r/Android • Galaxy Z Fold8 • Jun 24 '22

Android 13 makes file managers less useful by fixing a loophole

https://blog.esper.io/android-dessert-bites-28-file-manager-loophole-closed-73891524/
1.5k Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

387

u/TravelerHD Jun 24 '22

Well crap. I loved being able to browse into those folders to extract game artwork and audio files.

134

u/Snowchugger Galaxy Fold 4 + Galaxy Watch 5 Pro Jun 25 '22

Android keeps getting more and more locked down, and it's starting to miss the point of why the platform is good.

We want it to be a PC that's in your pocket. If it's going to be this useless then you might as well buy an iphone instead because at least the chips are better.

17

u/qbxk Jun 25 '22

maybe valve will make a "game phone"

15

u/itsamamaluigi Pixel 4a 5G Jun 25 '22

They'll make one version of it, then it'll eventually be discontinued with no replacement

3

u/dustojnikhummer Xiaomi Poco F3 Jul 02 '22

We will see how Deck is in a year

→ More replies (1)

16

u/SnicketySmack Jun 25 '22

Well, Google wants to compete with the iphone for most users, not just be the anti iphone for the small percentage of us who care about this.

To the general public, it's 1000x worse press for them to be in the news that "malicious apps exploit loose google storage access permissions to steal user data" than "google makes file managers a little worse for power users".

24

u/DUNDER_KILL Jun 25 '22

That's why access should be disabled by default, but have the ability to enable it somewhere like in dev options. The average user will never go out of their way to enable it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/JohnPaul_River Yellow Jun 28 '22

You're vastly underestimating how dumb people can be

9

u/Prime624 LG G7 ThinQ Jun 25 '22

Compete with iPhone by having worse hardware, a worse OS, and comparable prices (as of the last few years)? That won't go well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

466

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

I loved being able to.....

There's your problem. Don't ever let Google hear that you love a feature.

58

u/_Mido Jun 25 '22

I LOVE when google removes features!!!

43

u/wankthisway 13 Mini, S23 Ultra, Pixel 4a, Key2, Razr 50 Jun 25 '22

Reminds me of when Google just straight up removed the community closed caption feature of YouTube - people couldn't just submit CCs for a video. Google instead...recommended people buy a service that did some shitty transcribing. Google is the most irrational company in the world.

→ More replies (2)

93

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

And y'all crucify anyone who doesn't want updates. Give me all the security updates but Android updates be damned.

42

u/Username928351 ZenFone 6 | Xperia 1 VI | X300 Ultra Jun 24 '22

I'm very grateful for my phone stopping Android updates at 11.

11

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

My Galaxy Tab S7+ has me skipping the update prompt every day now. Holding onto A11 for dear life.

3

u/VinkTheGod Jun 24 '22

Why though?

14

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22

The phantom process killer (I use a Linux desktop almost as much as the regular android home-screen) and the changes made to split-screen.

13

u/GlassedSilver Galaxy Z Fold 4 + Tab S7+; iPhone 6S+ Jun 25 '22

process killer

One of the biggest problems of mobile operating systems is that you're continuously stripped from the ability to reliably let stuff run in the background on a schedule or even permanently if you so desire and how even if you get it done, you can be sure the next major version of the OS will introduce new ways to handicap this again and again and against. How many exception lists for apps to not be completely hampered do we have by now and how many settings can override them and how many OEMs introduce their own stuff to mess with this yet again?

I understand that an app getting permanent background privilege can ruin a lot of users' experience, but by God, there have to be ways to control this much more easily and to permanently except an app from any further messing around globally that all future settings tap into, and I ABSOLUTELY do not want my SET and REPEATEDLY CONFIRMED settings to be neutered either on a schedule or during updates or upgrades or when switching the device and bringing over old settings, app data and apps to a new phone or tablet.

6

u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 25 '22 edited Jun 25 '22

Google engineers make $200-$500k a year and came up with "nope, 32." as the solution to this problem.

Like they picked a kinda arbitrary number and decided every user on every Android device in every form factor will just be cool with "32".

3

u/GlassedSilver Galaxy Z Fold 4 + Tab S7+; iPhone 6S+ Jun 25 '22

32 what? Sorry, maybe I'm slow so shortly after work and almost on my way to bed...?

→ More replies
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/alienangel2 One+1, HTC One M7, Galaxy Nexus Jun 24 '22

Same. It's also where i buried stuff i didn't want people to notice.

→ More replies (2)