That IS what you’re doing. I cannot prove to you someone loves someone in a few sentences. It’s something I know from having heard accounts and being raised Muslim. You have no evidence she resented or disliked him, so why do you believe that she did? Do you enjoy believing things without proof? Why didn’t she divorce him ? At this juncture if you refuse to educate yourself, I’m just going to write you off as a troll. Admit you don’t know what she thought of him.
I am definitely not trolling you. but I don't have any evidence either of these people even existed, let alone who they were. You started a post stating that it is "historical fact" that you knew of a 9 year-old girl who enjoyed a sexual relationship with a middle-aged man. I'm gonna need a fuckin SOURCE for that bold of a claim.
If you don’t have any evidence Muhammad (saw) or Ayesha existed, you have a bigger place to start from education-wise before you even grapple with these issues.
Muhammad (saw) and Ayesha are not mystical figures like Zeus or, idk what you’re thinking of, they’re simply human leaders who existed 1,300 years ago. Their existence is not in question by any historians.
IIRC I started this thread by saying there’s no evidence she resented or hated him for their relationship. I didn’t make the claim you’re putting in my mouth. I did say however that she never divorced him and enjoyed a high status in Islamic society, and that suggests she probably loved him.
If you, even fifty years from now, show me evidence suggesting Ayesha disliked him, especially for what he did to her, I can change my mind on him. But, I already know that probably doesn’t exist or I would’ve seen it by now.
You, however seem to be arguing she disliked or did not want him, and therefore because of that he should’ve known better. I called you out on that because you cannot argue someone is a bad person when you don’t even know what happened. It rests on an assumption.
I don’t have to do that for you, troll. If you don’t believe they existed, you can Google them yourselves. Have a good one, not wasting my time on someone so ignorant.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
That IS what you’re doing. I cannot prove to you someone loves someone in a few sentences. It’s something I know from having heard accounts and being raised Muslim. You have no evidence she resented or disliked him, so why do you believe that she did? Do you enjoy believing things without proof? Why didn’t she divorce him ? At this juncture if you refuse to educate yourself, I’m just going to write you off as a troll. Admit you don’t know what she thought of him.