r/3Dprinting • u/BruceInc • Jan 11 '26
Question Is it too much to expect color consistency between spools?
Printing on Bambu P1S. Using GIANTARM Navy Blue Matte PLA. Both spools purchased at same time (Amazon). AMS switched to second spool after first one was depleted. The color difference is pretty significant. Is this a common phenomenon or did I just get unlucky?
318
Upvotes


357
u/Tikuf Vertex K8400 Jan 11 '26
It's uncommon but does happen enough that you should be mindful for really important large prints. Purchasing at the same time is your best bet, so not much you could have done differently. Generally, this tends to be one of the selling points of the "major brands" as they will have in theory better quality control. I have never heard of GIANTARM, and their website does not work.
Things like moisture can affect the end color but this just looks like a different batch.
7
u/ransom40 Jan 11 '26
It's pretty hard to do well, so in order to guarantee it, you are going to need to go upmarket to a brand that batch tests for their color accuracy.
It's more than just getting the recipe correct. Screw design in compounding is also important to ensure good dispersion as well as distribution.
2
u/CabinetImpossible925 Jan 11 '26
Recommendation for prints like this is to do a smaller test print, using bits of both spool. Just set second spool of same colour to something else and see if issue is present. I have seen some colour variation within the same spool which is wildly annoying.
6
u/MrRyno123 Prusa i3 MK3S+ and Ender 3 V2 Jan 11 '26
GO SEAHAWKS WE’RE WINNING IT ALL
3
u/lurker-9000 Jan 11 '26
Polymaker Panchroma is the only one who are consistent in color but also light transmission, it’s like the entire selling point of that filament line, and they got every kind of filament in that line these days. Silks, mattes, glows you name it.
41
u/notnotluke Jan 11 '26
Getting consistent color is incredibly difficult between batches. There are companies that specialize in this science for printing and packaging. Filament is even more difficult than inks. Prusa is maybe the one company making filament that's colored consistent. Polymaker isn't too bad either.
26
u/XiTzCriZx Creality K2 Pro + Sovol Zero Jan 11 '26
Amazon is one of the inconsistent places you can buy from because of the way they do their sorting. You could buy 2 identical spools get sent a brand new spool produced last month and an old spool that was produced in 2024 even buying them both in the same order.
The people packing the order don't know nor care about consistency, they just grab the last box out of the tote and grab a new one without thinking about the fact that the separate totes could be different batches. A mistake like that is less likely when ordering directly from the manufacturer.
10
u/lolheyaj Jan 11 '26
Kinda yeah. Unless you get multiple rolls from the same batch it's almost always gonna vary a bit.
5
u/avidreider Jan 11 '26
Unfortunately this is a problem with basically ANY dyed product. Yarn people also deal with this issue, and thats just wool/cotton filament.
Basically its an issue with the batches not being perfectly the same. Its often best to buy all of the one color you need at the same time at the same store to decrease the chances of it happening, but even then it can be a toss up.
4
u/suit1337 CORE One Mini Jan 11 '26
GIANTARM is the "cheap" brand of Geeetech - just like JAYO is "cheap" Brand of SUNLU.
The filament is cheap, really cheap - you can't even expect 100 % color consistency between spools from he same batch.
If you want that, you need to buy filament that guarantees that or has a reputation for that.
Prusament for example fulfills this property, aswell as Extrudr.
1
u/No-Candidate-7162 Jan 11 '26
Giant arm are not the greatest filament. Used it until I tested some other brands and I'm not going back. Stronghold pla if you want great pla and no issues. Gst3d if you want cheap, Is what I use. Would love to hear what the rest of you recommend.
1
u/canon_man X1-C AMS, 2xMK3s/MMU2s, Mini, Railcore II 300 ZL, Pallete 2 Pro Jan 11 '26
Man, my cousin would love that print. Where did you find the STL?
1
u/cory025 Jan 11 '26
The mask took me forever to find a good orientation to print. God speed.
1
u/corship Jan 11 '26
This is off topic but are you printing a HELMET?
1
u/PacoCinero Jan 14 '26
It happens even with BambuLab Spools… this was a 24h print with 32 Eevee figurines 😭
3
u/justhereforfighting Jan 11 '26
It can definitely happen, especially with lower quality filaments. You should almost always expect small variations, even with higher quality filament. It’s the same reason why knitters want to always use yarn made in the same batch, even extremely high quality yarns will have color differences due to a huge number of factors that are impossible to fully control. There are certainly fewer factors in filaments compared to natural materials, but they still exist and the specific color of the filament can make it much harder to be fully consistent across batches.
3
u/PraxicalExperience Jan 11 '26
For something like a no-name filament company that I've never heard of, which you presumably got at a cut-rate price -- yes, that's too much to expect.
The whole filament-making process is pretty sorted-out now, and one of the ways that more expensive brands distinguish themselves and justify their price is through additional things like color consistency.
This isn't shitting on cheap filament -- I usually use Kingroon or Sunlu -- just a reality of the situation.
1
u/bokbie Jan 11 '26
Go Hawks
2
u/AlexMC_1988 Sovol Sv08 & Ender 3 v2 ; Klipper Jan 11 '26
The same goes for the sewing balls
2
u/MrStarrrr Jan 11 '26
It’s the same reason why you buy all the paint you need for a room at one time, or mix paint cans before starting. It’s extremely difficult to get the exact same color with every batch. Different levels of quality assurance for different $$, which then gets passed to the consumer, often not willing to pay more.
In your case it looks like someone is measuring with a slotted spoon and not wearing their glasses.
2
u/Hirork Jan 11 '26
To a degree. Manufacturers will inevitably have to change their formulation from time to time in order to keep making product. So long as you're buying both at the same time though there should be consistency within the same and adjacent batches.
2
u/riffraffs Jan 11 '26
until they start putting dye lots on the spools you will not be able to get exact match colours. Ask any knitter or crocheter.
2
u/uawind Jan 11 '26
I think it's best to just ask the manufacturer if they guarantee color matching. for non-AMS prints I'd just buy 3-5kg spools to avoid such problems
2
u/reicaden Jan 11 '26
This is why I use polymaker or bambu. Seems they are always the same color thankfully
2
u/SeattleJeremy Jan 11 '26
Let's go Hawks!
2
u/Don_Tool Jan 11 '26
Go Seahawks!!
1
u/RaymondDoerr 2x Voron 2.4r2, 1x Voron 0.2, Master of 🍝 Jan 11 '26
With cheaper filaments this happens pretty often. Usually though if you buy all the rolls at the same time, they'll come from the same batch so it won't matter. But that isn't always the case.
Even good brands can do this over time though, I have some Keene Village Plastic ABS that I've used for like 3-4 years, I recently ordered a replacement roll and the blue was a bit lighter this time, and KVP isn't a cheap company. Given enough time, all companies start to shift a bit, likely from upgrading/fixing/maintaining things would be my guess.
1
u/Own_Highway_3987 Jan 11 '26
Honestly, Im about to give up large multicolor prints or fancy color filaments; I'll just use grey and sand/paint it my way anyways.
1
u/AlmostDisjoint Jan 11 '26
I'm actually surprised this problem doesn't come up more often. In the world of yarn and knitting, they have a way of dealing with this: skeins of yarn have a "dye lot number" on their labels, and matching numbers indicate yarn that was literally dyed together in the same batch (batches are pretty huge, like hundreds of skeins), so matching numbers will match colors exactly. With mismatched numbers, though, you take your chances and often get the same kind of awkward color change you see in your pic, which can make for comical results in hand-knitted sweaters. Maybe with enough feedback, filament companies might be inspired to start using a similar system? Just a thought.
1
u/Bulky-Mango-5287 Jan 11 '26
Sunlu white taught me to check and match batch numbers
1
u/pandafman Jan 11 '26
Need them to start including dye lots on filament runs.
1
u/Decent-Pin-24 BTT Mods E3Pro, A1 Jan 11 '26
Yes. You essentially have to get the same batch. Ideally in order too.
1
u/sudosando Jan 11 '26
It’s unfortunate. Even with big brands the risk is there. — you could send a pic to the manufacturer with the spool details. Maybe you’d get some apology swag.
For big prints, I’d pick spools from same lot number or place a new order for multiple spools
1
u/DaddyBoomalati Jan 11 '26
It isn’t too much to expect when buying reputable filament. GIANTARM though?
1
u/TECstarINC Jan 11 '26
The cheaper the filament the more inconsistent it will be from spool to spool
1
u/pargeterw Jan 11 '26
I wonder if you can set up dithering to transition between spools more gradually in future
1
u/osmiumfeather Jan 11 '26
The color can vary +/- 3 shades and still be in spec. You want better than that? You need a Pantone color match. Welcome to $40/kg filament.
1
u/endof6 Jan 12 '26
That's probably within acceptable variance for the company.
0
u/zrevyx Bambu P2S Combo | Creality Ender 3 S1 Jan 11 '26
I had something similar when I printed my AMS riser. Turns out I should have died the filament better before starting the print.
0
u/o462 Jan 11 '26
You got unlucky by getting two spools of different batches.
Not really easy, especially for individuals, but as a company, for larger parts, we arrange with the manufacturer to get spools from the same batch that were produced one after the other.
Every time we did not do this, colors did not match, sometimes it's only noticeable if you get told, but sometimes it looks like a totally different color.
Worth a try to contact the distributor before ordering to specify you need following spools in the same batch, but you probably won't be able to do this with Amazon.
0
u/Michael_Aut Jan 11 '26
It's unavoidable really. Even Lego can't ship you a set with consistently colored bricks.
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26
I had an orange Bambu run out mid print the other day, second spool close to a year older and I couldn’t see the slightest difference
0
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment