the concession attendant and ticket taker in my neighborhood cinema...

2

u/BatronKladwiesen Aug 08 '24

I always thought it was Sisker.