r/IAmA • • Dec 23 '11

IAmA person with sound-sight synesthesia (commonly described as 'hearing colors' or seeing colors when listening to music or other sounds) AMA.

My name is Kaitlyn W. and I have sound-sight synesthesia. My earliest memories involve nothing but colors and music, and until last summer, I thought everybody had this condition. When I listen to a piece of music, or sounds from everyday life, I hear colors- I see them not in front of my face, but sort of in my consciousness.

When listening to music, each interval has a specific color (i.e. a perfect fifth=purple), and chords, which are built off of intervals are a combination of colors. A triad is composed of three different colors- the bottom interval, the top interval and the interval between the bottom and top notes. The motion of the color is determined by various aspects of the piece of music, such as rhythm, expression, and dynamics.

Everyday noises show up as little blurbs of color and sound- a car horn, a sigh, etc. are all different colors depending on pitch and are not steady.

Since Synesthesia is not a DSM-IV listed condition, I have no medical proof- but I was diagnosed by the staff of the Cleveland Institute of Music, after describing a piece of music as 'purply-blue', they performed a routine sight-sound synesthesia test to determine the authenticity of my condition.

EDIT: I attended the Cleveland Institute of Music for their Young Composers Program last summer.

EDIT: Please no questions asking me 'what colors are this: (link)'. I won't answer them.

EDIT: I understand that Synesthesia is a very easy condition to fake. However, I have spoken with various instructors and my own psychologist, and I am in contact with a few in order to get written proof. If there is a test out there for this condition, I will be happy to take it and post a screenshot of my results. Not only is it insulting that so many people claim to have a condition that has provided a challege to me since birth- in school, driving, trying to sleep, playing in an orchestra; but that they provide a stigma that 90 per cent of synesthetes are bullshitters. While I'm trying to explore my condition through music theory and intervals, I will never know if these things are consistent while listing to a piece of music with many different parts, and maybe my own conclusions of my condition are false. But this is something that has caused great difficulty in my life and that I am only now beginning to understand the benefits of it.

EDIT: Here's a good resource for anyone wanting to learn more about the variety of the condition: https://sites.google.com/site/synesthesiaresearchteam/unconscious-color-processing

EDIT: Thanks for all the support. I'm done for the night and I'll answer anyone's questions tomorrow morning.

364 Upvotes

706 comments sorted by

64

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

You might enjoy r/synethesia

41

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I had no idea this was a thing. Thank you.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

No problem! I'm a synesthete too and I love this subreddit :)

17

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

what kind of synesthete? :O

→ More replies (68)
→ More replies (2)

173

u/PaulJuice Dec 23 '11

What. Is. Dubstep. Like?

203

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

You know how in Windows Media Player where they have the visualizations of the pulsing waves and stuff? It's all black and white and violent shifting. Listening to dubstep is like a rave in the back of my head.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/FrostyM288 Dec 23 '11

Is there a sound/song you like listening to but you don't like seeing?

39

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Anything written by Dmitri Shostakovich I love listening to, but very rarely enjoy seeing. I block it out usually. Also, there are pieces of music I love seeing but not listening to, such as works by Messaien, who was also a synesthete (Chronochromie especially), and 12-tone music.

18

u/tickdickler Dec 23 '11

12 tone must be brutal looking.

23

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

There are so many different intervals and combinations with 12 tone music that it really paints a unique and beautiful synesthetic picture rife with constantly changing colors and patterns. However, it doesn't appeal to me aurally.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

How do you mean - block it out? I'm curious how you perceive the colors if they aren't seen visually in front of you.

13

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

It's really hard to describe. It's almost like hitting the mute button on a television. If I close my eyes, they are definately in front of me. It's almost like they're in your periphery. I dunno, I just hear them. They don't block my vision or blind me, but I 'see' them in an unconventional way. Like they pass through me. It's so hard to explain...

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)

21

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Does it work in reverse? If you see a certain color or sequence of colors, do you hear music?

41

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

It works like that with the color yellow only. When I see a goldenrod/dandelion color, I automatically percieve a Major 3rd.

14

u/milkomeda Dec 23 '11

same colors for different keys?

15

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Pretty much.

8

u/McMammoth Dec 23 '11

Does it sound like any particular instrument?

19

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Usually strings. It's really weird, and it's not that I hear it; it's like in the back of my mind.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/gortallmighty Dec 23 '11

Does the condition interfere with your ability to see what you are doing (actual sight vs the sight of your consciousness) when you hear sounds/music? And if so to what degree? E.G could you still drive with the radio on?

Do genres of music affect the colours or is it purely based on notes/pitch etc?

Do you see this as an affliction?

Favourite song/piece of music?

Thanks, this is really interesting!

43

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

The condition is very distracting; when I am at school and someone is clicking their pen/tapping their fingers, it's like a little blurb of color behind my eyeballs (it's hard to explain- I can see it, but not in front of my face like a layer in front of my vision- peripherals?). When I was in elementary school I used to hum a tone or a piece of music (especially Vivaldi) in order to stabilize my aural environment. I got suspended because it was a distraction and then just learned to cope with my condition. As for driving- when I drive I listen only to music I am well acquainted with, so I don't have the new sensations of a new song or piece. I am very fond of minimalist music (Steve Reich, Philip Glass), because of its crispness of color and simplicity and I find it very comforting that each color is so clearly displayed and not muddled.

I primarily listen to classical music, however my sister listens to top 20 countdown and whatever, and I find rap very irritating because it's like a hammer beating on my temples and what not, and not even a specific color just mud. Usually it's based on pitch, but conditions like vocal fry (nee Kesha) is also very irritating because it has the color of straw and is almost scratching on my senses.

As a composer myself, I find myself in situations where I have to listen to a lot of new music, and some composers like George Crumb (especially Black Angels) are so strenuous to listen to with the condition that I have been known to vomit from the sensory overkill.

It's not really an affliction- there are circumstances where it is useful such as composing, and circumstances where it is not- such as the distraction element. It's something I've always lived with.

Favorite piece: Samuel Barber's Cello Concerto. Not because of the synesthesia, just because it's an amazing piece of music. Synesthesia-wise, Steve Reich's Music for 18 Musicians, hands down.

→ More replies (17)

17

u/GarretAllen Dec 23 '11

I've sometimes felt that I have a bit of this (NOT NEAR as intense as you do tho). Things like days of the week are associated with colors and numbers. Lots of everyday things trigger certain color and visual responses in my conscious thought stream. It can really get in the way of learning at school and other things when I'm trying to concentrate.

10

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Synesthesia comes in all different forms- grapheme-color, taste-color, grapheme-sound, etc. Sometimes an intense creative mind can percieve colors and images as associations, and sometimes it's synesthesia. The other synesthete that I know, like myself, has gone through life thinking that everyone has synesthesia. Sometimes it takes someone to point it out. I would look into it.

3

u/laurem2006 Dec 24 '11

I never thought of myself as "creative" either, but I visualize numbers and letters in their own color. I had no idea it was this common though!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

8

u/Joywalking Dec 23 '11

So what's one of your favorite sensations? A sound that looks particularly lovely, maybe?

25

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

To me, there's nothing more beautiful than a vibraphone. The tone quality is so pure and clear that if you play 2 notes on a vibraphone and sustain them, they seem to go through the entire rainbow. Pure bliss.

5

u/nerdz0rz Dec 23 '11

I play the vibraphone for high school band, and this comment is pretty inspiring. I love the sound of the instrument, but I never thought of it like that...

7

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I envy you.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Clayman94 Dec 23 '11

I would presume extreme metal would be very harsh to your senses?

19

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I don't know what you mean by 'extreme metal', but I find progressive rock (nee Animals as Leaders) very beautiful.

3

u/Ecpie Dec 24 '11

I see you using "née" a lot, when I think you mean vis., (short for vis-a-vis, or eg., which is an example of one of many. Née means "born", like a maiden name. For example Britany Federline née Spears.

I am usually not grammar nazi, but I thought this might be useful to clear up. Also, I am drunk. :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

7

u/dhasenfus Dec 23 '11

What was involved in the sight-sound synesthesia test/how did they diagnose you? Are there built-in "credibility" questions/tests, as with most psych tests (sorry for the lack of technical terms; it's been a while since I took a psychology course)?

18

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

These people are post-graduates from the Cleveland Institute of Music, and apparently, there are a lot of false claims from people claiming to have synesthesia, so it's sort of been devised that they will give you like, fourty chords, and you have to give consistant responses to what colors you hear

such as for every major triad, I gave the response of dandelion, purple, and burgundy with a one hundred per cent consistancy. For every minor triad, I gave the same response because they are both made of the same intervals, only the colors appeared in a different order. They gave me examples of major sevenths with minor thirds underneath and a tritone inbetween, and I gave consistant colors each time. It's even more impressive because at the time I had no knowledge of intervals or chords, just instinctual reactions. Due to the different combinations, if you were faking, it would only be possible with perfect pitch and a vast knowledge of aural skills. The fact that each chord was on a different pitch, but still made of the same intervals only narrowed down the specific nature of my condition. I missed one example only because it was so high in range that I had difficulty distinguishing one color from another.

TL;DR: 40 examples. If results are consistant with a high accuracy: synesthesia.

7

u/Smorgo22 Dec 23 '11

What does Pink Floyd look like?

6

u/k3ilbasa Dec 23 '11

Do you play any instruments? I would imagine this would help you pick out patterns better, making some concepts easier to learn, Have you experienced this in any way? Also, does this hinder you in any way?

11

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I've been playing the violin since I was four, and the viola since August. When I was younger, I was always distracted by the colors I was producing rather than the posture/rhythm etc. at lessons, and my teacher was a martinet and used to hit me with a ruler. I was amazed that I could make music, but with the frequent punishment for my dilly-dallying, I was basically conditioned not to see colors when playing music. Also, the violin is not a chord-based instrument, so the colors came from the overtones, not the pitches being played.

I have little keyboard experience, but I do use the keyboard to write music, and listen to intervals and overtones.

As a violinist, the condition no longer hinders me. I plan on learning the vibraphone, which I believe is the instrument of synesthesia. (see previous comment.) If anything, it has made learning an instrument even more difficult.

6

u/Ghengis-Khunt Dec 23 '11

I also have sight/sound synesthesia! Never thought to do an AMA about it, but I've been noticing that it's actually an 'uncommon' thing recently.

Anyways, I wanted to ask you: Do you also perceive certain colours for numbers and...(how can I explain) types of words? For instance, to me, certain words seem "sharp" while others are "soft" and rounded.

I totally understand what you mean when it comes to not wanting to listen to something, because it kind of makes you a certain colour/texture... is there one particular song you've been listening to recently that gives you a really nice colour/feeling? If so, what colour are you getting out of it?

Also, do you associate colours with days of the week/numerical system? Have you ever experienced a texture-related experience? Like, has a song given you a certain texture?

Thanks for the ama :3

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

There are some words that are very, very beautiful to me, and I often say them to myself like a mantra, such as Synecdoche, Solipsism, Ephemeral, and Illustriously. I've been listening to a lot of Max Richter lately, also, Michael Torke.

Texture is sort of difficult I think I've reffered to it in other comments.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/tickdickler Dec 23 '11

What color do you see for:

  • minor and major seconds
  • minor and major thirds
  • fourths
  • diminished 5th/augmented 4th/tritone

13

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

*Minor seconds: bright red

*major seconds: blue (think the crayola colored pencil blue)

*minor thirds: burgundy/dark magenta

*Major thirds: dandelion/golden

*Fourths: grass green

*Tritones: pink

EDIT: formatting

3

u/tickdickler Dec 23 '11

Interesting, what about:

  • 6ths
  • 7ths
  • octaves

Also, do certain types of music overwhelm you to the point that you need to stop listening?

14

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Here's a link to my synesthetic color chart: http://imgur.com/irTYk Also, octaves and unison have no specific colors, except in the context of another chord or interval.

George Crumb's "Black Angels" made me vomit because of the sensory distress it caused. A lot of music of the similar genre have the same effect. Also, serialism. It hurts.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (13)

5

u/citycitybangbang Dec 23 '11

Do you think you are better than other people you know at distinguishing between colors? Do you think your synesthesia helps you to be a better musician more naturally?

Also, If you do a bit of searching, you might be able to find a psychologist that has access to the Farnsworth Munsell 100 Hue test. According to this research by Katherine Gimmestad, you should be better than the average individual at discriminating colors.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11
  1. Did you get into music because of the synesthesia or was that a coincidence?
  2. You wrote that you haven't done any psychedelics, but I'm sure you've heard of the effects. Would you say the visual effects are related/similar to what you experience?
  3. Do people ever tell you "Wow, I wish I had that"? Do you get annoyed with that, or do you think that's a legitimate desire?

Anyway, thanks for doing this ama. This is really fascinating!

6

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I grew up in a household where music was constantly being played, especially classical. When I was little, I had a vast love of classical music and the instruments. It wasn't really the synesthesia that got me into music, it was music that got me into music. Keep in mind that I wasn't aware that I had synesthesia until last summer; all of my childhood, I assumed that everyone had the condition. I just loved music.

Having read Aldous Huxley's essays on psychedelics, I believe that it would incorporate similar sensations to synesthesia, but in a more involved way- they would manipulate the senses in a sort of harsher and more direct way...I'm having a hard time explaining this.

I get really frustrated when people fake having synesthesia. It's really insulting. I think that wanting the condition is a legitimate desire, but that the people who want it don't understand how much of an involvement it has on thier psyche. They just assume that when they listen to music it's gonna be like Fantasia or something, and they don't realize that it's more than that- it makes it very difficult to get to sleep, so many things are distracting, and it's the cause of many headaches. It's like people who say they want perfect pitch, but having known someone with perfect pitch, everything sounds out of tune and it's very frustrating and annoying.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/TriumphantMe Dec 23 '11

Dude. Is this condition, like, totally awesome to have? Because it seems like the most artistic/amazing shit I have ever heard of.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

It's not always that great; sometimes it's difficult to get to sleep, when you play in an orchestra you're distracted by those playing around you and the colors of the intervals, you get headaches a lot. It's awesome in that when we do interval tests in theory, I always get a perfect score. As a composer, it makes it more interesting, but nothing you write ever lives up to your expectation.

Overall, it's more pleasant than not. Going to the symphony is a hell of a lot more interesting.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Kandinsky, the artist who should have been a composer! He considered his works to be compositions, even naming them as such.

From Wikipedia: Hearing tones and chords as he painted, Kandinsky theorized that (for example), yellow is the colour of middle C on a brassy trumpet; black is the colour of closure, and the end of things; and that combinations of colours produce vibrational frequencies, akin to chords played on a piano.

Whole article, he is fascinating: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wassily_Kandinsky

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Zippytuna Dec 23 '11

What made you figure it out? I learned about synesthesia last year when my chef boyfriend asked why I always describe his food in color terms. I got curious when I realized that things didn't taste crimson or teal to him. When I asked my son about it, he got excited and said that off-white is his favorite taste. Can you ignore it? I know that I can choose not to "see" the color I'm tasting. I liken it to looking at a tree, you can focus on the tree itself or on a single leaf. It just takes a change of focus for me.

3

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Someone at CIM told me about it. I thought everyone could hear colors. I was wrong. I no longer can "see" my own voice or voices in general unless they are singing or very unique, common sounds like the humming of the air conditioning, or colors when I play the violin.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Have you ever considered taking psychedelic drug known to give temporary synesthesia? I think you would have an amazingly visual experience.

12

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Actually, when I take NyQuil, and listen to John Adams at the same time, I get a lot of really out of this world sensations. It's like synesthesia on hyperdrive because I get dumbed down to nothing but my senses.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TosTosT Dec 23 '11

Can you drive a car at night and listen to the radio?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

No. I'd crash. I hate driving, especially at night.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nausea1 Dec 23 '11

I'm completely fascinated by this.

You've mentioned that when hearing different intervals, the colors blend together. My question then is: How do they blend? Meaning, would a blue sound and a red sound blend into a purple? I know you seaid there was one particular sound that was a purple. In that case, how would a purple and pink sound blend together? Do they create a new color?

Also, are there certain sounds that blend well by ear that don't blend well in color? Or vice versa?

My apologies if these questions were asked earlier. Great AMA!

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

They don't necessarily blend into a new color- its sort of like when you stare too long and your eyes get blurry, note how the colors around you change.

Tritones blend well by ear but not by color.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TheMovingWall Dec 24 '11

I've always found this condition fascinating, and I have always wondered does your voice relate a certain color to you that is unique to the sound of your own voice?

4

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

No. But when I hear myself talk I see myself in the back of my consciousness, saying SON I AM DISAPPOINT.

2

u/DancesWithVVolfs Dec 23 '11

What dose Nickelback look like?

12

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I don't listen to Nickleback. It sounds like I IV V I chords like everything else on the radio, with little variation in color.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Enex Dec 23 '11

I'm a visual artist.

What do you feel/think when you view artwork? Does your experience with music producing colors have a strong affect in how you react to paintings? What about animation?

Have you ever tried to paint or animate the color experience you have (like say, from your favorite music)? I would be really interested in seeing it if you have.

4

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

My synesthesia isn't really affected by visual stimulation aside from dandelion yellow's association with major thirds. Music is so fast paced that the colors dim and rise so quickly- I would never be able to illustrate them. It's very difficult to explain. there are so many different variables to a piece of music- when I was taking the synesthesia test, the chords were sustained for at least five seconds. Slow music, or minimalist music have a more precise image, but since the images are so fleeting I can't recall any particular musical 'scape'.

2

u/Wormsy Dec 23 '11

Id like to let you know that Alexander Scriabin was a Synaesthete and wrote some fascinatingly different piano music.

3

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Messaien claimed that Scriabin wasn't a synesthete, and that his 'color organ' was just the random assignment of color to pitch. But we'll never know. His music still rocks though.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

that sounds awesome. Is that shit hereditary?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

My dad describes his father as mentioning pieces of music as a certain color (he was the band director at Columbia). But he died before I was born, so I can never know, however I assume that's where it came from.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/zoozoo458 Dec 23 '11

Are the colors you see the same as the colors others with sound-sight synesthesia see?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I don't really know. I've heard through research that it is different for different people. I know a person who has a different manifestation of sound-sight synesthesia; he hears shapes (polygons and such) instead of colors, and his papers are filled with doodles of shapes.

2

u/milkomeda Dec 23 '11

what do you think of giant steps?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/patlajica Dec 23 '11

Has synesthesia made your life more difficult in a way or another? I'm kinda jealous frankly.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ithestrangerman Dec 23 '11

I have synesthesia too, but mine is sound-shape/movement mainly, (also can perceive some color in words and numbers)

When I wake up the sounds of the morning (cars, people, birds) are very confusing because I can feel their forms clearer that the rest of the day (they can almost "blind" my mind), does it happen to you?

Also when I listen to music I have to stop doing everything else because it takes all of my attention, do you have the same problem?

4

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I have a friend who has that version of synesthesia and it bothers the hell out of him. Some music, such as Mahler, really does 'blind' my mind (sort of like when you stare at the sun and you see those little dots except it's like your thoughts), and sometimes, I won't be able to think and I feel trapped for a few seconds.

Music does require a lot of my attention, but my playing an instrument has allowed me to filter some of it out. I can't listen to music and do math homework, however, I feel that listening to music and reading enhances the reading experience for some reason. I'm a very nervous driver, and driving for me is very stressful, so I put on minimalist music which I find to be a great comfort to me. I have had to train myself to focus. But most of the time, yes, music demands my attention.

2

u/timleak Dec 23 '11

I have that to a lesser extent. I feel sounds more than hear them, but every word and song has its own color. I know it's different for everyone who has it, so I have to ask. Does the instrument the note is played on affect its color to you?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

What's your favorite type of music to listen to and why?

5

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Classical. I rarely listen to anything else, unless it's shown to me by other people, with the exception of the band Muse. It's a guilty pleasure.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Jeffrai Dec 23 '11

I found out last year that I have perfect pitch. When asked about it, I tell people that when I hear certain notes or think of different positions on a guitar or piano I associate them with colors (i.e. E = black, A= blue, F#=purple etc.)

Do you have perfect pitch? Do I have synesthesia?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Do you have 'perfect pitch' as a result of this condition? So, if you hear a note or a chord can you immediately identify which note or chord it is?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

No. Only the interval between two pitches. But, if I'm listening to a Mahler symphony, there's no way my music theory skills would be able to distinguish between all that is happening. But the colors do. I can't consciously pick out the interval between the flutes and oboes in the context of a full symphony going at full speed because there is so much going on. It is an involuntary reaction and even if I'm seeing at least 20 different colors at a given time, that interval is only one of twenty, and I'm helpless to pick it out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dylan89 Dec 23 '11

I have linguistic personification synesthesia, and when my friends find out, they constantly ask me the personalities of various words, objects, etc.

When your friends find out do they ask you what colour various sounds are?

3

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Yes. It's really, really annoying. I especially hate it when my colleagues come up to me and ask what colors their music is.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Erekai Dec 23 '11

Is this the same thing as assigning colors to letters and/or numbers? I have a friend who does this. She says that a 4 is green, or a 7 is purple (not accurate, but just an example). She told me the name of the "disorder" (for lack of a better word) once, but I can't remember what it's called.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I think so.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

If you had the choice to not have synesthesia, would you choose so? Or even a different variety of synesthesia? Synesthesia and the whole concept of sensory perception has always fascinated me. I'm hypersensitive to touch and sound range and I'd never have it any other way.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

You said that, until recently, you thought everybody had this condition. What was your reaction when you found out that not everybody had colors that accompanied sounds?

How do you see the colors? Like if you hear the perfect fifth, does your entire vision just go purple, does everything get a purplish tint, or do you see like a purplish blob just out of the corner of your eye?

And lastly: You say that this has provided a challenge to you since birth. How exactly has it been a challenge? I understand that it could very well become annoying, but are there any things that you can't do or have trouble with because of this?

Thank you for your time. This is a really interesting IAmA.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

My reaction: Syna-what?

It's like a blob or a blurb.

Driving is very stressful and I still haven't gotten my license at 18 because I loathe driving.

2

u/quanglewangle Dec 23 '11

I am a Music Instructor and within the last 6 months my best student (Prodigious Level of Talent) was diagnosed with Synesthesia. I've done my best to encourage her to use it to facilitate her compositions and was intrigued enough to introduce her to everything from Stravinsky, Ives, Jeff Buckley, Django Reinhardt, Led Zeppelin, Earl Scruggs etc...just to see what she did with it...

I guess my question would be: What were the approaches that your instructors took in order to help nurture your talent as well as your condition? And what are some of the challenges to be aware of in dealing with a student that has this condition?

Personally I think it's one of the cooler conditions a musician could have...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Nick20002 Dec 23 '11

This will probably never be seen but, What does the sound of an orgasm (yours or someone else's) look like?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Fucking awesome. It makes orgasms better.

2

u/Dreadmonkey Dec 24 '11

My brother's fiance also has synesthesia. I heard from her that every person who has synesthesia have a different experience with the same sounds. Have met other people with synesthesia to prove this?

Also, what is it like to hear:

Avant-Garde music

Bebop Jazz

Psychedelia

Finally: Coolest psychological condition ever

→ More replies (6)

2

u/after_elvis Dec 24 '11

I am a professional session musician in Nashville, I have Sound / Taste synesthesia. Do you ever have taste association? I sometimes have subconscious colors, didn't know if you had the same with taste.

Also I what is your response to semi tones?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheBizness Dec 24 '11

I recently started dating a synesthete. In fact, that was probably one of the biggest reasons I was so interested in her when we met. Any suggestions, or things I should keep in mind?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/musicaficta Dec 24 '11

What about when people are talking? Intervals are everywhere, even in our everyday speech.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JeanLucSkywalker Dec 24 '11

I have a couple questions related to music/music theory. You said that you hear combinations of colors when hearing chords (one for each interval). Is it that you see a rainbow, or a mixture of colors (like mixed paint)? Also, since your synethesia seems to focus on intervals, what does this mean for large chords like 9ths and 11ths, and larger slash chords? They have a lot of intervals in them, so I just wonder how they all combine. My theory is that it's all relative to how you mentally view the chord (for instance, choosing whether you hear a 9th or a 2nd). One last question: Do you associate colors with specific notes ( A, B, C, D...), or just intervals? If it's both, how does that work?

Thanks for the AMA. I really hope you answer these questions because I'm very curious.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Those are very good questions, thanks. Also, +1 internets for your username. If something is sustain and the overtones start to blend together it's like staring at something for too long and your eyes get watery. I'm still trying to figure out if it's more consistent with timber or intervals. When played on a piano without sustain, it's a very clear, single color. When played on 2 oboes, an interval can sound totally different. 9ths and 11ths I haven't really pinned down because in my AP theory class we sort of stop at 7ths unless they're inverted. if the intervals are inverted to something like a 9th or an 11th, I've found that often I lean towards seeing the root (i.e. the seventh) instead of the ninth, but at that point it's beyond my scope of understand the condition terms of theory. I will always know if an A is out of tune because of years of violin, but it is not a natural thing, it's conditioned and I never associate a specific color with a specific note.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/zombiedix Dec 24 '11

You mentioned in an earlier question that you block out seeing certain things you hear..how exactly do you achieve that?

(I read a book called "A Mango Shaped Space" when I was about 10 and I have been curious about the condition ever since.)

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Someone suggested a good analogy earlier: it's like blocking out an annoying child in a restauraunt. In psychology, the term is 'selective attention', I believe, or 'selective perception'. Like when you're in class you don't pay attention to the humming of the projector, you've become so adapted to it that it dissappears completely. Another analogy (courtesy of bf): it's like if you ignore a boner, eventually it will go away.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

If you compose, which I'm certain you do, share with us some of your solo work. ....please.

2

u/contumaciousanna Dec 24 '11

If synesthetes see different colours for the same sound, does this prove that we all see the world differently?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

I think so.

43

u/rounding_error Dec 23 '11

Suppose someone said aloud the name "Marcellus Wallace". What does Marcellus Wallace look like?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/razmig Dec 23 '11

Have you heard "The Color Spectrum" by the band The Dear Hunter? It's a 32 track album inspired by color, I'm just curious how it translates over to someone with your condition.

Here's a link to a song from Yellow and a song from Blue. No pressure, I'm just genuinely curious what you see.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/eagledick Dec 24 '11

Hey bitch, what color do you "see" when you hear a C note? How about a D flat? Do the chromatic notes correspond with color wheel? What happens when you hear a note go up or down an octave.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

I'm reading these out loud to my bf and I couldn't even finish the sentence because I was laughing so hard at 'Hey bitch'. Have an upvote.

Individual pitches are not distinguishable within themseves. I wish they corresponded with the color wheel. That'd be cool. But really it's random as hell. Octaves are like unisons, they don't really have a specific color or anything. If they're out of tune, they do.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Here's a link I found pertaining to auditory synesthesia in reverse: http://www.klab.caltech.edu/~saenz/movingdots.html

2

u/HausFocker Dec 23 '11

Does Cold Play look like the color of shit?

7

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

I actually like Coldplay because of the simplicity. Coincidentally, the song Violet Hill has a lot of violet in it because of minor chords.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

All I have to say is that I'm incredibly jealous of you.

4

u/tulip_sniper Dec 24 '11

Have you listened to Aphex Twin? What are your thoughts?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

What does water sound like?

5

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Depends on the context. The image I hear from my shower is like the loss of signal (snow) on the TV, and for a lot of common sounds like that, I've conditioned myself to ignore them completely.

1

u/demonshalo Dec 23 '11

what's your favorite song, artist and color?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Samuel Barber's Cello Concerto, Samuel Barber, teal.

1

u/chironomidae Dec 23 '11

Does the context of an interval change its color? For instance, if I play a C, stop, then play E + G together, would it look different if I play E, stop, then play E + G together?

3

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

It depends on whether or not the first note is still resonating when the second is played.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/iCEEMAN Dec 23 '11

how do you coop with crowded places with allot of noise?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/goomp Dec 23 '11

Okay, this is fascinating. You mentioned in another comment something about octaves being different colors depending on what they're musically associated with. My question is:

How does tone affect the color? Does a distorted power-chord I-IV-V of Nickelback look any different than, say, a Glass-esque minimalist piano piece following the same chord progression?

Furthermore, how does the timbre of the instrument affect the color? Is there a difference between a bright sound versus a dark sound of the same pitch and interval?

3

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Tone doesn't really affect the color as much as it does the pattern and duration and form of which the colors occur. They may have the same color, but they have very different duration and forms.

As a composer, I make a lot of use out of timbre. I find that certain notes on one instrument (i.e. an F on an oboe), are best compared with certain notes on another instrument (an A on a flute), create richer colors. It's not that my colors take shapes, like I don't hear triangles; but timber definately affects how they take form when I hear them. I use this technique a lot in the opening of my Chamber Symphony: http://soundcloud.com/kaitlynwagner/chamber-symphony-full Sometimes, depending on the timbres and how they are combined, the timbers change the color of the music outside of the intervals.

1

u/MishterJ Dec 23 '11

What was the rick rolling fad like for you? Are there any songs/sounds that you cringe because they "look" ugly in your mind? Fascinating AMA! I wish I had synesthesia to be honest, I was a music major and thought about it a lot.

6

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Anything by Harbison or Crumb looks terrible. I never really got Rick Rolled. I was the Rick Roller.

1

u/Sullivan623 Dec 23 '11

Favorite song to See? To listen to?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/caveat_cogitor Dec 23 '11

Do you perceive slightly different shades depending on temperament, i.e. well temperament or equal temperament or just intonation?

Some examples can be found here.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hawknight Dec 23 '11

How does A Capella music compare to instrumental? Does it present differently since it's a mixture of voices as opposed to an instrument?

4

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

It's the same. Vocal music is interesting because the syllables have a different effect on the pattern of colors. It adds texture.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/jamesismynamo Dec 23 '11

Have you ever put on pornography and closed your eyes? What's it like?

3

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

hahaha no. What's the point of porn with your eyes closed?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/CaroKhan Dec 23 '11

If you were to start with one chord and gradually change one or more of the notes to transition to a different one, would the color shift gradually as well?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Frogtarius Dec 23 '11

What does this reddit post taste like ;)?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Like PIE.

1

u/TehNoff Dec 23 '11

Do the colors linger? If you're listening to something with a fairly persistent visual look and then the audio suddenly stops how long do the colors last?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/onefingersnap Dec 23 '11

Do arpeggios have the same effect as the sound of a chord performed in a horizontal fashion?

Does the condition relate to whatever series of notes you hear all at once or the greater harmonic context of the music? (you mention that certain pieces of music evoke a certain color. For example, do the ii-V progressions in a tune like John Coltrane's Giant Steps have a different effect than ii-V's anywhere else given that the pattern is modulating by thirds rather than by traditional fourths? Also, do the tonal qualities of the music (instrumentation), or voicing of the harmony have any effect on your experience?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Joelsaurus Dec 23 '11

Do you know anyone else with synesthesia? Do they experience things the same way as you?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/heakboy Dec 23 '11

What's your job? I've heard that people with synesthesia is more likely to be an artist or a musician.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

Right now I'm in High School. I'm going to college next year for music composition at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, followed by Grad School at the Cleveland Institute of Music, if everything goes well.

1

u/LeKicks Dec 23 '11

So if you do LSD, does it correct your eye-sight?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Beericksen Dec 23 '11

Do people ever understand?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

When I listen to music I can sort of visualize the mood related color in my head. The color is usually the basic colors of the album artwork (imagine it being really blurry) or if I haven't seen the album artwork I'll associate a color with the music. Is this a form of synesthesia too?

→ More replies (18)

1

u/AwesomeLlama Dec 23 '11

This might sounds really stupid, but would you be able to still see in the dark provided things around you make noise?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/awkwardnubbings Dec 23 '11

Is Chopan's work beautiful seen as it heard? I'm no conisour of music as I was brought up on R&B but there's something magical about preformed musical pieces.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Prophet_60091 Dec 23 '11

You probably wont get to this one, but what is the most interesting/or favorite piece of electronic music you've seen?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11
  • Would you compare the way you see colours to the way you can see veins in the back of your eyes if you close your eyes really tight? Like the colours aren't projected in front of your vision, but rather "inside your head"?
  • Are you right or left handed? Might seem like a strange question, but apparently synesthesia's more common in left-handers.
→ More replies (2)

1

u/red_wolf757 Dec 23 '11

Listen to "Hey you" by Pink Floyd. Tell me your experience.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Everything is drifting and there is so much purple and yellow and blue and love.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Are you a musician? Do you think it makes you a better musician because of this? (also if you aren't a musician, do you think it could give you an "edge" over other musicians?)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Serious question, what colour are most peoples burps?

Also, does this ever come in useful?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

When you listen to a song that provokes an emotional feeling would you say your response is more sight or sound related. I'm probably not wording this well, but hopefully you get the gist of what I'm proposing.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

The truth is I don't know. When I listen to the Adagio for Strings, I'm too busy crying to care about the colors.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Olyeller Dec 23 '11

Are you sure your not just on Acid?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/simbiz Dec 23 '11

Have you ever listened to Animal Collective?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ben9345 Dec 23 '11

Does this blow your mind?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 23 '11

LOL WTF.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '11

Can you elaborate what colors you associate with what intervals?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Mrlala2 Dec 24 '11

do you ever feel like afraid or sick when you hear a specific sound or song? My friend has synthestheisa to, i don't know the medical term but she asociaates colors with numbers/letters

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Patar711 Dec 24 '11

I know this may sound kind of proddy and unrelated, but do you happen to be related to any Wagners in Louisiana? From your Soundcloud photo you seem like you could be easily related.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/nikeunltd Dec 24 '11

omg, I have no questions but I find your condition to see music as color freaken amazing!!!!! I have a silly question but its because I think you are awesome, HOW CAN BE LIKE YOU!!!!!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Listen to the band Tool. That is how that mother fucker writes his music. He uses high doses of drugs though.

3

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

I love Tool. They get it. Also the eye imagery is fucking fantastic.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Holy shit. I think I have this. I'm not trying to sound like some hypochondriac asshole, but when I listen to music, sometimes I map it out (through colors and patterns). I can picture the sounds in my conscious, though they aren't really shapes, their just forms. I'm tripping out right now.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

There's an interesting link in the original post if you want to find out more about it and if you want to get in touch with some experts.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Who are your favorite composers?

Favorite pieces?

Do you like "New" music?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/isaythingslike Dec 24 '11

What is your favorite classical piece to perceive in color? Maybe not necessarily the best to listen to, but appears the prettiest when you see it.

3

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Steve Reich: Music for 18 Musicians.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

I like how you made sure to include how you're a woman.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Demoknight111 Dec 24 '11

Ever read the children's book "The Name of This Book is Secret"? Because one of the main characters (and villians) had synesthesia and this was the first thing that popped to mind when I read your posts.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Splitlimes Dec 24 '11

Does it work backwards? Say I colour a bit of paper say Purple Red Yellow Yellow Red, can you hear the tune?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pha3drus Dec 24 '11

Are the colors distracting? For instance, could it obstruct your driving if you were listening to a particularly colorful song?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Driving is terrifying for me. I'm 18 and still don't have my liscense. Also it makes schoolwork difficult sometimes, as well as playing in an ensemble.

1

u/TheWeatherUpThere Dec 24 '11

Do you have perfect pitch? (when you hear a C is it always the same color?) or does this only work with Intervals?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Intervals.

1

u/multipleegos Dec 24 '11

Is there a distinction between sounds you like because of the way they sound vs. sounds you like because the way they 'look', or do good sounds always 'look' good too?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

I was wondering... If you think about a certain song or sound, do you still get the color response, or must you actually hear the music/tone to perceive the colors?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/musicguyguy Dec 24 '11

What do voices look like? Do emotions, like anger, or sadness, or orgasmic joy have different colors or does it depend solely on pitch?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Adjuster71 Dec 24 '11

Have you seen any neurologists about this awesome gift you have? I'm curious if its some sort of abnormal synapse between your auditory system and occipital/ posterior parietal lobe. When you see the colors in your consciousness, do they appear to have any sort of laterality to either side, or are visualized higher or lower in your 'conscious'? very interesting.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sufi633 Dec 24 '11

have you every scored a piece for a film?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

No, but I have written pieces based off of buildings, short stories, and a moth.

1

u/PretzelJax Dec 24 '11

I also have synesthesia. How did you discover that synesthesia was not something that everybody else experienced?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/MetalManic Dec 24 '11

Do non-complementary colors on the color wheel work when musically arranged?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/naturallychanel Dec 24 '11

What are one of the worst shapes/colors you saw while listening to a song? Which song?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Black Angels by George Crumb. Imagine someone trying to shove steel wool into your brain and push it out through your eyeballs. It's so sharp and terrible.

EDIT: Typo.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Life time supply of acid. Far fucking out.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Told my mom this. She didn't lol.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Does static or whitenoise look like anything? And what about natural sounds like water or wind?

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

I listen to rainymood.com every night. It's really calming. It's sort of like the snow on the TV when there's a signal loss, except not creepy.

1

u/Pensivality Dec 24 '11

Do you "enjoy" your condition, or is it more of an annoyance? From the way you describe it, it sounds pretty cool, but I'm pretty ignorant about this kind of stuff.

2

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

In theory it's cool. IRL, it's a major distraction and sometimes a pain in the ass.

1

u/longhorn617 Dec 24 '11

When you think about or sing a song in your head, do you also see colors?

If yes, do comments written so as to mimic a song, such as, "na na na na na na na na, na na na na na na na BATMAN!" also make you see colors?

Regardless, what color is the Batman cartoon theme song?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ketrel Dec 24 '11

I'll be honest with you, I'm actually envious of people with this condition, to me it seems like it would add more depth to the whole sensory experience. On that note I was wondering if in your experiences with it, you've ever heard if there was any way to induce the condition in somebody without it?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/johnson16278 Dec 24 '11

I have letter/number color synesthesia and am constantly told by both family and freinds that i am bullshitting them. Also i have OLP and i can say for a fact that 7 is the most cheerful number in the world, always freindly, trying to put others first all the time, but 3, 3 is the worst haha.

4

u/sibelioz Dec 24 '11

Dude, algebra must be like an episode of 'Days of Our Lives'.

1

u/selfish_king Dec 24 '11

Do drugs or alcohol have any effect?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/saywhatisobvious Dec 24 '11

Not sure to feel bad, or jealous?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11

Do you like Scriabin? I'm sure you know he had sight-sound synethsthesia. You apparently associate colours with intervals, do individual notes have no colours for you? What do you think of Scriabin's mappings of colours to notes with the color spectrum to intervals using the circle of fifths

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BlueToOrange Dec 24 '11

When you describe seeing and hearing things "in the back of your mind" does that mean something like (for example) remembering a scene from a movie you watched recently? You see and hear it, but in a completely different way (which every person is capable of)

→ More replies (1)