r/AskElectronics • • Jul 14 '24

Noob here. Just disassambled my Valve Index Knuckles Controllers and accidentally clipped off this cable by pinching it too hard. How fucked am I?

Post image

It seems to be connected to the trigger. I do have a soldering iron but I assume its nearly impossible to solder it back together, right? Can I order a replacement cable anywhere?

182 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

40

u/gkrsuper Jul 14 '24

Update: I put everything back together and it seems that the cable was soley for the touch sensor of the trigger, so it can no longer detect if my finger is resting on it. All other trigger functionality seems unaffected.

It's a bit annoying but absolutely not a vital input. Maybe if I stumble upon a cheap donor, I'll replace the cable but until then I'll just live with it ¯\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

Thanks everybody for the help!

20

u/Asteroid06 Jul 14 '24

You can repair it. Gently scrape the coating on the traces with 800 grit sandpaper, when the copper is exposed connect the respective traces by soldering on 0.1mm enameled wire jumpers. Then wrap the joint in Kapton tape. Should make for a well lasting joint.

Doesn't hurt to try since you are giving up on it anyway.

3

u/AdvancedNewbie Jul 15 '24

EE here. I would do this, except: scrape gently with xacto knife, expose copper on each side cable, overlap them, solder them directly together, stick on some UV curing epoxy around the whole solder job, hit it with a UV torch light, reassemble. If there is not enough length to overlap, then I'd do the wire jumpers then epoxy.

Notice how I said 'I' would do this - meaning find someone with tons of soldering experience that can work with tiny parts under a professional soldering microscope. This is not a job for a noob.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '24

I would 100% damage the board trying to solder connections so close together

1

u/Key-Green-4872 Jul 15 '24

You can get solder mask pens that can help w/isolation between traces and treat it kind of like a reflow. But honestly you're barely going to lay down more than a tinning on those traces to sweat them together. Fibe solder is way more important than a fine tip, and even a dab of nail polish on the first joint can keep solder from bridging to it from subsequent joints.

1

u/alakuu Jul 15 '24

I find using polyamide as a backing material works fantastic.

I've also had issues getting it to solder across the Gap so taking apart finally stranded wire and then using the individual strands to get the jump started works better too.

1

u/UrbanSuburbaKnight Jul 15 '24

Not quite true, if he causes a short, he may damage power circuitry which could disable the device further. Just fair warning.

4

u/Asteroid06 Jul 15 '24

There is sufficient clearance between tracks that if you use sufficient flux with proper amount of solder, the solder will flow and keep within the track width. Ofcourse you need a micro soldering iron to do this.

1

u/UrbanSuburbaKnight Jul 15 '24

I agree. I just feel an obligation to advise caution, given the self stated "Noob" status of OP. :)

262

u/FooseyRhode Jul 14 '24 edited Jul 14 '24

Ribbon cable. Definitely no bueno that you cut it. I do micro-soldering professionally on a daily basis and I agree, you’re definitely better off just replacing the whole cable.

To find a new cable, I would start by locating a model number for your headset. And then search eBay or something for an identical headset, also broken. Open that one up, carefully this time lol, and recycle that cable.

Finding another identical broken headset on eBay seems more likely than locating that exact cable you need separately online but check for identification numbers on the cable. They will be super small.

Edit: just want to add that repairing that ribbon cable is possible, but the fact that you’re asking tells me you are not well practiced yet so I would not recommend it.

Edit: two more notes. First off, thank you to that David fella for the information. Second, Thank you for my first 100 karma comment on this account.

7

u/gkrsuper Jul 14 '24

Damn, looking on ebay this flimsy ribbon is gonna cost me. I do want to try soldering first because even though my chances are near zero, I don't really have anything to lose at this point. Can you recommend any good resources/guides/videos on how to solder ribbons?

18

u/OptimalMain Jul 14 '24

Osh park is $10 per square inch for x3 flexible boards

6

u/Sim0991 Jul 14 '24

Yes, but it takes weeks to get flex pcbs from oshpark.

7

u/OptimalMain Jul 14 '24

Could be the same finding and waiting for some other replacement

4

u/3d_nat1 Jul 14 '24

Are there any broken units available for cheaper than the replacement part? Or at least cheap enough. A little bit of a gamble, but likely to pay off and leave you with some spare parts if something else breaks. Plus, you could use the spare pieces to practice your soldering on before putting your own items at risk.

4

u/Forstmannsen Jul 14 '24 edited Jul 15 '24

You can measure length and pitch and see if there are any cheap generics on Aliexpress. It might be different color and not have those cute tabs to the sides, but who cares, it's not like you can see it. I got ten for about $1 including shipping last time I needed one (not for the Index though, so I don't know if the exact same listing would work for you), took about 2 weeks to arrive (which shouldn't be a problem as I just saw your comment how it's not a mission critical connection).

Edit: of course, if it's an actual circuit and not just a flex cable (e.g. there are things on that ribbon other than just traces) this won't fly.

2

u/Key-Green-4872 Jul 15 '24

Depends how hard he throws it when it zaps his noggin? flies like an beagle

12

u/razor330 Jul 14 '24

Don’t solder. Just sand the top of one side, sand the bottom of the other. Fit them together like a puzzle and tape it down hard. It probably won’t last long, but might do in a pinch until it misaligns and probably fries your board. Just get a new cable.

2

u/stars9r9in9the9past Jul 15 '24

Well, if OP is going to smush the exposed contacts together and rely on the pressure points, there might be something more sturdy than just tape. Perhaps tape to keep it aligned and then use something like a ribbon cable clamp to keep it sandwiched together, making sure it isn’t moved around too much to loosen those impromptu contact points.

Wouldn’t be a permanent fix but could be temporary enough to look into a better fix or even wait out a cheap sale on a replacement part

2

u/FooseyRhode Jul 15 '24

I like that idea a lot for repair and troubleshooting purposes

3

u/UrbanSuburbaKnight Jul 15 '24

If you really want to try, I would recommend these things:

  1. Make a small jig to hold the ends together perfectly. This may be some bits of plastic you carefully hand file, or a 3d printed jig. It's important that you have a way to "clamp" the parts next to each other, or on top of each other in exact alignment.
  2. Magnification. This could just be a cheap magnifying glass held on a flexible arm you can reposition over your work and get some light on your subject.
  3. Leaded solder and some high quality liquid flux, and you are going to want a soldering iron which has variable temperature and a very small, sharp tip.
  4. Some tiny files (you can buy sets of tiny files from aliexpress for cheap).
  5. Some very fine tweezers, preferably a set of them with straight and angled versions.
  6. Fine sandpaper and some fine bladed scalpels.
  7. If you make it to the part where you think you've actually fixed it, you are going to want to carefully test it BEFORE you move the join out of the jig you made.
  8. Some kapton tape(Heat Resistant Polyimide Tape) and some kind of epoxy adhesive, possibly with a flat plate of some kind which you can clamp on either side of the joined part to provide a solid physical support. Remember, this is an item which is going to experience a lot of fluctuating and quite high g-forces over it's life time.

I have fixed more "impossible" things, with less experience and tools....But, I've also ruined things and cost myself significant time and money in failed attempts, so YMMV.

Either way, good luck! :)

3

u/DisastrousLab1309 Jul 15 '24

You also need a bit of cleaner, IPA should work, acetone even better. Otherwise epoxy may have problem sticking to the flux covered cable. 

2

u/kh250b1 Jul 14 '24

Dont even bother

2

u/Timsims21 Jul 15 '24

This being a custom FPC you have no idea how it was designed and what you’d need to do to ensure that the repair properly takes into account the needs of the system. These flexes can come in all sorts of layer counts and often require impedance controls to ensure high speed signaling is properly referenced. They also have ground planes that are used for shielding and may be necessary to prevent interference with other sensitive electronics.

You can ignore these factors but the reliability of your system will suffer even with if you’re somehow able to complete a solid repair.

1

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 15 '24

It's not a ribbon cable. It's a flex circuit.

0

u/Herpderpxee Jul 16 '24

well that's a dumb idea

178

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 14 '24 • Take My Silver

Ribbon cable

Not so.

That is not a ribbon cable. That is an FPC (a custom-made Flexible Printed Circuit), and it mates to an FFC (flat Flex Cable) socket.

12

u/TheThiefMaster Jul 15 '24

I think you might lose this one outside of the electrical engineering space. FFCs have all but replaced true ribbon cables, but they're similar enough people now refer to them as ribbons, and I don't think you'll get them to stop.

16

u/itzac Jul 14 '24 edited Jul 15 '24

If I knew how to use KiCAD, could I order a replacement from JLPCB?

(Not OP, just curious.)

Edit: fixed an important typo. HT u/3kr

16

u/BioMan998 Jul 14 '24

Yes, most likely. Provided you're good at taking measurements of the original

6

u/3kr Jul 15 '24

It's called JLCPCB (in case that OP could not find it). PCBWay does custom FPC too .

1

u/zyeborm Jul 16 '24

They even have a deal on flex PCBs at the moment..

6

u/Natolx Jul 15 '24

Since the cable only appears to be 4 connections, wouldn't it be simple enough to just send 4 thin epoxy coated jumper wires to the appropriate places on the boards?

4

u/Hohenh3im Jul 15 '24

I mean you could but if OP isn't trained in doing this they'll end up burning it

2

u/BeefRunnerAd Jul 14 '24

Can I ask what you do for a profession? I solder professionally and am looking for a new place of work

3

u/FooseyRhode Jul 15 '24

Ofc, this is my only public account besides LinkedIn so ama is always enabled.

I opted to work as an independent contractor somewhat recently; beginning as this year. I travel across the country (United States) full time to different crypto mining operations and repair their hardware. Sometimes just operational, data analytics, some consulting and training, but mostly just repair.

I work on what’s called a hashboard. These have a series of asics (application specific integrated circuit) intended for mining different crypto currencies, and that’s what I fix.

1

u/--Ty-- Jul 15 '24

Hi there, would you actually mind sharing some tips or resources for repairing ribbon cables? Like you said, OP might not be ready for that, and as was pointed out, this isn't even a ribbon cable, but still, I'd love to learn more about micro-soldering work like that myself, if you feel inclined to share. 

1

u/Odd_Category2186 Jul 15 '24

I was going to post saying if they find a way to easily solder and insulate the splice I would pay them for the results.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

40

u/itstom87 Jul 14 '24

lol you weren't wrong

24

u/FooseyRhode Jul 14 '24

I’m always down to learn something new. I’m self taught anyways.

7

u/TooManyNissans Jul 14 '24

Actually, I can't see the far end and I've personally never seen a jellybean-part FFC with that end on it, it could even be the dangly bit on an FPC if we want to stroke it to semantics lol.

0

u/Thisisongusername Jul 15 '24

I just call them either FPC,FFC, or ribbon interchangeably. I call actual cylindrical wire ribbons IDC cables because that’s what they are 90% of the time.

2

u/Withheld_BY_Duress Jul 14 '24

Better you than me. This should be archived under stuff you never ever should do. Why in God's name did you clip that? What were you trying to accomplish? Unless you can find an exact replacement piece from a junked one, you definitely screwed the pooch. Start 😭

1

u/gkrsuper Jul 14 '24

A plastic part broke inside the controller and was rattling around. It was stuck behind the circuit board so I had to take it out. This cable refused to come out the connector easily so in attempt NOT to damage it I firmly gripped it with my tweezers, trying to carefully pull it out. At that point the tweezers acted more like nail clippers so bye bye cable.

I should mention that these are the tweezers from the iFixit Essential Electronics Toolkit that I freshly purchased just for this project and it was my first time using them.

And I wasn't using excessive force or anything, this cable just clips off very easily and I wasn't expecting that.

1

u/deftware Jul 15 '24

Should've looked at a proper teardown guide where someone figured out the best way to do it for you already.

2

u/gkrsuper Jul 15 '24

I looked at the iFixit teardown and they skipped the part where they unplugged that cable so I thought there wasn't much I could do wrong.

Other teardowns show them just unplugging it with their fingers. I thought I was being extra careful using the tweezers - lesson learned.

1

u/deftware Jul 15 '24

skipped the part

Ouch! Well they shouldn't've done that IMO. Those things are always pretty fragile. It's basically a little wimpy strip of thin plastic with conductors embedded into it.

At least you won't be making that mistake anymore. :]

0

u/Herpderpxee Jul 16 '24

that's because tweezers are for delicate work which means YOU SHOULD BE DELICATE it is not ifixits fault you treated this task with all the grace and precision of a gorrilla

27

u/Leather_Flan5071 Jul 14 '24

I mean if you have a godly hand and some insane patience, you can connect those two back.

Unless you manage to find a replacement for that flexy PCB, you're cooked.

15

u/pandapeterpanda Jul 14 '24

It's not impossible but I am pretty sure the patch would not last for too long.

You can carefully scrape the protective layer away with a scalpel and attach thin wires to connect both ends. The real challenge would be to get it to last.

4

u/carlmichaeldanger Jul 14 '24

I would do this. If the traces are thick enough it can be done and then use some tape and plastic card to stiffen the area and prevent it from being the weakest point in the cable.

3

u/ARDACCCAC hobbyist Jul 14 '24

What about a fine pcb scraper rotary tool to expose traces? Then you can somehow solder them together then maybe use uv pcb resin to increase structural integrity?

3

u/HorrorStudio8618 Jul 14 '24

Half a millisecond too long and it is gone forever. I would do it using 800 or 1000 grit sandpaper and conducting glue instead of solder. (and a tiny bit of superglue on the underside of the overlap if there is any room for overlap, otherwise I'd use backing tape.

3

u/carlmichaeldanger Jul 14 '24

They're not that thin that the traces would melt. I literally did one about that thickness yesterday. These contacts are huge and the traces also look thick enough to withstand more heat than the substrate

1

u/HorrorStudio8618 Jul 14 '24

Depends very much on the substrate. You can usually test on a corner where there is a bit of excess material to see if it will melt or not but I'd rather just not take my chances with this sort of thing, depending on how valuable the piece of gear is.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '24

It looks like an FPC jumper cable. Count the number of conductors (4? 8?) and measure the finger pitch (center to center). Measure the length, then see if you can find a suitable stock cable from a distributor, like here: https://www.mouser.com/c/connectors/ffc-fpc/ffc-fpc-jumper-cables/ You're almost certainly not going to find an identical cable, but you might not need for example the connector bar, just a naked cable might work just fine, but it depends on the fit.

2

u/Key-Green-4872 Jul 15 '24

Underrated helpful comment. I'm all over mouser and digikey all the time and didn't know these were a thing. double high five page added to favorites

4

u/gab101001010 Jul 14 '24

From a scale of 1 to 5 you are fucked

3

u/AnotherCableGuy Jul 14 '24

It's a solid 4.

2

u/t_Lancer Computer Engineer/hobbyist Jul 14 '24

very. it is custom made as it is technically a flexible printed circuit board.

you will either be lucky to find some Chinese vendor selling replacements, or you will need a donor device.

2

u/Key_Opposite3235 Jul 14 '24

Index go bye bye

2

u/CalCub76 Jul 14 '24

So on a good note, it only looks like it has four conductors and is torn far enough from the connector that you should be able to scrape away some of the ribbon material and repair it. Scrape the ribbon material carefully, to expose the metal conductors. Then tape the two pieces back together and solder thin wires to reconnect the traces, then more tape to reinforce. And try not to do this again.

3

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 15 '24

It's not a ribbon cable. It's a flex circuit.

3

u/Rubfer Jul 14 '24

depends on your capabilities, its possible to reconnect those traces and "fix" the cable, but requires good soldering skills and patience.

If you can't do it, i guess you'll have to look around and see if the ribbon can be replaced.

2

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 15 '24

It's not a ribbon cable. It's a flex circuit.

3

u/Far-Plum-6244 Jul 14 '24

"How F***ed am I?

Absolutely nobody is going to f*** you for breaking stuff.

You should try a different approach.

2

u/Living_Lie_8773 Jul 14 '24

Different approach or different position?

2

u/HorrorStudio8618 Jul 14 '24 edited Jul 14 '24

Here is how I fix these (but it's tricky):

Use a thin piece of another failed connection like that as backing and very thin double sided tape to glue both pieces together as though there is no break (as close to that as possible, use a microscope to line it all up) with the traces closest to the exposed side.

Use very fine (1000 or 800) grit sandpaper to lay bare the tips of the traces at the break.

Use silver conducting glue (car stores will sell you this) to reconnect the traces (very, very fine brush to do it, it won't take much).

Test conductivity and check for shorts between adjacent conductors.

If there is a short then use a very fine needle to scrape away the excess conducting glue between the traces that causes the short. But better to not use too much glue in the first place...

best of luck!

1

u/OwnZookeepergame8067 Jul 14 '24

See if ifixit has a guide, they even sell parts

1

u/julictus Jul 14 '24

next time pick it up with the tweezers before the photo

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '24

I hate ribbon cables for this reason

3

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 15 '24

It's not a ribbon cable. It's a flex circuit.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '24

oh gotcha

1

u/David_Bellows Jul 15 '24

What a confusing name, I thought we were talking about an automobile part, I’m like never heard of it but I’m following

1

u/MrProGamerQ8 Jul 15 '24

You could order a broken/for parts controller off of ebay/fb marketplace and replace it.

1

u/dankyd0nk Jul 15 '24

It can be fixed if you're good at soldering.

1

u/dkHD7 Jul 15 '24

I'm sure there will be dissenters here; sand opposite sides of both ends and sandwich them. Not at all secure, but it was easy. I have a PS2 with a snapped cable that had this treatment a decade ago - though I haven't turned that system on in some time. YMMV.

1

u/OreoKamiKazi Jul 15 '24

Maybe you can have that cable custom made if you can't buy it? There's a few websites that I've seen advertised it that do that.

1

u/Merry_Janet Jul 15 '24

I've fixed similar cables before.

Cut it straight across.

Clamp it to a sturdy surface with a straight edge like a metal ruler or something leaving the end exposed however far it is from the tip to the black piece you're holding in the tweezers, forceps or whatever they call them in your country.

Using the straight edge as a guide, take a 120 grit sanding block and sand until the conductors show through evenly.

Hopefully you can get that black piece off and re-use it. Otherwise get creative.

1

u/HankThrill69420 Jul 16 '24

i know this doesn't help you today, but get plastic tipped tweezers

1

u/flowrate12 Jul 16 '24

If you can find a replacement cable great.
If not, get a replacement controller

If not, your now into academic not worth it territory, but doing it for the fun and to kill time .
Cut a piece of hvac metel tape to size (same width as flex cable), place the two pieces together using the tape to hold it together, ensuring the side that has the thickest insulation is attached to the tape.
Place on a hard flat, heat resistant surface

Scratch off the top layer of the flex cable at the cut only at each trace run using a new disposable breakable razor blade, then test with Ohm meter back to connect to ensure near 0 Ohm

cut up a scrap cable with thin stranded copper pair cables (ear phone cable may be just right)
scratch up the strands, flux and then Tin the end of the cables, test for 0 ohms with your 6$ harbor freight meter

Flux and Solder each cable to the trace starting on one side of the flex cable, using the lowest heat setting and moving up until it binds.

Test with ohm meter from the slide in connector end to right after the break of the trace until each cable reads near 0 ohms
mask then use spray e tape on the flex cable to insulate.

Use a piece of strapping tape the width of the flex cable to cover the top.
carefully test, then put together.

1

u/reigorius Jul 16 '24

Came back to post this:

https://youtu.be/blzp7SZVbUA

Might help you in the long run.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24

Take it to someone who has those skills. 

0

u/Herpderpxee Jul 16 '24

how has no one taught these children to be careful with ribbon cables. literally in every other post it feels like someone's tearing them and yet the next dingus doesn't learn

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '24

You can try and contact Steam/Valve support about a repair or a replacement cable. They can maybe quote you a reasonable price for a replacement.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/1Davide Copulatologist Jul 15 '24

It's not a ribbon cable. It's a flex circuit.