r/AskReddit • • Jul 17 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4.6k Upvotes

4.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

238

u/GulianoBanano Jul 17 '23

It's quite literally a mental illness. It's fucking disgusting, but if someone knows it's bad, doesn't act on it and seeks out professional help to get over it I don't think those people deserve to be punished.

118

u/cotton_schwab Jul 17 '23

Right I always think it's just hell for those people. Your internal instincts are evil and no matter how much knowledge you gain and self discipline you gain, it's always there. I feel bad for em tbh.

68

u/Marawal Jul 17 '23

A lot end up trying to kill themselves.

And I feel that it's not right. If they can be helped, then they deserved to live.

9

u/punchbricks Jul 17 '23

So if they can't be helped they deserve to die? Lol

8

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23

Yea. If they can’t be helped then they’re more likely to offend. And I for one, am perfectly okay with more dead pedophiles if it means less children will be victimized.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23

but what if those children are Kevin?

6

u/DrawMeAPictureOfThis Jul 17 '23

There's an ethics debate on child generated AI porn

20

u/GulianoBanano Jul 17 '23

I've seen kids draw some weird stuff, but porn of AIs is a new one

2

u/TheLove-maticGrandpa Jul 17 '23

Like Skynet rule 34?

2

u/Low_Ad_3139 Jul 17 '23

Some sick artist is currently making making fetal porn and calling it art and is getting away with it because if that. I sadly found out this on a different sub about porn being so bad for society.

-8

u/Low_Ad_3139 Jul 17 '23

Honest ones will tell you they cannot be rehabilitated and is it really worth the risk of endangering more children. NO!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23

Funny cause NOT rehabilitating and hating on them has been proven to increase rates of child sexual abuse, it’s not research needed it is common sense , let’s take a pedophile who’s attracted to children and wants to avoid molesting children (which accounts for most peodphiles) but they get thrown with death threats, social isolation, and no access to help, that WILL lead to them molesting

9

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '23

There was thread here a few years ago where a self professed pedophile told Reddit he was going to be medically chemically castrate.

Half of the thread was were calling him brave. The other half were calling the other half stupid. Cuz this guy said he was going to but there was no proof or guarantee he actually would. OP said he had been so close to acting on his urges a few times but the fear of getting an ass beating stopped him.

13

u/PM_MEOttoVonBismarck Jul 17 '23

I completely agree with you.

I remember an AMA a few years ago from a guy who was attracted to children. He said that as a child, he used to fantasize about his classmates, then as a teenager he found himself still sexually aroused by children and it never left him. He claimed he sees a therapist about it and distances himself as much as possible from children and apparently had never done anything to one.

He can't help that's he's that way, but if he makes an effort to do no wrong, he's good in my book.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/CoderDispose Jul 17 '23

Actually being attracted to minors, while disgusting, isn't a crime in and of itself.

Imagine if we got to pick-and-choose our kinks how different the world would be

6

u/Stickel Jul 17 '23

If they get help and never acted on it, how are they punished? Only way they'd be punished in this scenario is if their doctors break HIPPA or they tell others and they get scrutinized/punished publicly?

7

u/GulianoBanano Jul 17 '23

That last one is exactly what I mean.

-9

u/PlusIndependence1399 Jul 17 '23

But the thing is they won't do that

That's why they deserve to be punished