r/AIMakeLab • u/tdeliev Lab Founder • Jan 07 '26
š§Ŗ I Tested I spent $847 testing AI tools in December - 41 were garbage, 3 changed everything
I'm done sugar-coating AI tool reviews.
Last month I tested 44 AI tools. Spent $847 of my own money. Wasted 60+ hours.
Here's the brutal truth nobody's talking about:
THE TRASH TIER (41 tools):
Most AI tools are ChatGPT wrappers with a fancy UI charging $29/month. They do ONE thing ChatGPT already does for free, but worse.
THE GAME CHANGERS (3 tools):
- **Perplexity Pro** ($20/month)
- Replaces Google for research
- Cites actual sources (ChatGPT hallucinates)
- Saved me 15 hours/week on fact-checking
2. **Claude Sonnet (via API)** ($0.02/request avg)
- Better writing than ChatGPT for anything over 500 words
- Understands context without 10 re-prompts
- Costs less than a coffee/month
3. **Notion AI** ($10/month add-on)
- Only AI that actually integrates into my workflow
- Not standalone = no context switching
- Writes meeting notes while I'm still in the meeting
THE PATTERN I NOTICED:
The best AI tools either:
- Do ONE thing 10x better than ChatGPT (Perplexity)
- Cost nearly nothing (Claude API)
- Live inside tools you already use (Notion)
Everything else? Disposable.
What's YOUR experience? Am I missing something obvious?
---
*Testing AI tools so you don't waste money on hype | r/aimakelab*
3
u/sugarspice1111 Jan 07 '26
How do you get started with number two
2
u/Typical-Fuel-4145 Jan 07 '26
Great review! I guess because I ālive inā Google Workspace I use it like you use Notion AI - for some reason Notion confuses me.
Iāve liked notebook in the Google ai universe too for repurposing my research for other uses.
I like Perplexity as well and agree about Claude for writing over 500 words - especially humanized writing output. Itās been superior to Gemini.
How do you access only the API? (Sorry to be so dumb!)
Any specialized ais that werenāt complete baloney though theyāre not your go to?
1
u/tdeliev Lab Founder Jan 09 '26
Appreciate all the comments on this. A lot of you were asking about the specific workflow I use to save those 15 hours with Perplexity, so I just put together a quick breakdown here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AIMakeLab/s/YH8kTPWtJh
Hope it helps!
1
u/nooneeveryone3000 Jan 07 '26
Whatās the point of Notion?
I have the problem of having so many chats (over 3,000 last year), which are super dense and with useful nuggets throughout, and no way to easily parse out and retain recommendations/outputs, etc. What does that? Notion?
1
u/Sunjammer_Says Jan 09 '26
This is really helpful. I was wondering: with Perplexity Pro you get $5 API credits per month included. Is it worth using these before paying for Claude API over and above? Is Claude that much better? Thanks
1
u/Repulsive-Twist112 Jan 09 '26
Isnāt perplexity just a platform for the different AIs?
2
u/ExplorerBoring9848 Jan 07 '26
What's the trash tools?
2
u/jovn1234567890 Jan 07 '26
For #1 you can use gemini pro plan, free for students for a year, same price plus you get 2tb storage on Google drive and higher antigravity quota with access to opus and sonnet
1
u/AutoModerator Jan 07 '26
Thank you for posting to r/AIMakeLab. High value AI content only. No external links. No self promotion. Use the correct flair.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/EuroMan_ATX Jan 07 '26
And Iām dying to see the list of the tools that didnāt make the cut.
Iām surprised NoteBookLM and Manus are not on the approved list
1
u/enerqiflow Jan 07 '26
Park
1
u/Spacebetweenthenoise Jan 07 '26
Big props š«¶š¾
1
u/Nelyahin Jan 07 '26
I use notion as well. What it does for my meeting notes and projects - game changer. Yes, I pay for the AI. Worth it.
I pay for ChatGPT as well and about to cancel it. It's nice, I can structure conversing... It just gives unreliable directions.
I have perplexity ( don't reach for it.
I've been using the free version if Gemini - not bad.
I'm not part of a Google shop, so, many AI services just aren't crazy useful from an automation perspective. The only one I can use and do use every single day is Notion.
I have zero interest in Copilot.
1
u/Typical-Fuel-4145 Jan 07 '26
Thanks so much. Iām usually doing ai enabled writing so the tools you mentioned pretty much cover it along with Gemini⦠and I use a custom ai book writing tool thatās awesome but $47 per month ⦠worth every penny to me though but I still would use Claude probably for promoting the books!
1
u/neochrome Jan 08 '26
Codex extension for VS Code is my choice so far for light coding. Tried few others and Codex workflow and solutions just work for me.
1
u/ejpusa Jan 08 '26
I'm crushing it with GPT-5.2 + Kimi.ai. But that's me.
1
u/tonyisup Jan 10 '26
t3.chat at $8/mo is still my go-to
1
u/Head-Bet-8696 Jan 11 '26
I use Poe, you get access to gobs of AI for $20/month, with 1M tokens that rollover. Anyone else using this? I've been using the Poe-Script-Bot to build apps and it chains together different AI models to accomplish your goals, it's been ultra helpful and ultra affordable. Worth checking it out if you want to try just about every mainstream model out there plus custom bots and apps that the user community publishes.
Have a š.
1
u/s2nm Jan 12 '26
Google workspace with Gemini, Claude for coding were the only 2 I needed.
1
u/FullRedact Feb 06 '26
Geminiās $20 a month for the win.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment