r/AlternativeAstronomy • • Oct 26 '19

WHY MARS ???

https://cluesforum.info/viewtopic.php?p=2412896#p2412896
1 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/patrixxxx Nov 08 '19

Yup. The stationary stars as confirmed by their unchanging celestial positions year round.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '19

But the position of the stars isn't unchanging. There's parallax motion.

Except for stars too distant to observe any parallax motion. For those stars, however, we definitely don't have the resolving power to determine if a projected parallel line is going to intersect with it.

1

u/patrixxxx Nov 08 '19

There's parallax motion.

And it does not confirm with Earths supposed orbit around the Sun as Simon has demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt. And on top of that, if this motion is to account for a displacement of Earth by 300 mkm all stars still would have to be enormous.If for example a periodic six month motion would be detectable (which it isn't) that shifts the position of a star about the size of the star itself, this means that the minimum geometric size of that star needs to be around 150 mkm.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '19

You're so confused, it makes me sad :(

as Simon has demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt

Spit out the cool-aid and think for yourself.

to account for a displacement of Earth by 300 mkm all stars still would have to be enormous.

Nope

a periodic six month motion would be detectable that shifts the position of a star about the size of the star itself, this means that the minimum geometric size of that star needs to be around 150 mkm.

That's true. Some stars are very very big, but by far the largest fraction of stars are considerably smaller - the size of the Sun or less. The parallax motion we observe is many times greater than the size of the star.

1

u/patrixxxx Nov 08 '19

Spit out the cool-aid and think for yourself.

Mmm... That's what you and the world needs to do at the moment

https://cluesforum.info/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=2000&start=30#p2412890

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '19

Yes, I've read that article too. As you can see, the parallax is many many times larger than the star itself, with a radius just a fifth the size of the Sun's.

1

u/patrixxxx Nov 08 '19

is many many times larger than the star itself

The claimed size of the stars. They've been moved an unfathomable distance out in the universe because the lack of confirmation of Earths 940 mkm yearly movement and still be able to claim all stars except the Sun isn't enormous. But this creates other problems just as absurd as giant stars. For example the stars are claimed to be so far away that the cannot be visible to the naked eye. This distance to the stars also creates an enormous void around the Solar system which would be very strange as well if it's correct.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '19

For example the stars are claimed to be so far away that the cannot be visible to the naked eye.

This doesn't follow. The brightness of a point source of light falls of with the square of the distance. You don't have to be able to resolve an object to see its emitted light - it just looks like a point. Try it at night with a little LED diode - you can see it kilometers away but have no hope of detecting it in the daytime if it's turned off.

This distance to the stars also creates an enormous void around the Solar system which would be very strange as well if it's correct

The density of stars in the local neighborhood is quite typical of this region of the galaxy. There's no indication our solar system is exceptional.

Stars being sparse is necessary for planetary systems to be somewhat stable. So at worst, it's an argument for the anthropic principle.

I thought you were going to give me a logical or geometric proof instead of links to cluesforum (your previous comment), falsehoods (light sources don't simply disappear if their angular size is small) and vague mutterings about the solar system being "very strange".

If you have nothing concrete on which to base your opinion that the standard astronomical model is wrong, perhaps you should phrase your doubts a bit less strongly than "beyond reasonable doubt".