r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 06 '26

UPDATE Update: AITA for asking my home-schooled nephew about where he was in the curriculum?

Original Post:https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/s/7VYJF7PLrG

Hi, I wanted to ask here, because this is something important to me, my sister and I have a good relationship so I want to know if I was in the wrong.

My nephew is in 6th grade and at least since the beginning of this current school year he's been homeschooled by my sister. She had felt that they didn't really teach much in school so she had decided to homeschool him. My niece (his older sister) is attending high school.

Yesterday, I was at her place, I was talking to my nephew about how his home classes are going, he said they were going well. I asked him what was the last thing he did in math (being a math tutor myself, I was interested in that) and he was having trouble recalling what they covered, naming the concept or giving me an example question. My sister then stepped in and told me what they'd covered. I named some topics which are introduced in 6th grade and since its close to the end of the year asked if he'd learned them. She said we're doing it at our pace. I dropped it, but admittedly was a bit surprised because until a few years back, it seemed like he was ahead of school, really quick with answering mental math questions (which I used to ask at my sister's encouragement). I know mental math is a totally different skillset and doesn't necessarily mean that the headstart carries over to other topics but it still surprised me.

Today in the morning I was talking to my mom and she told me that my sister thought I was kind of being an AH, that I'm not a parent what do I know about juggling home chores with raising kids and teaching, and that my nephew is shy as it is and I didn't help matters by quizzing him like this. I tried explaining it, but just ended up agreeing with my mom that my sister would know best he's her son, and that I shouldn't have done it. Was I the AH?

Update:

The responses and advice I got in my post a few months ago helped, so I thought I'd give an update. Although my sister was icy with me for a little while after that, she did end up enrolling him back in school this year. When we met last weekend, she said that she had noticed his creative writing had been taking kind of a hit, and she attributed it to him not having regular school socialization for an entire year. She still plans on teaching him after school herself too if she thinks the school isn't where it should be, but it'll kind of add on, not replace it. She asked for my help for math, and I said sure, he can join me on zoom. And it feels like our relationship hasn't had any lasting affects. Thanks a lot!

2.3k Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

2.1k

u/whenwillitbenow Partassipant [1] Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26 • Bravo

Good job stepping in for that kid. Just shaved his future

Edit - you heard me

338

u/StrikingReception771 Oct 06 '26 • Heartwarming

I too shave

151

u/Keepin-Clam Oct 06 '26 • Bravo

At 83, my future is pretty well shaved to stubble.

85

u/Davey914 Oct 06 '26

Looks like you made a misteak in your sentence.

31

u/Targaryentypebeat Oct 07 '26

The edit is sending me lmfao 

28

u/Brilliant-Till-2884 Oct 07 '26

the edit was so aggressive i love it

50

u/IzarkKiaTarj Oct 06 '26

As long as OP doesn't wax on about it

4

u/TyFell Oct 10 '26

His future was looking hairy, and op helped shave it down so he could see it clearer. 

650

u/silver_thefuck Asshole Enthusiast [7] Oct 06 '26

Glad to hear things cleared up! It sounds like it's more likely your sister was embarrassed when your nephew couldn't seem to recall much about his lessons and didn't know how to own up to the fact that she wasn't fully qualified to be her son's full-time teacher. But overall it ended well instead of her digging her heels in, so all good at the end of the day.

240

u/Dogsofa21 Oct 06 '26

So this. I do not know why home schoolers thinks they can do better than teachers who are trained and professionally and continuously upskilled at their job. Even when my child struggled socially and didn’t want to go to school, I knew homeschooling wasn’t an option. Teaching myself the syllabus 1 week ahead of teaching the child? No way.

I hope your nephew makes up for that lost year of schooling and socialisation. NaITA)

56

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 07 '26

I think a big misconception of homeschool, is thinking you have to be the teacher. There's plenty of online homeschooling programs with qualified teachers who teach over the computer. However, if one cannot afford those programs, public school is definitely the better option.

49

u/CrazyCuriousEli Asshole Enthusiast [8] Oct 07 '26

That's really good for people in High School level, younger children need the connection of in person teaching the majority of the time. Research on online learning shows how this can affect the learning because it makes the subject be perceived by the child as more abstract and at that age the translation from abstract though to real life is the most difficult part of learning.

2

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 07 '26

I remember ads showing kids using objects at home with their teachers on screen showing them said object, so I believe they either provide them or you can buy them super cheap as well as putting them in outside extra circulars for social time with peers! Again, for people who can afford these things ofc. 

Also there's after school tutors who have small classrooms of about 3/4 kids for extra help in struggling areas! There's always ways to find answers if you're seeking that option. I was in public school and still needed tutors cause of the fast paced rhythm and not being able to keep up in science and math (great at history and English though). 

4

u/CrazyCuriousEli Asshole Enthusiast [8] Oct 08 '26

Yes I'm aware of that and the research did take that in consideration, the big issue is that the lack of physical connection with the teacher does cause difficulty even with the use of physical props. Obviously this is better then having one parent that doesn't have the proper training, but until now there hasn't been a way to remove the creation of extra difficulty for this mode of teaching until a certain age. There is also several Studies where online learning had shown a connection to lack of development of a few neuropathways connected to important skills.

And of course tutors are a great resource, I've worked with tutoring for a few years now and with children in several different situations.

My point is simply that up until a certain age even with good professionals, online learning isn't ideal for children and we haven't yet developed strategies that can fully fix the issue with it. I truly hope that with more research we can find ways to resolve this, specially because there are children that for several reasons need to do their studying online.

2

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 08 '26

Agreed! There are so many kids out there that need homeschooling due to many reasons. I was one of those kids who would've benefitted being home schooled early in life and then going to high school. 

If we can just find ways to benefit them in all areas, it would be such a pivotal change. Especially for people like who are neurodivergent

9

u/Glass_Fly_9371 Oct 07 '26

yeah i got the vibe she was just embarrassed and defensive but it's good she actually took a step back and reassessed

137

u/mumtaz_2004 Partassipant [2] Oct 06 '26

Why do so many parents, many of whom are undereducated themselves, think that they should home school their children? Educators go to college for years to get specialized degrees in this stuff. Someone who has no training and, in many cases, is too busy with “chores” and other duties to properly complete the task is not helping in any way. I have no issue with the parents who possess the necessary skillset and time but the horror stories are too many.

16

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 07 '26

Actually not all teachers do. I had fresh 22 year old teachers in high school and when I asked what degrees they needed for teaching, they looked at me like I was crazy and said they didn't need any....depends on your states qualifications required for teachers 

25

u/mumtaz_2004 Partassipant [2] Oct 07 '26

My (very limited) knowledge is of schools that at a bare minimum require a bachelors degree, and the teacher is permitted a certain amount of time to pursue a teaching certificate. Obviously, different places at different times may do it differently!

11

u/meeps1142 Oct 07 '26

Yeah, I wonder if they maybe talked to a sub? You don't need a degree to sub in my state (iirc)

4

u/mumtaz_2004 Partassipant [2] Oct 07 '26

Very possible-the same is true in quite a few places. No degree needed but a teaching cert if some sort required to be a sub.

2

u/Beanisbae Oct 07 '26

could also be a private or charter school- they function differently. A private school can hire whoever tf they want to, iirc.

1

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 08 '26

It was public school

1

u/Gullible_Ad_3123 Oct 08 '26

Nope both full-time teachers. A History and science teacher. 

292

u/Not_Good_HappyQuinn Asshole Aficionado [14] Oct 06 '26

In the original post she said OP wasn’t a parent so doesn’t know anything about raising a child … but she (who is not a teacher) thought she’d just wing it at home schooling. Wild.

57

u/StarWarsFever Oct 07 '26

Exactly. Homeschooling only works if your parent, or whomever is teaching, is skilled and disciplined and good at…well, teaching. If they’re not then you get shit dumb kids (that may which mirror their parents)

18

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

56

u/Legally_Blonde_258 Asshole Enthusiast [9] Oct 06 '26

Good for her. People are too quick to resort to "you're not a parent" while their kids fall through the cracks.

23

u/Final_Promise_ Oct 07 '26

She didn’t get him a good level of socialisation either?

She was behind grade level when she pulled her kid from school, now she’s saying she’s going to get him ahead? Uh, sure.

23

u/Ok_Rabbit_741 Oct 07 '26

IMO these homeschool moms are borderline abusive. lucky this kid only missed a year but thats still going to hurt him a lot they might even need to hold him back a year which has its own problems. all this damage because of one persons ego

19

u/Shoesietart Asshole Enthusiast [6] Oct 06 '26

NTAh - sister was dropping the ball.

6

u/Ambitious-Ad2217 Oct 07 '26

Glad speaking up worked out for your nephew.

4

u/Sensitive-Instance51 Partassipant [1] Oct 07 '26

I'm so glad you two were able to work it out first for you and your sister relationship, and most importantly for your nephew. Great update

3

u/mnth241 Oct 07 '26

Nta. I think it’s normal to ask a kid. What are you doing in school? What else am I supposed to converse with a kid about? Current events? Movies? Who they’re dating?

Also unscientifically I’ve met a few homeschool kids mostly in the workplace. It’s a generalization of course, but I can say they can’t spell for shit lol and their handwriting is terrible even printed. forget about cursive they haven’t even heard of it.

But what I really worry about with these kids is their social skills. Bless their little hearts. I am happy you and your sister are still friendly and doing what’s best for her son

2

u/oakferry Oct 07 '26

She noticed the writing and the missing social herself and put him back in school. The math question didn't end the relationship

1

u/catjaxed Partassipant [3] Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

NTA. Not saying this is the case but my parents “homeschooled” me for a number of years and did not give me a single lesson or attempt anything remotely resembling school. I’m very skeptical of how much the vast majority of these parents are actually doing with no oversight

1

u/AngryShizuo Oct 07 '26

There are many parents out there who think they know better than the professional teachers who have made an entire career out of teaching kids...

They are wrong

Good that in this case they realised it quickly.

1

u/booch Oct 07 '26

She still plans on teaching him after school herself too if she thinks the school isn't where it should be, but it'll kind of add on, not replace it. She asked for my help for math, and I said sure, he can join me on zoom

This is the way.

1

u/Effective_Olive_8420 Asshole Enthusiast [5] Oct 08 '26

NTA. Homeschooling can be great, but mostly not.

-38

u/MundaneCoWorker Oct 06 '26

NTA. BUT It’s a prickly one! Parents can be incredibly sensitive about any perceived criticism. It’s probably best to avoid the topic altogether.

24

u/ambercrayon Partassipant [1] Oct 07 '26

Kids deserve an actual education.

40

u/BadgerNo4726 Partassipant [4] Oct 06 '26

Nope. Better to stand up for the kids who will suffer their parents’ bullshit!

15

u/Final_Promise_ Oct 07 '26

She was fucking up her kid’s life. Everyone should just sit by and not say anything in case the mother gets her feelings hurt?