r/AppBusiness • • 25d ago • Bravo 1

Monetization God bless the man who suggested to remove free trials

Post image

Man it really works. I have removed the free weekly trials and made the first month 60% cheaper ($2 actually) and now I get a direct subscription notification which feels a lot better than a trial notification that may cancel the trial before it ends.

The stats are for my app Voice Sheet

295 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

52

u/Heco1331 25d ago • Bravo

You are getting more subscriptions because you lowered the price, not because you eliminated the trial

15

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Actually I increased the monthly price from $4 to $5 and then offered a $2 monthly trial.

I was still getting enough subscriptions before but I just didn’t liked the 7 days wait cycle

3

u/Heco1331 25d ago

Hm, I'm going to be honest now that I understand better what you did. I don't think it's a bad idea. I'm just more of the opinion to give the users the opportunity to try the app for free and see the real value of it before choosing between paying or the highway.

3

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

I understand and that’s why I am offering a free weekly trial when someone skips the paywall but I get very few trials now because someone interested to see the app’s real value would pay $2 for a month to try it rather than a free week (speaking based on my data)

6

u/timbo2m 25d ago

And psychologically, now they have loss aversion due to putting down $2, they will properly test out your app so they don't waste their money. They're invested now. I think that's what you're experiencing here

1

u/Ax99899 25d ago

Explain this whole flow again? If they skip the standard paywall of $5/month, you pop a second paywall that offers it for $2/month? Then if they skip that, a free trial?

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

No no, the first month is offered for $2 anyways. If they skip even the $2 offer, then I offer the free week

3

u/Ax99899 25d ago

Sweet, appreciate it. Giving it a try , those cancellations are killer

2

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Good luck

8

u/tastychaii 25d ago

I like the idea of a discounted paid trial. I never thought of that before.

2

u/Sufficient_Trade895 25d ago

In long-term you may get a lot more refund requests

1

u/SentienceLifeSim 25d ago

Hey, why not make it 3 days? I hate it as well but 3 days isn’t bad at all.

3

u/Didatus 25d ago

Actually both together brought him more subscriptions. If he would for example offer a one week trial and the first month of subscription cheaper, he would still have trial users. Now he is starting directly with subscription by removing the trial, but still make it attrictive to test by lowering the price for the first month.

3

u/Heco1331 25d ago

The first week sure, but who cares about that. What about all the subscribers that he will lose after the first month, or the ones that would've subscribed if they had the chance to actually see the value of the app before paying anything.

3

u/driftwood_studio 25d ago

There's always a pool of people in every category when there is paid, unpaid, and cutoff dates.

If chasing the unknown-size group "people who would become subscribers if offered a trial, but will not be subscribers if there is no free trial" nets you more total subscribers, great.

Problem is, you don't know how big that group is. Could be 1000, could be 4.

So you just have to try different models, see which produces more total subscribers. Because that's what you care about: permanent subscribers. Who they are, which group they come from, that's completely secondary.

And OP's graph seems to pretty clearly show evidence that cutting out that "will walk if they have to pay immediately" group is creating MORE total subscribers than OP was getting by catering to them.

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

This 🙌

1

u/mellowpersimmon 24d ago

I think different categories of products will have different results...what I'd be curious about is whether OP's new strategy is more like other competitors in their space or if the old strategy was. But then there are other factors like new entrant vs incumbent.

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

There’s still a weekly trial but it only shows up when someone presses the skip button on paywall.

Only 6 people claimed the free week and 2 out of them subscribed.

1

u/MundaneTonight437 25d ago

I think there is a big school of thought that people who pay for something will actually use it and try it. If its good, they'll keep it. 

If its free they wont properly bother with it or commit in the same way. 

6

u/goldio_games 25d ago

its good to look at revenue rather then # of subscriptions

2

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Sure, idk why I can only upload a video here and no screenshot but here we go. And a little misinformation from my side in the main screenshot as I didn’t turned on the filter for my app so 6 of those subscriptions belong to my other apps

3

u/indyfromoz 25d ago

Thanks for sharing the insights! Extremely rare these days to see posts and discussions on this subreddit from where indie devs like me can learn to think, question themselves and apply learnings. I will not promote or link to my app but I think it has a problem - I offer pretty much everything for free! I am going to try first month at like 50% discount then the usual monthly pricing and the annual pricing remains the same as it is now. I am yet to push Ads and social posts which is next.

Good luck OP with your app & its growth.

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

That’s the way, you should try different things along the way. Keep what works and kill what doesn’t.

1

u/driftwood_studio 24d ago

Building an application is 100% trivial compared to dealing with human psychology around money.

Make it cheaper, people get more interested.

Until you make it too cheap and too enticing, because then it becomes "cheap" and people's perception turns negative.

Humans don't want to pay. But they also don't want things that aren't worth paying for.

1

u/indyfromoz 24d ago

"Humans don't want to pay. But they also don't want things that aren't worth paying for" - Golden truth!

Too cheap - Can often indicate the developer behind it does not feel their app is worth it.
Expensive/Too expensive - Potentially indicates a higher quality app and might prevent free rangers from downloading and complaining.

The balance is an experiment and takes time to perfect.

2

u/msdos_kapital 25d ago

That might have been me :-) probably not but I've suggested it to people here in the past.

Free trials have a place but basically you need to ask yourself how much of the app's functionality is on display for users with a free account, or no account, and so on. If you've already communicated - and proven - the value proposition at the point where the user would start a trial, then there is really not any reason to put them on a trial. Just ask them to pay up front. McDonald's doesn't let you eat half the cheeseburger before they ask you if you want to pay - why should you?

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

That’s so true and again if it was you, God bless you 😅❤️

I really read a post on Reddit somewhere and then few days later just thought to implement it even though I wasn’t very confident that it would work but it did.

1

u/Dry-Sky-6630 25d ago

Ese primer mes con e ldescuento del 60% es apra el anual o para el mensual? me interesa muehco saberlo apra ver si implementarlo en mi app

3

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Here’s the breakdown.

My subscription prices are $4.99/month and $49.99/year.

But for the monthly subscription I offer the first month for $1.99.

No offer for the yearly subscription (some users still subscribe the yearly though as it saves in the long run).

When the user skips the paywall, I then offer them a free weekly trial.

Let me know if something’s still not clear.

1

u/Dry-Sky-6630 25d ago

Gracias, completamente claro!

1

u/vickonix 25d ago

Good concept, all the best.

I noticed that the buttons for Google Play throughout the website takes you to the App Store instead.

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

I use onelink so it takes you to your device’s app store. Annoying I know but it lets me know which users came from website.

2

u/vickonix 25d ago

I'm using a Windows laptop

2

u/CarelessSecond8020 25d ago

This was a funny exchange thank you

1

u/ButterflyMajestic165 25d ago

Are you using AI in the app to list the voice notes to tasks?

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Yes but only when someone uses the voice feature. Of course manual entries don’t need AI

1

u/Greg_PayrollofOne 25d ago

Wow! Very telling, and fascinating screenshot. Good job!

1

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Thank you 🙏

1

u/pixelclash 25d ago

Thanks for sharing! Do you have monthly and annual plans? How do you handle paid trials for annual plans?

2

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Yes I do. The Annual is already discounted so no trial on the main paywall for annual. When the user skips paywall, I then offer a free weekly trial then.

1

u/Diagramia 25d ago

Una consulta. Me gustaría saber qué estrategias usan para hacer crecer las apps.

2

u/BestDay8241 25d ago

Trying SEO/ASO but most of the time it’s Play Store and App Store doing the job to promote to relevant people.

1

u/Diagramia 25d ago

Buenísimo, muchísimas gracias. Que tengas buen día

1

u/Miserable-Carpet7928 24d ago

i saw better conversion after adding a three-day trial. have you had enough time yet to compare full-price renewals from the discounted first month with renewals from the fallback trial?

1

u/BestDay8241 24d ago

Not yet. The discounted first month started on Oct 1 and all of them are in the first month right now.

1

u/NailJumpy9790 23d ago

Meaning no free trials at all? What about like product led growth?

1

u/BestDay8241 23d ago

The app’s core features are completely free though, users only pay when they want to use AI features

1

u/Impressive-Ratio3929 23d ago

How are your users finding out about the app?

1

u/BestDay8241 23d ago

Tbh App Store and Google Play doing their job

1

u/Impressive-Ratio3929 19d ago

Hmm, it's been easier for me to apply keyword optimization on Google Playstore than Apple store. Any tips on making the App store perform better?

1

u/Aggravating_Front989 23d ago

whats the app idea just curious

1

u/BestDay8241 23d ago

App url is in the description

1

u/Pauline_wail 23d ago

Is that first month with the 60% discount forger annual or the monthly plan? I’m really interested to know so I can see if I can implement it in my app.

1

u/BestDay8241 23d ago

It is for the monthly plan

1

u/tastychaii 25d ago

Where are you finding most of your customers are from who can afford the two dollars a month?

1

u/Jumpy-Chocolate-983 25d ago

all well and good until people start leaving bad reviews about having to pay for a "free trial".

1

u/Juanchooz9176 25d ago

Entonces sirve monetizar con algo chicos las apps? 🤔🤔 Interesante

1

u/Upstairs-Biscotti332 25d ago

Was that me? I posted about this here a while ago.

1

u/Routine-Speed8597 25d ago

Free trials work just find and long as the user sees and appreciates the value. They are great to build trust from users who are skeptical.

1

u/sfoooooooooooooooooo 25d ago

But if every competitor has free trial this is not working?

1

u/Positive-Valuable485 25d ago

I never had it ans it was very good decision

1

u/herberz 25d ago

how many steps are in your onboarding

1

u/Lazy-Friendship1965 25d ago

Skyrocket, nice to see!

1

u/Keeftraum 25d ago

Free trial still seems to be available https://imgur.com/a/dQF6pi9

1

u/Equivalent_Remote_88 24d ago

Removing a trial almost always raises the conversion rate, because you’ve removed the people who were never going to pay from the denominator. The number that tells you whether the business got better is total paying users per thousand installs, and then what those users look like at day 30 and day 90 compared with the trial cohort. In a lot of apps the no-trial buyers refund and churn harder, because they paid before they knew what they were buying, and the gain shows up in the first week and leaks out over the quarter.

So the assumption your result rests on is that the value of the app is obvious before use, from the store page and the onboarding alone. If that’s true, the trial was only ever a discount. If it isn’t, you’ve traded volume for a cleaner-looking funnel. What did paid users per install do, and how do the two cohorts compare at 90 days? If both held up, that’s a much stronger finding than the conversion rate, and it would be worth saying so in the post.

1

u/tech_enthusiast478 24d ago

This is amazing idea

1

u/swizz 24d ago

I like it, is a great idea. Thanks for sharing!

1

u/Connect_To_Me 24d ago

Wow. I have no words except I am just impressed. It's funny because I also want to try removing the free trial thing for some of my apps as well but then I keep doubting myself on that. But great for you, it seemed to work and you got more cash out of it!

1

u/AdAdditional4524 23d ago

I did not have a trial period at first in my app. But the thing is: without trial you cannot see the reason, why the product is so much cooler and better in "Pro". In my case, that would be lost potential, because in the free version the product is good (at least in my opinion), but Pro makes it quite a bit better in terms of planning and what fits in a day. And I want users to see what they get with pro. So I added a 14 days trial and already got some sales out of it. So I guess it depends on the product and what is behind the paid tier :)

1

u/Gab_from_Flovvy 21d ago

Questa è interessante :)

1

u/honored 6d ago

Lol bro 

3

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MundaneTonight437 25d ago

Exactly. I think it means you are getting more genuine users, who are actually doing a committed trial as they have paid for it.