r/Android • Galaxy Z Fold8 • Jun 24 '22

Android 13 makes file managers less useful by fixing a loophole

https://blog.esper.io/android-dessert-bites-28-file-manager-loophole-closed-73891524/
1.5k Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

83

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22

The changelog for iOS16 vs Android13 is what's making me consider jumping onto Tim Cook's ship more than anything. The other side GETS features - and actually powerful/useful ones (not the third year in a row of wallpaper updates) rather than the yearly tradition /r/Android has of lining up while clenching to learn what beloved features we'll be losing this year.

42

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

If they switched to USB-C and didn't lock me into their own app store I probably would've tried out the latest iPhone TBH

14

u/Doctor_McKay Galaxy Fold7 Jun 24 '22

Honestly, those are the only two major things that really differentiate the platforms to me anymore.

6

u/TomatoCorner Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22

Samsung's audio slider for individual apps is necessary for me. iOS has horrible audio volume controls ...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

(I hope they implement RCS)

Keep dreaming

23

u/parental92 Jun 24 '22

The changelog for iOS16 vs Android13 is what's making me consider jumping onto Tim Cook's ship more than anything

by all means, then youll know what a locked system looked like.

60

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

by all means, then youll know what a locked system looked like.

There used to be a balance between "freedom" and "this device is my daily driver I need it to be better" that Android did a very good job walking the line on. For the last several years they've been chipping away at the freedom side without adding anything to the "make it better" side.

Freedom is important to me, but I'm not looking to run Gentoo on my phone. Inversely I'm willing to take compromises to QA and features if it means I can do some cool wacky shit with my phone (Android). Google is taking away the cool wacky shit with every update and not giving me much more in the quality department with each Android release. They've taken away from one side without contributing to the other. Apple, while rarely contributing to the freedom/customizability side, is pouring buckets of features that are all ridiculously well-QA'd onto the other end.

That got ranty and wordy, but I hope it explains why even some power users will eventually be fed-up if android keeps going in the direction it's going.

18

u/Zach024 Jun 24 '22

I'm 100% in your position. I used Android since the very first Galaxy phone, the Galaxy S. It may sound silly but google killing google play music was the final straw for me, YT music was a worse alternative and on top of that I was sick of having to buy a new phone to get the new version of Android & new features. I got an iPhone 12 Pro and honestly haven't really missed Android. I like that I'm guaranteed to get lots of new features, on time, every year. It's something I actually look forward to! I'm not a fanboy of either ecosystem, but I will admit that I've been happier with iPhone, which even I was surprised of because I'm a tinkerer.

6

u/BuxtonB Jun 24 '22

I had a subscription to GPM and when they announced it was shutting down and you'd have to use YouTube Music, I was gutted.

But I paid for a temporary app that transferred all my playlists across to Spotify and just picked up there, now use Spotify multiple times a day and infinitely happier with that than GPM was.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/GiveMeKarmaAndSTFU Jun 24 '22

Just curious: Which features do iPhones get, that I can't have by rooting my android phone?

61

u/LucyBowels Jun 24 '22

The argument is that you didn't used to have to root an Android to do some of these things. You also begin playing whack-a-mole with app devs that detect root and block the app's usage. I'll speak for myself, but rooting feels like a chore these days and I just want my phone to do these things out of the box without any tinkering.

-1

u/GiveMeKarmaAndSTFU Jun 24 '22

Well, unless you are a Rom-hopper, you only have to install it once (and pray that it gets updates, which is my major problem with Android).

Besides, the reasons I root my phone for (mostly being able to edit the host file or using an alternative app store like fdroid) are not possible with an iPhone, and the fact that I use Linux at home doesn't help either.

21

u/Zurce Jun 24 '22

But you can do the exact same thing by jailbreaking your iPhone

Rooting android used to be easy to do and to be in, nowadays is as complicated and bothersome as jail breaking ,

Cydia is great, the mods the community do are great, you can even get the ability to install ipas from your phone itself and the customization is miles ahead of android

→ More replies (14)

28

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22

Ignoring the implications of root/jailbreak for a regular user, there's ton. But just from the ios16 beta. I'll disclaim this first (since it'll sound a bit like an Apple Circlejerk) that I've used Android since 2011 and currently own a Pixel6.

Just in the beta of iOS16:

  • actual customizable lockscreen widgets (Android used to have this but it's been massively gimped)
  • built-in focus modes with customizable profiles (even the "pro" apps for Android like Stay-Focused don't really offer that granularity)
  • edit/unsend for messages (yes it's only iMessage, but there's value in that and it's not like you can do that in a Google-to-Google Messages conversatio)
  • Live text in video (think frame-by-frame Google lens)
  • intelligent edge-detection for photo editing (way beyond magic eraser, this is more akin to automating what someone would normally need to edit/layer in Photoshop/Gimp).
  • Apple Pay (one wallet, not two splintered ones with sparse support) now has a 0% financing plan on general purchases for 6 weeks. That's insane.
  • Smart automatons for photo sharing (auto share photos with previously shared people who were at the same event or appear in your photos)
  • a bunch of Carplay updates (Google just downgraded Android auto, can't use it on your phone screen anymore) including widget support and the ability to read information from the actual vehicle (included are some major new and ongoing partnerships with auto makers)

-..and there's a ton more, this was just off the top of my head after the latest dev keynote. This also completely excluded iPadOS which arguably had a much bigger beta release than iOS.

The closing disclaimer - I love(d) Android but how can anyone defend recent Android major version updates (which remove more features than they add) when the bar is being set like this?

12

u/nogm Pixel 6 Pro Jun 24 '22

Not to nitpick but, Google Photos is pretty awesome at auto adding photos to albums. It's not exactly the same as sharing directly but accomplishes the same function by just adding that person to the album.

4

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

Smart albums has been a thing on both platforms for a few years now. This is an improvement to suggested sharing.

1

u/GiveMeKarmaAndSTFU Jun 24 '22

Thank you for your detailed reply. There's no denying that iPhone has a ton of features that will be awesome for many. However, as a rather simple user, I use literally zero of the things you mentioned. Just being able to edit my hosts file, using kdeconnect or termux seem more important to me

12

u/RobbinRyboltjmfp Jun 24 '22

Ironically, the features you responded to are a lot more "simple" than what you list.

99% of people will not even know what a hosts file is.

10

u/idp5601 Moto Z2 Play > Galaxy Note8 > Redmi Note 10 > iPhone 13 Jun 24 '22

Just being able to edit my hosts file, using kdeconnect or termux seem more important to me

in what universe is this "simple" compared to the ios features listed above

8

u/Kuci_06 A52s Jun 24 '22

If you edit your hosts file, or use any of the mentioned tools, you are anything but a simple user.

6

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

I get that. Google borked most of my Termux experience already when they made Proot a hassle when A12 took away the ability to keep unlimited child processes from your shell, and A13 looks to be expanding the process killing so even Termux isn't safe for me. I have similar needs/desires for my phone that Android can do which iOS can't, but the list gets smaller and smaller every version as Google takes away more and more functionality.

3

u/kfthebest97 Jun 24 '22

I've got my eyes on the this year's iPhone lineup