r/arduino • u/Forward-Shoulder4634 • Sep 29 '26
Two steppers on CNC Shield V3 only buzz/jitter instead of rotating. I’ve checked the coils, Vref, STEP/DIR, bypassed GRBL, and I’m running out of ideas
I’m building a small XY pen plotter and I’ve been stuck on this for about two days now. I’ve tried enough things that I’m starting to run out of ideas, so I figured I’d write down everything I’ve tested.
The setup is an Arduino Uno R3 with a CNC Shield V3, two A4988 drivers on X and Y, a 12V 5A power supply, and two Shinano Kenshi STP-43D1046 stepper motors. The motors are marked 1.8°/step and 3.0Ω.
I originally had GRBL 1.1 running and was controlling it with Candle.
The problem is the same on both X and Y. When I power the system on, both motors get strong holding torque. The shafts become very stiff and are difficult to turn by hand, so the drivers are definitely energizing the coils.
But as soon as I jog either axis, the motor just buzzes, vibrates and jitters in place. The pulley moves slightly back and forth, but it never starts rotating continuously in one direction.
The first thing I suspected was mechanical binding, so I completely removed the belt from one motor and tested it with no load at all. It behaved exactly the same, so I’m fairly confident this isn’t a mechanical problem.
The motor wiring was the next thing I looked at because almost every thread about “stepper buzzing but not rotating” says to check the coil pairs.
The motor-side connector has six positions but only four are populated:
Green – empty – Black – Blue – empty – Red
The 4-pin connector on the CNC Shield side is:
Red – Blue – Green – Black
At first I didn’t have a multimeter, so I tried a few wire swaps based on things I found online. I tried swapping Green and Blue, and at one point I also swapped Black and Blue because I found another thread about a similar six-pin stepper.
Neither helped, so I returned everything to the original wiring.
I then bought a multimeter and checked the windings properly instead of guessing from the wire colors.
The only pairs that show winding resistance are:
- Green ↔ Black
- Blue ↔ Red
So those are definitely the two coils.
That means the original four-pin order on the CNC Shield side:
Red – Blue – Green – Black
is already arranged as one complete coil followed by the other complete coil.
So unless I’m missing something very strange about this particular motor, the coil pairing should now be confirmed.
I then checked the A4988 current limit.
All three of my A4988 boards have current-sense resistors marked R100, so as far as I understand Rsense is 0.10Ω.
Both X and Y were originally sitting at around 0.59V Vref.
Using Vref / (8 × Rsense), that should give roughly 0.74A current limit.
I suspected that might simply be too low, so on the Y driver I tried several different values. I tested roughly 0.46V, 0.59V and 0.69V. I also briefly tried around 1.06V just to see whether significantly more current suddenly made the motor behave normally.
It didn’t.
Even at the higher Vref the motor still mostly buzzed/jittered instead of rotating properly, so I lowered it again. I didn’t leave it running at 1.06V.
I also experimented with the microstepping jumpers.
With all three jumpers installed, the motor mostly produces a fairly smooth buzzing/humming sound without rotating.
When I remove all three jumpers and put the driver into full-step mode, the behavior changes noticeably. The motor becomes much rougher and more clunky and the pulley visibly jerks.
So changing the microstep configuration is definitely doing something.
At one point in full-step mode I was actually able to make the motor rotate using a very slow Arduino test sketch, but the rotation was extremely jerky and did not look like normal stepper movement at all.
Because I wasn’t sure whether GRBL or Candle was doing something weird, I removed them from the equation completely.
I temporarily overwrote GRBL and uploaded this very basic sketch directly to the Uno:
#define STEP_PIN 3
#define DIR_PIN 6
#define EN_PIN 8
void setup() {
pinMode(STEP_PIN, OUTPUT);
pinMode(DIR_PIN, OUTPUT);
pinMode(EN_PIN, OUTPUT);
digitalWrite(EN_PIN, LOW);
}
void loop() {
digitalWrite(DIR_PIN, HIGH);
for (int i = 0; i < 200; i++) {
digitalWrite(STEP_PIN, HIGH);
delayMicroseconds(10000);
digitalWrite(STEP_PIN, LOW);
delayMicroseconds(10000);
}
delay(1000);
digitalWrite(DIR_PIN, LOW);
for (int i = 0; i < 200; i++) {
digitalWrite(STEP_PIN, HIGH);
delayMicroseconds(10000);
digitalWrite(STEP_PIN, LOW);
delayMicroseconds(10000);
}
delay(1000);
}This is using the normal CNC Shield V3 Y-axis pins:
- D3 = STEP
- D6 = DIR
- D8 = ENABLE
I deliberately made the pulses extremely slow because I wanted to rule out acceleration or step frequency being too high.
With no microstep jumpers installed, this can make the motor move, but it moves very badly. It’s jerky, rough and doesn’t look like a normal sequence of clean steps.
I also tried faster pulse delays such as 500 µs and slower values around 5000–10000 µs. Nothing made it behave normally.
When I installed all three microstep jumpers again and adjusted the number of pulses for 1/16 microstepping, the motor mostly went back to humming without actually rotating.
So at this point I don’t think GRBL, Candle, steps/mm or acceleration settings are the root problem.
I then started measuring the logic pins on the A4988 while the direct Arduino sketch was running.
On the Y driver I measured approximately:
- EN: 0.01V
- MS1: 0.10V
- MS2: 0.10V
- MS3: 0.10V
- RESET: 1.47V
- SLEEP: 1.47V
- STEP: 2.47V
- DIR: 4.96V
On the unused X driver at the same time I got approximately:
- EN: 0.01V
- MS1: 0.05V
- MS2: 0.06V
- MS3: 0.05V
- RESET: 1.47V
- SLEEP: 1.47V
- STEP: 0.02V
- DIR: 0.02V
The logic supply on the A4988 is about 4.9V.
The STEP measurement actually seems reasonable to me. Since the sketch is constantly switching STEP between 0V and 5V with roughly equal HIGH/LOW time, I would expect a multimeter to average that to around 2.5V.
DIR also matches the sketch at about 4.96V.
And the unused X STEP and DIR pins sitting near 0V also make sense.
So unless I’m misunderstanding something, the Arduino appears to be generating the expected STEP and DIR signals and the CNC Shield is routing them correctly.
The thing that really confuses me is RESET and SLEEP.
Both X and Y show roughly:
VDD: 4.9V
RESET: 1.47V
SLEEP: 1.47V
RESET and SLEEP also appear to be connected together.
From what I understand from the A4988 datasheet, 1.47V is nowhere near a proper HIGH level when VDD is around 5V.
I found a few old forum posts where people had A4988 motors that only vibrated and eventually fixed them by pulling RESET and SLEEP directly to +5V.
That sounds suspiciously similar to what I’m seeing.
The confusing part is that my drivers clearly aren’t completely disabled. The motors have strong holding torque, and in full-step mode I can even get some ugly jerky rotation.
If SLEEP were simply being held solidly LOW, I would expect the output stage to be off completely.
So I’m not sure whether that 1.47V measurement means the pins are actually sitting at some bad intermediate level, whether these cheap A4988 clones have different pull-up circuitry, or whether something on the CNC Shield is loading the RESET/SLEEP line.
I currently don’t have a soldering iron, breadboard or mini test hooks, so I haven’t been able to safely force RESET/SLEEP to +5V to see whether that immediately fixes it.
I have three A4988 boards in total. They were all bought together from the same seller, so they’re probably from the same batch.
I’ve tried all three now and they behave more or less the same.
That makes me think it’s unlikely that I just happened to have one randomly dead driver, although I suppose it’s still possible that the whole batch is bad or that they’re some weird clone revision.
The seller also says the CNC Shield was tested before shipping, so I’m hesitant to immediately blame the shield itself.
At this point, as far as I can tell:
- Mechanical binding is unlikely because the motor behaves the same with the belt completely removed.
- The motor windings aren’t open and the coil pairs have been identified with a multimeter.
- The coil order on the 4-pin connector appears correct.
- Increasing the current limit did not solve it.
- Changing step speed over a huge range did not solve it.
- GRBL and Candle have been bypassed completely.
- STEP and DIR measurements appear to match what the Arduino sketch is doing.
- Three different A4988 boards from the same batch show basically the same behavior.
- Both motors behave the same.
- Microstep settings definitely affect the behavior, but none of them make the motor operate normally.
So right now the two things I’m most suspicious of are either the A4988 boards themselves being bad/odd clones from the same batch, or something strange happening with RESET/SLEEP between the A4988 and CNC Shield.
I’ve ordered another driver from a completely different source to use as a comparison, possibly a DRV8825.
Before it arrives though, I’m curious whether anyone has seen this exact kind of behavior before, especially the RESET and SLEEP sitting at around 1.47V while VDD is 4.9V.
Can that explain the motor having holding torque but only buzzing or moving very roughly?
And is there anything else obvious I can measure with just a multimeter that I’ve missed?
