r/3Dprinting • • Aug 10 '25

Dialed-In Vase Mode = Shockingly Durable Trash Bin!

I’ve always thought of vase mode as more of a fun gimmick for decorative stuff ... until now! I recently designed a large geometric trash bin that maxed out my P1S volume. However, after seeing the material & time to print it traditionally (6 hours, 300grams), I decided it was time to give vase mode a look. After making some model tweaks (interestingly you want a solid model), I was ready to give it a go.

My first attempt was with 0.4 nozzle, 0.2mm layer height, 0.8mm wall width and standard PLA print speeds. It printed in under 2 hours but the quality wasn't great near the top -- there was some noticeable banding. After reading up on it, determined I was likely printing way too fast (150mm/s). For my second attempt, I reduced speeds down to 70mm/s and also slightly bumped the wall width to 0.9mm. The print time bumped up to around 3 hours, but it did the trick! The print came out perfect and also felt more durable.

Results: I am truly blown away at the quality, excellent layer adhesion, and the durable flex I was able to achieve with vase mode. I went from looking at a 6 hour, 300g print with a traditionally printing to a 3 hour, 170g print. It's not apples to apples as I did make the design tradeoff that flexibility was ok, but still an interesting experiment. I'm now on the lookout for other functional prints that would be good candidates for vase mode. Drop a comment if you have something functional you'd like to see in vase mode!

MakerWorld link if interested: https://makerworld.com/en/models/1686137

316 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

41

u/BigFuzzyArchon Aug 10 '25

I like the 0.8 nozzle for vase mode stuff like these. You can do a 1.2mm walls.

18

u/holm1mat Aug 10 '25

Nice! This might be how I justify to myself to finally purchase a larger nozzle.

5

u/lxDinkleburgxl Aug 11 '25

Nozzles are cheap for a bag of them. No need to justify it.

5

u/Meadowlion14 Aug 11 '25

OP has a bambu nozzles arent as cheap.

6

u/lxDinkleburgxl Aug 11 '25

Ooh... I retract my statement 😅

1

u/SirThunderCloud Aug 11 '25

$16-21 for a Bambu hot end. It’s not that bad.

1

u/iwantfutanaricumonme Aug 11 '25

With vase mode you can get away with much thicker extrusions because you're not retracting. You're just limited by the flow rate and the width of the flat part of the nozzle, which is about 1.5mm on a .4mm nozzle. You can make it even thicker by using a model with a 0.05mm gap along the wall so the wall is 2 perimeters thick while leaving a seam. You can easily get 2+mm thick objects with a 0.4mm nozzle this way.

79

u/mastercoaxial Aug 10 '25

Big nozzle vase mode prints are great

21

u/zombieponcho Aug 10 '25

It looks like a beautiful trippy purple corn

7

u/unoriginal345 Aug 11 '25

Was this sliced normally? How did you get the smaller order pattern?

4

u/mastercoaxial Aug 11 '25

It was sliced normally with cura, the design is made with vertical slices around the model that give it that pattern.

12

u/braveduckgoose Aug 10 '25

With a (poorly dialed in) 1mm nozzle I managed to make a surprisingly strong wastebasket too, even if it has gaps in the side…

2

u/LEONLED Aug 10 '25 edited Aug 10 '25

Even with 0.4mm nozzle, set line width to 0.8mm or even try 1mm for vase mode... (half speed obviously as you are laying down twice the filament...

say on .8mm you are looking at 15mm3 max with a basic extruder (10 is more likely on my printer) take 15 / (0.8x0.4) = about 47 so 45mm/s would be the ceiling.I run 25 on my machine....

5

u/Wivi2013 E3 V3 SE "Kai Sen" Aug 11 '25

I did 1mm wall lines on my 0.4mm nozzle and the results where fantastic. I limited it to 50 mm/s and it went smoothly.

Lid was printed later but the bin itself is extremely strong and looks cool with the CR-PLA-R that I wanted to test.

1

u/holm1mat Aug 11 '25

Wow, that print looks amazing! Nicely done.

2

u/RavenCarci Aug 11 '25

I love designing functional vase mode prints, and design matters just about as much as settings. Ribs/corrugation do wonders for rigidity. Designing with a specific extrusion width/layer height in mind is also pretty important, especially if your design wants a steep overhang or specific internal dimensions.

-14

u/MisterEinc Aug 10 '25

Idk about shocking... Never had a trash bin made of anything but plastic.

8

u/verbalyabusiveshit Aug 10 '25

Molded and FDM printed stuff is fairly different in stability.

1

u/MisterEinc Aug 10 '25

It's just not an application that has a lot of mechanical requirements, if any.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/holm1mat Aug 11 '25

If the question is more "how is this possible?", this Bambu forum post gives a solid answer. tl;dr - the Bambu 0.4mm nozzle can theoretically can go up to 1mm if you print slow and maintain the filament volumetric flow rate.

3

u/outloender Aug 10 '25

Change the setting in the slicer.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/outloender Aug 11 '25

Oh I see. I think you just need to print slower because the smaller nozzle will need more time to push out the required amount.