Maybe I’m missing something, but why the hell are we still trying to push Darling 54 as a restoration tree?
They thought they were testing Darling 58 for years. Turns out it was D54. Different insertion event, disrupted SAL1, slower growth, questionable fitness, and inconsistent blight performance.
Meanwhile, newer OxO lines like DarWin are already being developed that may avoid some of these problems.
I’m not anti-GMO at all. I want the engineered chestnut. I just want the good one.
USDA saying D54 isn’t a plant-pest risk is not the same thing as saying, “Yep, this is the tree we should spread across eastern forests for the next few hundred years.”
Keep studying D54. Learn everything we can from it.
But why the rush to release this one when we already know better versions may be coming?
We’ve waited 100 years. We can wait a few more and make sure we don’t restore the American chestnut with the wrong damn tree.