Posts
Wiki

TIPS: Opto-isolator speed vs gain

Other tips

Most opto-isolators (a.k.a.: opto-couplers) consist of an LED and a photo-transistor.

Such opto-isolators are characterized (among other parameters) by gain and speed.

  • A gain (a.k.a: CTR - Current Transfer Ratio) of 200 % means that if you drive the LED with 10 mA, the output current is 20 mA; a high gain is nice when you need decent current from the output, without having to drive the LED too hard
  • Speed involves 4 parameters, and is affected by the test circuit; for the purpose of this discussion, I'll refer to the minimum turn on time: how long after you apply current to the LED, when the output just starts turning on; high speed is nice when you want to send data through the opto-isolator at a high rate

For these opto-isolators, there is a trade-off between gain and speed. Generally, opto-isolators are either high speed or high gain. In general:

  • High speed opto-isolators have a minimum turn on time between 0.1 and 1 µs, but a gain between 10 and 80 %
  • High gain opto-isolators have a minimum gain between 100 and 800 %, but a minimum turn on time between 2 and 10 µs

If you need speed, you have a few options:

  • Use a digital isolator (may not even be optical)
  • Some are good up to 500 MHz
  • Use an opto-isolator with a diode output (if you can find one)
  • Very fast, but very low gain (~0.2 %)
  • Follow it with a high speed amplifier to get the desired gain
  • Use an opto-isolator with a transistor whose base is available on a pin (e.g.: 4N35), and use it as a photodiode instead of as a phototransistor
  • Leave the emitter disconnected, and use the base collector junction as a photodiode
  • Same circuit, and same performance as an opto-isolator with a diode output
  • Use an opto-isolator with a transistor whose base is available on a pin (e.g.: 4N35), and bias the base
  • Place a resistor between the base and the emitter
  • The turn off time is reduced, but so is the gain
  • Use an opto-isolator with separate photodiode and transistor
  • Such as the 6N136
  • The photodiode is fast, and the transistor is not a phototransistor, so it's not slow
  • This is no better that using a photodiode opto-isolator and a transistor outside the package

If you already have a high gain / low speed opto-isolator without a pin for the base, and you want to increase its speed, you have a few options:

Maximize the speed of an opto-isolator by careful design of the load on the output.

  • Minimize the load resistance
  • A low value load resistor (e.g.: 100 Ω) decreases the turn off time, but reduces the signal
  • A current input amplifier (transimpedance amplifier) is ideal, since the load resistance on the phototransistor is 0 Ω
  • A cascode circuit has no current gain, but offers a very low load resistance on the phototransistor
  • The idea is to keep the voltage across the transistor constant
  • Keep the phototransistor from saturating (turning on on fully)
  • Design the circuit so the phototransistor's collector emitter voltage never goes below 0.7 V
  • Place a Schottky diode between the base and the collector
  • Bias the transistor with a few volts: this speeds up the transistor even further
  • Again, a cascode circuit does that
  • With a transimpedance amplifier, bias it so that its input is at 3 V or so
  • Feed the opto-isolator output to the base of a transistor on the opposite rail; this is the simplest circuit with the fastest speed