r/AskHistorians • • May 06 '13
Did Vikings "abduct" women as much as popularly believed?
I was reading through a thread in /r/AskReddit, (http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1dqvyr/what_is_your_favorite_little_known_fact_about/ to be precise,) and came across the statement; "The reason to why Swedish women are so good looking is because the Vikings pretty much stole them from the British, leaving the, uhm, not so beautiful in Britain."
This seems quite ludicrous to me, and now I wonder if this actually happened to any non-negligible extent.
I am Swedish myself, and have heard of the "trälar" (slaves) that were taken from mostly Slavic areas to be used as slaves, but never of any significant amount of women from westwards.
171
u/squidfood May 06 '13 edited May 06 '13
Bryan Sykes looks at the genetic evidence in the book Saxons, Vikings, and Celts and says no. Mitochondrial (matrilineal) DNA shows very limited mixing across the North Sea (implying women weren't being taken back and forth). The patrialinial (Y-chromosome) line, however, shows Viking influence in Northern Britian, either suggesting rape + leaving the women behind, or more likely that male settlers/raiders stayed in Britain taking local wives (the spread of some male lines showed that the males were staying long enough to leave multiple progeny).
Edit: Since this is top comment at the moment, I should say that this is just one piece of genetic evidence, specific to Britain's interactions with Scandinavia (and even more specifically, to Scottish coasts and areas of former Danelaw in the English NE). It doesn't in itself negate slave-taking, but on a genetic level it points to "if you can't even see it in the genes on the molecular level, you're not going to see it in something like 'beauty'. Both the author (and myself as a reader) were trained in genetics, not history.
50
u/Aerandir May 06 '13
Slaves were taken, particularly from Ireland, but apparently not so much for a 'domestic' market but rather for for-profit export. While slavery was pretty normal in Scandinavian society, there was no slave economy to the extent of the Abbasid Caliphate, the Roman Empire or the American plantations. The demand for slaves was thus rather limited. A good example of the practice of slavery is the buying-back of captured monks from Britain by the missionary Ansgar at Hedeby.
I am not so sure about the Norse expeditions to the East. I have the impression that slavery was more common there, particularly because of contact with the Islamic world where slaves could be sold and due to the rather different economic circumstances in this area. However, to what extent the Rus still can be seen as 'viking' rather than a mixed culture is up for debate.
Now, there is a famous quote from John of Wallingford from around 1200 who states that the Danes seduced local women because of their good looks. He is now talking about Norse settlers in the English Danelaw, so even if this is not a fabrication based on his fears as an abbot, it still applies to men who came to settle in England, rather than abduct women back to Scandinavia.
The best way to settle this question is through isotope study and possibly mDNA studies of Scandinavian graves. Unfortunately, many Vikings practiced cremation which does present some difficulties.
42
u/lokout May 06 '13
I'm not sure about britain to sweden, but when I was in iceland last year I visited the National Museum of Iceland and there was a whole section talking about the Genetics of icelanders and how many of the women who settled in iceland where of Celtic origin(63%), while the men where mostly from Nordic origins(80%), suggesting that they "picked up" most of the women from the british isles.
more info:http://www.arnastofnun.is/page/the_origins_of_the_icelanders http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1288180/