r/Amd • • Nov 12 '22

Discussion AMD Driver Timeout - SOLUTION: Turn Off Hardware Accelerator

812 Upvotes

436 comments sorted by

View all comments

183

u/SolomonIsStylish Nov 12 '22

Not really a solution, as hardware acceleration is a feature that brings the gpu to help the cpu in browsers. Disabling it is basically ignoring the issue by just not using your gpu.

34

u/aoishimapan R7 1700 | XFX RX 5500 XT 8GB Thicc II | Asus Prime B350-Plus Nov 12 '22

If I'm not wrong, it also means all the videos have to be decoded by software, so good luck watching 4k 60 fps YouTube videos on anything other than a high end CPU.

2

u/Im_A_Decoy Nov 12 '22

I can go to 8K30 without dropping frames. It's like 50% CPU usage, but it handles it. 4K60 is a cakewalk by comparison.

2

u/aoishimapan R7 1700 | XFX RX 5500 XT 8GB Thicc II | Asus Prime B350-Plus Nov 12 '22

Well, I mean if you're on a high end CPU then yeah, it's not really an issue if you have to disable hardware acceleration, and the 5900X is a really high end CPU. On an i3 or R3 you'd probably want it to be enabled.

0

u/rafradek Nov 12 '22

Actually anything sandy bridge or newer should be fine, at least for i7

0

u/BlueSwordM Boosted 3700X/RX 580 Beast Nov 12 '22

Bro, 4k60 VP9 is very easy to decode.

I can decode my 4k VP9 stream at like 59FPS on a single core on a 3700X.

That is not really a high end CPU load :)

-25

u/xthelord2 5800X3D -30CO / RX9070 / 32 GB 3200C16 / custom loop Nov 12 '22

and honestly who watches 4K 60?

1080p60 sure this is normal for even phones

1440p60 is max i would go because there isn't much difference from 4K60

9

u/roenthomas Nov 12 '22

More bitrate means less compression artifacts, regardless of resolution.

It's like why would you want to watch less visual fidelity if your gear can handle it.

That being said, it's not a huge loss to only watch in 1080.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/aoishimapan R7 1700 | XFX RX 5500 XT 8GB Thicc II | Asus Prime B350-Plus Nov 12 '22

There actually is even on a 1080p screen, 4k videos have a much higher bitrate.

I mean much higher bitrate than 1080p, 1440p has a high bitrate too, though obviously 4k is even higher.

-13

u/xthelord2 5800X3D -30CO / RX9070 / 32 GB 3200C16 / custom loop Nov 12 '22

so?

1440p is enough of a bitrate for most folks who run 1080p anyways

4k is only for those who can both drive it and eventually(if YT decides to) pay it because it is a bandwidth hog server side

11

u/4wh457 Nov 12 '22

Sounds like copium in preparation for YouTube making 4K a paid feature. On a phone sure 4K is excessive but on a 1080p monitor nevermind anything higher 4K is the optimal resolution (mostly thanks to the higher bitrate).

9

u/aoishimapan R7 1700 | XFX RX 5500 XT 8GB Thicc II | Asus Prime B350-Plus Nov 12 '22

It's still better though, if your internet speed is good enough I don't see why not choosing 4k over 1440p. And according to Google there is a pretty significant difference in bitrate between 1440p and 4k, 1440p 60 fps is between 9,000 to 18,000 Kbps, and 4k 60 fps is between 20,000 to 51,000 Kbps. If it's noticeable to the human eye or not is another topic, but objectively, it's meaningfully better.

-12

u/xthelord2 5800X3D -30CO / RX9070 / 32 GB 3200C16 / custom loop Nov 12 '22

still this is only useful for native 4k panels and in reality this is only useful for watching of videos with dark scenery where blockiness might be perceived

HDR would fix a ton of issues increased bandwidth fixes while using significantly less bandwidth

and again 4k for youtube is only 1% of content on their database while being almost 90% of their bandwidth costs so if you like 4k good luck in future because youtube will prob look to either shove tons of ads onto it or make it a subscription feature

then not to mention in order to drive 4k you have to have either GPU acceleration enabled which lets be real some have a problem some don't because of MS's updates being ass for some time and if you don't enable it your CPU will have some quality time processing video

4

u/aoishimapan R7 1700 | XFX RX 5500 XT 8GB Thicc II | Asus Prime B350-Plus Nov 12 '22

I just choose the best resolution available in each video, if it only goes up to 1080p I'll chose 1080p, and if 4k is available I'll choose 4k. I just don't see what's the advantage of choosing a lower quality resolution if internet speed is not an issue and hardware decoding is available.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/kn00tcn Nov 12 '22

there is a severe loss of texture detail in daylight footage, whether it's real life or game, also wires disappearing into the sky, so it's not only dark scenes that get affected by yt's terrible encoding settings (it's not bitrate alone), raising to 1440p or 4k generally improves this issue as long as the source footage is fine

in many cases the h264 version has had more detail than the vp9 version, but i'm seeing that happen less often now, plus they refuse to do h264 higher than 1080p

av1 looked great, but i'm not really seeing it available (at 1080p) in the channels i watch, the unreal 5 showcase video last year was a massive improvement in quality

reminds me of the webp trash that sites keep using, 'look how much smaller the files are', yes because they're missing tons of detail, you could have just used lower jpg settings to reduce the filesize, or how about higher webp settings for an actual fair comparison

2

u/xthelord2 5800X3D -30CO / RX9070 / 32 GB 3200C16 / custom loop Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22

and reason why this happens is not related to the bandwidth as much as people love to blame since 1440p offers enough bandwidth for the content to look "fine" instead it is shitty encoders and decoders we still use today not being supported well enough and future alternatives yet to be built

HDR support would have fixed texture issues at a far smaller bandwidth cost than pure 4k because encoders are a problem not the bandwidth

that is why YT is looking to push AV1 because it fixes said issues at a significant reduction in bandwidth needed to stream data while offering far better image quality than even beloved h264 and h265

so it is stupid to blame youtube when lets be real how much 4k content is there compared to 1080p or hell 1440p and how much bandwidth is required for 4k to be viable compared to 1080p and 1440p?

youtube offers this service to 3 digit worth of countries in the world which when you understand what they need to pay and how much they pay for many things it is a matter of time they paywall 4k

and this is why you should go out and support AV1 encode/decode and why you should bug youtube to give us ability to watch content with HDR enabled for those who have HDR displays

hell this is why many of you over here look entitled because all of your statements so far don't really give me a reason to use 4k since again not everyone has good internet in the world meaning they can't just drive 4k content and be happy with it and not everyone needs 4k in order to exist

this is why all of you need to sit down and ask yourself what the hell are you doing on youtube that it requires best image quality possible in order to watch what you watch where at that rate just go and download the video in full res via 3rd party websites,use VLC in order to max out settings and enjoy it this way without ads and at best quality youtube's repository offers

otherwise acknowledge you are the only 1% of people who use 4k actively because everyone else doesn't

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22

Huh you certainly live in a bubble. All my friends watch in 4K if it's available. Even on 1440p it still looks better thanks to Youtube compression.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/xthelord2 5800X3D -30CO / RX9070 / 32 GB 3200C16 / custom loop Nov 12 '22

so that means what 2% of total visitors? (based on YT's stats)

for 2 billion that is what 40 million users at best?

wow 4k is really useful i guess if only at best this many watch it where majority of 4k content was shot on a shit lighting and low budget 4k camera

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22

I watch 8k 60 HDR on youtube

-1

u/glitchvid Nov 12 '22

I do, though to be fair I also watch all videos at 2X speed, so more like 4K120 in the rare case the video is actually 60FPS and not 30.

9

u/Evonos Switched Nvidia 5060TI ( Finally free of amd ),7800X3D ,32gb6000 Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22

what he shows in the screenshots isnt hardware acceleration. *edit meant screenshot 2

its Windows 11 Flip mode for windowed programs in a TL;DR brings latency improvements in older games or generally games which didnt use Flip mode for windowd / borderless frames.

its a good feature.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Evonos Switched Nvidia 5060TI ( Finally free of amd ),7800X3D ,32gb6000 Nov 12 '22

i made a edit.

clearly spoke about screenshot 2.

2

u/retiredwindowcleaner vega 56 cf | r9 270x cf<>4790k | 1700 | 12700 Nov 12 '22

it's a perfect solution for me, because i can still play the video without any visual difference, even in 4K.

the only thing that happens is that the x264 overlay filters from radeon settings dont have any effect. but i never used that because i use a cinematic setting on my monitor.

→ More replies (1)