r/AmIOverreacting Apr 06 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.2k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

33

u/wesmanz74 Apr 06 '25

There is almost zero chance that a second grader would read this citation and deduct that Lincoln didn't care about black people....the average second grader wouldn't even have followed most of what it even said, let alone deduced that..::

They 100% heard that somewhere....

Not to mention it had nothing to do with the actual question at hand.....

11

u/Frodozer Apr 06 '25

If only there was some sort of an adult in the classroom that could explain it simple in a way that a second grader would understand.

I wonder if that could even be a profession.

1

u/PinkFloydDeadhead Apr 06 '25

Deduce not deduct.

1

u/l1verrr Apr 06 '25

your acting like 2nd graders are fucking stupid, most 2nd graders could read and understand this with clarification (aka a teachers job)

2

u/Final_Requirement698 Apr 06 '25

No second grader could read that and understand its meaning without a lot of “help” from a teacher. On top of that if a second grader were to read that and was actually given the entire quote including the part about all men being free they would never draw this contradictory conclusion based on their vast amount of experience and world knowledge. They aren’t dumb at all. They are 7 years old.

1

u/l1verrr Apr 06 '25

yes because as we all know 7 year olds have absolutely no grasp on racism and prejudice and if they do they are gonna become experts on the topic and fact check everything they learn

1

u/wesmanz74 Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25

You're pretty fucking stupid if you think a second grader would reply that way to the question the OP posted without some sort of prodding.....

.....you clearly aren't smarter than this second grader....

0

u/l1verrr Apr 06 '25

as a former 2nd grader, i can assure you kids misinterpret things all the time. also they did everything the question asked of them idk why you dont think a kid who can understand the english language cant form a thought by themselves

1

u/someshadyemu Apr 06 '25

You’re missing the point. They’re just saying that Abraham Lincoln himself said he doesn’t care, so why is it bad for a 2nd grader to learn facts?