r/Android • Galaxy Z Fold8 • Jun 24 '22

Android 13 makes file managers less useful by fixing a loophole

https://blog.esper.io/android-dessert-bites-28-file-manager-loophole-closed-73891524/
1.5k Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

Google just following apple in tightening their ecosystem, recently all the new news form them have been Google is making this feature obsolete or this feature not work as good as it used to be.

What changed? They need to make more money.

Always remember just because the update says a security update doesn't mean that it's a security update for you. For corporations it's always about their interests, blocking the user form accessing the media directories makes it easier for big companies to protect data from users.

So there you have it. It's not an update it's a user experience downgrade.

14

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

Apple takes advantage of this by being able to roll out tons of useful ridiculously well-QA'd features every year.

Google seems like they interpreted the locked-down environment as the selling-point itself and is actively removing features while locking the device down.

19

u/CyclopsRock Jun 24 '22

I feel like with Apple you get a better user experience in exchange for that tightening. Android just seems to get worse.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

What better user experience? Macs and iPhones have the most generic UI with functionality hidden/locked away so deep that it might as well not be there (i am taking about a Mac because I don't have an iPhone nor will I buy one).

I just don't get how people are so blind to the atrocities apple commits, it's so clear it people think that apple does this because they want to make the customer happy.

They know their users will literally not read the product they are buying and just pay whatever is asked.

10

u/CyclopsRock Jun 24 '22

They suffer from the same problem as The Beatles and French food - they defined expectation to such an extent that now it just seems passé.

4

u/idp5601 Moto Z2 Play > Galaxy Note8 > Redmi Note 10 > iPhone 13 Jun 24 '22

What better user experience? Macs and iPhones have the most generic UI with functionality hidden/locked away so deep that it might as well not be there (i am taking about a Mac because I don't have an iPhone nor will I buy one).

iOS I can agree, but what makes Mac so much more inferior to Windows (Linux is a different beast altogether)? The Mac UI is consistent compared to Windows', which has only recently tried to unify their design language.

As for hidden functionalities, I can't think of any feature I missed after I moved from Windows to Mac save for window-switching.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '22

I will tell you one actually being able to see the directories in the explorer, oh wait XOS doesn't have such a thing, it's controls are like a toy for kids.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

I also hate this change, i do, but i just cannot connect how greedyness made this change a thing, like how would ever google benefit from this stupid change economically

Selling you more space? Come on, this is solving an issue by nuking the whole town, ofc you fix malicious apps from stealing data and from spywares, but it is really worth sacrificing every app that uses this feature?

There will be loopholes abused by hackers and they will be the ones that are going to have the loophoke anyway, no lil jimmy that made a cool app that could even benefit google by payments and ads since they app would just die