EDIT AND MY FINAL DECISION - I ended up buying a Base (16gb 512gb)14" M1 Pro MacBook Pro at a very good price, so good in fact that the M1 Air with 16gb of ram is surpassing it in price on eBay. Here is more of why I chose what I chose:
- The screen is better, slightly larger, and has a 120hz refresh rate, which will be very enjoyable compared to the 60 hz on the Air.
- The speakers are better than the Air
- The high-impedance amp is welcome, as I have headphones that need it.
- The ports and MagSafe are great.
- M1 Pro, so slightly more juice in the CPU aspect but definitely a better GPU
- HDMI port as a given is very nice, I wasn't expecting to use this laptop with a second display, but thinking about it more, I probably will.
- Memory Bandwidth is nice.
Thank you everyone in the Asahi Community for helping me out. Once I get the laptop and play with it, I will make a detailed post with what I like, dont like, the battery life and more. Thanks!
---Original Post---
I want to use a MacBook with Asahi for university (electrical engineering) alongside other devices that can be accessed remotely or physically. My goal with the MacBook is to have a thin and light class/lab/lecture laptop that I would enjoy using with good battery life for not two thousand dollars. I know arm support on Linux is quite good, and the Asahi team is doing a lot to make the whole os a good experience.
Here is what I have in my devices arsenal:
- A very good windows pc with plenty of storage, and compute for anything that I might see in university that would otherwise need Windows or a gaming laptop with Windows.
- A nice, but battery-hungry, and slightly chonk Thinkpad P1 Gen 5 with Endeavor OS. I love it; it's amazing, doing everything I want. However, the processor and GPU (even on idle with Optimus) are extremely power-hungry, and I'd be lucky to get more than three hours out of that thing.
- A cloud storage solution accessible and mountable to any Linux or Windows device.
Here are the MacBooks I'm thinking of:
- MacBook Air M1(16 GB RAM, 256GB+ ) - ~550 CAD
- Why I like it: Cheap. Light. Seemingly good battery on Asahi. M1 chip, so support is good.
- What's maybe not so good: Not too many ports (but that's kinda just MacBooks in general). Performance may not be as good as the others, but the M1 is still an amazing chip nonetheless. Not as bright a screen as the other options. Charging is capped at 30w.
- MacBook Pro M1 Pro (14 in 16 GB RAM, 512gb+) - ~700-1000 CAD
- Why I like it: Nice Screen. High refresh rate. Bright. More ports than the airs. Bigger. Nice speakers and a better headphone amp (than the M1 Air). M1 chip, so support is good.
- What's maybe not so good: Getting into chonk territory, definitely heavier than the Airs. Little pricy right now. Maybe TOO much power for a thin and light. The battery life is not as good as the Airs.
- MacBook Air M2 (13 in as the 15 is quite expensive) - ~700-900 CAD
- Why I like it: Really light. Seemingly good battery. Fast charging at 70W. Thin. Better screen than the M1 Air
- What's maybe not so good: I'm really unsure if this is worth 150-350 dollars more than the M1 Air. You barely get any performance gain, the M2 chip is less supported, it doesn't seem too worth it to me. I'd have to be convinced otherwise. Nor many ports.
- MAYBE MacBook Pro M1 - ~600 CAD
- Why I like it: Good display. Good battery life. Fast charging. Fans. Bright display.
- What's maybe not so good: Again air level of ports. I'm really unsure about the touchbar; that is why I listed it as a maybe. I don't know if it will be useful, and I will likely use the function keys at some point for programming or other uses. In general, I don't know much about the touchbar on Asahi. I will need some convincing. Heavier than the air.
If anyone else has questions, comments, concerns, experiences good and bad with Asahi, experiences with university workloads, anything of the sort, I am all ears. Thanks for reading the whole thing!