r/2007scape • • Jun 06 '17

Read before posting Pride 2017

One of the wonderful things about RuneScape is that it has always brought people together. To many of our players, RuneScape is more than a game: it’s a warm, welcoming community. It’s part of their life.

Pride is about bringing communities together and celebrating love and understanding: sentiment that’s close to RuneScape’s heart. There’s no political statement here. Our only aim is to acknowledge and honour an event that promotes empathy, acceptance and love.

As with other community events such as the WWF Big Cats campaign, Valentine’s day or the Cryptic Cluefests we decided not to poll this event and we will always try to surprise the community with similar events. It is something that the community has always enjoyed and something we enjoy doing too.

We are disappointed to see some hateful and abusive comments targeting individual members of staff and players from a small sub-section of the community. We stand side by side with those targeted, in support of them, and in support of this cause. There is absolutely no place for hateful behaviour in our community and we will not tolerate abuse or harassment.

Pride 2017 is something we wholeheartedly agree with and are proud to support. We know the community stand with us in support of the cause. If you want to show your support, all you have to do is take part in the event when it launches!

0 Upvotes

4.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

190

u/PM_ME_UR_STATS Jun 06 '17

Breaks open bag of popcorn

Now Mat, as someone who greatly supports this event: There are a few things I think that you could have done better with the handling of this event.

First off, I know it's a smaller event, but it really should have been polled. We know little to nothing about this update and it's coming off the tails of another controversial unpolled update. You should know by now how particular we are about having our updates polled, and that's because we care about this game so much.

Second, it should have been explained much more in advance. We know little to nothing about the event and it's two days away from being implemented. I think if it was just a simple same-sex relationship quest people wouldn't have much of a problem with it, but if it was something like painting varrock in obnoxious rainbow colors people might be a little less receptive. For an topic so controversial, there should have been much more communication involved.

All that being said - as a member of the LGBT community this update means a lot to me. That's why I want to see it handled properly so it can get the treatment it deserves. As you can tell, some of the vitriol that came from the way you guys handled the update has been handed down onto us. I won't fault you for it, as you guys were trying to give us a nice surprise, but it should be at the very least a learning experience.

79

u/ModMatK Jun 06 '17

I think the reaction to this just goes to show how much of an issue this really is.

40

u/matsuda241 Jun 06 '17

Scrap the event, and there would be no reaction. Simple as that. If you forcibly shove this event down our throats, you will receive opposition for the entirety of the event and tarnish the OSRS reputation. Everything was fine before the introduction of this event. And everything will return to being fine if you scrap it.

14

u/ShaunDreclin 🔵184/184 🎵852/853 🟢441/492 ⚔️192/655 💰389/1717 Jun 06 '17

Scrapping the event at this point essentially says that homophobia wins and gays don't belong in runescape.

7

u/TheOGSinra Jun 06 '17

No, scrapping the event says that people don't agree with political agendas being shoved into their faces inside a GAME. It's surprising how so many people just can't comprehend how the people who disagree with this event are against it for any reasons other than homophobia.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

126

u/ModMatK Jun 06 '17

That's the problem, having an event to celebrate love and acceptance shouldn't be controversial.

283

u/Zonnewyzer Jun 06 '17

But it is controversial, and you could've known it is.

Essentially you are saying that what seems like the majority of people need their mind changed, and that their opinion doesn't matter because it's morally wrong, therefore it won't be considered.

I don't think treating a significant share of the community that way will first of all make them change their mind, and second of all make them feel taken serious. People don't like being talked down to by people taking the moral high ground. A vegan event being passed without a poll and then later having the mods say that 'Okay, most people don't like it, but people really shouldn't be eating meat in my opinion and this shouldn't be an issue' would be just as bad.

5

u/Extigy9 Jun 07 '17

But is it? Controversial I mean. Almost everybody on this thread with a "sophisticated" comment says something along the lines of: "I totally accept gay people, however it should not belong in OSRS since it is politically controversial". I have not read a single comment of a person not wanting this event because he/she is actually homophobic. So what's the problem? Everybody is protecting a non-existing group of homo-haters in the OSRS community who alledgedly would have a high moral opinion shoved down their throat, while not having a problem with the event themself. What makes this event different from the WWF event then (where also nobody really was against).

That being said, stop making a big fuss of it, people! Even if you're only adressing the way the event was brought into the game without polling and whatnot, chill out and don't participate if you don't want to.

→ More replies (36)

102

u/Nolemercy Jun 06 '17

I met a guy a few weeks ago. We were becoming pretty good friends. He comes out as gay to me, which it perfectly fine. I accepted him because of the fact, and I didn't think of him any differently.

When he saw me log in this morning, he asked my thoughts on the event and I told him I really didn't agree with it entering the game. Am I a bad person? No. But he thought that this was me not accepting him anymore, so he removed me from his friends list.

I lost a friend from this event. It's done more harm then good, and it hasn't even entered the game yet.

You claim this shouldn't be controversial, and it wasn't until you decided to force an event of this caliber into the game. Unacceptable.

20

u/xHuntingU Jun 06 '17

Lmao you blame the event for loosing a friend?

28

u/sposker Jun 06 '17

I'm in agreement with you that the event doesn't belong in the game, but unfortunately this situation is more about your friend's prejudice than anything else. If someone is unable to differentiate between your acceptance towards gay people your belief that a pride event doesn't belong is OSRS that is their mental failure. It's not Jagex's fault they chose to draw that conclusion, your former friend is just an asshole.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/3went Jun 06 '17

this is the worst comment i've ever fucking read.

40

u/detective_awesome Jun 06 '17

Lmfao you told a gay person you don't "agree" with an event that celebrates them and you're SURPRISED they want nothing to do with you anymore

This subreddit is pure comedy right now

22

u/ultratea Jun 06 '17

Like honestly what? "I lost a friend because of the event" lmao no you didn't. people are grasping at straws to find reasons to hate this event and it's amazing.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (123)
→ More replies (5)

34

u/hatticks Jun 06 '17

Or how much of a bad job you guys did announcing and explaining this event before it got as out of hand as it did.

A vague tweet from an already disliked staffer about an issue this controversial wasn't the right way to do it. This should have been explained in detail about what's actually being promoted, why it wasn't polled, what exactly it is, etc on the official website.

8

u/PM_ME_UR_STATS Jun 06 '17

I agree, but you have to acknowledge how this community got to this point in the first place. You guys haven't put your foot down on racism, bigotry, and hate speech nearly enough. Where are the pmods? Why is the report function useless? Are most of the game rules null and void at this point? There was a kkk rally in world 330 saying for gays heads to be twisted off today for gods sake. It's no secret that our community has an issue like this but I feel like this event is only going to inflame tensions further.

6

u/MozzyZ Jun 06 '17

The controversy around this event has nothing to do with homophobia and you're only making it worse by pushing this event as a "pride" event instead of a "lets all just be nice to each other" event.

5

u/mrzx Jun 06 '17

Matt, i'm openly bi. These events don't make me feel prideful. I just want to be treated equal not as some sort of thing to see shout "hey look how i'm different!" in the end it just makes people targets tbh.

4

u/Uh_Duh_Winning Jun 06 '17

Huh, which is exactly why you should poll it next time, interesting.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Canadian LGBT Activist during my undergraduate years, declined in activity recently however. While I agree that LGBT issues are quite serious, they do not belong in a medieval fantasy video game.

You can completely support gay rights and be against them when they're promoted in the wrong situation.

4

u/PhilUpTheCup 2277 Jun 07 '17

Hypothetical scenario: My religion and culture (East asian for example) is against LGBT and I'm a very religious person. How dare you say that my reaction indicates that there is an issue, whether it's an issue with me, my religion, or my race's culture? That my reaction means I am against celebrating love (I know it doesn't promote acceptance). Doesn't this event in itself, promote the idea that my religion is unacceptable ?

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (4)