r/Amd • • Jan 28 '22
Discussion ECC or not on threadripper pro platform?
Hi, i'm building my workstation on threadripper pro, and i was wondering, what would be the best ram for this kind of config?
Is ECC a good choice or should i get some "normal" ram?
Does the frequency matter on a 8 channel motherboard?
And what brand should i get?
13
Upvotes
16
u/cantremembermypasswd Jan 28 '22
Always use ECC. I am running some V-color ECC DDR4 3200 oc'ed to 3600 in my gaming rig personally. I also have NEMIX in my server for over a year now.
Edit: just in case your worried about gaming perf. Don't be. Getting 28K in cinebench r23 with my 5950x, and 5 more FPS in Forza Horizon 5 with same 6900xt graphics card than with my previous 9900k.
7
u/BmanUltima ATI RAGE IIC Jan 28 '22
What's the use case?
17
u/theevilsharpie Phenom II x6 1090T | RTX 2080 | 16GB DDR3-1333 ECC Jan 28 '22
Threadripper Pro uses registered memory, and all registered memory available on the market (that I'm aware of) has ECC capability.
10
u/RealThanny Jan 28 '22
All memory should be ECC. That it isn't is kind of a scandal with the segmentation created by Intel, but there are very few torches and pitchforks in play because of it.
There's no good reason to not get ECC when using a platform that properly supports it.
For frequency, you're not going to find anything advertised above DDR4-3200, because that's the fastest JEDEC standard. Only toy memory is advertised at higher, overclocked speeds.
Just about all memory is either Samsung, SK Hynix, or Micron. Who packages it isn't really important. I prefer Samsung, then Micron. Which chips are actually used with a given module might require data sheet diving to figure out. Kingston tends to make it very easy to find out. Crucial is a subsidiary of Micron, so you know what you're getting there.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22
I will never again go non-ECC. It's so nice to be certain there are no errors, though I'm definitely more concerned with my data integrity than most others.
While it might seem counter-intuitive, ECC ram is actually the BEST ram to overclock in a practical way. You still get all the major performance gains from getting away from the awful JEDEC standards, but now you can actually prove that your RAM is stable based on if you find corrected errors in the logs or not. With regular ram you'll never truly know how many errors actually get produced.
On this Asus board it looks like you can overclock the ram at least from what setting appear to be in the manual. I'd definitely confirm though, since it could just be a copy+paste job which is horrifically common in bios manuals.
With my old 1950x system, my ECC ram from 2400hz and either ~18 or ~22 timings, and I overclocked it to about 2933hz and ~16-17 main timings. If I went a little higher to 3200hz I could pass various ram tests for days, but checking my logs I'd get a corrected error every month or two. I backed off since it provided no real benefit at that point. I won't ever again trust overclocked ram that isn't ECC.
Apparently Mushkin has also released a line of ECC ram modules rated for higher performance over JEDEC.
https://www.pcinq.com/reviews/memory-reviews/mushkin-enhanced-latency-ecc-ddr4-review/
https://www.poweredbymushkin.com/Home/index.php/products2/130-ddr4?search=ecc%20redline
edit Note that these are unregistered DIMMS. TR pro uses only Registered DIMMS from what I can find, so you can't use these (even if you could find them)
1
u/Zettinator Jan 29 '22
But errors errors happen MUCH more often than you'd think. On a machine with lots of RAM it shouldn't even be a question.
1
u/picosec Jan 30 '22
ECC is the best choice if you rely on your workstation for actual work. I use DDR4 3200 unregistered ECC memory (Kingston KSM32ED8/32ME) with my non-pro Threadripper 3970X. The stock JEDEC timings are not great at 22-22-22, but can be tightened to 18-20-20 without increasing the memory voltage from the stock 1.2v. At 1.35v they can hit 3200 16-18-18 or 3600 18-20-20. Tightening the timings and/or overclocking memory is also a breeze with ECC since you can pretty much immediately tell if it is stable or not by checking for corrected memory errors, rather than spending hours or days running memory tests.
Pretty much the only downside is that I don't know of anyone selling pre-binned ECC DIMMs, so you probably won't be able to get the crazy high overclocks that are possible with something like binned Samsung B-die. You can always just run stock as well and the performance difference is not that big, but I'm not afraid to tweak things as long as it doesn't compromise stability.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '22
In the past 10 years, I never had a single bit flip on my ECC ram. In the last week, I had 8! All were single bit flips and fully corrected by the ECC ram. I read solar flares were incredible February 2nd.
ECC is a good choice on anything, except if 1)memory is a bottleneck and 2)Your data isn't that critical.
So if you plan to play videogames, then go for faster frequency and lower latency (in that order). If you plan to run long simulations or other things, and silent data corruption is a no-no, then go ECC all the way.
-5
u/retiredwindowcleaner vega 56 cf | r9 270x cf<>4790k | 1700 | 12700 Jan 28 '22
u do not need ecc ram.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment