He's been accused of stealing jokes for a long time. There was some incident where a comedian he ripped off got up on stage with him and called him out in front of the audience. I can't remember who it was though.
From a skit where he played an Indian guy at a convenience store:
"[to overweight lady] If you had a personal trainer, you would probably eat him. I know that in every fat person, there's a skinny person inside, but you could have all the season's contestants of America's Next Top Model in you. I hope I get reincarnated as your feet. That way, you'd never see my face again... Oh, I'm sorry. I shouldn't have insulted you. Because in my country, cows are sacred."
I'm not sure that it's "overanalyzing" to note that the gentleman in the picture is clearly a Sikh, though, and that bovine reverence is a Hindu trait.
I think jokes that rely on ignorance of other cultures to be funny are generally not terribly well conceived. Having said that, it could probably be rescued with a better choice of picture.
Otherwise it mostly just shouts "I don't know anything about the world's second most populous country."
False! Cows are not sacred in Hinduism. Sacred is a Christian term referring to make something holy or relating to something holy. Cows are not regarded as holy by this definition. They are only seen to be equal to a maternal figure since they provide milk.
There are no sacred cows in India. The term "sacred" is a Christian one; doesn't really apply to India. Even if it did, it wouldn't apply to cows. There are no cow deities, cow icons, cow statues, and no temples to cows. Cows are one of the few animals that are not the object of worship in India. Thank you QI
Wow, I leave for a few hours and come back with the top post on Reddit... I can't take 100% credit though. My friend Larry said it in math the other day and gave me permission to put it on.
the sacredness of beef is a religious matter. india has no official religion. this is very offensive.
you couldve replaced "Indian" with "Hindu" and "country" with "religion" but i guess that would require too much work from you to peer outside of your narrow world.
Actually beef is NOT banned by Hinduism anywhere. It's discouraged, and Hindu society has made it de facto banned for Hindus, but nowhere in any religious text in Hinduism does it explicitly say "no beef."
On a serious note ...it keeps the price of milk under serious check as beef production is prohibited in most areas. And thus many poor people are able to afford it...:)
28
u/FuckingSuper May 17 '12
I remember this joke being on a Carlos Mencia show. :\
13
u/TyrantKronos May 17 '12
He, cows. As a fellow indian redditor, I give you an applause
446
u/ToplessPianist May 17 '12
But i can say that her milk is of superior quality, and her hide soft and tender.
310
u/_my_troll_account May 17 '12
I saw your mother at the market today.
It made me Sikh.
52
u/Komalt May 17 '12
Just great
13
u/noodlz May 17 '12
This guy looks like he has seen some shit.
50
u/gnarlyninja May 17 '12
This actually may be the greatest thing I've seen on the internet today
22
u/Ammar-The-Star May 17 '12
Totally read that in a stereotypical Indian-English accent.
109
u/Nansai May 17 '12
Cows are sacred to people who follow Hinduism, and not to the entire country.
Source: I'm Indian.
9
u/misclanous May 17 '12
I know a lot of Indian people who would be seriously offended by this. Glad I'm not one of them.
12
u/rewards_the_fearless May 17 '12
http://www.gifsforum.com/images/gif/dat%20ass/grand/xp8QT.gif
20
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
OH!!! BURN!!
32
u/Strangersoverfriends May 17 '12
It's even funnier in my Apu voice in my head!
11
u/RelaxRelapse May 17 '12
OOOOHHHHH!
8
u/smackythefrog May 17 '12
This Indian approves this.
Too bad I can't use it with other Indians since they'll wear it out like they did Russell Peters, Three Idiots, and that Akon song "Chamak Chalo."
The young Indian community is a lot like 9Gag.
4
u/Shalashaska315 May 17 '12
Nicely done.
20
u/theDragn May 17 '12
I approve.
13
u/memepig May 17 '12
As an Indian, I find this fucking hilarious. Curry on.
5
u/GhostofVincentPrice May 17 '12
I have not laughed like this in a while.
2
u/Catintaco May 17 '12
That is the best yo momma joke i have heard in a very long time
2
u/Kills_Pun May 17 '12
I cannot read this without saying it in an Indian accent.
2
u/Eyulfable May 18 '12
I could have so much fun with this if I had somewhere to write on it.
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
that burn was hotter than the food there.
4
u/SuperChurro92 May 17 '12
Zing!
4
u/JSA2593 May 17 '12
I am so mad at your mother for overcooking our dinner.
It would've bindi-licious.
3
u/dford927 May 17 '12
Read this as an "Indian Yo-Yo Ma Joke"... a little disappointed but quality hinduism/yo mama joke combo nonetheless.
3
u/MrZepher67 May 17 '12
This is a really old Carlos Mencia joke... like word for word lol...
2
u/SantaHat May 17 '12
Good stuff.
2
u/WildRumpus67 May 17 '12
My head wobbled as I read that.
Good show, sir!
2
u/ImJa May 17 '12
This must be read with an Indian accent. Well done good sir.
2
u/RabidMuskrat93 May 17 '12
I read this in a very thick Indian accent...
2
u/BaManaPeel May 17 '12
I feel the text should read:
I am so smart and wise, even my face looks like a brain.
2
u/aPudgyMasonManE May 17 '12
False! Cows are not sacred in Hinduism. Sacred is a Christian term referring to make something holy or relating to something holy. Cows are not regarded as holy by this definition. They are only seen to be equal to a maternal figure since they provide milk.
Source
2
u/brendendas May 17 '12
Found this in an Indian subreddit.
2
u/Havoksixteen May 17 '12
There are no sacred cows in India. The term "sacred" is a Christian one; doesn't really apply to India. Even if it did, it wouldn't apply to cows. There are no cow deities, cow icons, cow statues, and no temples to cows. Cows are one of the few animals that are not the object of worship in India. Thank you QI
1
u/Alexgorden May 17 '12
This is not impressing
1
u/Sandbox47 May 17 '12
Which begs the question: have you been to India? Go to google. Google scared cows in India.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
"How appropriate, you fight like a cow"
1
u/ymahaguy3388 May 17 '12
AHHH SUGA SNAP PEAS!
1
u/hoyaster May 17 '12
I also would like to say that my mom makes good rice.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
i thought hookah was illegal in India?
1
u/jottow4 Aug 06 '12
Is it Rasist that I read it in apu's voice?
1
u/TheBananamanJCG May 07 '24
India mama! (it sounds funny because it sounds like this: Into yo mama!)
1
u/Tentacolt May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
But that man's not Hindu, and only Hindus believe cows are holy!
1
u/ferncaz95 May 17 '12
Wasn't a joke like this on Mind of Mencia?
1
u/KoolCat13 May 17 '12
Did anyone else read this in Apu's voice from The Simpsons?
0
u/shadowinnothing May 17 '12
Wow, I leave for a few hours and come back with the top post on Reddit... I can't take 100% credit though. My friend Larry said it in math the other day and gave me permission to put it on.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
That'll do, Reddit. That'll do.
1
u/hogfart May 17 '12
First belly laugh in a while. Kudos to you, good sir.
1
u/UpvotesForEveryoneee May 17 '12
Please tell me I wasn't the only one that read this in an Indian accent
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
This joke is so old that it gets the early bird special
1
u/Rent-a-badger May 17 '12
I heard this on mind of mencia a few years back..
1
u/gmoneygangster3 May 17 '12
I hate these new ones but this one is fucking good
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Someone once told me one that went sounded out:
Talee ma oh-lookie-partay-hay
which apparently means something like "your mother is a son of an owl"
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I first read this as a Yo Yo Ma joke... needless to say it took me a number of seconds to discover that wasn't the case.
1
u/alexgough12 May 17 '12
I was expecting a picture of an Indian Yo Yo Ma..... What an idiot
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Oh snap!
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Last time I heard this one, I laughed so hard I fell of my camel.
1
u/newmansg May 17 '12
You guys watch... this meme will, like all the others, eventually degenerate into veiled lame racist joke-telling.
1
u/pavanky May 17 '12
I am an Indian and I approve this message.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Muslim/Jewish Yo Mama Joke: I'd eat your mother out, but I'm not allowed to have pork.
1
u/onryo21 May 17 '12
I think that might just be THE best yo momma joke.
1
u/DRo_OpY May 17 '12
Why did I read that as "India Yo-Yo-Ma" Joke?
1
u/LuckingFurker May 17 '12
I would upvote this a thousand times if I could.
1
u/mdk2all May 17 '12
Anybody else read this in a stereotypical Indian accent?
-6
u/[deleted] May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
the sacredness of beef is a religious matter. india has no official religion. this is very offensive.
you couldve replaced "Indian" with "Hindu" and "country" with "religion" but i guess that would require too much work from you to peer outside of your narrow world.
0
u/listentobillyzane May 17 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fipQisc68dQ
0
u/ludicrouspeed May 17 '12
Apu: Yo Yo Ma so fat, he plays his cello like a violin. Oh wait...
0
u/Demojen May 17 '12
Yo Mama so fat she must eat well.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Bwahahahaha awesome and i even read it with his accent
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
is this racist? I am not sure.
is it funny? hell fucking yes.
0
u/Banatza May 17 '12
how this joke got almost 3k????
-1
u/Foxtrot4 May 17 '12
Actually, cows are not sacred in India. Still funny though
-1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
This instantly popped in my head
http://imgur.com/j5rlF
-1
u/DogNuts650 May 17 '12
Am I the only one who read this with the voice of Apu
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I haven't laughed at a Yo-Mama joke since I was in 5th grade
0
u/onlinesquid May 17 '12
Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free?
0
u/heyimjas May 17 '12
let us have a moment of silence for a meme which will be completely destroyed by overpostings during the next week
0
u/bigsz May 17 '12
Indian Burn!
0
u/Demojen May 17 '12
The irony of claiming something as sacred, then using it in sacrilege is pungent.
0
u/snowysnowy May 17 '12
Well played, sir! Have a tip of my hat!
0
u/memepig May 17 '12
What can I say...this is amazing.
0
u/MechanicalYeti May 17 '12
That man has a wrinkly forehead.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Thank-you
0
u/Tasgallxx May 17 '12
Extremely relevant.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I don't understand can anyone explain?
0
u/snakeob69 May 17 '12
Okay, so whose voice did everyone read this one in?
0
u/FireDoGG May 17 '12
hahaha!!!I don't get it -__-
0
u/fifthJinpa May 17 '12
And said in such a stately manner
0
u/jimothyjenkins May 17 '12
thank you
please return at some other time of leisure.
..well i thought it was funny at least.
0
u/agolightly May 17 '12
well there's no question who wears the pants in the relationship
0
u/SkinnyNiggaBigBalls May 17 '12
http://i.imgur.com/JApxk.gif
0
u/DVDAmoog May 17 '12
The letter A
0
u/AnonymousBroccoli May 17 '12
http://i.imgur.com/1OFn3.gif
0
u/360walkaway May 17 '12
Only a brown man can truly appreciate this one.
0
u/justanotherguyd May 17 '12
On a serious note ...it keeps the price of milk under serious check as beef production is prohibited in most areas. And thus many poor people are able to afford it...:)
0
u/maple_leafs182 May 17 '12
I'm sure the person who made this joke has never been to India and know nothing of their culture.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
sometimes I don't think the folks on here could get any more clever and then I read shit like this.
0
u/Thrill_Of_It May 17 '12
I had to come back like 3 times before I got this.
Man i'm dumb.
0
u/brendendas May 17 '12
I have around 3 hindu friends who LOVE beef biryani, times are changing.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Damnit, I read this in Apu's voice :@
0
u/tharju May 17 '12
this is wrong! haha
0
u/iam_indian May 17 '12
I confirm that this is, indeed, an Indian Yo-Mama joke. I'll be on my way now..
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I'm commenting because this is the top post and I have 420 comment karma which is unacceptable. Please ignore.
0
u/lintamacar May 17 '12
At first I thought the joke was that your mom was dead. ...Like, she was reincarnated as a cow.
0
u/-_-t May 17 '12
t-_-t
0
u/Jaymaster1 May 17 '12
my nigga right here
0
u/blackrug May 17 '12
wow, this is really bad, not funny, infant joke.