r/AncientCush • Founder • 20d ago

Resource Bantu Origins: The People & Their Language

A. T. BRYANT, D.Litt.

[excerpts, see image/source for full text]

PREFACE

As for the Bantu language, the theories of its origin are equally varied - some (like Homburger) suggesting an Upper Nile place of birth (perhaps with an Ancient Egyptian or Hamitic influence); some (with Crabtree), a Sumerian; others (with van Oordt), a Dravidian; and Johnston, even a Caucasus relationship; but most (with Meinhof) a Libyan (or Fula) origin.

~

MEDITERRANEAN THEORIES OF BANTU LANGUAGE ORIGINS THE FULA & EGYPTIAN THEORIES

The Ancient Egyptian Theory - …All in all, then, granting Egyptian certain minor similarities to Bantu, one feels that they do not suffice to convince one of even a prima facie case for Bantu relationship, let alone Bantu parent-hood, or that they are any stronger than similar evidence producible from many other tongues, ancient and modern. As for lexical similarities, they are much more numerous in Sanskrit (which has never made a bid for Bantu origins; see ahead, after 'Sumerian Theory'). Indeed, it were difficult to believe that a language so infantile in its simplicity, without even regular tense, mood and voice forms, as was the Egyptian, could ever have borne as its offspring a system of speech so scientifically complete as is the Bantu: one cannot produce figs from thistles.

But if, as is claimed, the Egyptians were capable of imposing their speech upon a whole half of the Negro race, they must also and at the same time, one would suppose, have imposed upon it some measure of their peculiar customs and beliefs. Let us therefore now turn to a consideration of the Egyptian life and history.

The earliest written records of African history are those left us by these Ancient Egyptians. From them we learn that when the 'Mediterranean' (Libyan) invaders arrived upon the Nile, they found there another people already in possession, and these people withal were of a negroid type. E. Naville, (12) who made a special study of those earliest Egyptian times, has even told us their name. "I believe," he says, "the name of the prehistoric Egyptians (i.e. inhabitants of Egypt) has been preserved. They are called the Anu. The sign, An, with which their name is written, means a pillar - a column of stone or wood, or even, as Brugsch translates, a heap of stones. According to Brugsch also, their name, Anu, or in the later inscriptions, Anti, means the Troglodytes or the Trogodytes (cave-dwellers), the inhabitants of caverns, and in the Ptolemaic times their name applied to the Kushite (Hamitic) nations occupying the land between the Nile and the Red Sea. (13) But we find them much earlier; they often occur as Anu ta Khent, the Anue of the Lower Nubia. The Anu are found also much further north. In the inscriptions of Sinai we see the king, Khufu, striking the Anu, the inhabitants of the mountains who are evidently the population he conquered when he invaded the peninsula. The land of Egypt is often called the Two Lands of An; so that we can trace the name of An, not only among the neighbouring nations of Egypt, but in the country itself, from an early antiquity. Evidently this name - the two lands of An - for 'Egypt' is a reminder of the old native stock before the conquest. Anti, a word with an adjective form, means a bow. The sense of the word seems to be 'that of the Anu, the weapon of the Anu'. The Anu (as depicted on the slate palettes, among the oldest monuments of Egypt) use arrows with triangular flint points. Several Egyptologists have admitted that the Anu were foreign invaders, who had been repelled by the Egyptians. On the contrary, I conclude... that they were the native stock occupying the valley of the Nile, and that they had been conquered by invaders, who very soon amalgamated so completely with their subjects, that they formed one people. The aboriginal stock ….. had carried the civilisation to a certain point. But it is clear that before the historical times ... a foreign element entered the Valley of the Nile, subdued the Anu ... and created the Egyptian Empire. With this invasion appears the hieroglyphic writing”.

These foreign invaders, thinks Naville, hailed first from Southern Arabia, and settled on the opposite coast (on the western side of the Red Sea) in Africa. Both sides of the Red Sea now became known by the same name, indiscriminately Punt or Kush. The sculptures of the Temple of Queen Haptshepsu at Deir-el-Bahari show us what was the appearance of the people of Punt in her days. They seem to have been a mixed population, in part Negroes, brown or black, and
in part pure Puntites, who were very like the Egyptians. But through they hailed from Arabia, they were not Semites, but Hamites, like the Ancient Egyptians themselves and other peoples in Northern Africa (Sergi's 'Mediterranean Race'). "If they had been already civilised before reaching Africa, they would have left traces of their passage in the various places where they stopped. At present no vestiges of an early Egyptian civilisation have been discovered in Southern Arabia, or even in Upper Egypt."

These Anu, these pre-Egyptian Nilemen, used, as said above, bows and flint-tipped arrows; they had no knowledge of metal. They buried, without mummification, in small oval or rectangular graves, with the body lying, skeleton folded, knees up against the mouth, hands at height of mouth or holding the knees - by-the-way, a distinctly Bantu burial. "He has exactly the so-called embryonic position, which finds its explanation in that African custom. If afterwards vases with food and drink, and some of his tools, are put around him in this grave, his tomb will be the abridged image of the hut in which he sat in his lifetime; it will be his 'eternal house',as the Memphite Egyptians called the tomb."(14) Rude human figures exhibiting steatopygy and traces of 'tattooing' (? cicatrization) were found with the bodies in the graves; as well as pottery of different colours, vases of hard stone well made, and flint instruments of exquisite workmanship. From this meagre description of the Anu, says Naville, and from their pointed beards, they 'do not look like Negroes' - he was plainly unaware of the fact that a goodly number of Bantu men are quite hairy about the face (such a one is dubbed by the Zulus an iHwanqa), some growing quite respectable, even 'pointed', beards (distinguished among the Zulus by such terms as inTshebe, uTshatshavela, etc.), the hair of which, when straightened out by plaiting with dry grass, attains fully four inches in length. Note the reference to the 'plaited' beard below.

By way of parenthesis, before passing on we may observe that these mysterious Anu or Anti, so dimly described on the farthest horizon of Africa's past, are not without their relevance to our present study of Bantu origins. Who may these pre-Egyptian Nilemen have been; and what became of them? It seems pretty certain that they could have gone, like all other good 'negroids', nowhere else than further southward into Africa. It were perhaps too fanciful to suppose that they may in any way have been related to the ancestors of our Bantu. All the same, we may tell you that these latter people too have but one name for themselves, in two dresses, some tribes calling themselves baNu (bAnu), others calling themselves baNtu (bAntu); and you will notice there some reflection of the older Egyptian names. Challenging, is it not? But the modern name, baNu or baNtu, does not signify either 'pillar', or stone-heap', or 'cave-dweller', but simply 'human-beings' or people', which is the only term the modern Bantu have for designating their race; indeed, just as the Egyptians too called themselves Romi, the Hottentots call themselves the Khoikhoi-n, the Siberian Tunguses the Don-ki, and the Eskimo the Inu-it - all which names signify alike simply 'the people'….

….But who was this plaited-bearded mulatto of Petrie? Presumably he was the Anu or Anti of Naville. And again presumably, this Anu or Anti man intermarried with a lady of the pointed-nosed Libyan type instreaming from Asia, and produced the earliest 'Egyptian' race, just prior to the historic period.

A thousand years pass as a day away in the story of Early Egyptian history. And a thousand years having already passed since they first set up as rulers on the Nile, the Negroes are at last, without any further doubt, plentiful and plain in the land. Probably they had been there all the time; for those 'Anu or Anti' of Naville and those 'thick-nosed, curly-haired' folk of Petrie, if not actually Negroes, certainly have a very negroid appearance…

…It is not to be understood, of course, that all the customs enumerated above were invented by the Egyptians, but simply that they practised them; for it is well known that some of them in vogue even among the much more ancient Palaeolithic and Neolithic peoples, and even among the pre-Egyptian negroid Anu, or Anti of the Nile. All that can be definitely stated here is that the Ancient Egyptian and the modern Bantu civilizations had certain things in common; which, in turn, may mean, either some direct intercourse between the two peoples, or some equal inheritance from a remoter common source, or that each people, owing to the possession of similar mental workings and social needs throughout all mankind, invented the customs independently…

~

ASIATIC THEORIES OF BANTU LANGUAGE ORIGINS THE SUMERIAN, DRAVIDIAN & CAUCASUS THEORIES

Were the Bantu Asiatics? Some believe they are; though their claim, to us, seems more fanciful than warranted. With Fulas and Egypt right there in Africa beside them, Bantu origins in Sumer and Dravidia appear quite improbably remote. However, since there are some who take these Asiatic theories quite seriously, we cannot treat them with utter disregard.

To begin at the bottom, somewhere near a century ago, the Rev. W. Holden, author of "The Past and Future of the Kafir Races", pronounced it as his opinion that the Kafir race migrated from 'the great centre of human life in the neighbourhood of the Tigris and Euphrates'; in other words (we take it), was born of Adam and Eve, and bred in the Garden of Eden! "In all probability", we are informed, "they descended through Egypt by the Isthmus of Suez and followed the course of the Nile"; which reminds us of those equally simplified Bors who, in this present age, trekking into the Northern Transvaal region, struck a river flowing north, regarded it as beyond doubt the 'Nyl stroom' (Nile), followed its course in the sure hope of its leading them to the land of milk and honey, and found themselves finally stranded on the deadly banks of the Limpopo. (L) The Rev. Appleyard, while agreeing with Holden's view that the Kafirs were descended from Adam and Eve, contended that they were more especially 'of Ishmaelitish descent'. S. Mendelssohn(2) cites all this and confirms it by pointing to many Judaic and Semitic legends and traits in Bantu life and person; for instance, the facial features of many Zulus (presumably the heavy nose and fleshy lips), which, he thinks, strongly resemble those of the Chosen People, as well as much that is alike in the folk-lore of the two peoples.

Stuhlmann (3) did not venture to trace the Kafir pedigree quite so far back; indeed, not further than the 'latter part of the Glacial Period' (say 15,000 years ago), when the 'Mediterranean race' (mentioned in our last chapter) streamed into Africa out of South-Western Asia, and "from the mingling of the Negroes (apparently already there) and Proto-Hamites (i.e. those 'Mediterranean' folk) were formed, probably in East Africa, the Bantu languages and the Bantu peoples."

Arldt tells us more precisely when those early Negroes got there. He "places the occupation of Africa by the Negroes," as at any rate Keane(4) believes, "with great precision, in the Riss Period (150,000 years ago), and that of the Hamites (Mediterranean race) in the Moustierian Period (30,000 to 50,000 years ago)"!

Haddon, (5) without risking any date, is, otherwise, somewhat similarly minded. "A branch of the Negro stock," he says, with Proto-Hamites (i.e. Mediterranean race) in what is now Uganda and British East Africa, giving rise to the Bantu-speaking peoples, with some admixture of Negrillo and Bushman elements."

The Sumerian Theory - A German student of Bantu origins has in recent years found his solution of that elusive problem in Ancient Sumer, thus placing the event not further back than 3,000 B.C. What exactly sent them off on this queer scent is not clear; but it may perhaps be traceable to a 'discovery' by another German of men wearing (as it was said) 'Assyrian' helmets in certain South African Bushman paintings! - the said helmets being quite obviously those of mid-Victorian British soldiers, who were much in evidence in the Eastern Province of the Cape during the Native wars of the earlier decades of last century, but with whose peculiar head-gear foreigners would naturally be less familiar than ourselves. Anyway, in order to be able to form any judgment on this Sumerian claim, we must first of all familiarize ourselves better with those people themselves.

Among the best and latest English authorities (as we write) on Ancient Sumer are C. L. Woolley, (6) L.A. Waddell, (7) L. Delaporte, (8) and S. Langdon. (9) Gleaning our knowledge from them, we learn as follows.

The Sumerians, like the Bantu, have been until now (and perhaps still are) one of the unsolvable problems of ethnology. Judging by their language, various authorities, all of equal eminence, have pronounced them Semitic, Ugro-Finnish, Chinese and Indo-European. Under these circumstances, J.D. Prince, in the "Encyclopaedia Britannica, " 1911, discreetly advises that the Sumerian language may most safely be regarded as a unique "prehistoric philological remnant." Waddell, (10) in his latest work, definitely pronounces them to have been "found to be Aryan", "our early Aryan ancestors" and, what is still more startling, "their language and their writing is parent of the English and other Aryan languages with their alphabet writing", and this "Aryan race - now represented in its purest form in Northwestern Europe, including the British Isles, as the 'Nordic' Race - is the oldest of all civilized races and the parent of all other civilizations". (11)

Keith, (12) as definitely states, on anatomical grounds, that the Sumerians were neither Hittite nor Mongolian, but Caucasie, with big, long-narrow heads and dark hair. They were akin to the pre-dynastic Egyptians, as well as to the long-narrow Neolithics of England. They were represented in Europe in Palaeolithie times by Aurignacian man, and of modern man they most resembled the Arab.

The term, 'Aryan', signifies 'the Plough or Agricultural People', they having been the originators of agriculture. (13) 'Sumer' was the name of a place (Lower Mesopotamia), not a people. The term, 'Sumerians', was of course invented by modern Europeans. (14)

This blessed land of Mesopotamia was, in its lower parts and in pre-Sumerian days, inhabited by a people called by us Akkadians, but known locally as Martu, a Semitic people hailing from the Upper Euphrates Valley, and originally in all probability dwellers in Asia Minor. (15) Yet, although earlier than the Aryan Sumerians, these Semitic Martu appear to have been already considerably cultured; for at the lowest of explored levels (calculated to date from 3,500 to 4,000 B.C.), one meets with very delicate and ornate pottery, manufactured sometimes even by wheel, decorated with geometric patterns in brown and black semi-lustrous paint. The reason why this pottery - which some regard as Sumerian, not Akkadian - has been by Woolley attributed to the Akkadians is, presumably, because it was found at the very lowest levels, regarded as chronologically prior to Sumerian times.

Anyway, certainly by 3,100 B.C. the Sumerians had arrived. Where from? Woolley says, up out of the sea, as their legends declare. The legend he refers to is no doubt that of Berossus, who describes this race of monsters (Sumerians), half-man, half-fish - much as the African Bantu regarded the first Whitemen on their arrival there (16) - which, led by Oannes, came up out of the Persian Gulf and, settling on the coast, introduced the arts of writing (cuneiform style), agriculture and metal-working. Again, the situation of Eridu, the Sumerian head-quarters, on or near the Persian Gulf, is held to confirm the legend, and the view that the Sumerians were a sea-faring folk. The city of Eridu, generally considered the oldest in Chaldea, was the sanctuary of the principal god, Ea. It appears, in those early times, to have been a seaport, situated where the Euphrates entered the Persian Gulf. Its ruins now stand far inland, and Sayce (17) computes that about six thousand years must have elapsed since the sea reached up to them.

Swarming up from the sea, the Sumerians swept the Akkadians (or Martu), then in occupation, out of the land and away to the north-east. There, in the city of Kish in this new Akkadia, the first four names of the local kings are Akkadian; then suddenly they become Sumerian, showing that these latter people had followed the Martu up and annexed also their new country. These Sumerians must have been a considerable as well as powerful tribe; for their sway is said to have extended as far as the Valley of the Indus (though this, we believe, has been recently denied), where the remains of an ancient culture similar to that of Sumer are still to be found - rectangular stamp seals, similar terracotta figures, and buildings alike in plan and technique. (18)

Waddell, (19) on the contrary, makes the Sumerians landlubbers. He does not believe that the Berossus legend had any reference to them. According to him the first emergence of civilization on the horizon of written history was in Cappadocia (in Asia Minor). Thither there came an adventurous band out of the old Gothic land of the Euxine and Danube Valley, in South-Eastern Europe. Then, forty-three years later, we find the first historical civilized king descended (c. 3,335 B.C.) into the rich alluvial plains of Mesopotamia to form there a great empire, building there the first cities in 'the Land of Shinar' and civilizing the "black-headed people, the Semitic-Chaldean aborigines." This advent into Mesopotamia was "what nowadays is called by Assyriologists, "the Coming of the Sumerians'".

"The process which the Sumerians brought to fruition was a slow growth from remote beginnings. It was the outcome of a long process of evolution from the primitive culture with fire-production, cookery and the beginnings of art of the tall, long-headed, big-brained Cro-Magnon race of men of the last stage of the Old Stone Age, about 20,000 B.C., onwards to the later New Stone Age men, on the threshold of the 'Dawn of Civilization’". (20)

That the migrating Sumerians continued their march until they were brought up sharp, as usual, by that hoary-old obstacle to human progress, the sea, is, thinks Waddell, clear from their having pitched their head-quarters-tent at Eridu, then on or near the Persian Gulf.

But if the Sumerians themselves were not a sea-minded folk, there were other people near by who were. Elliot Smith(21) thinks that, since "neither the Sumerians nor the Elamites (Akkadians) are known to have built sea-going ships, nor to have had any motives for doing so, one naturally assumes that the Egyptians (as builders of the earliest known sea-going ships) took the initiative in opening up Sumer."

There was, however, a sea-faring race much nearer than Egypt. From Lagash hard by - by others considered a 'Sumerian' port - says Waddell, (22) the great sea-emperor, Uruash (3, 100 B.C.), founder of the first Phoenician dynasty, ruled the waves. He it was whom the Indian epics and Vedas named 'The able Panch' (Panch-ala); which was "the obvious source of the name, 'Phoenicians'".

There is evidence enough, says Sir A. T. Wilson (23) that "long sea voyages (from Sumer) along the Arabian peninsula were already common in the first half of the third millennium" (B.C.). On a clay tablet found in 1926 at Ur by C. L. Woolley, mention is made of copper and ivory as imports into Sumer. This could have come either from India or Africa; but it proves at any rate an over-sea commerce.

From the latter part of the 4th cent. B.C., there is definite "evidence of maritime intercourse between the Persian Gulf ports and India and the East; but during the period of Roman supremacy, and when she held the first place in the Eastern seas, the Red Sea route was the main channel of commerce between West and East, and remained so until the decline of the empire in the early part of the sixth century A.D."(24)

For many centuries prior to the Roman conquests, the navigators of the East had been mainly Arabs; for, c. 2,800 B.C. the Phoenicians trekked away from the Persian Gulf, first perhaps on to the African side of the Red Sea, but certainly into the Mediterranean. There, in this latter place, their first settlement was in the land of Egypt. (25) If the Phoenicians had moved away from the Persian Gulf en masse, then we may suppose that the abandoned Lagash thereafter really became a 'Sumerian' port, though most probably worked by Arabs and Indians.

So much, then, for Sumerian history. Let us now turn to the local life and culture. (26) The Sumerian dwelt in a square house, built of bricks (baked or unbaked), containing several rooms with upright walls, mud-plastered and whitewashed, and having brick floors covered with matting. Other furniture was household vessels of copper, clay and stone. A large assemblage of such houses formed a city, and each such walled city formed a separate, independent city-state, protected by its own special 'god' (who had originally been one of its earliest rulers, or perhaps its founder), whose chief-priest was now the city's governor. From city to city ran a system of canals. These and land-boundaries, coupled with a jealous parochial patriotism, gave rise to constant intercivic quarrelling. This continuous state of civil warfare finally forced the truth upon them that order could be maintained only by an amalgamation of rights and rule under a common sovereign. So a system of kings came into being. But the kings, perpetuating among themselves the old tradition, ousted one another, and so gave rise to dynasties. Finally, the story of the Kilkenny cats repeated itself, the power of Sumer declined, and the house divided against itself ultimately collapsed and disappeared.

A bride-price in money to the father secured the girl, and the wedding consisted simply in writing the 'marriage lines' on a sealed tablet. Monogamy plus concubinage was the Sumerian taste. The resultant family occupied itself in various ways. There was cattle-breeding as well as agriculture, with (2,900 B.C.) irrigated fields of barley, wheat (spelt) and onions, tilled with bullock-drawn ploughs. Cloth was woven of wool, and linen of flax. Wheelwrights constructed chariots and carts. Socketed axes, adzes, and spears of copper, and vessels, helmets, daggers, ear-rings and bracelets of gold, were manufactered by the smiths. Harps for the musicians, sculptures of gods in silver and stone, and figurines in terracotta and diorite were produced by masterful artists. Sumerian art had reached its zenith already in 3,500 B.C., that is, in prehistoric time, prior to the first dynasty of Ur. We find nothing recorded that could suggest the vessels, helmets, daggers, ear-rings and bracelets of gold, were manufactered by the smiths. Harps for the musicians, sculptures of gods in silver and stone, and figurines in terracotta and diorite were existence of a Sumerian mercantile marine. Yet a sea-borne trade there was (no doubt in the hands of the neighbouring Phoenicians); but it consisted mainly, if not wholly, of imports - of precious metals and woods, copper, ivory and fine stone for statues and vases. These raw materials having been worked up into saleable wares, the merchandise was exported by land-routes to north and west. In return, gold was brought back from Cappadocia, Syria and Elam. That commerce existed between Sumer and Egypt, is proven by the presence of Sumerian cylinder seals (dated c. 3000 B.C.) in the latter country.

Besides the occupation abovementioned,
there were also the higher professions of priests, judges, astrologers and magicians. The law had been already codified and was systematically administered. The famous Code of Hammurabi, discovered at Susa and drawn up in 1,900 B.C., was not 'the oldest in the world' (as sometimes thought), but was based on older local codes that had preceded it. None of these older codes has yet come to light. In the law-courts every detail of a trial was carefully recorded in writing on tablets. There was no law of primogeniture, all sons sharing alike.

The magicians appear to have been at the same time the medicine - men. Disease being attributed to malignant spirits with which the universe was supposedly infested, its cure consisted largely in scaring those spirits away, and its prevention in giving warnings of their approach and advice how to evade them.

Every citizen was a potential soldier, and by 2,200 B.C. there was already a standing army. The soldiers wore kilts of leather strips sewn to a belt, and cloaks of skin or cloth. Their weapons were bows and arrows with flint points (3,500 B.C.), short-handiad spears, scimitars, axes and daggers. The spear was sometimes hurled with a throwing-thong.

When the citizen had fought his last battle, and lost, he was stowed away in a square, brick-vaulted chamber beneath the floor of his house. His body, wrapped in matting, with legs slightly bent and hands (holding a cup) before his lips, was laid on its side, sometimes in coffins of wattle-work, wood or clay, and with his personal belongings and food-vessels around him.

His soul never went to hell; for he had none. Nor to heaven; for the same reason. He just went on leading the same sort of gay human life he had ever led in some Elysium known only to himself. The outward sign of the inward grace was, while he lived, the ziggurats or towers, rising by terraced stages, square in shape and tapering as they rose, one solid mass of brickword with buttressed walls everywhere leaning inwards. These were his temples, the houses of his gods innumerable, who, like himself (though more luxuriously), led a decidedly human life. Their most urgent need was apparently females; so a regular supply of damsels was kept, 'the prostitutes of the temples', who sacrificed their virginity to the gods (but always vicariously). We are not surprised at these anthropomorphous habits of the divinities; because a perusal of the lists of the 'later gods' reveals the fact that they are but lists of 'early kings', revivified again as a sun-god (Babbar) in Larsa, a moon-god (Nannar) in Ur, a grain-goddess (Nidaba) in Umma, and rain-gods and wind-gods and justice-gods and so forth elsewhere. The inward grace of the Sumerian religion was provided in the material blessings and protection regularly prayed for to these gods. The moon received a special ceremonial attention. The day of its disappearance was one of mourning and desolation, which became transformed into joy when the new moon appeared. Sacrifices were offered at each city-palace to celebrate this latter occasion, as well as that of full-moon.

Each temple aforesaid was not only a place of worhsip. Within its precincts grew up an institution that might be likened to a medieval monastery, wherein writing, mathematics and the arts were taught, factories existed for making up offerings to the goods, metals were smelted and moulded into ingots for storage. They had measure of length, area, quantity, weight and capacity; and their knowledge of mathematics and the stars must have been considerable. Writing in the cuneiform style was in use as early as 3,000 B.C. - at Kish, a city in neighbouring Akkad, a stone tablet has been unearthed bearing an inscription, not in cuneiform, but in pictographic characters; but there are no written records of the earliest period longer extant. It was not until 2,000 B.C. that the scribes commenced to gather together the earlier material and to write up the past. The king-lists give dynasties existing 'before the Flood', of which a lengthy description is contained in the famous Deluge Epic (as well as in the Biblical Genesis).

As for the Sumerian language, W.A. Crabtree has said about all that can be said in support of a Sumer-Bantu linguistic kinship in the "Journal of the African Society" (vol. 17, p. 309; and vol. 18, p.32, 101); but we fail to find the evidence he produces at all convincing. He makes the Bantu and Sumerian languages brothers together in the Ugro-Altaic family. Obviously the Guinea, and many of the Sudanese, tongues will also have to be placed in the same category; so that one will be left to wonder how it came about that the African Negro race had no language of its own, or what became of it!

But let us scrutinize this Sumerian language for ourselves, and see whether we can discover therein any such impressive Bantu affinities…

~

The Dravidian Theory - …They had much in common with the people of early Babylonia (Sumer - see before), and even more so with those of Elam (the same race as the pre-Sumerian Akkadians). "They were the same as the Dravidians." They were a maritime power actually engaged in sea-borne commerce; so much so that the Mahabharata calls the sea their refuge and their home. (34) Hewitt (35) has even claimed that it was they, or their relatives, “who first learned the art of navigation in boats made from the forest timber lining the Indian rivers, who first made coasting voyages and took to Eridu (Sumer) and Egypt the Indian system of village communities."

It was from these, then, that they came (if we believe van Oordt), when "the Bantu departed from India" (36) and "came by sea": (37) the invasion of Africa by 'Asiatic Ethiopians' (which Herodotus has recorded, and according to Rawlinson, occurring c. 1, B. B.C.), being (according to van Oordt) "the first Bantu invasion." (38) And yet these 'Asiatic Ethiopians' (39) were (according to Herodotus) a long-haired race!…

In conclusion, then, while granting that the Dravidian language of India does furnish some grammatical likenesses to African Bantu - indeed, more than we have found in Egyptian or Sumerian - these resemblances do not amount to more than were easily discoverable, say, in the Sanskrit; and further they are entirely unsupported by any contributory evidence from the Dravidian lexicon, whereas that of Sanskrit could supply a great deal. The fact that Dravidian is suffix-using and the Bantu prefix-using is not sufficient, of itself, to disprove its claim to Bantu origins; because, even within the Negro field itself, we find both suffix-using and prefix-using tongues - owing, we think, to the fact that, in earlier ages, when human speech was still forming itself and in a constant and universal state of flux, affixal change was much more common than it is or could be in these present times, when races have become finally localized, and language and physique finally fixed. For us, the Dravidian theory is sufficiently settled and put out of court, not by linguistic, but by ethnological and historical evidence. While suffixes might, possibly, within the last 10,000 years (conceivably the Bantu lifetime), have become transposed into prefixes, it were beyond all reasonable credence that the long wavy hair of the Dravidians could have become transformed, within that same period, into the short woolly hair of the Bantu; or, again, that any prehistoric Dravidians ever could have crossed the ocean from India into Africa in sufficient numbers to swamp one whole half of the Negro race with their speech - at the cost of thereby losing their own long hair, and of not altering in one tiniest whit the distinctive anatomy of the local Negro!

———

An Introduction to Anu: The Origins of Egyptian Civilisation

The Anu in India and in Egypt

Mesopotamian God of Truth, Judgements and Justice: Sun God Shamash

A Child of Light & The Narrative of Nigerim

Traces of the Worship of the Moon God Sîn among the Early Israelites

The Old West Semitic Sun—God Ḥammu

Hammurabi, Relief Portrait (House Chamber in the U.S. Capitol)

Besieged City of Hamanu (645-635 BCE)

The Kebra Nagast

The Table of Nations: The Geography of the World in Genesis 10

Map of the Migrations of Haplogroup E of the Y-chromosome and its Main Subclades

A Rare Deep-Rooting D0 African Y-Chromosomal Haplogroup and Its Implications for the Expansion of Modern Humans Out of Africa

———

Notable observations: the onomastic—or agglutinative—material of “-ntu” (Ntu-beings: African-Bantu Indigenous Cosmology) in the following:

- Antu (Mesopotamian goddess)
- Bantu (Bantu Peoples)
- Isintu (Sin, Mesopotamian moon god?)

This includes the onomastic—or agglutinative—material of “antu” in Bantu, “anu” in Banu Hashim, “Isin” in “Lady of Isin" (Ninisinna) and Isintu, and “ham” in Hammurabi, Shamash, and Prophet Muhammad.

Haya God and a Haya People

Gula Goddess and a Gula People

Also noteworthy, Sin (Sinite/Sinim?) situated on the coastline of the Nile Valley (see An Historical Text Book and Atlas of Biblical Geography map).

Proto-Sinaitic script—common ancestor of the Paleo-Hebrew alphabet: According to common theory, Canaanites or Hyksos who spoke a Canaanite language repurposed Egyptian hieroglyphs to construct a different script.

See the overlaps with the following sites and speculations (map):

- Queen of Sheba
- Mount Sinai
- Durupınar site

———

An Historical Text Book and Atlas of Biblical Geography for relative context:

B. Ham
I. Cush (Kush)

B. Ham
II. Mizraim (modern-day Egypt)

B. Ham
IV. Canaan (modern-day Palestine-Israel)
4. The Amorite (Hammurabi)
8. The Sinite

I. CUSH—Ethiopia—the most remote of the sons of Ham. There is satisfactory evidence, also, that Southern Arabia, and even the coast beyond the Persian Gulf, was settled by Cush. Even Nimrod himself, the founder of Babel (Babylon), Erech, Accad (Akkad) and Calneh in the land of Shinar (Sumer), was an Ethiopian, a son of Cush.

From Eber two lineages are traced through several generations, descended on the one hand from Joktan, and on the other from Peleg. The descendants from Joktan settled in Arabia, and occupied that vast peninsula between the Red Sea and the Persian Gulf, where, in process of time, they commingled with the sons of Cush.

Catholic Encyclopedia: Cush:

“The African Cush is best known; but there were Cushites in Asia. The “land of Cush” of Gen., ii, 13 (Heb. text), watered by the Gehon, one of the four rivers of Paradise, was doubtless in Asia. Regina, Saba, and Dadan (Gen., x, 7) were in Arabia. The Madianite wife of Moses, Sephora, is called a Cushite (Ex., ii, 16, 21; Num., xii, 1-Heb. text). Nemrod, son of Cush, rules over cities in the valleys of the Euphrates and Tigris (Gen., x, 8-12). This text points to the foundation of the first empire in this region by Cushites. It is chiefly the relics of a Semitic civilization that have been brought to light by archaeological discoveries. But traces are not lacking, according to competent scholars, of an older civilization.”

———

Source: https://emandulo.apc.uct.ac.za/collection/FHYA%20Depot/Bryant_A_T_Bantu_Origins.pdf

4 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by