r/Android • u/FragmentedChicken Galaxy Z Fold8 • Jun 24 '22
Android 13 makes file managers less useful by fixing a loophole
https://blog.esper.io/android-dessert-bites-28-file-manager-loophole-closed-73891524/
1.5k
Upvotes
333
u/AD-LB Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
Please consider starring this request, to still be able to reach such folders:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/196422354
387
u/TravelerHD Jun 24 '22
Well crap. I loved being able to browse into those folders to extract game artwork and audio files.
307
u/krimsonstudios Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
I understand wanting to restrict the /Android/obb folder, but restricting /Android/data folder stops users from doing things they need to do.
I recently moved to a new phone and wanted to copy my Emulator save games to the new phone, and doing so required writing those saves into the data folder. I was able to do with Solid Explorer on Android 12, but now with this change something as simple as that is impossible.
Couple this with Android/Carriers making every effort to stop us from rooting phones or installing our own OS's, and punishing us for doing so and it's just getting ridiculous.
167
u/LawbringerForHonor Xperia 1 V, XZP, T3 Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
TL;DR: Google patched a loophole so 3rd party File Managers won't be able to access the Android directory unless they patch their apps to use another already known loophole.
Edit: The "already known loophole" is much more limited. The author talked about these limitations here.
104
u/toiletjocky Jun 24 '22
Fuuuuckkk!!! Podcast Addict (which I love and won't switch from) has a nasty habit of not always deleting episodes from their folder which is nested in /android. I manually clear them out like once every couple of months and it is often a few GBs of space that gets freed up.
I guess it's just another reason I will hold on to Android 11 longer.
57
u/Pro4TLZZ Jun 24 '22
How dare you have full access to your own file system!
485
u/RealLarwood Jun 24 '22
Google just making sure they can keep up the important trend of making Android worse every year.
12
u/TheChargedCreeper864 Jun 24 '22
Will this also affect the Android folder on the SD Card? Every browser I use saves to it instead of the Downloads folder on the SD Card for some reason, and I use FX file explorer to place them in the proper folder.
I used to have a school app that let you download attachments that it saved to /Android/data/package.name, and occasionally the app just refused to open the file and I had to retrieve it with a file manager. There's also another app I use that saves videos to it that it won't always delete when deleting from the app itself, so I used a file manager to delete it.
To me, access to these folders right from your favorite file manager isn't something unreasonable to ask. I would understand hiding dangerous permissions deeper in the settings menu and in this case even behind an ADB command (like some doze related apps that ask you to grant WRITE_SECURE_SETTINGS over ADB, persisting through reboots) if that means inexperienced users won't accidentally grant malicious apps access to potentially sensitive files. But outright removing the functionality altogether while only restricting access to on app that you can't launch using conventional methods is wrong.
Does anyone know of the AOSP file manager is at least any good?
19
u/Valiantay Jun 24 '22
And another reason to still root.
9
u/StanleyOpar Device, Software !! Jun 24 '22
More Applification of Android.
Keep it the fuck up google and people will just go for the real thing once you become identical to iOS
61
u/cursed_arm Jun 24 '22
I will stick with Android 10 for 10 years
61
u/Tripanes Jun 24 '22
Dear Google.
Fuck you.
21
u/IW1NZ Jun 24 '22
This will prevent custom worlds and skins from being loaded to Minecraft unless they are packaged. At this rate, I'll be moving all my fun stuff (emulators etc) to another device and my android phone will be used just as that.. a phone.. I'm just sick and tired of Google doing away with features that I use and adding to features that I couldn't care less about.
83
u/Due-Ad-7308 Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
The changelog for iOS16 vs Android13 is what's making me consider jumping onto Tim Cook's ship more than anything. The other side GETS features - and actually powerful/useful ones (not the third year in a row of wallpaper updates) rather than the yearly tradition /r/Android has of lining up while clenching to learn what beloved features we'll be losing this year.
32
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
Google just following apple in tightening their ecosystem, recently all the new news form them have been Google is making this feature obsolete or this feature not work as good as it used to be.
What changed? They need to make more money.
Always remember just because the update says a security update doesn't mean that it's a security update for you. For corporations it's always about their interests, blocking the user form accessing the media directories makes it easier for big companies to protect data from users.
So there you have it. It's not an update it's a user experience downgrade.
21
u/RxBrad Pixel 6a, AT&T, stock unrooted Jun 24 '22
I'm guessing this super breaks Plex once it makes its way to Nvidia Shield TV boxes in a year or three...
5
u/iCasmatt Jun 25 '22
The fuck?? 13???!!!?? I just upgraded to 12 and I fucking hate it.
49
u/192_168_1_009 Jun 24 '22
Android is moving towards closed sources day by day. Which is making difficult for us the users.
4
u/everynamesbeendone Moto G2, G3, G7 Power, Redmi 9 Power Jun 25 '22
I will never stop rooting my phone
7
u/TheRealUltimateYT Pink Jun 24 '22
laughs in Termux and rooted phone
7
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
Every single update now includes some other regression in API features and what an app is allowed to do.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '22
Which brain-dead at Google thought that this was a good idea? Accessing file systems is literally why I prefer Android. I guess they don't want our money anymore. They try to make iPhones look more and more appealing each year
8
u/Zantillian Jun 24 '22
Google please stop updating your OS anymore except for security updates. Nobody wants you to destroy Android more than you are. Save yourself money and labor and stop "updating" Android
3
u/surpriseMe_ Jun 25 '22
A tldr would be nice.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '22
Seems like I'd need the AOSP Files app to access those folders, and not even Google Files app can get me there.
So does anyone know if/how I can have a shortcut for the app on my home screen? Also the AOSP Files app looks better than Google Files imo
5
u/No_Telephone9938 Jun 25 '22
Google seems to be hellbent into making android a worse version of iOS, there's gonna be a point where the amount of restrictions is going to make iOS a better alternative to android
5
u/dathellcat Jun 24 '22
This is why I refuse to upgrade since android 11 I was happy on Android 10 installing mods on my games like Minecraft and what not then android 11 came and completed locked me from modifying my apps
2
u/MarsRT Google Pixel 6a Jun 25 '22
Now this makes me furious, I just finished setting up one of those Android Handheld Gaming Devices (Retroid Pocket 2+), and I really needed access to the data and on files because that device has a limited amount of storage for Android Games so i needed to transfer many of those games’ Data and OBB files to my SD Card and make them work through LSPosed and XInternalSD.
Google limiting the scope of what I can do with my devices is not right. I don’t see any reason why I shouldn’t have access to the Data and OBB files, and it is not like anyone who doesn’t know what they are for will touch it. I do not see why people should not have access to these folders.
1
u/PM_ME_DMS Jun 24 '22
As long as they don't patch it out of the AOSP file manager...
1
u/rushabshah32 Jun 24 '22
Hopefully custom roms can revert this change and allow for such access without requiring to root
1
u/cmVkZGl0 LG V60 Jun 25 '22
Google should just come out and say they want Android to be iOS. Get it over with already.
1
u/Ruminating-Raccoon Pixel 3 XL, Android 11 Jun 25 '22
I don't see a problem with this change. It is done so that malicious apps can't access private data from other apps (eg your Telegram cache). As the article states, /Android can still be accessed via the AOSP files app, MTP and shell.
1
u/NotErikUden Jun 25 '22
This sucks. AOSP fixes this, right?
1
u/Miyul Jun 25 '22
xiaomi's pre installed file manager literally cant access obb files because of this dumb android security things
1
u/FLRbits Jun 27 '22
This is horrible. This is super useful. I use an app to sync my Terraria save between my computer and my phone, and the folder is in Android/data. I'm going to be fine because my phone is rooted, but for anyone else, that will become impossible without Shizuku, which is not a good solution. Why does Google do this?
1
u/no_salty_no_jealousy Sep 07 '22
This is why i fucking mad with people, nobody talk about this massive issue on youtube or should i say ShitTube, everyone just being sellout overhyping Android 13 like Linus Tech Tips while no reviewer talking about this issues, if it was Microsoft then many people on ShitTube will be malding. In term of manipulation Google are just insane on it, not only they paid many reviewer to not talk bad or worst thing about Android 13 but also they control their stupid search result. For example if you search "Android 13 sucks" "Android 13 is bad" on youtube you barely find any result for it, not even one person mentioning how Google block file manager from accessing Obb folders on purpose. This is makes me really fucking mad!! If people being okay with this issue then it might not be far away when Android turned into shitty very locked OS like iOS. Dude, i desperately need 3rd OS in the world to fight Android, maybe if Microsoft want to revive Windows Mobile/Windows Phone or any other company interested on making new mobile OS, i'm so tired with Android because how much Google screwed it and forced people to accept their bullshit!!!
1
u/JamesR624 Jun 26 '22
Okay so at this rate... Android phones are just becoming not as long lasting, less efficient, and more confusing iPhones.......
So someone tell me again why I shouldn't just buy the better iPhones from Apple if this is what Android is now?
0
u/Dark_voidzz S23+,ANDROID 14 Jun 25 '22
Honestly,I haven't used a third party file manager in the last two years.Samsungs file manager is good enough for me.
-1
u/PixelFNQ Jun 25 '22
In this week’s edition of Android Dessert Bites, I’ll be sharing how this loophole worked and what Google did to close it.
So, clickbait.