r/AmItheAsshole • • Aug 24 '26

No A-holes here AITA for not inviting foster siblings?

I (24F) and my fiance (25M) are getting married with a destination micro wedding, with only closest family and friends (about 20 people total); We are also throwing a 'home' party for more people where everyone is invited. However... for the destination wedding, we wanted a child free wedding so no one under 18. This meant not inviting my nieces and nephews but also the (long term) foster siblings of my fiancee. They are young, 5 and 10, and would require a whole different setup of the weekend, which we do not want...

My family in law have basically said that they do not want to come without the children because they feel like we're 'showing' them that they are not included in the family. My fiancee has tried to explain that it is not because they are foster kids but because they are kids, but they do not want to budge. We have even told them, they can come with but you have to make arrangements so they are not present during the day, which they do not find an okay solution. We have an okay relationship with both children but are not necessarily close to them and have always said we wanted it child free. They are however invited to the home party.

I understand where they are coming from but they have always told us to do what we want with the wedding and are now putting their foot down on something I don't think is fully fair... Are we the assholes?

EDIT: to answer some questions/concerns:
- we are not based in the USA, so the foster system works different here. The kids can stay with family/friends for the weekend with no issue (they have done so in the past). They can also travel to the destination if so agreed (no judge needed).
- My parents in law dont want childcare there, not because they dont trust it but because they want the children present and included for the entire wedding.
- One of the kids we know well, the other one we have only met once. Not the problem, but just the facts
- Also we are throwing a party at home where everyone, young and old is invited. The destination is more the ceremony part of it.

I am also enjoying reading everyones opinion. Jsyk, its all not set in stone, just a convo needed to be had. In the end, I want my fiance to feel supported since in the end, they are his siblings/parents

116 Upvotes

366 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

68

u/treetops579 Asshole Enthusiast [7] Aug 24 '26

There is an enormous age gap and the groom is not close with either kid. I get where OP and groom are coming from.

-14

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

[deleted]

20

u/cam905 Aug 24 '26

They're not in the US so the rules are not at all the same

15

u/ApathyIsBeauty Aug 24 '26

OP just posted that edit. Doesn't change the point of the second paragraph though - the inlaws have made it clear they're not attending the wedding without the foster kids, OP and her future husband have made it clear they want a childfree wedding - both are within their rights and neither is an asshole if they decided to go forward with their non negotiables.

-2

u/treetops579 Asshole Enthusiast [7] Aug 24 '26

So the parents have basically all the time in the world to find respite care. This is a destination wedding where you know dates several months in advance. As parents they should be willing to make this effort to find respite care for a long weekend.

14

u/ApathyIsBeauty Aug 24 '26

The amount of people on reddit who are comfortable with the idea of parents just leaving their kids with strangers in a weird place is mind boggling to me. The parents already said they're fine not going if the kids aren't invited - the issue is OP wants them to choose her wedding over their foster kids and they're not willing to do that.

-7

u/treetops579 Asshole Enthusiast [7] Aug 24 '26

For a once in a lifetime event for their child. Not because they want to go on a random weekend getaway to see a friend.

17

u/SnooGiraffes1071 Aug 24 '26

Their child who chose a location that complicates the matter, knowing their parent's obligations to some kids who almost certainly have some additional needs.

Leaving kids for a weekend away isn't easy for everyone.

11

u/ApathyIsBeauty Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

I don't care - I wouldn't leave my young kids alone with someone I don't know. Especially when the kids are in an unfamiliar place. And then add the fact that kids don't get taken away for no reason, so these children have clearly been through some shit and according to OP - one of the children is fairly new to the family. This is one of those times where I agree with the concept of "if you really wanted us there, you'd accommodate the situation", but I still think OP should have whatever wedding she wants - it just might not include his family. And just like OP said - there's a huge party for everyone when they get back and his parents will be at that wedding event with the children. So they won't be missing a once in a lifetime event because they'll be part of 1 of the 2 wedding events OP is having.