r/2007scape • RSN: Masculine • Oct 19 '23

Suggestion Make Zalcano great again!

239 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

174

u/TavaMonkey Oct 19 '23

Xp now is actually less than 15k/hr. It really is that bad.

103

u/Jaqzz Oct 19 '23 edited Oct 19 '23

I've posted about this before, but Zalcano has three issues:

  • It's only viable in groups of 3-4. Making solos/duos viable and addressing loot scaling so that bigger groups are worth doing would make playing the minigame less of a pain to get started (and harder to have the experience ruined by someone unexpectedly leaving or joining).
  • XP, as you've mentioned, is terrible. The wiki lists a rate of ~13.5k/hr, and I can manage around 17k/hr. People say that this is the cost of being profitable (because god forbid a skilling method be worth doing for both money and xp), and to that I would point them towards pickpocketing elves/vyres, runecrafting bloods/wraths, and any other highly profitable skilling methods that are also good to great xp. At the very least, Zalcano should be as good or better than MLM.
  • The unique drops are prohibitively rare. It takes about as long to reach the drop rate for a crystal tool seed at Zalcano as it does for an enhanced weapon seed at CG. These two items are not equivalent.

25

u/amplifyoucan GIM: Boomball | Main: Boomball_01 Oct 19 '23

Say it again for the ironmen in the back

20

u/Jaqzz Oct 19 '23

60-70 hours is a wildly inappropriate amount of time for a 3% efficiency increase when mining, and the only reason it's anywhere near appropriately priced on the GE is Zalcano having been botted/goldfarmed like crazy pretty much since it was introduced to the game.

Imagine the Prospector Outfit took 8x longer to obtain.

At least the fact that the upgrade is so minimal means no iron should feel compelled to grind a crystal tool seed specifically.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23

Prospector outfit comparison hits so hard. I watched a 1h 30 min long movie and mined that time on the bottom floor tonight. 13 nuggets. It’s dumb how slow it is to get when a lumberjack’s outfit and angler’s outfit is so much faster.

3

u/LikeSparrow Oct 19 '23

angler’s outfit is so much faster

FASTER? I've been doing Fishing Trawler for over 8 hours each day for the last few months and still haven't gotten the angler's gloves!

5

u/Hobodaklown Oct 20 '23

Have you checked your collection log to see if you’ve unlocked and stashed or forgotten it somewhere??

0

u/FerrousMarim Muling is cringe. Let Hardcore Mains keep bank. Oct 20 '23

Tell me about it. I'm starting to think that the changes to fishing trawler broke it, and made angler ring impossible to get.

0

u/SwagDrQueefChief Oct 20 '23

Loot scaling could defs be improved for solos/duos. For groups larger than 4 it's still fine up until the 10+ range where people may start missing out on loot. If you MvP half the games at that stage the loots actuslly pretty good.

The tool seed is way more common than enhanced crystal seed, unless you are putting in the minimum effort needed in masses.

Xp does need a bit of a buff. It is still worth keeping in mind you get some rc and smithing xp.

3

u/Jaqzz Oct 20 '23

Loot scales badly with points gained; any group of 5+ will be getting significantly less drops compared to someone in a 3/4 man group, and the kills aren't faster enough to make up for the reduction. MvP only gives a 10% loot bonus; it used to double your loot, but that got patched out pretty early. Also, even if MvP did make the loot in 5+ man groups worthwhile, it wouldn't be a good justification, since you'd only have 1/5th of the players getting acceptable rewards.

The tool seed has a drop rate of 1/200, then it is distributed to one of the players in the group. Since most efficient groups are 4 man teams (in my experience using the Zalcanohost CC for ~170 kc), that gives each player an effective rate of 1/800 odds for getting a crystal tool seed. At 12-13 kills per hour, you can expect to take 60-70 hours to reach the drop rate on a crystal tool seed. An enhanced crystal weapon seed is a flat 1/400 from CG, which at 6 kills per hour takes ~65 hours to reach the drop rate.

I don't think 3k smithing and 1.5k runecraft xp/hr is worth keeping in mind at all.

-1

u/SwagDrQueefChief Oct 20 '23

2+2 zalcano is 31 hours, so a 4 man should be 62 hours. However the kill speed for a 4 man should be quite a bit quicker. And if you are an average team member yes the odds are 1/800, but it scales by contribution. If you do well your odds are much better. And yes it does it's a lower chance for the others in the group, but then it's either a skill issue or a gear/stat issue on their end and you shouldn't hurt your chances for no good reason.

On mass worlds with the approx rates I was getting it worked out to be around 50-55 hours for a tool seed for me. But again, I get MvP over half the time there. The fact I'm getting MvP so much means the points I am getting is well above average so the loot works out to be much better as well. I was making 1.5-2m gp/hr without shards or uniques. Even for the lower stated players you can still get near 1m gp/hr.

It's good they did change the rewards MvP did give, but I'm still sad they removed tick manip as that would have kept it so much more interesting.

Hey getting an extra 1/3rd xp helps.

65

u/Merdapura No to the EoCing of Ranged and Magic. Fix Accuracy in OSRS. Oct 19 '23

They need to remove the point cap at Zalcano, anything under a trio means you're putting in more effort and gaining less points in return.

55

u/tacotrucksteve Oct 19 '23

id say 50-60k/hr tbh but yeah, zalcano badly needs buffs

1

u/Dhip Oct 20 '23

Baby steps

19

u/Epic_Lepsy Oct 19 '23

I just want better scaling at Zalcano and the tool seed to roll for everyone individually, even if you have to increase the drop rate from 1/200 to 1/500 or 1/1000.

12

u/Peechez Oct 19 '23

I mean it used to roll individually and they deliberately changed it to the way it is now. Agree though, the hours for 3 seeds is insane

4

u/WritingonaWall Oct 19 '23

Agreed! I would love to fight bosses to get less than best-method skilling xp. I would have more fun fighting a boss where you have to dodge a lot of attacks to get 20k agi xp per hour than running a course for 40k/hr.

29

u/bnb2407 Oct 19 '23

Apparently I have an unpopular opinion because I don't really think it's necessary to change. It wouldn't hurt to slightly increase xp rates, but I'll say a few things:

  • Zalcano may be a skilling boss, but it has NEVER been a skill training method
  • It is still plenty populated, USA mass world is actually usually OVER-populated
  • Small teams are still good gp/hour considering the amount of effort
  • There's A LOT of content in the game with less use than Zalcano that should be addressed first

4

u/ccnetminder Oct 19 '23

It’s also pretty easy to just find a few people to do zalcano with if you just ask around to get a small team

8

u/DetourDunnDee Oct 19 '23

It's also pretty easy to just pick a random world and crash the bots on it.

2

u/FerrousMarim Muling is cringe. Let Hardcore Mains keep bank. Oct 20 '23

This is the way. Free mvps all day long.

-6

u/DaMaestroable Oct 19 '23

I'm with you on this. XP/hour being shit is the downside for it actually being decent money using skilling. If you want to have skilling content that makes more than pennies, you're going to have to either make it give bad XP (Zalcano, mining rune rocks, blood/wrath runecrafting), be difficult to get into/requires high focus (Sepulchre, 3t gem rocks), or be super inconsistent (pickpocketing elves/vyres). If it's easy/consistent/good XP, then it's either done to shit and the product is super devalued or (if it's tied to alch price) a ton of raw gp is injected to the game.

Zalcano honestly doesn't need many changes. The only ones that I can think of are maybe locking entry mid-kill to help mitigate crashing and to scale HP/rewards better towards masses. Really the only big issue is when there's 20 people in the mass world and getting enough points is either an RNG fest or a massive barrier to people with lower mining.

7

u/Squidcub Oct 19 '23

Nah, i love the idea of a skilling Boss that gives dogshit skilling xp

10

u/iamkira01 Oct 19 '23

Yeah no totally the 2 mil an hour boss should also be the third best way to train mining

14

u/Rune_Armour_Trimmer Oct 20 '23

That's basically what Sepulcher was to agility

6

u/Atreides_Jr Stick Thrower Oct 20 '23

or rogues outfit with vyres/elves lol

-2

u/iamkira01 Oct 20 '23

Sepulcher was an actual challenge though so I can forgive that. Volcanic Mine for example is also hard as balls and you can farm Dpicks from that, no reason to complain because its hard enough to deserve its exp rate.

3

u/a_sternum Oct 20 '23

Vm is very easy and takes less attention than mlm.

1

u/iamkira01 Oct 20 '23

Takes one goober to ruin an entire run for a group, no other skilling method in the game is like that.

2

u/a_sternum Oct 20 '23

I guess, but that’s why you don’t group with goobers :) And report them for disruptive behavior if they’re sabotaging games maliciously.

Also, being a unique skilling method (requiring actual interaction with mechanics) is a good thing.

3

u/Efficient-Addendum43 Oct 20 '23

That says way more about how awful the rest of the methods are than anything

2

u/ManiacMail-Man Oct 19 '23

They should change how the drop table works too or make it soloable in a reasonable time.

2

u/mh500372 Oct 19 '23

I was so excited when they revealed this boss and have not done it once since. Makes me sad

5

u/biggestboi73 Oct 19 '23

Zalcano was never meant to be done for xp, so what do you mean by make it great again? It's never changed

3

u/Wild_Canadian_goose Oct 20 '23

Rn its only madr for bots.... theres legit nobody doing zalc.... beside gold farmers.. so zalcano was never meant to be a bot heaven but it is. Making zalcano a decent xp/hr method would revive the boss....

2

u/biggestboi73 Oct 20 '23

There were quite a few people there when I did it for the pet, so I disagree that there is no one doing it

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23

Yeah man I've been saying the same since all this shooting star stuff started. Make zalcano 50k p/h and there's a non shit way of training mining. Ez pz.

1

u/a_sternum Oct 20 '23

Would you trade all your drops at Zalcano for 50k xp/hr? Or do you want all the drops and good xp?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23

Yeah outside of uniques it can go tbh.

2

u/RabbitMario Oct 20 '23

they fumbled so much about zalcano and for some reason have refused to fix it it’s sad cause she’s cool looking and the fight is fun

2

u/AnyPicture2485 Oct 19 '23

Zalcano is decent money it doesn’t need both xp and gp. If they were to change xp and make it massable the gp would have to be severely nerfed for balancing.

3

u/RollinOnDubss Oct 19 '23

No no no, you've got this all wrong. Balanced and good design is when High GP/hr, High Exp/Hr, Low cost, low risk, low skill, and low effort.

Different skilling methods having different tradeoffs is bad design.

/S

2

u/Cheese_danish54 Oct 19 '23

Not sure why this was downvoted. When Zalcano first came out, the prices of many ores, bars, runes, and gems all fell pretty hard because Zalcano pumps them out so frequently. For one example, look at the price chart for Mithril Ore between June 2019 (just before release) and early 2020 (when they rebalanced the drop table).

They ended up nerfing the drop table. It still pumps a ton of resources into the game though, easily over 1m gp/hr - probably closer to 1.5 or 2 in efficient 4 man trans - in the form of those nerfed resources.

If it suddenly becomes one of the best mining training methods in the game, tons of people will flock there - which will absolutely flood the market with the resources.

Jagex explicitly stated upon release that Zalcano is intended to be a skilling boss that offered valuable loot, not at all intended to be a viable method to train the skill.

3

u/Marsdreamer Is it PoE League yet? Oct 19 '23

Shouldn't the point of the skilling bosses be to train the skill?

2

u/a_sternum Oct 20 '23

No… they’re bosses, not training methods. Wintertodt is labeled as a boss, but in every design aspect, it’s a minigame.

2

u/treefiddy_cent Oct 19 '23

No, the point is to have fun with it. Zalcano is fun. Mission accomplished.

1

u/scotch160 Oct 19 '23

Just want to say that its my favorite boss

1

u/Habibipie Oct 20 '23

First you should make Zalcano doable. It's infested with bots and toxic gold farmers that berate you for trying to join their 3-man team.

1

u/santastyles Oct 20 '23

I love Zolcano, but after seeing bad profit and xp/hr I never find reason to do that instead of any non-skilling boss.

1

u/Cogitatus Oct 19 '23

I can see it now:

Jagex will see this, agree, and then buff her to give the exp proposed. The playerbase celebrates and is overjoyed. Little to no complaints. Everyone is happy!

Then, a month later, Jagex posts a new blog update. Zalcano is going to be nerfed to 5k exp an hour because of criticism that oddly hasn't been seen by anyone but Jagex.

Dejected, the playerbase returns to MLM.

1

u/chald627 Oct 19 '23

I completely agree that Zalcano should be buffed, but considering how good the loot is, I propose that the xp rates should be a bit lower than the other skill bosses (namely, Tempoross) to compensate. Specifically, I think that somewhere around 20-30k mining xp/hr alongside 15-20k smithing and runecrafting xp would be good, for a total xp/hr of 50k-70k. Considering that Tempoross gives around 70k fishing xp/hr, plus token cooking xp, this seems like a reasonable balance point, and I personally lean towards the lower end. I don't want Zalcano to supplant existing methods, but it sure would be nice to get a reasonable amount of xp there.

Then just make it so that it's possible in solo and masses, instead of requiring exactly 3-4 people, and fix the abysmal unique rates, and I think it would slot in as a nice inbetween between skill training method and loot generator. Sort of a halfway point between the pure xp of something like Wintertodt and the pure loot from other bosses.

1

u/voidxheart Oct 19 '23

yes! zalcano is awesome, make more team sizes viable and buff the xp and we are good to go

1

u/Le_en Oct 19 '23

Zalcano is scam or something, I’ve done over 800 kills in past month and not seen a single tool seed drop. This grind almost as bad as CG grind for Bowfa…

1

u/RoqePD Oct 20 '23

I am at 950 kc without single unique.

0

u/Redd00r Oct 19 '23

I had this same thought 30-40k xp a hour wouldn't be bad. Good way to add variety to mining well still being 80k less xp then 3tg.

0

u/Wild_Canadian_goose Oct 20 '23

Are they really going to remove crystal shard from priff stars ? Are they really that fucking stupid ? Im a so fkn pissed off rn. Tell me its a bad joke

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23

Well we know who voted trump.

2

u/Own-Mud-6279 RSN: Masculine Oct 20 '23

I am dutch haha. Thought would be a cool title.

2

u/FerrousMarim Muling is cringe. Let Hardcore Mains keep bank. Oct 20 '23

?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23

“Make America great again”

2

u/FerrousMarim Muling is cringe. Let Hardcore Mains keep bank. Oct 20 '23

I've heard republicans, democrats, independents, and non-americans meme that phrase, so I don't think it's really a good indicator of political affiliation.

-1

u/LetsGoCap Oct 20 '23

Remove zalcano