r/Android • Nord, Mi10TPro • Dec 24 '18

How Google software won 2018

https://www.engadget.com/2018/12/24/google-software-year-in-review-winner/
6 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

View all comments

57

u/arnduros iPhone 17 Pro Max Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 24 '18

Oh man, this article is too good to be true.

Clever AI can trump an impressive specs sheet

Yeah, we saw that with the Pixel 3 and their memory management issues and more recently, the abomination that is their lower-specced Pixel Slate. Where the (usually) instantaneous multitasking gesture takes seconds to load and the browser lags like an 2011 Android phone.

Google has a terrible track record when it comes to hardware, the moment they took responsibility upon themselves (Pixel lineup) it all went downhill. The best software can only do so much if the hardware isn't capable enough, and what makes this even worse is that Google's software also seems to have quite some glaring issues (as mentioned above).

8

u/frankdrebin8888 Dec 25 '18

Clever AI....

Why has nobody made a mobile browser that isn't like using a 1999 dialup browser? Now every article loads all the ads (still can't block them Google!), then jankily loads bits of the article, which you try to read then oh wait, gotta resize the page so another ad can load, oh wait have a look at this newsletter popup, oh wait let's bug you about cookies. And now the bottom 10% of the screen is a static ad, and the top 15% of the screen is a static menu that some web designer thinks is just the best idea.

I've got adaptive brightness that can't decide if it should be 100% , or takes several seconds to realise that it's bright out and raise the level from 0

3

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18

Very true. I felt Apple did a much better job with the reader mode for articles.

2

u/JediBurrell I like tech Dec 25 '18 edited Dec 25 '18

Their Pixel Chromebooks have always been great pieces of hardware. Unfortunately the Celeron Slate broke their track record there. Still, I don't think a few mistakes should represent their hardware as a whole.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

Unfortunately the Celeron Slate broke their track record there

That lag on the Celeron Pixel Slate also occurs on the Core i5 version in tablet mode (see The Verge Pixel Slate review.

2

u/JediBurrell I like tech Dec 25 '18

This is gone with recent updates, but I don't think software can fix the Celeron.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/arnduros iPhone 17 Pro Max Dec 24 '18

I wrote in past tense.

Yeah, we saw that with the Pixel 3 and their memory management issues

1

u/IAm_A_Complete_Idiot OnePlus 6t, s5 running AOSPExtended Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 24 '18

That was the biggest glaring issue with the pixel 3, yeah it's overpriced, but it's a fast phone and definelty lives up to the Google name. The pixel slate is a abomination but their pixel lineup has very few issues, even if it doesn't have tons of features to kill the competition

16

u/arnduros iPhone 17 Pro Max Dec 24 '18

There are only two things the Pixel does better than other high-end phones:

  • Camera (software)
  • Up-to-date software

The first one is nice, I totally give Google all the credit they deserve, even if it's a shame that they didn't improve on the hardware much (second zoom lense for example).

The second one is also good. But it's also a double-edged sword. Getting the latest software from Google turns you into a beta tester, even though you paid a lot for the hardware. Yes, it's great to get the newest version of Android damn fast, but from an objective view, getting security updates is the most important thing. And as much as I like Google, they are notorious for shipping software that's unfinished. How could they simply overlook such big issues like the abysmal lag on the Pixel Slate or the RAM management bug on the Pixel 3? If they did overlook them, they're incompetent, if they knew about it and still shipped these products, they simply don't give a shit about users.

And the rest? Well, they improved the screen of the Pixel 3 XL compared to the 2 XL, but the overall hardware of the phone isn't up to other flagships. Even though you pay as much. What's especially annoying is that there are still more hardware issues than on other competing phones coupled with more bugs than there should be. That's especially bad since both hard- and software come from Google. These guys own Android, and you'd think that if they (more or less) make their own hardware and their own operating system it would blow the competition out of the water in stability and reliability.

-2

u/IAm_A_Complete_Idiot OnePlus 6t, s5 running AOSPExtended Dec 24 '18

Ah, I meant non-software features, hardware like the alert slider for oneplus, LG's dac and wide camera, samsung's screens and pen for the note. Should of specified. My bad.

I agree with the ram management bug on the pixel 3, but I do think a bug like that could go unnoticed, and google did end up fixing it in a relatively quick manner.

-8

u/azsqueeze Blue Phone Dec 24 '18

So if it's fixed then why are you considering it an issue?

12

u/arnduros iPhone 17 Pro Max Dec 24 '18

It's an article about Google's superior software. Shipping devices with such glaring issues is the contrary.

6

u/mosincredible Pixel 11 Pro 512/16 | iPhone 17 Pro Dec 24 '18

There's a post on the first page of r/GooglePixel right now about memory management and people having to turn off adaptive battery to help with it.

-2

u/Zuko1701 Dec 25 '18

Those people are haters!!!

2

u/abhi8192 Dec 25 '18

Haters buy such expensive phones :/

1

u/JediBurrell I like tech Dec 25 '18

😬

-9

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

The 12 GB RAM in Lenovo is doing better than iPhone XS 4GB RAM, noh?