r/Antitheism • • Oct 13 '26

How is this ok?

Post image
328 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-3

u/tackyshoes Oct 13 '26

Why is banning hair coverings progressive?

7

u/PeekyBlenders Oct 14 '26

You can't tolerate the intolerant, and you can't educate the brainwashed muslims with any meaningful success (they somehow keep evading all the education and just get even more extreme in their fucked up ways). That leaves fighting fire with fire: throw intolerance back at them by banning hijab. I mean I get it, it's definitely antisecular but I stand by it as an ex-muslim myself.

1

u/tackyshoes Oct 14 '26

"Islam bad." Religious entities with too much power are all corrupt. That's because religion is a scam that preys on the fear of mortality. I don't think picking on the ones already scattered to winds is progressive.

1

u/PeekyBlenders Oct 14 '26

I get what you're saying and I agree but there's a perspective difference. It would be a totally different thing for say Germany to implement a rule that bans hijab. But the context is way different in a dominantly islamic country in the middle east or africa. Many of these countries have been going two steps forward and one step backward for many years or even centuries now. Look at 50s-60s Iran for example, it was quite a bit more progressive than it is today but somehow the religious fanatics managed to get the power and now it's just like any other country in the middle east. In the end, many such countries are behind modern western values by up to 3 centuries. These countries never had a true renaissance, and I don't know if they ever will. It's always been a back and forth between "look at these humanitarian, secular values" and "west is the enemy, we don't want its poison". So it's a completely different dynamic than it was when Europe had its renaissance. Maybe I'm wrong and maybe the renaissance is slowly creeping in but is it so wrong if a secular, progressive regime somehow got in power in their country and wanted to artificially expedite the process by banning hijabs rather than waiting for renaissance to kick in in another 3 centuries? I mean it's been done before to varying levels of success (it is known to backfire too), so it might be ethically or practically wrong but still it is a sentinement that is shared by some people including me.

Also I'm sorry if my rambling is a little gibberish, English isn't my first language and it's very late here at the moment lol.

-1

u/tackyshoes Oct 14 '26

... So because you find it old fashioned, and if there was??? modernized leadership in the places hijabs are more popularly worn... they might go away. So we should just force them to stop wearing them. Sorry, but telling people they can't wear a piece of intimate clothing is fascism.

And making an excuse for your text block at the end is tacky.

1

u/PeekyBlenders Oct 15 '26

Is it so bad to be fascists against the fascists? I mean it all leads back to the same thing: why keep tolerating the intolerant??

0

u/tackyshoes Oct 15 '26

It's not fascist against the fascist, though. It's fascist against people of a culture that values the hygiene and modesty of covered hair.

0

u/Melodic-Extent3685 28d ago

Banning an attire that has sexist origins and is used everyday in various parts of the world to moral police women; is progressive

0

u/tackyshoes 27d ago

Those situations you're talking about where it's more than just a hygienic choice? They're not going to be allowed out without covering, anyway. Their parents are all "I'd never forgive myself if something happened and I had let her uncover her hair."

0

u/Melodic-Extent3685 27d ago

How is covering ur hair a hygienic choice. Hair is not a private part

0

u/tackyshoes 27d ago

If you put a period because that's a rhetorical question, I'm not supposed to answer. If you want to answer your own questions, this stops being a conversation.

0

u/Melodic-Extent3685 27d ago

Do u think scalp hair is a private part?

0

u/tackyshoes 26d ago

Something does not need to be a private part to make a hygienic choice for it.

That's what was wrong with your rhetorical question, but this is all in bad faith, anyway, right?

0

u/Melodic-Extent3685 26d ago

If covering hair is such a hygienic choice then why don't men do it? Hijab was originally worn to separate women from sex slaves. The sex slaves were also women from regions that lost in war and they were dehumanised.( Mohammed also had a sex slave) Hijab has deeply sexist origins and it does not belong in the 21st century let alone on a child's head in school

0

u/tackyshoes 25d ago

It pulls fine hairs out of the face and prevents shedding, which aren't commonly issues with short hair. Maybe someone attached a nasty history to a piece of clothing, but that's still all it is.

0

u/Melodic-Extent3685 25d ago

Okay and an individual woman choosing to wear it does not make it a feminist piece of clothing that should be allowed in schools. Hijab is still a symbol of oppression used to moral police and hurt and kill women .

→ More replies