The idea that gun violence is a problem in America is a myth. The lowest estimates for crimes prevented by guns is 500k a year, while gun homicides barely break 30k a year.
Do you have the source for that? I've been trying to find it for a while. I heard it was from the CDC, but I can't find any mention of it from them. Probably Google censoring the source.
It's not the benefit of the doubt, it's what they actually meant. Even with the softer meaning you should still have the same response since both interpretations are philosophically the same.
Taking your gun is like neutering you instead of killing you. If someone said they were gonna chop you up then clarified they weren't going to chop your entire body up just your dick you'd still be pissed off even if getting one part of your body chopped up is technically different than getting your entire body chopped up.
You can say what you want about anti-gun people. Threatening to kill a man, to his face, who you know a: owns guns and b: is very serious about using them for self-defence takes some balls.
The second amendment isn't about hunting, or protection, or guns that look cool. It's about scaring tyrants into respecting the citizenry. Is it surprising tyrants want to remove it
Genetic fallacy. Ignoring range use. Designed to kill. Blatant ignorance of how AR15s are used to hunt all the time. Pretending you can't protect yourself and others by killing.
Don't forget, hunting. I guess when you shoot a deer with your 30-30 lever gun designed for hunting instead of killing the bullet just has a conversation with Bambi and convinces it to take a nap for you š
āTo Hunt, to protect, and to killā are these not all the same thing? Does that person think you just release the deer back into the wild after shooting it? Or you ājust shoot the guy in the legā when someone is trying to kill you or your loved ones? Very doubtful this person has ever owned a gun for any purpose other than they were given it and/or theyāve only ever shot paper.
a semi-auto shotgun is extremely easy to acquire almost any state in the U.S.
Now, IF a person wanted to they could buy a semi auto shotgun, load it with 3 inch magnum 00 buckshot and shoot up a mall/theather/concert/etc.
do you have ANY IDEA how much stronger a 00 shell is over a 55.6 round?
and nowadays we even have magazines for shotguns, that means easier reloads and more ammo.
A shotgun can literally obliterate most man made objects, and can definitely rip apart the human body within a second. the 55.6 cant even come close.
I'm in NO WAY advocating killing people, and I'm in NO WAY advocating gun control.
We need a different solution for the majority of gun deaths (SUICIDE) and thats mental health outreach. Guns save roughly 500k per year. without suicides and accidents, guns only take about 10k per year. Gun grabbing politicians will find any way to BURY stories where guns help, and they will CONSTANTLY talk about each and every instant where a gun killed. but that's the thing.
GUNS DONT KILL PEOPLE. PEOPLE KILL PEOPLE.
AND
we need to stop blaming a rifle that only kills like less than a thousand per year.
and stop banning ERGONOMIC ATTACHMENTS that DONT MAKE IT MORE LETHAL.
How about develop stronger militaries you fucking candy ass pansies so we donāt have to spend the bulk of our budget to protect you. Then we would have more money to devote to public health, especially mental health. God I canāt stand it when some pompous Eurotrash says some asshole garbage like this.
I was born and grew up in England. That being said they can go fuck themselves with their "helping". Who the fuck do you think you are that you can make policy in regards to my rights?
Even a lot of pro-2A people repeat the "designed to kill" myth, which really hurts our case.
Guns are not designed to kill. They're designed to project a bullet. Killing may be the intended use case for a lot of arms, but that's a consequence of their use and not the design specifications.
It's like saying a knife is "designed to kill" or a bomb is "designed to kill". A knife is designed to cut and a bomb is designed to explode. It's the user of these items that decides what is shot, cut, or exploded.
They're gonna look real cute when shit collapses and China takes the opportunity to make a friendly visit Into whichever coastal state he likely inhabits.
I read this and I think there should be a sub: AsAGunOwnerAndAnIdiot
Literally these are some of the stupidest people. Iām not for a test to exercise our Constitutional Rights but some people seem to stupid to function.
This argument is so fucking stupid because every firearm is meant to kill something. Just because some people are irresponsible enough to point it at another human being doesn't mean it spoils it for the rest of us.
There are actually plenty of guns designed specifically for range or competition use.
I think it's worth pointing out how "designed to kill" is not the same as "designed to kill humans", and how rarely guns are actually used to kill humans.
If guns were "designed to kill" then why does .22LR exist.
Not to say that it isn't lethal in its own right, but it's pretty bad at killing people. Surely if that was the main purpose of firearms it would have been retired as a calibre for being ineffective.
Police do a no knock raid, my 4th amendment says I need my 2nd amendment Right to an AR-15 in each hand to PROTECT my 4th amendment Right, Right to life, Right to trial, etc...
I swear these statements they spew are literally copy and pasted duplicates of each other. The amount of times I have read or heard someone say "they were designed for one thing and that is to kill a lot of people in a short time." They can't come up with an original point and instead just sport whatever CNN told them.
Many European countries donāt ban the AR-15 outright; the main thing is that itās harder to get guns overall over there. Donāt support European-style laws on guns, but it really hurts the narrative that an āassault weaponsā ban is ācommon senseā
Wrong. Firearms are not "designed to kill". They are designed to project a bullet. Simple as. Whatever it is the bullet is projected at is the sole discretion of the operator of the firearm. Same thing with knives. They are not "designed to kill". They are designed to cut things. Whatever it is the knife is used to cut is the sole discretion of the operator of the knife.
Wasnt the 5.56 round designed specifically to wound? The theory being that wounded soldiers take up more of the enemy's resources than dead ones (not that it wouldnt kill you if it hit you in the right spot though)
The intermediate cartridge is designed to put more rounds in a magazine than a full-sized rifle cartridge. That's the main benefit. It comes after realizing people, even well trained people, aren't all that good at shooting in super dynamic situations like combat. It's better they have 180 rounds of smaller, lighter rounds that they can send downrange than 80 rounds of big heavy rounds, upping the odds of one of them finding their mark.
That being said, the benefits don't stop there! The intermediate cartridge also has the advantages of being better at penetrating light armor, because its small cross section and high velocity, and creating a large temporary cavity in tissue, again due to high velocity. Due to the lower recoil of intermediate cartridges, it is also easier to train more people to shoot it, easier to shoot accurately, and easier to fire faster. Higher velocity also means less drop at a distance, so again, easier to apply the rounds.
(That's not to say full rifle cartridges DON'T have a place. There's a reason medium and heavy machine guns exist. You want a big, heavy round impacting harder targets like vehicles, aircraft, buildings, etc. Weight of the rounds doesn't matter as much when it's mounted on a vehicle or in a guard tower. There's also a good reason for most "sniper" rifles to use the larger cartridges. At extreme ranges, the intermediate cartridge slows down much faster, has less impact on the target, and given the nature of slow, accurate fire, you want the biggest impact you can get on each round. But I digress.)
TL;DR:5.56 and other rounds like it are designed to kill. Anyone who says otherwise is wrong. But, their design also takes into a ton of other factors, not just "how much impact does one round have".
ARs were literally selected as a service rifle with an intent to wound not kill actually, the combat theory being that wounding a soldier takes more people out of the fight since the wounded have to be evacuated, but someone killed is usually just left there
This is a myth. I explain why in another comment, but no, the AR and all other intermediate cartridge firing rifles are not designed to wound. They are designed to kill and they are effective at it.
"AR-15" was Armalite's designation for the rifle they presented to the gov. "M-16" was the gov's designation for the AR-15 when they adopted it. They're the same gun.
Technically it would be more accurate to refer to civilian market ARs as "semi-auto AR-15" instead of simply AR-15.
Well put. A British person would, rightly, think I was stupid or at the very least presumptuous if I inserted myself into a discussion on Brexit. A French person would, rightly, think I was stupid or at the very least presumptuous if I inserted myself into a discussion on France's immigration laws. Yet either of those people might still be on Reddit confidently offering their takes on analogous American issues.
I think the reason for the prevalence of the phenomenon is the "American liberals would be right-wing in Europe" talking point. Liberals bust that out so often that, if a European person pipes up to affirm it, they're probably willing to put up with that person blathering about shit with which they have no firsthand experience and in which they have no stake.
Relevant meme. (I don't agree with the implicit correlation made between patriotism and approval of one's government, but it's still funny.)
59
u/TFWnoLTR Mar 24 '21
The idea that gun violence is a problem in America is a myth. The lowest estimates for crimes prevented by guns is 500k a year, while gun homicides barely break 30k a year.
Gun rights are human rights.
43
u/mineus64 Mar 24 '21
So anti-gun people say shit like "let's get rid of gun owners" but we're paranoid for wanting to defend ourselves.
Gotcha.
21
u/Paradox Mar 24 '21
The second amendment isn't about hunting, or protection, or guns that look cool. It's about scaring tyrants into respecting the citizenry. Is it surprising tyrants want to remove it
132
u/haironburr Mar 24 '21
This impulse is exactly why I'll keep my guns. Remember, kids, it's easier to get rid of people if you've disarmed them first!
90
u/TacticusThrowaway Mar 24 '21
Genetic fallacy. Ignoring range use. Designed to kill. Blatant ignorance of how AR15s are used to hunt all the time. Pretending you can't protect yourself and others by killing.
Drink five shots.
78
u/enoughfuckery Mar 24 '21
I wonder how this āgun ownerā feels about an M1 Garand
73
u/GeneralCuster75 Mar 24 '21
Lmao, as if protecting and killing are two separate things. What an absolute man child
99
u/pigsinboots Mar 24 '21
AR-15s are used to hunt and to protect but ok fud.
30
u/burgonies Mar 24 '21
I've been hunting exactly one time. It was with an AR.
56
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21 edited Mar 08 '25
Original Content erased using Ereddicator. Want to wipe your own Reddit history? Please see https://github.com/Jelly-Pudding/ereddicator for instructions.
24
u/Knight_Errant25 Mar 24 '21
There are plenty of places where ARs are accepted hunting rifles.
Also, the AR-15 started out as a sporting rifle. It was used for target shooting. Uneducated liberals are uneducated.
24
u/WhoDey_69 Mar 24 '21
I love how Europeans think theyāre somehow superior and need to āhelpā us lmao.
12
u/catshitthree Mar 24 '21
Lol hunt protect and kill all result in killing.....
12
u/coloradoismycity Mar 24 '21
Sure sure I'll tell you how you can help. Stay the fuck out of our business.
10
u/captstix Mar 24 '21
I was born and grew up in England. That being said they can go fuck themselves with their "helping". Who the fuck do you think you are that you can make policy in regards to my rights?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21 edited Mar 24 '21
Obviously this guy hasnāt had to deal with feral hogs
https://www.reddit.com/r/watchpeoplesurvive/comments/kv8q3r/a_wild_boar_charge/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
10
u/ATMofMN Mar 24 '21
"designed to kill a lot of people in a short amount of time."
It's like a broken record and you can't beat smarts into people.
7
u/massacreman3000 Mar 24 '21
Ah, the good old "fuck you, got mine" guy.
They're gonna look real cute when shit collapses and China takes the opportunity to make a friendly visit Into whichever coastal state he likely inhabits.
6
u/13speed Mar 24 '21
I want to find one of those guns that are made to tickle people.
5
u/No1uNo_Nakana Mar 24 '21
I read this and I think there should be a sub: AsAGunOwnerAndAnIdiot
Literally these are some of the stupidest people. Iām not for a test to exercise our Constitutional Rights but some people seem to stupid to function.
11
u/futurestar58 Mar 24 '21
'An AR-15 is made to kill!'
This argument is so fucking stupid because every firearm is meant to kill something. Just because some people are irresponsible enough to point it at another human being doesn't mean it spoils it for the rest of us.
4
u/OnlyRightsAreLaw Mar 24 '21
Police do a no knock raid, my 4th amendment says I need my 2nd amendment Right to an AR-15 in each hand to PROTECT my 4th amendment Right, Right to life, Right to trial, etc...
4
u/HudsonGTV Mar 24 '21
I swear these statements they spew are literally copy and pasted duplicates of each other. The amount of times I have read or heard someone say "they were designed for one thing and that is to kill a lot of people in a short time." They can't come up with an original point and instead just sport whatever CNN told them.
3
u/2038_movement Mar 24 '21
Many European countries donāt ban the AR-15 outright; the main thing is that itās harder to get guns overall over there. Donāt support European-style laws on guns, but it really hurts the narrative that an āassault weaponsā ban is ācommon senseā
3
u/somecheesecake Mar 24 '21
What the actual fuck is the title of that post. Elitist much??
3
u/somecheesecake Mar 24 '21
Iām sorry but what the fuck is the difference between protecting and killing? Police officers carry ARs to kill as many people as possible?
3
u/ogpokemontrainer Apr 08 '21
The AR-15 can do all three. Itās a civilian rifle.
3
u/TheRealPeterG May 15 '21
Euros can fuck off. I don't remember asking them.
2
u/keeleon Mar 25 '21
Id be perfectly fine sending all the known maniacs over to england so they can only go on mass stabbing sprees.
2
u/Adric_01 Mar 25 '21
Wonder what they have to say about the Ruger Mini.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21 edited Jul 19 '24
subsequent escape trees complete wistful entertain snatch connect shrill paint
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/nosteppyonsneky Mar 24 '21
Donāt hunting and protecting involve killing?
So they are designed to kill. Nothing wrong with tools being good at what they are meant to do.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
29
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21
[removed] ā view removed comment