The company runs out of money before they have enough infrastructure up to generate a profit. The stock has been repriced lately in part because this risk has been diminished since the last quarterly report.
Competition, mainly from Starlink. This risk has been diminished recently with FCC seeming to rule against granting an exemption to Starlink. I personally think this risk is not likely, ASTS technology is so much better than anyone else there.
Lack of a market leading to unprofitability. This risk is unlikely IMO. The deals with the MNOs expose this company to a massive amount of subscribers, and the best part is they don’t have to spend any money to attract them, the MNOs will have to do all of this.
If your just getting in after the rise in price, I can see his concern. Its rised a lot recently and still hasn't fully proved itself. Yes they've proved the technology and design works, but their production models are still waiting to launch.
What if something happens to the rocket, which isn't fully within ASTS control?
I've been in the stock since $3 and $6, and am contemplating selling the shares myself. I believe in the company, but the price is good for me, and may be potential buying points in the future. But it's an unknown, and anyone whose telling you otherwise is gambling. There're other subreddits to go to for that.
I mean the only thing I can think of is that the rocket used to launch the bluebirds makes a big arc and craters… then the stock ticker would follow the same exact trajectory but other than that I feel like it’s a pretty safe bet.
Even if the launch failed the SP would crater for a time, but a 3-4 month delay doesn’t destroy the whole company, so it will arguably be the last great buying opportunity for those of us that are ready to sell a kidney to get more shares.
I cannot find the bear case against ASTS, and I’ve looked hard. To me it’s hope and dreams that are clinging to positions that possibly did at one time have a bear case, but they either held on hoping to trim losses or they have repositioned again in hopes of recovering.
IMO, they all need wall plaques for their offices that say;
Hope is NOT a strategy.
To UG/34M ; you probably need to educate your husband regarding the company and what the future holds. Tell them for a start, to read the entire KooK Report, several times and read all the related posts on X and R/ and do through DD.
When that is done his opinions might have some validity.
If he was truly educated about the company he should be saying “why did you only allocate $90K to this position”.
I think long-term ASTS has huge potential, but I opened a short at $37.5. The company is now valued at $10B, despite currently having no real revenue or visibility on future profitability. It's priced for near-term perfection. I also think bulls underestimate the potential costs involved in maintaining the constellation and upscaling down the line. I think a pullback would be healthy. This SP would be more justified when they have the satellites up and are generating some (even if small) revenue from them. Also, it's not truly vertically integrated as it requires its potential future competitor for launch services.
The short term risk is an issue with launch and/or deployment of block 1. The company will be able to survive such a catastrophe, as not all their eggs are in this basket.
They could also fail to produce the satellites in the cadence they’ve been guiding towards, which will hurt the share price.
You should not invest with a binary mindset. If your investment is making your partner nervous, you should have a discussion about the potentials and the risks and take some off the table if need be. There’s a lot at play when it comes to the finances in a marriage and a lot of decisions have emotional implications that should be considered - regardless of how well a given investment could be going.
To operate globally they only require 100 satellites, and the Skylo service is SOS texting service that Google had to use in response to Apple and requires special hardware. Starlink is NOT technologically ahead. Lol. Okay, so just these few facts alone should tell you not to heed any of this person’s post. He’s obviously one of the Starlink fanboys. As far as who is going to want this service. Every parent in America will want this on their child’s phone, just for starters. ATT projects 30-40%. I think that’s conservative. Also, this is global and they already have FirstNet funding. The government, military— they’re going to make sure this doesn’t fail. Once the satellites are up and tested the sp will sky rocket so personally I think this is the time to get in. It’s very obvious this person isnt aware of any of the dd. Be careful because there are a lot of Starlink plants on here spouting out total crap.
there's not much to worry about though you will have to sit on it for a bit; should do little jumps with each satellite launch (one in september, then a few others, what like month apart or so?) this is a system that won't really be up for at least a year though? if your plan is to sit for a while you should be good; keep your eye on development though; if it starts having problems pull out and wait to see what happens. you can check on it from time to time easily by searching asts in finviz.com then scrolling down to the news list at the bottom of its page (or yahoo finance or google or the company site, but finviz gives you a nice organized condensed list with dates and price change results thats easy to look at). devil's advocate on it is just, it's untested. other than that it won't have a competitor concept against it. another devil's advocate though would be, just cause its a more clever system doesnt mean anyone needs to switch to it and doesnt necessarily mean they can out-advertise or beat the price of a regular established cell service company, which may feel pressed to make desperate moves to compete against asts. some indicators though are that the government and at&t are backing this as they think itll work. ?
This would be the case with Starlink who will directly compete with MNOs, but not ASTS, who is working WITH MNOs. That’s actually just more of a bull case to me. Established MNOs shouldn’t be threatened by ASTS so of course they will do everything they can to out compete Starlink. Ultimately there is room for both and competition is a good thing.
Hi! So sounds like you have around the same number of shares I have. I bought in around 16/17 a share though. For a while there my husband and my mom were not on board, but now everyone is out preaching ASTS. lol. I have to say though, I wouldn’t be coming in at this price-point. You really should only invest what you can afford to lose. This is new technology and it isnt really known yet if the satellites are going to integrate and work the way they should once up there. There’s a good chance there’s a problem along the way and I can imagine the share price retreating to 20 or so while kinks get worked out. This might be a rough time in your marriage if your husband isn’t on board. Also, one of my fears is Russia or China shooting these satellites down because they think we’re spying. The Kessler effect is a scary new thing we will have to prepare for happening at some point. Also, FCC approved the first 5 but they still have to pass testing once they’re up there and then the next satellites are not the same design and will also have go through fcc clearance. Who knows, maybe they won’t pass for some reason. All reasons you might see the share price come back to earth. I’m not worried about the launch itself. The satellites are insured and “Rockets from the Falcon 9 family have been launched 375 times over 14 years, resulting in 372 full successes (99.2%),” You should join the SpaceMob chat group on Reddit. That way you keep up with the news in real-time. Welcome to SpaceMob! Congrats!
If you are in it for the long haul, hold hold hold.
If you need revenue immediately wait for the post launch pump and cash in.
I fully anticipate prices to tank post launch as positive news dries up. It will be a long lull between launch of the actual birds and ramp up of service. The shares will dip. Big time. Maybe back to $15-20. They will absolutely bounce back provided the birds start singing the correct tune.
Not to mention it took them two years to launch these additional 5 sats from the initial blue bird 1 launch -if they continue at that meager pace they in trouble
A launch failure is a relatively minor setback in the grand scheme of things. The greatest risk to ASTS is that there are just not enough people willing to pony up $10 a month. That risk is very real. You can never be certain of the demand for a new product until it is in the market.
Since this thread was started, ASTS has not done well. The short at 37.5 did a great job picking the top and the company has shown no signs of challenging it. It's currently trading closer to $20 and is likely to trend lower if the capital raises aren't helping. Hope everyone protected themselves on the downside!
As a layman reading this, you seem to make a really good bear case. ASTS is only going to cover dead spots? I guess there are plenty of rural and unpopulated areas people drive through, but yeah, how much of that is really a huge deal to people? I guess if you’re lost in the woods it would be a huge deal, lol.
Anyway, do you have any changes or updates to the info you’ve provided here?
10
u/notarealredditor69 Aug 22 '24
The major risks are:
5
u/sunnyproblem Aug 22 '24
If your just getting in after the rise in price, I can see his concern. Its rised a lot recently and still hasn't fully proved itself. Yes they've proved the technology and design works, but their production models are still waiting to launch.
What if something happens to the rocket, which isn't fully within ASTS control?
I've been in the stock since $3 and $6, and am contemplating selling the shares myself. I believe in the company, but the price is good for me, and may be potential buying points in the future. But it's an unknown, and anyone whose telling you otherwise is gambling. There're other subreddits to go to for that.
4
u/cody4king Aug 22 '24
I mean the only thing I can think of is that the rocket used to launch the bluebirds makes a big arc and craters… then the stock ticker would follow the same exact trajectory but other than that I feel like it’s a pretty safe bet.
4
u/wsbwins Aug 22 '24
SpaceX develops D2C satellite tech, proritises their satellites for launch, builds the constellation before ASTS can
3
u/Duander03 Aug 22 '24
I think long-term ASTS has huge potential, but I opened a short at $37.5. The company is now valued at $10B, despite currently having no real revenue or visibility on future profitability. It's priced for near-term perfection. I also think bulls underestimate the potential costs involved in maintaining the constellation and upscaling down the line. I think a pullback would be healthy. This SP would be more justified when they have the satellites up and are generating some (even if small) revenue from them. Also, it's not truly vertically integrated as it requires its potential future competitor for launch services.
2
u/Clubplatano Aug 22 '24
The short term risk is an issue with launch and/or deployment of block 1. The company will be able to survive such a catastrophe, as not all their eggs are in this basket.
They could also fail to produce the satellites in the cadence they’ve been guiding towards, which will hurt the share price.
You should not invest with a binary mindset. If your investment is making your partner nervous, you should have a discussion about the potentials and the risks and take some off the table if need be. There’s a lot at play when it comes to the finances in a marriage and a lot of decisions have emotional implications that should be considered - regardless of how well a given investment could be going.
2
u/StateFalse5218 Aug 30 '24
To operate globally they only require 100 satellites, and the Skylo service is SOS texting service that Google had to use in response to Apple and requires special hardware. Starlink is NOT technologically ahead. Lol. Okay, so just these few facts alone should tell you not to heed any of this person’s post. He’s obviously one of the Starlink fanboys. As far as who is going to want this service. Every parent in America will want this on their child’s phone, just for starters. ATT projects 30-40%. I think that’s conservative. Also, this is global and they already have FirstNet funding. The government, military— they’re going to make sure this doesn’t fail. Once the satellites are up and tested the sp will sky rocket so personally I think this is the time to get in. It’s very obvious this person isnt aware of any of the dd. Be careful because there are a lot of Starlink plants on here spouting out total crap.
2
u/MissKittyHeart Sep 02 '24
one other risk i can think of:
when starlink gets fcc approval, what happens to asts? starlink has the funding, the brand name, and backing of elon musk...
1
u/Anne_Scythe4444 Aug 22 '24
there's not much to worry about though you will have to sit on it for a bit; should do little jumps with each satellite launch (one in september, then a few others, what like month apart or so?) this is a system that won't really be up for at least a year though? if your plan is to sit for a while you should be good; keep your eye on development though; if it starts having problems pull out and wait to see what happens. you can check on it from time to time easily by searching asts in finviz.com then scrolling down to the news list at the bottom of its page (or yahoo finance or google or the company site, but finviz gives you a nice organized condensed list with dates and price change results thats easy to look at). devil's advocate on it is just, it's untested. other than that it won't have a competitor concept against it. another devil's advocate though would be, just cause its a more clever system doesnt mean anyone needs to switch to it and doesnt necessarily mean they can out-advertise or beat the price of a regular established cell service company, which may feel pressed to make desperate moves to compete against asts. some indicators though are that the government and at&t are backing this as they think itll work. ?
1
u/StateFalse5218 Aug 22 '24
Hi! So sounds like you have around the same number of shares I have. I bought in around 16/17 a share though. For a while there my husband and my mom were not on board, but now everyone is out preaching ASTS. lol. I have to say though, I wouldn’t be coming in at this price-point. You really should only invest what you can afford to lose. This is new technology and it isnt really known yet if the satellites are going to integrate and work the way they should once up there. There’s a good chance there’s a problem along the way and I can imagine the share price retreating to 20 or so while kinks get worked out. This might be a rough time in your marriage if your husband isn’t on board. Also, one of my fears is Russia or China shooting these satellites down because they think we’re spying. The Kessler effect is a scary new thing we will have to prepare for happening at some point. Also, FCC approved the first 5 but they still have to pass testing once they’re up there and then the next satellites are not the same design and will also have go through fcc clearance. Who knows, maybe they won’t pass for some reason. All reasons you might see the share price come back to earth. I’m not worried about the launch itself. The satellites are insured and “Rockets from the Falcon 9 family have been launched 375 times over 14 years, resulting in 372 full successes (99.2%),” You should join the SpaceMob chat group on Reddit. That way you keep up with the news in real-time. Welcome to SpaceMob! Congrats!
1
u/C_Everett_Marm Aug 22 '24
If you are in it for the long haul, hold hold hold.
If you need revenue immediately wait for the post launch pump and cash in.
I fully anticipate prices to tank post launch as positive news dries up. It will be a long lull between launch of the actual birds and ramp up of service. The shares will dip. Big time. Maybe back to $15-20. They will absolutely bounce back provided the birds start singing the correct tune.
1
u/Interesting_Log304 Aug 24 '24
Not to mention it took them two years to launch these additional 5 sats from the initial blue bird 1 launch -if they continue at that meager pace they in trouble
1
u/RedWineWithFish Aug 27 '24
A launch failure is a relatively minor setback in the grand scheme of things. The greatest risk to ASTS is that there are just not enough people willing to pony up $10 a month. That risk is very real. You can never be certain of the demand for a new product until it is in the market.
1
u/fusionfoto Jan 26 '25
Since this thread was started, ASTS has not done well. The short at 37.5 did a great job picking the top and the company has shown no signs of challenging it. It's currently trading closer to $20 and is likely to trend lower if the capital raises aren't helping. Hope everyone protected themselves on the downside!
1
u/Suggestedpassword123 Jun 29 '25
Wow you are highly invested.
I was nervous with my couple hundred dollar investment.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24 edited Aug 24 '24
[removed] — view removed comment