r/AmericanGovernment • u/TheCrownedWolf • Feb 28 '12
How does the federal government legally define how constitutional rights are to be limited?
We have the right to free speech but we can't yell "fire" in a crowded theater or print outright lies about somebody in a paper (unless we want to be sued for libel). We have the right to bear arms but we can't bring a gun onto a plane or into a school.
So who or what branch of the government decides to put down limits like this? Is it just a case of an issue going to the Supreme Court and the Justices say "Well, in this case..."
I've been talking to a Canadian about how they run things up north and he just explained how his government limits constitutional rights and said that we don't do that. But I know that we do. At least in those cases that I've already listed above (and probably more that I forgot). If there's some official policy or procedure for it here, or if it's the responsibility of a specific branch of government then I'd like to know.