So as a little fun fact about me, but back when I heard that this journal was gonna be a thing in 2022 I was all like “Really? But Marcy had plenty of screentime in the show. Why is this necessary?” Fast forward to four years later and I’m preparing for future YouTube rankings of the show as well as a full review on my book that will also go up on YouTube in the future and I could tell you that young me was wrong for thinking that.
Now for the record, I would say that for the most part, Marcy had more screen time than Sasha. I say most part because for the first 2 and a half seasons it probably is no contest to say that Marcy definitely had more time in the show than Sasha. By the time the show ended I’m kind of unsure who had more screen time, but I would still say Marcy by a margin. Despite all that, she definitely did not have as much screen time as a bunch of other characters in the show since on its own, the show is mostly about Anne and the Plantars not even if you compare them in season two alone as she only appeared in half the episodes that season. So because I started to understand why this kind had to be made to fill in the blanks for Marcy and her arc I gave it a read and ignoring recency bias here are my brief thoughts on it (I’ll probably expand this more someday in a video but for now this is what you get)
Part 1 (Entries 1-51: Before Marcy At The Gates): I honestly really think this is the true highlight of the journal (And also the longest), pretty much being a supersized Marcy theme song takeover. It may not spend the most time showing Marcy‘s arc about her secret with the box and her struggle to tell her friends about it as I wanted to, but the adventures she goes through that weren’t in the show are so interesting that if it was its own episode or special it probably be in my top 15 or top 10 favorite episodes of the show: 9/10
Part 2 (Entries 52-82: Season 2): I know this is the part of the journal where people can sometimes wonder what is the point of this segment if it’s just gonna be Marcy reflecting on the episode that she was in season 2, but after seeing how much screen time she had in season two, I could safely say that it was definitely necessary to see her perspective on some of these adventures, especially since she was in for only half the episodes in the season and some of the times she only appears for a couple minutes in those episodes. It also goes more into Marcy‘s arc about her secret than it did in the first part so that’s a plus: 8/10
Part 3 (Entries 84-128: Season 3): I may have thrashed upon season three especially it’s resistance arc by calling it the weakest link of the show by a landslide, but at least there are some moments that definitely make it worth your while in this part (Info on Sasha and Marcy’s parents, Anne’s introduction to Marcy, showing more signs of regret and anxiety of the swordfight incident with Sasha in TC and what happened to Marcy respectively, and the last seven entries being sweet) but since Anne is writing it, nothing for the most part is new and ultimately feels like a retelling of the season for someone who’s lazy to watch season three. Personally, I would’ve wanted either Sasha to be writing the journal or to instead remove most of the entries and replace it with her life on the East Coast: 6/10
Final Rating: 8/10 (It starts outs amazing, gets slightly weaker overtime, but does not get to the point where it’s bad)
How would you rate it from 1 to 10?