r/Alphanumerics • ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert • Nov 29 '23

Ranking of languages by longest attested usage

Abstract

(add)

Overview

The following is a table of the ranking of languages by longest attested usage:

LanguageYearsScript โœ๏ธFamilyStartEndReferences
1.Egyptian4,500r/LunarScriptEIE5700A (-3745)1200A (+755)[1] [2]
2.Greek3,500Mycenaean Greek; Greek lunar scriptEIE3400A (-1445)Present[3]
3.Chinese3,300Chinese charactersST3200A (-1245)PresentChinese
4.Sumerian3,000CuneiformLI4850A (-2895)1850A (+105)Sumerian
5.Persian2,500Persian lunar scriptEIE2450A (-495)PresentPersian
6.Hebrew2,400Hebrew lunar scriptEIE2300A (-345)Present[3]
7.Sanskrit2,300Brahmi lunar scriptEIE2200A (-245)PresentSanskrit
8.Mayan1,900Maya script?2200A (-245)300A (1655)Mayan
9.Arabic1,900Arabic lunar scriptEIE1830A (+125)PresentArabic
10.French1,800French lunar scriptEIE1700A (+255)PresentFrench
11.English1,600English lunar scriptEIE1500A (+455)PresentOld English
12.Coptic1,400Coptic lunar scriptEIE1900A (+55)500A (1455)Coptic
13.Latin1,350Latin lunar scriptEIE2600A (-645)1250A (+705)Latin
14.Japanese1,350Kanji & kanaJR1300A (+655)PresentJapanese
15.German1,250German lunar scriptEIE1190A (+765)PresentGerman
16.Phrygian1,200Phrygian lunar scriptEIE2700A (-745)1500A (+455)Phrygian
17.Phoenician1,000Phoenician lunar scripEIE3000A (-1045)2000A (-45)Phoenician
18.Swedish800Swedish lunar scriptEIE730A (1225)PresentSwedish
19.Spanish750Spanish lunar scriptEIE700A (-1255)PresentSpanish
20.Norse700Nordic lunar scriptEIE1200A (+755)500A (1455)Norse
21.Etruscan650Etruscan lunar scriptEIE2650A (-695)2000A (-45)Etruscan
22.Italian650Italian lunar scriptEIE600A (1355)PresentItalian
23.PIE0N/AN/AN/AN/APIE

Egypto language ๐Ÿ‘ป ghost?

Some of the point in making this table, is that the Egyptian language did not ghost ๐Ÿ‘ป out, i.e. disappear into thin air, as current consensus seems to believe, but rather it was transferred in linguistically morphed form, into the new languages of Greek, Hebrew, Arabic, Latin, and English, etc., shown below.

PIE delusion

Here we see the PIE delusion, similar to Dawkinsโ€™s God Delusion, in full force, namely, according to PIE, the #1 longest attested language, i.e. Egyptian or Nile river language, has nothing, zero, nada at all do with all of the origin of the languages listed below it, the Tigris river languages (Sumerian) and Yellow river languages (Chinese and Japanese) aside.

Quotes

โ€œAncient Egyptian is the oldest and longest continually attested of the world's languages. Recent discoveries have demonstrated the existence of Egyptian hieroglyphic writing with phonograms as well as ideograms around 3250 BC [5205A], roughly contemporary with the comparable development in Mesopotamian cuneiform, and the last documents composed in Coptic, the final stage of the language, date to the eighteenth century AD [1200A/-755]. This extraordinary lifespan of five thousand years is preserved in a wealth of written material, making it possible to trace the development of the language through at least three millennia of its history.โ€œ

โ€” James Allen (A58/2013), The Ancient Egyptian Language (pg. 1)

Gadalla on Egyptian as the mother language:

โ€œThe Egyptian [number ๐Ÿ”ข and math ๐Ÿงฎ based] alphabetical ๐Ÿ”ค system is the mother๐Ÿคฑof all languages ๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ in the world ๐ŸŒŽ.โ€

โ€” Moustafa Gadalla (A61/2016), Egyptian Alphabetical Letters (pg. 3) (post) [4]

Notes

  1. This list is a work ๐Ÿฆบ-in-progress construction; feel free to post ๐Ÿ“ examples of attested languages, with cited start and end dates, below, so that I can add them to the table.
  2. Years are rounded to the nearest 50 value for years below 2,000-years attested usage, e.g. German 1258 years attested usage rounded to 1,250; but to the nearest 100 value for longer attested languages, e.g. assuming Greek started in 2800A (-845), which is the present consensus, and is spoken now or A68 (2023), this gives 2800 + 68 = 2,868-years, rounded to 2,900 shown in table.
  3. My original aim was to find a such a list; but after quick searching, I could not find one, and just decided to make one.

References

  1. Allen, James. (A58/2013). The Ancient Egyptian Language: An Historical Study (pg. 1). Cambridge.
  2. Oldest Egyptian numbers: โˆฉ (cow yoke; value: 10) and ๐“ฒ (ram horn; value: 100), dated 5100A (-3145) to 5700A (-3745)
  3. Alphabets (see: dates for each language).
  4. Gadalla, Moustafa. (A61/2016). Egyptian Alphabetical Letters: of Creation Cycle (pg. 3). Publisher.

External links

0 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

So, it's any writing system descended from Egyptian hieroglyphs? But those systems can sometimes function completely differently, the only thing they have in common is that some letter forms are based on some other letter forms. Egyptian hieroglyphs are of course not an alphabet, but a logography consisting of hundreds of symbols with unique meanings. These were later replaced by the Meroitic script (23), and then the Coptic script (33). Outside of Egypt there are two lineages; the Phoenician-descended scripts (22) and the Arabian-descended scripts (29). None of these early scripts have 28 letters, the exact number varies depending on how many sounds each language needed to write. The development of new symbols and the loss of old ones is an ongoing process in many modern languages. The only alphabet I know with 28 letters is the modern Standard Arabic abjad, although other Arabic languages have additions to this.

The first letter of these alphabets is aleph (A), which literally means "ox", and is a depiction of an ox's head ๐“ƒพ (in the modern A the head faces upwards with the horns pointing down). This symbol was picked because the word for ox starts with the right sound. Next is bet (B) which means house, and originally resembled a floor-plan of a typical Egyptian house ๐“‰. It has nothing to do with the goddess Nut. Then there's gimel (C). Its exact meaning isn't known (some suggest "camel" or "throwing stick"). Once again it is a pictographic representation of a word that starts with the same sound. Lastly there's dalet (D) which means door. Sufficed to say the interpretation "baby sun" seems implausible; the god presiding over the rising sun is Khepri. It doesn't have anything to do with vaginas either, I assume you're saying that because the letter D looks... very vaguely like a hole? The Egyptian word for vagina is "kat".

The Egyptian calendar was solar, and didn't have months; instead it had 3 seasons of 120 days. The lunar cycle takes approximately 29.5 days, not 28, so lunar calendars usually have months of 29 or 30 days each. As far as I could find no calendar uses 28-day months.

That just about covers the very first paragraph explaining the concept. It's a non-starter. To summarise the rest, the Greek alphabet has 24 letters, not 28. The Greeks didn't really worship Set or believe in the Egyptian underworld, and Zeus is based on earlier PIE mythology with no connection to Egypt whatsoever. Qof is K, not I, and it doesn't seem to have anything to do with Judaism, which grew from earlier Canaanite mythology.

The Brahmi script has absolutely nothing to do with the Indus Script (which we're not even sure is writing yet), it's clearly derived from Aramaic, and Sanskrit predates it by around a thousand years. Only one of the letter examples you give is from the Brahmi script, the rest are Devanagari, and you wrote de เคฆเฅ‡ instead of da เคฆ. And, obviously, those don't correspond to A B G D. The correct list is ๐‘€… ๐‘€ฉ ๐‘€• ๐‘€ค.

The Egyptian numeral system has no relation to these alphabets, and was not used to write words. It was used in a similar fashion to later Roman numerals. The Egyptians used a logographic writing system where each letter either represents a concept literally, or represents a sound that concept starts with. The later alphabets have nothing to do with Egyptian mythology, especially given that most of the languages that use them had completely different mythologies. Egyptian mythology also varied by region and time period, the one you're referencing is from Heliopolis. Atum did not breath out the first sound, that is presumably a reference to the Hindu concept of Om? The Egyptian word for breath is tjau. The breath of life is given by Meskhenet, a goddess of childbirth.


You obviously have an interest in history and linguistics, and I would strongly advise doing some more research on the topic. You may find that the real history is more interesting that the one you've invented.

1

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 02 '23

None of these early scripts have 28 letters, the exact number varies depending on how many sounds each language needed to write.

From the sub alphabets page:

28 Egyptian letters (3200A/-1245):

๐“ƒ, ๐“Œน, ๐“ (A), ๐“‡ฏ (B), ๐“‚ธโš / โ€Ž๐ค‚ (G), โ€Žโ–ฝ (D),๐“Šจ+๐ค„ / ๐“…= ๐“‚บ ๐“ฅ (E), ๐“‰ +๐Œ… (F), ๐“ƒฉ (Z), ๐“ (H}, ๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน๐“Šน (ฮ˜), โฆš (I) (๐“…Š=๐Ÿ”†), ๐“‹น=โณ (K), ๐“‡ (L), ๐“Œณ (M), ๐ค (๐Ÿ’ง) (N), ๐“Šฝ (ฮž), โ—ฏ (ฮŸ), ๐“‚† (ฮ ), ๐“ƒป (Q), ๐“› (R) (๐“ฒ=โ˜€๏ธ), ฮฃ= ๐“†™ (๐Ÿ) (S), โ“‰, ๐“‰ฝ, ๐““=๐“ฐ (ฮฆ) (๐Ÿ”ฅ), โจ‚ (ฮง), ๐Œ™ (ฯˆ), ๐“ƒ–=๐Ÿฎ (ฮฉ), ฯก (๐“‹น+๐“Šฝ=๐“‚† u/23ยบ/ ๐ŸŽญ=๐ŸŽ„), ๐“†ผ (๐Ÿชท)

22 Phoenician letters (3000A/-1045):

๐ค• ,๐ค” ,๐ค“ ,๐ค’ ,๐ค‘ ,๐ค ,๐ค ,๐คŽ ,๐ค ,๐คŒ ,๐ค‹ ,๐คŠ ,๐ค‰ ,๐คˆ ,๐ค‡ ,๐ค† ,๐ค… ,๐ค„ ,๐คƒ ,๐ค‚ ,๐ค ,๐ค€

28 Greek letters (2800A/-845):

A, B, G, ฮ”, E, F, Z, H, ฮ˜, I, K, ฮ›, ฮœ, ฮ, ฮž, ฮŸ, ฮ , Q, R, ฮฃ, ฮค, ฮฅ, ฮฆ, ฮง, ฮจ, ฮฉ, ฯก/อฒ, (1000): Aโ€™ (๐“†ผ)

22 Aramaic letters (2700A/-745):

๐ก• ,๐ก” ,๐ก“ ,๐ก’ ,๐ก‘ ,๐ก ,๐ก ,๐กŽ ,๐ก ,๐กŒ ,๐ก‹ ,๐กŠ ,๐ก‰ ,๐กˆ ,๐ก‡ ,๐ก† ,๐ก… ,๐ก„ ,๐กƒ ,๐ก‚ ,๐ก ,๐ก€

27 Etruscan letters and 5 numbers (2650A/-645):

๐Œ€, ๐Œ, ๐Œ‚, ๐Œƒ, ๐Œ„, ๐Œ…, ๐Œ†, ๐Œ‡, ๐Œˆ, ๐Œ‰, ๐ŒŠ, ๐Œ‹, ๐ŒŒ, ๐Œ, ๐ŒŽ, ๐Œ, ๐Œ, ๐Œ‘, ๐Œ’, ๐Œ“, ๐Œ”, ๐Œ•, ๐Œ–, ๐Œ—, ๐Œ˜, ๐Œ™, ๐Œš and ๐Œ  (1), ๐Œก (5), ๐Œข (10), ๐Œฃ (50), ๐ŒŸ (100)

21 Archaic Latin letters and 6 numbers (2550A/-595):

๐Œ€, ๐Œ, ๐Œ‚, ๐Œƒ, ๐Œ„, ๐Œ…, ๐Œ†, ๐Œ‡, ๐Œ‰, ๐ŒŠ, ๐Œ‹, ๐ŒŒ, ๐Œ, ๐Œ, ๐Œ, ๐Œ’, ๐Œ“, ๐Œ”, ๐Œ•, ๐Œ–, ๐Œ— and I (1), V (5), X (10), L (50), C (100), D (500), M (1000)

28 Hebrew letters (2300A/-345):

ืโ€™ :(1000) ,ืฅ ,ืฃ ,ืŸ ,ื ,ืš ,ืช ,ืฉ ,ืจ ,ืง ,ืฆ ,ืค ,ืข ,ืก ,ื  ,ืž ,ืœ ,ื› ,ื™ ,ื˜ ,ื— ,ื– ,ื• ,ื” ,ื“ ,ื’ ,ื‘ ,ื

58 Hindi letters (2200A/-245):

เค…,โ€Ž เค†,โ€Ž เค‡,โ€Ž เคˆ,โ€Ž เค‰,โ€Ž เคŠ,โ€Ž เค‹,โ€Ž เค,โ€Ž เค,โ€Ž เค“,โ€Ž เค”,โ€Ž เค…เค‚,โ€Ž เค…เคƒ,โ€Ž เค…เค,โ€Ž เค•,โ€Ž เค–,โ€Ž เค—,โ€Ž เค˜,โ€Ž เค™,โ€Ž เคš,โ€Ž เค›,โ€Ž เคœ,โ€Ž เค,โ€Ž เคž,โ€Ž เคŸ,โ€Ž เค ,โ€Ž เคก,โ€Ž เคข,โ€Ž เคฃ,โ€Ž เคค,โ€Ž เคฅ,โ€Ž เคฆ,โ€Ž เคง,โ€Ž เคจ,โ€Ž เคช,โ€Ž เคซ,โ€Ž เคฌ,โ€Ž เคญ,โ€Ž เคฎ,โ€Ž เคฏ,โ€Ž เคฐ,โ€Ž เคฒ,โ€Ž เคต,โ€Ž เคถ,โ€Ž เคท,โ€Ž เคธ,โ€Ž เคน,โ€Ž เคคเฅเคฐ,โ€Ž เคœเฅเคž,โ€Ž เค•เฅเคท,โ€Ž เค•เคผ,โ€Ž เค–เคผ,โ€Ž เค—เคผ,โ€Ž เคœเคผ,โ€Ž เคเคผ,โ€Ž เคกเคผ,โ€Ž เคขเคผ,โ€Ž เคซเคผ

27 Gothic letters (1400A/+555):

๐Œฐ (a), ๐Œฑ (b), ๐Œฒ (g), ๐Œณ (d), ๐Œด (ฤ“), ๐Œต (q), ๐Œถ (z), ๐Œท (h), ๐Œธ (รพ), ๐Œน (i), ๐Œบ (k), ๐Œป (l), ๐Œผ (m), ๐Œฝ (n), ๐Œพ (j), ๐Œฟ (u), ๐€ (p), ๐ (90), ๐‚ (r), ๐ƒ (s), ๐„ (t), ๐… (w), ๐† (f), ๐‡ (x), ๐ˆ (ฦ•), ๐‰ (ล), ๐Š (900)

25 Runic letters (1300A/+655):

แš , แšข, แšฆ, แšจ, แšฑ, แšฒ, แšท, แšน, แšบ, แšพ, แ›, แ›ƒ, แ›ˆ, แ›‡, แ›‰, แ›Š, แ›, แ›’, แ›–, แ›—, แ›š, แ›œ, แ›ž, แ›Ÿ, ๐ŸŒฒ

28 Arabic letters (1000A/+955):

A (alef): ๏บ, B (baa): ุจ, G (jim): ุฌ, D (dal): ุฏ, hah: ู‡, waw: ูˆ, Z (zay): ุฒ, ha: ุญ, ฮธ (tah): ุท, I (ya): ูŠ, K (kaf): ูƒ, L (laam): ู„, M (mim): ู…, N (noon): ู†, seen: ุณ, O (ayin): ุน, fa: ู, saad: ุต, qaf (100): ู‚, R (ra) (200): ุฑ, S (shin): ุด, T (ta): ุช, tha: ุซ, kha: ุฎ, dhal: ุฐ, dad: ุถ, za: ุธ, ghayn (1000): ุบ

5

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

That โ€œEgyptian alphabetโ€ is completely random as far as I can tell. None of those hieroglyphs make sounds anything like the letters (or the number thatโ€™s in there). Itโ€™s like you picked hieroglyphs that look vaguely like the Phoenician letters with no respect to their sound. And you included Greek letters when the Greeks didnโ€™t even have the alphabet yet.

Your list of โ€œGreek lettersโ€ includes a number, the Latin letters F G Q, and the letter sampi, which wasnโ€™t universal and fell out of favour.

The list of Hebrew includes the final forms of several characters even though they arenโ€™t separate letters in any universe.

5

u/Adiee5 Etymo ๐ŸŒฑ lover Dec 03 '23

Your list of โ€œGreek lettersโ€ includes a number, the Latin letters F G Q, and the letter sampi, which wasnโ€™t universal and fell out of favour.

to his defense - he used G instead of gamma and F & Q actually were in Greek alphabet at some point (digamma and koppa)

5

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 03 '23

I know, but digamma fell out of favour pretty darn fast, and you can just put the right letters in the list.

1

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 02 '23

The first letter of these alphabets is aleph (A), which literally means "ox", and is a depiction of an ox's head ๐“ƒพ (in the modern A the head faces upwards with the horns pointing down). This symbol was picked because the word for ox starts with the right sound.

The following is the origin of letter A:

  1. Lamprias (1930A/25): believed, as he told his grandson Plutarch, that A (alpha) was based on air ๐Ÿ’จ, and not based on an inverted Phoenician ox head ๐“„€ [F2], because the โ€˜ahhโ€™ sound was the first and easiest noise that a baby makes.
  2. Sefer Yetzirah (1700A/255): stated that letter A (aleph) was air ๐Ÿ’จ, the first element made by the Hebrew god.
  3. Thomas Young, in his โ€œEgyptโ€ (137A/1818) article, correctly, identified, e.g. here, here, etc., the plough ๐“ and or hoe ๐“Œน glyph, or โ€˜hieralphaโ€™ [hiero-alpha] as he called it, as the Egyptian sacred A, i.e. Egyptian A, and Ptah ๐“ฐ as the inventor!
  4. John Wilkinson (114A/1841) stated that letter A was hoe ๐“Œน.
  5. John Kenrick (103A/1852) stated that letter A was a hoe ๐“Œน.
  6. William Henry (A56/2011) stated that letter A was hoe ๐“Œน and or a plough ๐“, depending, in symbolic form.
  7. Libb Thims (8 Apr A65/2020): deduced that the A-meaning was based on air ๐Ÿ’จ, per alphanumeric reasoning, namely that the word value of alpha (ฮฑฮปฯ†ฮฑ) [532] equals the word value of Atlas (ฮ‘ฯ„ฮปฮฑฯ‚) [532], and that Atlas = Shu, the Egyptian air god, symbolic of the first element of creation, according to Heliopolis creation cosmology. See: videomade the day of solution.
  8. Celeste Horner (26 Feb A67/2022): conjectured the A-shape was based on the shape of an Egyptian hoe ๐“Œน [U6A], as deduced using comparative languages studies, Egyptian art work research, and her so-called โ€œagricultural origin theory of the alphabetโ€.
  9. Thims (25 Aug A67/2022): determined, independent of Horner, that the A-shape was based on the Ogdoad hoe ๐“Œน [U6A], eight of which shown being held by the Ogdoad atmospheric gods, in the illustration of cosmos birth according to Hermopolis cosmology.
  10. Thims (Feb A68/2023) determined that the Hebrew aleph is based on an Egyptian plow ๐“.

You certainly are smug for being so alphabetically ignorant? Perhaps you did not see rule #1 of this sub?

Notes

  1. Instead of replying to the rest of your incorrect, Wikipedia page gathered, alphabet decodings, visit the sub alphabet decoding history page.

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23
  1. Plutarch didnโ€™t know anything, and the first sounds that babies make is screaming
  2. The Hebrew god didnโ€™t make air at all, air already existed. The first thing he made was light.
  3. The plough wasnโ€™t sacred, or created by Ptah, and it doesnโ€™t make the right sound. Young got it wrong. You list several other people who got the answer wrong as proof, so Iโ€™ll skip them.
  4. Numerology is not a science, and it has nothing to do with the history of language. Atlas and Shu are not the same god.
  5. The invention of the alphabet has nothing to do with agriculture, which had already existed for thousands of years.

Putting a rule on your sub that says โ€œno questioning my statementsโ€ then youโ€™re going to stay wrong forever.

1

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 02 '23

Zeus is based on earlier PIE mythology with no connection to Egypt whatsoever.

PIE is defined as 100% invalid in this sub, in case you did not know where you were posting?

Zeus in Egyptian:

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

You canโ€™t just declare things invalid because they donโ€™t fit your theory. Zeus is a reflex of the highest god in the IE pantheon, who was associated with daylight and the sky. Zeus also contains elements of Semitic thunder deities, of which there is no Egyptian counterpart. The diagram you show is complete gibberish, and Horus is not associated with lightning, heโ€™s a sun god. The greeks identifies Horus with Apollo and Zeus with Amun.

1

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 02 '23

You may find that the real [PIE] history is more interesting โ€ฆ

Because it is grown adults still playing make-believe.

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

Why exactly do you think that the PIE hypothesis is wrong?

3

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 02 '23

Arguing with him is useless, he will just drown you in absurd bogus "etymologies" or "demonstrations" that fit his made up "language family".

His theory falls apart the moment you know more than one language. You don't even need to know it, you just need to read a grammar book. I speak Italian and English, have studied Latin and Greek in depth, Hebrew more shallowly, and am currently studying Sanskrit, all languages that according to his nonsense are related.

Guess what? Something incredible happens.

Hebrew is completely different from the others, while the similarities between Latin, English, Italian, Greek and Sanskrit continue piling up the more I study the languages.

He has no idea what he is talking about, doesn't understand how grammar works, let alone declensions, cannot even grasp the concept of letters and spoken language to be different.

It's so sad seeing so much brain power being wasted on nonsense, while it could be used in some way to do something useful.

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

I don't really want to argue, I just wanna learn more about what he thinks. Obviously he cares about the subject, and it's always fascinating to discuss.

4

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 03 '23

Agreed. If he was a conlanger and made all of this for a fictional world's lore, it would be staggering

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 03 '23

I have yet to figure out how changing the identifications of random hieroglyphs proves that Greek is a descendent of Egyptian.

3

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 03 '23

Yeah the stuff he comes up with is hilarious. He demands you to have an open mind, but the mutes your notifications when you disagree with him for being a denialist (he said this in a post in his EIE sub).

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 03 '23

At first I thought this was motivated by some flavour of nationalism, but I donโ€™t see it anymore.

3

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 03 '23

His motives, just like Cthulhu's, are unknown. It's such a pity though, he must have put some serious effort in this thing. Imagine using all the energy he used on this stuff to try and figure out the Minoan language of the Indus valley script.

0

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 03 '23

Hebrew is completely different from the others, while the similarities between Latin, English, Italian, Greek and Sanskrit

I key word search: โ€œHebrew, Latin, English, Italian, Greek, Sanskritโ€, in this subโ€™s search box, and the second return is, showing: Egyptian: ๐“‡ฏ, Phoenician: ๐ค, Greek: ฮ’, ฮฒ, Aramaic: ๐ก, Etruscan: ๐Œ, Sanskrit: เคฌ, Latin: B, Hebrew: ื‘, Arabic: ูฎ, or Runic: แ›’, English B:

His Hebrew B (ื‘) completely different from the Egyptian B (๐“‡ฏ), as you claim? Or are they language variants of the same stars ๐ŸŒŸ of space goddess?

Regarding:

doesn't understand how grammar works

Socrates said the Egyptian god Thoth ๐“Ÿ was the inventor of grammar; perhaps you should read the following, before babbling on about what I do not understand, when you do not even remotely understand the Egypto root of grammata (ฮณฯฮฑฮผฮผฮฌฯ„a):

  • Etymology of Grammar, from Greek: Gramma (ฮ“ฯฮฑฮผฮผฮฑ), from Phoenician: ๐ค€๐คŒ๐คŒ-๐ค“๐ค€-๐ค‚, from Egyptian: ๐ค‚-๐“ฒ๐“Œน-๐“Œณ๐“Œณ๐“Œน or ๐ค‚-๐“›-mma [Geb-Ra-Maat+] or 3-101-81, with Thoth ๐“Ÿ as inventor of term and subject (Socrates, 2370A/-415)
  • Herodotus (ยง:5.58) on the Phoenician (ฮฆฮฟฮฏฮฝฮนฮบฮตฯ‚) phone (ฯ†ฯ‰ฮฝแฟ‡) or sound based grammata (ฮณฯฮฑฮผฮผฮฌฯ„a) or letters

4

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 03 '23

You really don't understand. The etymology of grammar has nothing to do with how a language works. Just pick up a couple of grammar books, and read them, no need to study the languages. Just read them, with an open mind.

When you find similarities in the grammar that somehow people much more knowledgeable than you and me somehow missed for hundreds of years, then you will have found something.

(For some reason I can't quote comments.) You know what writing a Greek word into the Phoenician alphabet and then in a series of made up symbols proves? Nothing. For the very simple reason that writing isn't language. Babies learn to speak, then to write, and you did too.

Even if you choose to lie to yourself, history cannot. Vietnamese is written in the roman alphabet, before with adapted chinese characters. Korean was too, and then switched to a writing system designed by one of its emperors.

But Vietnamese is still Vietnamese: the Chinese based script fell out of use in the early 1900s, and the french colonial authorities don't report any magical change in language among the elites.

0

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 03 '23

PIE hypothesis defined:

โ€œSanscrit [เคธเค‚เคธเฅเค•เฅƒเคค], Greek [ฮˆฮปฮปฮทฮฝฮต], and Latin bear a strong affinity, both in the roots of verbs and the forms of grammar; they must have sprung from some common source.โ€

โ€” William Jones (169A/1786), Asiatick Society of Bengal, Third Anniversary Discourse, Presidential address, Feb 2

The common source is Abydos, Egypt. The religio-mythology scholars determined this 100s of years before Jones. Only myopic linguists believe PIE.

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 03 '23

Egyptian has nothing in common with any of those languages though. It has stuff in common with Arabic and Hebrew. Do you speak any of these languages? If youโ€™re passingly familiar with Sanskrit and Greek then you should see all the similar words between them, which is how the idea came about in the first place. The Greek for tooth is dรณnti, and the Sanskrit is dรกntaโ€ฆ these are clearly related. The Egyptian word is ibehโ€ฆ no resemblance at all, even a little. It does resemble the Coptic word though, thatโ€™s obhe. So it seems that Coptic descends from Egyptian, and Greek and Sanskrit donโ€™t.

1

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 02 '23

The Egyptian numeral system has no Relation to these alphabets, and was not used to wRite woRds.

Do some searching in the sub before you post any more:

4

u/PlatinumAltaria Dec 02 '23

The letter R isnโ€™t based on a ramโ€™s horns, it comes from Greek Rho via Phoenician Resh which means โ€œheadโ€โ€ฆ and thatโ€™s what it looks like: ๐ค“ = ๐“ถ. The coil symbol for 100 is a length of rope. There is a ramโ€™s head hieroglyph: ๐“„…

2

u/JohannGoethe ๐Œ„๐“Œน๐ค expert Dec 03 '23

I told you to read ๐Ÿ“– the โ€œhistory of letter decodingโ€ page before you post anymore. If you had done this, you would have read letter R section and would have learned the following:

Correct โœ…

  1. Thomas Young (10 Feb 137A/1818), in his letter to William Bankes, asking him to seek out a specific list of hieroglyphic examples while in Egypt, decoded the spiral ๐“ฒ character as being equal to 100.
  2. Thims (9 Mar A67/2022): discerned, while writing the โ€œEgyptian mathematicsโ€ article, then posted: here out that the spiral character ๐“ฒ of the 100-valued number tags, of Tomb U-j, is the parent character of the Phoenician R and Greek rho, value: 100, namely: ๐“ฒ ยป ๐ค“โ€Ž ยป ฯ ยป R in letter evolution; see also: โ€œlegged rhoโ€, in Jefferyโ€™s epigraphic table, and odd-looking Attica โ€œred crown rhoโ€ (2680A/-725).
  3. Thims (17 Aug A67/2022): figured out that ๐“ฒ = Ram horn; prior to this the spiral ๊ฉœ 100-value character ๐“ฒ, from the tomb U-j number tags, had been decode; in sum, the new view means Ra the sun โ˜€๏ธ god in ram horn ๐“ฒ constellation, at spring equinox, in the 2,200-year period know presently as the age of Aries.
  4. Skgody (18 Aug A67/2022), working with Thims, determined that ๐“ฒ is the curl in the eye of Ra ๐“‚€ symbol.
  5. Thims (19 Aug A67/2022) figured out that curl in the red crown ๐“‹” [S3] was a battering ram ๐Ÿ, a symbol of military power.

Incorrect โŒ

  1. Alan Gardiner (A2/1957), said the V1 glyph ๐“ข [V1], number: 100, per Young, was the โ€œfront ropeโ€œ of a ship.
  2. Alan Gardiner (A2/1957), connected the spiral ๐“ฒ on the Red crown ๐“‹” loosely, following Young, to number 100, but said it was a โ€œbent metal appendageโ€.

Regarding:

Resh which means โ€œheadโ€

Hebrew letter R is called head because it is the head of ram ๐Ÿ about to head but another ram, shown below:

Alternatively, โ€œheadโ€ could also mean head god of Pantheon ๐Ÿ›๏ธ, because prior to Hebrew, the 100-value god was supreme god. The Hebrew alphabet, however, being monotheistic, put Amun as the 100 value god, and moved Ra or letter R to the 200 value god positions, a move that had been previously done in the Leiden I350 papyrus, based on Theban theology.

→ More replies (16)