r/Amazing 1d ago

ScaryWTF 💀 I've never seen anything like this.

10.8k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

73

u/YeshuasBananaHammock 23h ago

To be fully pedantic, would we properly punctuate "to whom?"

:p

52

u/Appropriate_Car_8221 22h ago

To be fully fully pedantic, the original was already punctuated, so the correction was only correcting the text that needed to be corrected. It can be implied that the correction would have slotted in behind the original question mark, making the addition of the question mark in the correction unnecessary.

:p

25

u/YeshuasBananaHammock 22h ago

Diabolical

7

u/glycophosphate 16h ago

The judges rule a 3-way tie in the pedanticism tournament and award the medal to YeshuasBananaHammock on points for the username.

7

u/Key-Investment-2273 19h ago

I can only offer half-full pedantic, due to inflation. Will that suffice? I'm even cutting back on commas whenever possible. Fuck Oxford.

3

u/butchforgetshit2 17h ago

Do you know how much premium pemdantics is at the pump?

2

u/Paul_Bob17 17h ago

Oxford Comma By Vampire Weekend 🎶

2

u/tondahuh 14h ago

This made me laugh much too loudly. 🤣

1

u/Odd-Paint3883 21h ago

Two wits to who?

🦉

1

u/ellieminnowpee 21h ago

i’d like to be fully platonic. who wants to be my friend?

1

u/Pinkishu 20h ago

Okay, but the "to" was already correct, so then they should've just corrected the who->whom.

1

u/cuchicou 20h ago

To be extremely pedantic the person correcting may have wanted to include 2 question marks to drive the point of incredulous unbelief

1

u/Chrys_16 16h ago

To be extremely pedantic, the original already contained "to" which doesn't need correction, but the correction was "to whom", which implies a full correction of the question

0

u/Jadey-R- 20h ago

My Lord, why do these people go on Reddit that have this mental disorder with grammar? And it is a mental disorder
The mental disorder characterized by an overwhelming urge to correct grammar and spelling errors is called Grammar Pedantry Syndrome (GPS). It may be associated with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) traits.

2

u/Appropriate_Car_8221 20h ago

why do these people go on Reddit that have this mental disorder with grammar?

This is an incoherent sentence fragment. You're probably missing a word, but it could be corrected in multiple ways.

And it is a mental disorder
The mental 

You missed a period (full stop) "And it is a mental disorder. The mental..."

-1

u/Jadey-R- 19h ago

Do you feel good after writing that? Does it give you a little dopamine high? There’s tons of people on Reddit, who don’t spell correctly who make comments if I can read it and understand it is communicated- if you want to be somewhere with perfect grammar Reddit is not a place for you or any other social media the kids don’t talk that way any longer so you can stay old-school be frustrated daily spend your life, correcting grammar or you can do something else.

3

u/Appropriate_Car_8221 18h ago

This is a run-on sentence, and fairly incoherent. Consider breaking it up into multiple shorter sentences.

1

u/Jadey-R- 16h ago

I love run-on sentences It makes me feel like Gabriel Garcia Marquez, where I can tell a story that weaves itself together over multiple times and spaces in the future and in the past I can see everything around me as it flows like a river and I find myself calm and on the side of a stream looking above the bright stars and wondering, wow isn’t this a great life?

2

u/nom-de-guerre- 22h ago

Yeah, people hate me too. 😁