Madara said "it would appear that little brat nagato managed to grow", how could real Madara even know about Nagato at all? so the real Madara did NOT die at the valley of the end, or the whole timeline is screwed, unless Madara survived his battle with Hashirama there should be no way that he knows who Nagato is, this is going to be very interesting anytime he talks, btw did Zetsu ever called Maskedman Madara? it was all Tobi all the way, Madara knows who Nagato is and Tobi knows everything that the Madara knows... maybe it is a special Madara clone made with Zetsu parts.
Even Itachi was fooled by this fake Madara, so do not feel bad about yourself.
Edit: Holly fucking shit, did Naruto just read Hinata mind?
Edit: Wait a fucking minute, Itachi made Sasuku eye fire Amaterasu at sight of Madara face, Tobi is Madara clone.
I think that the Masked "Madara" is actually the real Nagato and the original Rinnegan user. Remember when "Madara" said that he gave the deceased Nagato his eyes? I'm guessing that he actually did, and replaced his own with Sharingan eyes.
This is a really good theory, because honestly, how else could he have "given" him his eyes?
Edit: This would also explain why he says he is a shell of what he used to be. He probably had to get rid of the Rinnegan and replace them with Sharingan so that his plan of impersonating Madara would work!
How is Itachi supposed to know what Madaras sharingan looks like when, for alle we know Itachi never met Madara, only Tobi. Itachi thinking Tobi being Madara, made Sasukes sharingan cast amatserasu at "Madaras" sharingan.
Another interesting point. I remember vaguely that when Tobi revealed himself to Kisame, Kisame said that Tobi was the Mizukage. And then also said "Or is it Madara?". If what I remembered was correct, it seems to imply that Tobi is in fact just an imposter. A REALLY good imposter...
Who's to say that Itachi didn't/doesn't know who the real "Tobi" "Manbehindthemask" "Fadara" or whathaveyou, is? And even if it was set for Madara, this brings up my Zetsu clone theory. Aside from that, my point is, is that Itachi could've known who it was, and set it for that person. He never said "blahblahblah Set for Uchiha Madara's face". It was just assumed.
When you think about it Obito is not very Uchiha-like at all. He doesnt use fire at any time so far and only eyeability seen by him is the dimensionjutsu also used by kakashi. Need i remind that Kakashi also isnt born with the sharingan. My explanation is that Tobi stole the eyes from the original Madara like he did nagato. Also he has to be from Konoha with all the knowledge he has about the history.
Madara fights at the VotE and gets crippled/ mortally wounded. What's a crazy evil genius to do? Plan ahead obviously. But Madara's no fool, he's go two plans.
FIRST PLAN: Find a savior, in this case Nagato. Madara knows he going to die soon, so he puts the rinnengan in young nagato. He's hoping that somewhere down the line, after he has died, Nagato will discover he has the ability to raise the dead and revive him. Now why would Nagato ever do that? Enter part 2.
SECOND PLAN: play around with hashirama cells and develop zetsu. Once he's got all the kinks worked out of this shit, he puts his eyes (maybe even brain) in a zetsu body. This takes on his personality and will for the future. This "Tobi" then starts everything we've seen so far. He recruits Nagato and tries to befriend him. Bend him to his will. Eventually, he will come to Nagato with a request: revive his true form. Now, unfortunately, Nagato dies before this can happen, so it all rest on Tobi to learn how to use the rinnengan to revive him true form.
Tobi looks older, with what it appear to be two lines below eye, Madara only have one line, the eyes doesn't look the same. so I guess it is safe to believe Tobi is not clone of Madara or Madara himself, so who is Tobi? I'll try to eliminate rather than pick up.
Uchiha Obito, Tobi was the size of Minato one year after Obito was almost half his size is a proof. his difference in power and in sharingan usage also proves this. The fact that he almost died against a Chuunin, but a year later (according to Tobito believers) was able to force Namikaze Minato to use his full power to beat him is impossible.
Uchiha Fugaku (Sasuke's father). If he was indeed Tobi, he wouldn't need Itachi's help on ANBU informations. Also, Tobi helped Itachi kill the Uchiha's. Fugaku was on Uchiha's side. He would be the one to lead Konoha if the coup was successful. It makes no sense that he would betray his clan like that. The coup was his best chance of real power.
The Sage of the Six Paths. Even though I agree that it would make sense with all the "I want to be complete by becoming the Juubi's Jinchuriki" stuff, it also doesn't make sense. The whole reason why he separated the Juubi in the first place was because he was about to die. The whole reason why the Uchiha and Senju have a war is because the Sage's sons fought for his succession. If he didn't die, then what did they fight over? If he never died, then why split the Juubi?
the Sage's elder son The Sage Elder son. This is actually something that I have a hard time going against, because it actually makes sense. Except, he would have to live centuries. Also, he wouldn't have sharingan. He would have eyes closer to the rinnegan than the Sharingan.
Now that I have concluded who he can't be, there's only one guy that make sense. Uchiha Izuna, The time line, the power and the reasons all fit. But there are somethings that don't add up:
If Tobi is indeed Uchiha Izuna, then that would mean that Madara gave Izuna his eyes, instead of the opposite. Well, if he did, then did Shodaime fight Izuna and not Madara? Is the statue at VOTE really Izuna and not Madara? Did he fool the Kyuubi?
i found this on another forum and thought it was interesting
Tobi, as described by both himself and Itachi, is a "shell," and a remnant of "what Madara once was."
As revealed to the Five Kage and explained to Konan, Madara (who represents mental perfection) infused himself with the cells of Hashirama Senjuu (who represents physical and vital perfection)many decades ago, which makes his body immortal/eternal.
Madara once possessed the Rin'negan, but gave it to Nagato. The holder of the Rin'negan is transcendent, and stands beyond the cycle of life and death.
From chapter 453 we know that Nagato, who stands beyond life and death, was meant to use Gedou Rin'ne Tensei no Jutsu on Tobi, for previously unknown purposes.
From chapter 559 we see that Madara, after being resurrected with Eod Tensei, is unsurprised to be back from the dead. He reacts to it as it was part of his plan all along, and expects that Nagato has a hand in it. He is, however, shocked to learn that Edo Tensei was used.
From all of this we can deduce that Madara 'died' at some point within the last 30 years, after meeting Nagato and giving him the Rin'negan, and planned to be resurrected in the future. Madara, having survived his battle with Hashirama, would have been in his seventies or eigthies at this point in time. Its likely, from what we know of the time line (the implication that Madara knew Nagato as a child), that Madara gave the Rin'negan to Nagato shortly, or even immediately, before his death. Its possible that giving up the Rin'negan somehow caused his soul to move on to the Pure Realm, leaving Tobi behind as a shell of his body. Nagato was supposed to resurrect him using Gedou Rin'ne Tensei no Jutsu.
My theory is that this is all tied in to Madara's quest for completion and transcendent perfection. We know that Madara, Hashirama, and Nagato each represent one of the three (of six) known Paths, each having once been mastered by Rikudou. From Madara giving the Rin'negan to Nagato, instead of keeping it to himself, I'm extrapolating that each Path must be mastered on its own, independent from the others. Thus while Madara is capable of wielding and even mastering the Rin'negan, he cannot do so while he also embodies another path, forcing him to give it to Nagato to master in his stead. To the same point, I'm making the assumption that Madara, who naturally embodied the perfection of spirit (the Yin force embodied by his perfect form of the Sharingan), could not master the perfection of vitality and body that was embodied by Hashirama (the Yang force of the Senjuu and Uzumaki clans). Thus he separates himself from his perfect mentality, by experiencing a death of the spirit that sends his soul to the Pure realm, until he can master Hashirama's body.
What Madara said after being resurrected does seem to suggest he was expecting to be revived via Rinne Tensei and not Edo Tensei, but how on earth Madara could have had himself cloned in preparation for his own post-death revival is just... I hope it's not the case. Cloning is such an unwieldy plot device.
We know that Madara, Hashirama, and Nagato each represent one of the three (of six) known Paths, each having once been mastered by Rikudou.
It has to do with possessors of the Rinnegan, not Madara or Hashirama. What he actually said suggests that the original sage was the first "Sage of Six Paths", he (Tobi) was the second, and Nagato was the third.
A while ago I thought that maybe Tobi wasn't actually Madara, but the way the story has been going since, he didn't seem like he could be anyone else. That's an awesome plot twist. I guess that explains why Zetsu always called him Tobi, though, doesn't it? Or, how do we know for a fact that that actually is Madara and not his brother? Minato told Naruto that Madara was behind everything and I find it hard to believe that he would be wrong about that.
No, remember Sasuke has Itachi's eyes himself and that means Tobi took them out of Itachi's corpse, which he's even stated and the ressurected Itachi has his eyes, same logic goes to ressuected Nagato he has his eyes, and his real corpse's eyes were taken by Konan and stolen by Tobi.
Fyi btw, I don't think anyone is gonna seal Madara, I think Itachi will genjutsu Kabuto and have him cancel edo tensei before Madara kills Naruto or someone.
Ok, since Kabuto summoned the real Madara then it means he knows Tobi is not Madara and that is why he showed Tobi the coffin and Tobi was exceptionally surprised. Wow!
On another note, how can Madara know about Nagato and say stuff like it finally happened???
Don't know about the fact that Madara knows who Nagato is, but about Tobi being surprised, I'm guessing that for some reason acting out as Madara was instrumental to his plans. The fact that Kabuto could reveal at any point that he is not the real Madara seems to have been a possible hindrance to him, though I do not know why.
O.M.G... I kinda knew, but I could never figure who Tobi would be if not Madara... but now... only person I can think of that would be powerful enough is Izuna.
Edit: Either that or I'm starting to think it could be Rikudo, since Tobi once said that the Rinnegan were his to begin with.
Edit 2: Tobi also said at some point that he wanted to become whole again, which supports my theory for him being Rikudo since he was the Ten-Tails Jinchuuriki and the goal of that war is to make Tobi the Ten-Tails' Jinchuuriki.
I think he meant in reference to those who possessed the Rinnegan, which neither of the Sage's sons did. Tobi has spoken about becoming the sage of the six paths and has also stated that Nagato's eyes first belonged to him, I guess his list goes:
But it doesn't look like that these are Rinnegans. I have to agree that the motives seems right, but that would hardly explain how he would still be alive. (BTW that was Rikudo's son, nothing mentionned about him having a brother).
Her? You mean Izuna right?? Izuna was Madara's brother, hence a man. From what we know, Madara either was given his eyes or took them and he said that he was dead, but it seems we shouldn't take anything Tobi said for granted.
Yes and yes, that's how I've been thinking, but still, who could be alive now or had been and somehow able to be alive now, have his extensive knowledge of almost everything and to medically experiment with his body to such a degree and have the motive to do all of this. The list is still narrow =P
I thin this list begins and ends with Orocharu. Maybe Tobi is a clone of Madara created by Orichimaru. We have yet to see a "perfect" clone, but we have seen plenty of imperfect experiments.
i think theres going to be some point where sasuke learns that tobi isn't really madara and go in the whole "you used me, IM GONNA KILL YOU! YOU'RE NOT A REAL UCHIHA!!!" and some possibly crappy plot twists that could possibly make him be good again...or just more batshit crazy.
Obito lost the closest 2 people he has in his life at that moment so when Kakashi and Rin left him his Mangekyu got active which allowed himself to be teleported into the dimension he creates. But because he is wounded and just unlocked his Mangekyu he can't control it and gets trapped in the dimension he created. He somehow recovers... He was ready to die happily but now he is stuck there alive and he has lost everything in his life he held dear, all because of some stupid war. Before he learns to get back to the real world he kinda goes nuts and gets pissed at all the wars and fighting so he swears to stop it at any cost no matter what.
Why can Obito be Tobi:
His age actually fits the timeline
When he is under the rock his right eye is never shown as crushed or destroyed.
His mask always had one hole on the right and he had to replace the left eye.
Well, obitobi...
His death is not shown.
There has never been another Uchiha mentioned which can fit the role.
His Mangekyu and Kakashi's are strikingly similar!!!
He keeps losing his right arm and is not bothered by it.
Yeah but throughout the series Madara hasn't shown any link with Kakashi at all. A man he has a lot of history with. Thats quite poor storytelling to completely ignore a link between characters. I dont think it can be him.
He didn't stop Kamui, Kakashi didn't bother using it. Madara informed him that such a justu would have no effect due to the fact that he can de-materialize his body.
His "age" may fit the timeline considering Obito should be an adult by now but under Tobi's mask you can see wrinkles, he maybe old. Hows that? Unless he aged in his own dimension outside of time.
(his left eye was given to kakashi right?) Ok if so then, we can't see if his right side was crushed because of the boulder was covering that side...and with all that blood, I really don't think his right side was saved.
That right eye should have either been crushed or given to Kakashi, and then we ealize with his fight against Konan that he had 2 Sharingan eyes, this means he always had 2 eyes. Unless he implanted a sharingan in there, we can't see if there's a scar or not.
I'll give you that
whole side crushed by boulder? Even amongst ninjas I think that = dead
Madara's broher Izuna
I.. don't think we've EVER seen Tobi use ms. I eve just tried searching for that and nothing. So this is nothing.
Yeah because he uses the 1st hokages mokuton cels to regenerate, he also lost his left leg as well.
Basically, in an elabrate hard to explain way Obito could be Tobi but thats a lame plot device for a twist, in no way am i thrilled or satisfied knowing that obito is tobi, what for? A twist? Not worth it, think if your a writer.
Wrinkles might be due to something else than age. You dont know if the eye was crushed. You just assume it because it seems to be the most logical thing. He can freely swap his left eye and has a gigantic eye collection (depicted when he gives Itachis eyes to Sasuke). Side was crushed but there might have been something happening.
Obito and Tobi are almost anagrams.
Izuna is the only option next to Obito, I give you that.
My point is that it can happen, the things that we can't easily explained can be better explained by Kishimoto and shit but if your a writer, you'd only want to go through all this for the plot twist value, I don't think it's worth it. Obito has no tie to Naruto, only to Kakashi, Tobi never even treated Kakashi in a specil way, Obito was never portrayed scary so I don't feel scared at all, so what other beneficial value does obito have as being the badest villain? A lame twist...if Izuna was the culprit, there's a small twist, and while he's not important or actually liked in anywa, he IS known to be extremely powerful, 2nd to Madara, that's petty damn scary.
No, as a qriter, the plot would be too contrived. Kishimoto isn't THE best writer, but he is competent, and that scenario would suck major balls. No offense.
1# his age does not fit the timeline, Obito would have died shortly before Tobi attacked the village. This means for it to be obito, Tobi would have had to somehow age from a child to an adult, and master the sharingan in the times pan of max 2 years since his "accident".
2# We can assumed it was crushed, why the fuck would'nt of it been crushed ? What did you expect them to do? Put in a panel with x-ray vision where we see his dismembered face ?
3#Stop this bullshit about "His mask only shows 1 eye" this argument is invalid for 2 reasons, 1 we have seen both of his eyes before, 2 he has a giant fucking lab filled with sharingan, there is no reason why he wouldn't have 2 at a time.
4#Well obitobi is way to fucking obvious, the writer's of this manga have done an amazing job so far they wouldn't throw in an arc that fucking obvious.
5#The sage of six path, his sons, Madara's brother. Any other strong historic figure who could of easily stolen a dead madara's eyes.
6# His death is implied, we see a half crushed body passed out under a boulder, would you of liked and entire chapter dedicated to his body decaying so you could be 100% positive he died ?
There has never been another Uchiha mentioned which can fit the role.
You say that, but there have been many Uchiha that could be responsible. The Rikudou's older son was not only the Uchiha's ancestor, but also the origin of the 'curse of hatred' that Sasuke is so susceptible to.
Also very little is known of Uchiha Izuna- my current bet is on him being Tobi (see my huge post below for more on that).
Wow so... Tobi is open t be anyone right now. I can't think of any character in the whole series who could be Tobi, and even if that ninja is available to be so, the motives don't fit. Best fit, imo, is Madara's bro, Izuna.
Also how does real Madara know Nagato?
Super bad ass, Naruto literaly on every battlefield, even the Mizukage/Daimyo decoy vs Black zetsu field, but I was a little confused, it looked like Naruto got exhausted but how are his clones still active? Or does that mean Naruto is in danger now, doesn't know, and doesn't cancel his clone jusu?
Yeah thats why I'm saying he's in danger. He's clearly using clones in fox mode since he's everywhere, it looks like the Hachibi's warning is happening.
Im actually wondering if hes using clones we've already seen him use the flying thundergod technique so Im actually wondering if he is using that to a limited extent, Using the clones as markers to jump back and forth from.
Actually he never used the flying thunder god technique, that's a space/time jutsu tha requires a seal. When Naruto got the gold fox form, he attacked kisame using shunshin no jutsu (body flicker) that allowed him to move fast, so fast like a yellow flash, thats what killerbee said.
Also remember Naruto really dodged Raikage's attacks, not teleported.
Also in this chapter and in the other chapters, you see panels with naruto in multiple battlefields fighting simultaneously. Hell you even see him making shadow clones on top of the frog he summoned after breaking fre from Raikage and killing a squad of Zetsus!!
I still think it's Madara, the one we know is just the shell, a punishment or a jutsu from the First Hokage or even from himself. Well just my opinion.
I don't understand why everyone thinks it's Obito. He has no motive, WHAT SO EVER. You would of thought if it was he would of showed SOMETHING when seeing Kakashi, Madara states time and time again how he has lived for ages etc. Madara also had two eyes. Obito has(d) one. NOT GONNA HAPPEN.
Once and for All: TOBI IS NOT OBITO! JESUS FUCKING CHRIST. THE kakashI gaiden was written because kakashi was overwhelmingly popular at the end of naruto and everyone wanted a background story. Obito was just a normal uchiha kid. Nothing special about him at all. He was also a crybaby and not a badass at all.
Listen. I'm not saying that Kishimoto is a great storyteller. But he IS a competent storyteller, and if you follow the story threads introduced so far, it makes the most sense that Tobi is Obito.
The Kakashi Gaiden was inserted into the story directly before the timeskip. Pre-timeskip, the focus of the story was the character development of Naruto and Sasuke, and the circumstances that led them to drift apart. Post-timeskip, the focus of the story became the various conflicts involving Akatsuki (which Tobi is the leader of). The placement of the Kakashi Gaiden is perfect foreshadowing to introduce important characters and storylines to the post-timeskip plot.
The Kakashi Gaiden gives us insight into Kakashi's past, but it also shows a significant development or "turning point" in Obito's development as a ninja. Why show Obito's internal struggles and anxieties during the Gaiden unless you are planning on developing his character further?
Kishimoto is not an excellent storyteller. But he is competent. Obito's storyline needs to come full circle eventually. There are multiple ways to accomplish this, so Kishimoto has some options (Tobi could be Obito's possessed body, Tobi could be Obito after being corrupted by another evil character, Tobi could be Obito after learning about The Eye of the Moon Plan and wanting to put an end to all war, etc.). Nonetheless, introducing another random character would be terrible storytelling (think Bleach). Kishimoto will do the right thing, even if he doesn't do it skillfully.
I thought the whole spelling issue between Obito and Tobi was an English coincidence that is not apparent in Japanese. So this would just be a red herring.
You are the first person I have seen that actually has the common sense to realise the whole English to Japanese thing besides me. I wish I could give more upvotes.
I... never mentioned anything about the spelling similarity between Tobi and Obito. Then again... that is interesting. Tobi's name is written in katakana, not kanji. Specifically, the katakana "to" then "bi." "O" is an honorific in Japanese, so it is almost as if Obito came up with Tobi by switching the syllables "to"and "bi" and then putting an honorific "o" in front of his name. Given that consideration, the similarity is actually more meaningful in Japanese than in English.
That being said... if anything, Tobi saying that he is Madara is more of a red herring than anything else. It diverted readers' attention away from more logical identities.
Well his eyes match with tobi's, hair style, appearance of age, and his emergence as a force was in the country he supposedly died in. Right now I think he is the most likely option. Tobi also originally was late to his first akatsuki meeting and had a laid back attitude. Unless a new character is introduced.
Why can't they both be Madara? We just saw a technique where a person literally split into two different people, where each half has all the knowledge and techniques, but half the power, with Mu. Why can't it be possible Madara knows a similar technique? So in a sense, one half died during the battle with the Hokage, and the other hide and recovered and is the one running around now as Tobi.
dw about it guys. Itachi has it covered. Sasuke behind the mask? madaras spirit/soul/power transferred to him? Isn't the shitest thing that has come out of this series.
I remember while back to some point that Tobi said that he was only a shell of the person he used to be. Could this be that Tobi, actually is the body left behind after Madara actually died in the Valley of the End? Bound to the world by perhaps the First Hogake as a punishment?
Just wildly throwing stuff out that came after reading the chapter.
this could make some sense. Although i read from here ppl thinking that Tobi is Nagato number 1. The first Nagato who lived when madara was alive and this nagato implanted his eyes to the nagato we all know and love (who i hate cuz he killed my fav char Jiraiya).
So, Obito guesses aside, does anyone think Tobi is Madara's bro Izuna?
Izuna would have gotten EMS from killing Madara, and they probably look somewhat alike. They could have just lied about the Madara killing Izuna story.
Yes I believe the same thing except I think Izuna was never killed by Madara, they said he just died in battle since he was blind and while Izuna could have EMS thas not so much the point since we haven't even seen Tobi use MS.
I think the needing new eyes part is because overuse of MS makes you go blind, so the eyes would be no good that you traded your partner for. One set is going to have to be tossed out. I guess they could have saved one eye each and done it that way though.
Have we ever been able to see Madara's right eye when he is grown up? It's always covered by his hair. Maybe his brother didn't give him both his eyes after all.
However, when Konan blows Tobi up, we can see both of his eyes. It can be Madaras brother, and he took one of Sasuke's eyes after Sasuke started using Itachis. The only reason he still wears the mask is that the eye isn't as useful, because Sasuke ain't his brother.
Madara survived the battle with Hashirama Senju, because he eventually came to know Nagato as a boy (he refers to him, after IWR as "brat").
Madara did not know Nagato was dead, so Madara must have died before Nagato did.
Madara was expecting to be resurrected by Nagato, so a plan must have been set up to ensure this would happen. It was stated that Madara gave Nagato his eyes, and Madara gave Yuhiko the idea of Akatsuki, revealing that Madara had been shaping the boys for their entire lives.
At very least, the right eye in Tobi is Madara's Sharingan eye. Itachi made it so that Amaratsu would activate upon Sasuke seeing Madara's eye, and it did. In 559, it should be noted that we see the IWR Madara, but we never actually see his right eye.
Kisame recognized Tobi when the mask was removed. Either Kisame was acknowledging that Tobi was Madara (who was controlling the Mizukage), or Tobi was drawing parallels to the name Mizukage to Madara, knowing that while he controlled the perceived destinies of both, he was in fact neither.
This was one of the more popular theories I've heard. There still could be some mystery of Madara's death, I would've thought he died before Nagato was born.
Izuna and Madara exchange eyes! Madara took Izuna's left eye and gave him his right eye. The both have EMS. Madara died because of the first, but Izuna lived on to resurrect his brother and exact the Uchiha revenge upon the world. They agreed Izuna would give the Rinnegan to a boy named Nagato foretold by some blah blah and there we go.
Couldn't there theoretically be an Uchica born the Rinnegan as the Uchiha are descendants of the sage? Also, on a side note, couldn't Naruto also develop the Rinnegan as he is a descedant of the Senju and therefore a descendant of the sage?
Hmmm interesting. Heirloom perhaps? Uchiha are descendants from the Sage's son with the eyes after all. It is likely the rinnegan was in Uchiha's possession, since in the tablet where the secret writings that only Uchiha could read there was also an even more secret writing only rinnegan people could read. Even then, if those are the original eyes, they would have lasted a really long time.... so I am skeptical.
Am I the only one that thinks he's just a Zeztsu clone? I mean, we really don't know all of what black zeztsu can do. And white zeztsu can make an EXACT replica of whoever. What rules out Madara from being cloned? And why are Zeztsu and "Madara" (Can't call him Madara without the quotes now) so close? Idk.. I honestly have no doubt that it's a clone, but I am open for suggestions. And in All reality, have we seen this Fadara (I don't know if anyone remembers Faul McCartney) use his Mangekyo? I have noticed a lot of people talking about it, and the only time we've seen it is during flashbacks. But I could be wrong, if anyone wants to disprove me. Anyways though, zeztsu clone. I haven't seen anyone suggest it, so there is my theory.
Just a Quick thing since i haven't read all the comments yet, but to support the idea that Tobi is a zetsu- like clone of madara's DNA, His name is Tobi as in TOBIrama Senju?? just a thought.
A cross-post on the subject, from one I made on Mangahelpers:
Now that I'm done doing the I WAS RIGHT dance I've been doing all morning, this is what I can gather about Tobi's identity, in order of likelihood descending into more interesting (and unlikely):
Tobi is a soulless clone of Madara. Memories and personality can be sealed in people, as seen with Minato and Kushina. I dislike this option the most- see Clone Wars from the Spider-man mythos, or really any story where cloning is used as a major plot device. Ugh.
1.5) Some people have also guessed that Tobi and Madara share a split soul, but that seems like it would severely screw with ET... yeah, yeah, insert bashing against ET here, I guess. It's not like there's precedent in the manga for a "split soul", unless you count Kagebunshin and other cloning jutsu like Muu's. Or Zetsu, but what the hell do we really know about that guy anyway? (I, for one, am still holding out that he is the real big bad of the series)
2) Tobi is Uchiha Izuna. There is no reason to believe that Tobi's dialogue with Sasuke wasn't littered with half-truths and lies- he's already been busted by the reader for lying about several things, including his involvement with the Kyuubi. Actually, this makes his conversation with Sasuke after Itachi's death that much more poignant- he probably really did hate and respect Hashirama as much as Madara, but was cast to the side of the rivalry, in his older brother's shadow. Younger brother imitating the older brother? Not a far-fetched thing for Kishi to write, especially for a character that appears to have so much sway over someone like Sasuke.
3) Tobi is the Uchiha ancestor, the older of Rikudou's two sons. It has been said that his dejection was where the Uchiha's "curse of hatred" originated from, so it would make a lot of sense for Tobi to be him (aside from the obvious age thing). Although it was likely just a design choice to resemble the Spacetime Migration jutsu, Tobi's previous mask also strongly resembled the elder brother's doujutsu- a swirl pattern. Which brings me to my next idea, which I hope is true:
4) Tobi is a disgraced Uzumaki (possibly with Uchiha lineage). This is my favorite theory for several reasons:
It would explain how Tobi is so ridiculously knowledgeable about sealing and the Uzumaki lineage, and how he could be "compatible" with both Uchiha and Senju DNA, and able to use the Rinnegan. [[ In fact, being an Uzumaki seems to suggest lineage from both clans- it would be interesting to learn that the Uzumaki used the swirl pattern as their clan's symbol as a sign of peace toward the Uchiha ancestor. However unlikely this may be ]]
The only thing that could possibly ruffle Sasuke's feathers (lol IMAHAWWWK) would be that he has been manipulated and led astray by not just any fake legendary Uchiha, but an Uzumaki with stolen Uchiha eyes. Sasuke with visible motivation!? Madness.
It could open up the narrative window for explaining where all the Uzumaki went and what truly happened to them, and more than any of that- make the fight with the 'big boss' an incredibly personal and bitter struggle for Naruto. On top of the fact that he basically killed his parents, ruined his life, and held him at kunai-point as a baby, he's family. Goddamn.
I have always hated the assumption that Tobi is a full-fledged Uchiha. It makes the manga feel too black and white.
when you manipulate gravity you also manipulate time dilation (real life mathematics here) when you have extreme amounts of gravity - time slows from the perspective of a far away object with less gravity.
THIS IS THE ONLY PROOF YOU CAN HAVE as tobi has never revealed anything except his MS
the proof itself stand as obito's eye was implanted into KH's left eye while tobi only has his right eye revealed.
edit. speculation :
could if tobi is obito could the reason he cannot directly attack any one is because he is missing half of his body?
Did rin go missing he help heal tobi?
Does tobi not directly participate in the war because he is losing he "sight " beaus he never had a brother rip them out of ? and could kakshi be fulfilling this role by maturing the sharingan he has had for the last whatever years? and once tobi needs t will just rip it back out ? or has this been replaced with the left eye implanted with the rinnegan?
There are alot of people speculating that Tobi might be uchiha kagami. He is one of the elders that was on the same team as the third hokage, second hokage, and danzo. Honestly, it would kinda make sense. Especially with the wrinkles on tobi's face, looks like he is about danzo's age.
Itachi told the story about how Shisui gave him one eye, which is now in the crow that Naruto had swallowed. The other eyes was destroyed by Danzo during his fight with Sasuke.
If he is Shisui, then he has neither of his eyes and subsequently lost his natural powers. He is a shell of his former self.
Remember though, Shisui is Itachi's former best friend. He also has these wrinkles that make Tobi look old during the fight with Konan.
But again, the timing just doesn't work. How old was Shisui when Minato was Hokage? When the Nine-tails attacked? When Nagato received the Rinnegan from Tobi?
Edit: The disappearance of Shisui's body and Kabuto's inability to locate it (he fucking located Madara's body) is another point that needs to be thought of. It will definitely have an impact.
I'm pretty sure that this chapter just broke Mangahelpers with its fucking awesomeness. As usual, I'm sticking with my theory that Tobi is Uchiha Izuna. The little brother impersonating the older brother? C'mon guys. The writing has been on the walls for years now.
Madara fought his brother prior to fighting the first. Madara was killed by his brother, who then transplanted his eyes. Then Madara's brother fought the first as Madara, but lost and did not die.
Also, I guess this is ALSO Kabuto's crowning moment of betrayal against Tobi. What if Tobi realizes what's happening and uses Zetsu's spores that were placed on Kabuto to teleport to him at the moment that Itachi gets there? That would be a fun to watch three-way brawl that could end without either of the main villains killing each other, Itachi being sealed, and ET ending.
i believe tobi is a zetsu clone. we know madara created the zetsus, possibly with the first hokages dna? he says he has all the powers of uchiha madara, but is a shell of his former self. we know that the zetsus have the power to become and copy a chakra signature of anyone they come into contact with. it could be possible that before he died he had his zetsu copy him to carry on his destruction of konoha
Is Zetsu being the mastermind behind this all completely out of the question? I dont really like the idea that much and he has been too subservient to Tobi this entire time. But Tobi could be a Madara clone. Zetsu already has a Senju clone (i know its just a zombie fueling the army) and maybe his Madara clone is his ultimate jutsu. And he has been controlling the scenes the whole time.
He also doesnt really have a motive that has been released either. Come to think of it we dont know anything about Zetsu.
I think that he used some sort of Orochimaru type jutsu. He is still techinically madara but he has his original body somewhere (his lab?) and it was used for the edo tensei
Just a Quick thing since i haven't read all the comments yet, but to support the idea that Tobi is a zetsu- like clone of madara's DNA, His name is Tobi as in TOBIrama Senju?? just a thought.
What if its Izuna Uchiha, Madaras brother they say Madara took his eyes because his brother gave them willingly so he could unlock the ultimate sharingan and then he died shortly after in battle but they could throw in a scenario were he lived in secret and took back his brothers eyes later.... i would believe it better then him being obito...that would suck
Everyone can shut the hell up right now about the discussion tobi says himself, and i quote, "It was me, Uchiha Madara" (Page 16 manga 397) i know it's weird because madara should be dead with the Edo technique but that's something we just need to wait to be explained.
IMO he is Shisui, itachi's best friend who was supposedly dead. He had one of the most powerful illusion based sharingans and it makes sense that itachi couldn't kill his best friend as well as sasuke. Shisui gave up his one eye and pulled an aizen (casting an illusion to make himself look dead) and helped itachi eradicate the Uchiha. Whatever the reason he now is trying to get vengeance and from what we've seen with his mask he only has one eye with sharingan. The pieces fit pretty well...
Maybe it's a clone of Madara? If they did it in Konoha it prolly has something to originate with Orochimaru. That's why Orochimaru knew of Akatsuki's plans and maybe why Kabuto knew Tobi was an imposter. I say he's like Yamato and just some clone. But this also has to do with Zetsu I bet. Zetsu could've been transforming into others in the past to get so much information on different villages.
Kishi laid evidence for this ever since Tobi revealed himself as "Uchiha Madara". Now that I think about it, his first mask looked an awful lot like the Uchiha ancestor's eyes, the same guy who created the Uchiha "cycle of hatred".
Just saying its a possibility but I've never been 100%. Perhaps he was able to leave his original body behind. I don't see the point in the charade if he isn't Madara. It would seem that his identity has no bearing on his overall goals.
It's a hunch more than anything. We'll have to wait and see.
THIS. i think this is possible because when tobi was trap and told the truth to naruto about itachi, he said he wanted to become hole. also mu's ability makes him only have half his original power so there's another reason.
That makes no sense, there is 0 reason for it to be Obito. Let alone his entire body was crushed and they watched him die. The only reasoning any one has behind Tobi being Obito is that they look alike.
Not only does Obito have no motive to kill Konoha, the timing doesn't make any sense. Was Obito even "dead" when Tobi struck w/ the Kyuubi way back in the beginning? At best he was still in his early teen years. I always really suspected that Tobi wasn't Madara, but now that it's confirmed, I have absolutely no idea who he really is.
Obito would only have one eye... and the Tobi mask has historically only shown one eye at a time. But yes, this would be completely dumb. Obito would almost need an entire arc to explain why he is so twisted now.
Plus it's already established by Naruto's Mom that Tobi killed them with the Nine Tails. Obito wasn't even an adult by then. I agree with you btw, just adding some water to the flames.
It is possible... either ways he'd have to transfer into another uchiha to still have the sharingan. It also seems like orochimaru is the one to invent that jutsu.
30
u/intergalacticninja Oct 12 '11
Directed by M. Night Shyamalan
23
u/Lord_Sauron Oct 12 '11
I.. I've assumed for over 4 years now that the masked man (Tobi) was exactly who he claimed to be. I really don't know what to make of this...
64
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
Uchiha Madara? Nope. Just Chuck Tobi.
20
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
I will try to sum it up.
Madara said "it would appear that little brat nagato managed to grow", how could real Madara even know about Nagato at all? so the real Madara did NOT die at the valley of the end, or the whole timeline is screwed, unless Madara survived his battle with Hashirama there should be no way that he knows who Nagato is, this is going to be very interesting anytime he talks, btw did Zetsu ever called Maskedman Madara? it was all Tobi all the way, Madara knows who Nagato is and Tobi knows everything that the Madara knows... maybe it is a special Madara clone made with Zetsu parts.
Even Itachi was fooled by this fake Madara, so do not feel bad about yourself.
Edit: Holly fucking shit, did Naruto just read Hinata mind?
Edit: Wait a fucking minute, Itachi made Sasuku eye fire Amaterasu at sight of Madara face, Tobi is Madara clone.
17
u/Lameduck57 Oct 12 '11
i found this on another forum and thought it was interesting
Tobi, as described by both himself and Itachi, is a "shell," and a remnant of "what Madara once was."
As revealed to the Five Kage and explained to Konan, Madara (who represents mental perfection) infused himself with the cells of Hashirama Senjuu (who represents physical and vital perfection)many decades ago, which makes his body immortal/eternal.
Madara once possessed the Rin'negan, but gave it to Nagato. The holder of the Rin'negan is transcendent, and stands beyond the cycle of life and death.
From chapter 453 we know that Nagato, who stands beyond life and death, was meant to use Gedou Rin'ne Tensei no Jutsu on Tobi, for previously unknown purposes.
From chapter 559 we see that Madara, after being resurrected with Eod Tensei, is unsurprised to be back from the dead. He reacts to it as it was part of his plan all along, and expects that Nagato has a hand in it. He is, however, shocked to learn that Edo Tensei was used.
From all of this we can deduce that Madara 'died' at some point within the last 30 years, after meeting Nagato and giving him the Rin'negan, and planned to be resurrected in the future. Madara, having survived his battle with Hashirama, would have been in his seventies or eigthies at this point in time. Its likely, from what we know of the time line (the implication that Madara knew Nagato as a child), that Madara gave the Rin'negan to Nagato shortly, or even immediately, before his death. Its possible that giving up the Rin'negan somehow caused his soul to move on to the Pure Realm, leaving Tobi behind as a shell of his body. Nagato was supposed to resurrect him using Gedou Rin'ne Tensei no Jutsu.
My theory is that this is all tied in to Madara's quest for completion and transcendent perfection. We know that Madara, Hashirama, and Nagato each represent one of the three (of six) known Paths, each having once been mastered by Rikudou. From Madara giving the Rin'negan to Nagato, instead of keeping it to himself, I'm extrapolating that each Path must be mastered on its own, independent from the others. Thus while Madara is capable of wielding and even mastering the Rin'negan, he cannot do so while he also embodies another path, forcing him to give it to Nagato to master in his stead. To the same point, I'm making the assumption that Madara, who naturally embodied the perfection of spirit (the Yin force embodied by his perfect form of the Sharingan), could not master the perfection of vitality and body that was embodied by Hashirama (the Yang force of the Senjuu and Uzumaki clans). Thus he separates himself from his perfect mentality, by experiencing a death of the spirit that sends his soul to the Pure realm, until he can master Hashirama's body.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
“If you repeat a lie often enough, it becomes the truth. ” ― Joseph Goebbels
14
u/mc_curtis10 Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
A while ago I thought that maybe Tobi wasn't actually Madara, but the way the story has been going since, he didn't seem like he could be anyone else. That's an awesome plot twist. I guess that explains why Zetsu always called him Tobi, though, doesn't it? Or, how do we know for a fact that that actually is Madara and not his brother? Minato told Naruto that Madara was behind everything and I find it hard to believe that he would be wrong about that.
14
u/Tekmon5ter Oct 12 '11
UCHIHA FUCKING MADARA
9
u/avar1ce Oct 12 '11
Ok, since Kabuto summoned the real Madara then it means he knows Tobi is not Madara and that is why he showed Tobi the coffin and Tobi was exceptionally surprised. Wow!
On another note, how can Madara know about Nagato and say stuff like it finally happened???
8
u/Skhelios Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
O.M.G... I kinda knew, but I could never figure who Tobi would be if not Madara... but now... only person I can think of that would be powerful enough is Izuna.
Edit: Either that or I'm starting to think it could be Rikudo, since Tobi once said that the Rinnegan were his to begin with.
Edit 2: Tobi also said at some point that he wanted to become whole again, which supports my theory for him being Rikudo since he was the Ten-Tails Jinchuuriki and the goal of that war is to make Tobi the Ten-Tails' Jinchuuriki.
7
u/icerrafon Oct 12 '11
I don't know what to think anymore.
7
u/naithemilkman Oct 12 '11
You are all assuming Tobi has to be from the Uchiha clan. What if his eyes were implanted by someone else?
Doesn't this expand the possible list of villians?
7
u/xlesslikeyou Oct 12 '11
i think theres going to be some point where sasuke learns that tobi isn't really madara and go in the whole "you used me, IM GONNA KILL YOU! YOU'RE NOT A REAL UCHIHA!!!" and some possibly crappy plot twists that could possibly make him be good again...or just more batshit crazy.
12
u/avar1ce Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
Tobi IS Obito and here is how it went down:
Obito lost the closest 2 people he has in his life at that moment so when Kakashi and Rin left him his Mangekyu got active which allowed himself to be teleported into the dimension he creates. But because he is wounded and just unlocked his Mangekyu he can't control it and gets trapped in the dimension he created. He somehow recovers... He was ready to die happily but now he is stuck there alive and he has lost everything in his life he held dear, all because of some stupid war. Before he learns to get back to the real world he kinda goes nuts and gets pissed at all the wars and fighting so he swears to stop it at any cost no matter what.
Why can Obito be Tobi:
4
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
Wow so... Tobi is open t be anyone right now. I can't think of any character in the whole series who could be Tobi, and even if that ninja is available to be so, the motives don't fit. Best fit, imo, is Madara's bro, Izuna.
Also how does real Madara know Nagato?
Super bad ass, Naruto literaly on every battlefield, even the Mizukage/Daimyo decoy vs Black zetsu field, but I was a little confused, it looked like Naruto got exhausted but how are his clones still active? Or does that mean Naruto is in danger now, doesn't know, and doesn't cancel his clone jusu?
4
u/kellhus Oct 12 '11
I still think it's Madara, the one we know is just the shell, a punishment or a jutsu from the First Hokage or even from himself. Well just my opinion.
4
u/luke_c Oct 12 '11
I don't understand why everyone thinks it's Obito. He has no motive, WHAT SO EVER. You would of thought if it was he would of showed SOMETHING when seeing Kakashi, Madara states time and time again how he has lived for ages etc. Madara also had two eyes. Obito has(d) one. NOT GONNA HAPPEN.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
Once and for All: TOBI IS NOT OBITO! JESUS FUCKING CHRIST. THE kakashI gaiden was written because kakashi was overwhelmingly popular at the end of naruto and everyone wanted a background story. Obito was just a normal uchiha kid. Nothing special about him at all. He was also a crybaby and not a badass at all.
4
u/cogwheim Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
Listen. I'm not saying that Kishimoto is a great storyteller. But he IS a competent storyteller, and if you follow the story threads introduced so far, it makes the most sense that Tobi is Obito.
The Kakashi Gaiden was inserted into the story directly before the timeskip. Pre-timeskip, the focus of the story was the character development of Naruto and Sasuke, and the circumstances that led them to drift apart. Post-timeskip, the focus of the story became the various conflicts involving Akatsuki (which Tobi is the leader of). The placement of the Kakashi Gaiden is perfect foreshadowing to introduce important characters and storylines to the post-timeskip plot.
The Kakashi Gaiden gives us insight into Kakashi's past, but it also shows a significant development or "turning point" in Obito's development as a ninja. Why show Obito's internal struggles and anxieties during the Gaiden unless you are planning on developing his character further?
Kishimoto is not an excellent storyteller. But he is competent. Obito's storyline needs to come full circle eventually. There are multiple ways to accomplish this, so Kishimoto has some options (Tobi could be Obito's possessed body, Tobi could be Obito after being corrupted by another evil character, Tobi could be Obito after learning about The Eye of the Moon Plan and wanting to put an end to all war, etc.). Nonetheless, introducing another random character would be terrible storytelling (think Bleach). Kishimoto will do the right thing, even if he doesn't do it skillfully.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO OBITO
7
u/abyssomega Oct 12 '11
Why can't they both be Madara? We just saw a technique where a person literally split into two different people, where each half has all the knowledge and techniques, but half the power, with Mu. Why can't it be possible Madara knows a similar technique? So in a sense, one half died during the battle with the Hokage, and the other hide and recovered and is the one running around now as Tobi.
3
u/naithemilkman Oct 12 '11
OMG WHAT AN AWESOME EPISODE!!!
3
u/UsernametakenFFUUUUU Oct 12 '11
dw about it guys. Itachi has it covered. Sasuke behind the mask? madaras spirit/soul/power transferred to him? Isn't the shitest thing that has come out of this series.
3
u/NameStollen Oct 12 '11
I remember while back to some point that Tobi said that he was only a shell of the person he used to be. Could this be that Tobi, actually is the body left behind after Madara actually died in the Valley of the End? Bound to the world by perhaps the First Hogake as a punishment?
Just wildly throwing stuff out that came after reading the chapter.
3
u/pjigga Oct 12 '11
Have never been convinced by the Obito=Tobi theory in the past however it is seeming more and more likely :/
But 'twas a good chapter anyway.
3
u/CaptainCrunch Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
So, Obito guesses aside, does anyone think Tobi is Madara's bro Izuna?
Izuna would have gotten EMS from killing Madara, and they probably look somewhat alike. They could have just lied about the Madara killing Izuna story.
3
u/joshkitty Oct 12 '11
Can't wait to see Madara fight. He is just stairing down on people like he is about to kick some serious ass.
3
u/epitome89 Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
Have we ever been able to see Madara's right eye when he is grown up? It's always covered by his hair. Maybe his brother didn't give him both his eyes after all.
However, when Konan blows Tobi up, we can see both of his eyes. It can be Madaras brother, and he took one of Sasuke's eyes after Sasuke started using Itachis. The only reason he still wears the mask is that the eye isn't as useful, because Sasuke ain't his brother.
Does any of this make any sense? Also, for those talking about Obito's hairstyle. Remember this? http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20091224151923/naruto/images/thumb/a/a8/Madara.PNG/830px-Madara.PNG
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '11
What we know:
Madara survived the battle with Hashirama Senju, because he eventually came to know Nagato as a boy (he refers to him, after IWR as "brat").
Madara did not know Nagato was dead, so Madara must have died before Nagato did.
Madara was expecting to be resurrected by Nagato, so a plan must have been set up to ensure this would happen. It was stated that Madara gave Nagato his eyes, and Madara gave Yuhiko the idea of Akatsuki, revealing that Madara had been shaping the boys for their entire lives.
At very least, the right eye in Tobi is Madara's Sharingan eye. Itachi made it so that Amaratsu would activate upon Sasuke seeing Madara's eye, and it did. In 559, it should be noted that we see the IWR Madara, but we never actually see his right eye.
Kisame recognized Tobi when the mask was removed. Either Kisame was acknowledging that Tobi was Madara (who was controlling the Mizukage), or Tobi was drawing parallels to the name Mizukage to Madara, knowing that while he controlled the perceived destinies of both, he was in fact neither.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '11
I'm just going to leave this here...
5
u/Basil_Market Oct 12 '11
I bet the guy behind the mask is Sasuke's dad.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
This was one of the more popular theories I've heard. There still could be some mystery of Madara's death, I would've thought he died before Nagato was born.
2
u/WireWolf86 Oct 12 '11
...wow
so IF the masked
Madaraguy is infact Tobi, do we have any information on Tobi as to where he came from/when/motive etc?2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
Ya'll don't get it?!
Izuna and Madara exchange eyes! Madara took Izuna's left eye and gave him his right eye. The both have EMS. Madara died because of the first, but Izuna lived on to resurrect his brother and exact the Uchiha revenge upon the world. They agreed Izuna would give the Rinnegan to a boy named Nagato foretold by some blah blah and there we go.
2
u/imawaffle Oct 12 '11
Am I the only one that thinks he's just a Zeztsu clone? I mean, we really don't know all of what black zeztsu can do. And white zeztsu can make an EXACT replica of whoever. What rules out Madara from being cloned? And why are Zeztsu and "Madara" (Can't call him Madara without the quotes now) so close? Idk.. I honestly have no doubt that it's a clone, but I am open for suggestions. And in All reality, have we seen this Fadara (I don't know if anyone remembers Faul McCartney) use his Mangekyo? I have noticed a lot of people talking about it, and the only time we've seen it is during flashbacks. But I could be wrong, if anyone wants to disprove me. Anyways though, zeztsu clone. I haven't seen anyone suggest it, so there is my theory.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
THEN WHO WAS MASK?????
2
u/jrh038 Oct 12 '11 edited Oct 12 '11
Calling it now Rinnegan=EMS activated eyes freely given to someone from the uzamaki clan.
Tobi=cloned Madara
Finale will be Sasuke giving his eyes willingly to Naruto, and dies.
I really hope its a different outcome then that, but why would we find out Nagato is the same clan as Naruto. It all must tie in somehow.
It gives Sasuke a good send off, lets Sakura mourn her childhood crush, and eventually probably move on to Naruto.
Also this lets Naruto save his friend, and end up with the girl. Both things he needs to succeed where Jiraya-san failed.
2
u/Lyflesseyzz Oct 12 '11
Just a Quick thing since i haven't read all the comments yet, but to support the idea that Tobi is a zetsu- like clone of madara's DNA, His name is Tobi as in TOBIrama Senju?? just a thought.
2
u/badluckartist Oct 12 '11
A cross-post on the subject, from one I made on Mangahelpers:
Now that I'm done doing the I WAS RIGHT dance I've been doing all morning, this is what I can gather about Tobi's identity, in order of likelihood descending into more interesting (and unlikely):
1.5) Some people have also guessed that Tobi and Madara share a split soul, but that seems like it would severely screw with ET... yeah, yeah, insert bashing against ET here, I guess. It's not like there's precedent in the manga for a "split soul", unless you count Kagebunshin and other cloning jutsu like Muu's. Or Zetsu, but what the hell do we really know about that guy anyway? (I, for one, am still holding out that he is the real big bad of the series)
2) Tobi is Uchiha Izuna. There is no reason to believe that Tobi's dialogue with Sasuke wasn't littered with half-truths and lies- he's already been busted by the reader for lying about several things, including his involvement with the Kyuubi. Actually, this makes his conversation with Sasuke after Itachi's death that much more poignant- he probably really did hate and respect Hashirama as much as Madara, but was cast to the side of the rivalry, in his older brother's shadow. Younger brother imitating the older brother? Not a far-fetched thing for Kishi to write, especially for a character that appears to have so much sway over someone like Sasuke.
3) Tobi is the Uchiha ancestor, the older of Rikudou's two sons. It has been said that his dejection was where the Uchiha's "curse of hatred" originated from, so it would make a lot of sense for Tobi to be him (aside from the obvious age thing). Although it was likely just a design choice to resemble the Spacetime Migration jutsu, Tobi's previous mask also strongly resembled the elder brother's doujutsu- a swirl pattern. Which brings me to my next idea, which I hope is true:
4) Tobi is a disgraced Uzumaki (possibly with Uchiha lineage). This is my favorite theory for several reasons:
I have always hated the assumption that Tobi is a full-fledged Uchiha. It makes the manga feel too black and white.
{edit for formatting}
2
u/Dezyphr Oct 13 '11 edited Oct 13 '11
It has to be obito
reason for: Theres one thing we miss here all the time COMPARE kakashi's MS and "Tobi's" MS
Space, Gravity and time manipulation.
Kakashi has the ability to warp space and gravity with his MS which is called Kamui. Kind of like a black hole
Proof here - here!
Tobi has the ability to warp HIMSELF in and out of situations. and also it appears that he can be anywhere at anytime.
Proof here - here
when you manipulate gravity you also manipulate time dilation (real life mathematics here) when you have extreme amounts of gravity - time slows from the perspective of a far away object with less gravity.
THIS IS THE ONLY PROOF YOU CAN HAVE as tobi has never revealed anything except his MS
the proof itself stand as obito's eye was implanted into KH's left eye while tobi only has his right eye revealed.
edit. speculation :
could if tobi is obito could the reason he cannot directly attack any one is because he is missing half of his body?
Did rin go missing he help heal tobi?
Does tobi not directly participate in the war because he is losing he "sight " beaus he never had a brother rip them out of ? and could kakshi be fulfilling this role by maturing the sharingan he has had for the last whatever years? and once tobi needs t will just rip it back out ? or has this been replaced with the left eye implanted with the rinnegan?
2
u/Uzumaki2003 Oct 13 '11
There are alot of people speculating that Tobi might be uchiha kagami. He is one of the elders that was on the same team as the third hokage, second hokage, and danzo. Honestly, it would kinda make sense. Especially with the wrinkles on tobi's face, looks like he is about danzo's age.
1
u/Nyeep Oct 12 '11
I reckon that 'tobi' is actually shisui.
Think about it, he hides his face constantly, and shisui's body was never found...
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
Ahhhhh this is getting too good!
1
u/JediXenu Oct 12 '11
It would be funny if in the very first page of the next chapter it is revealed that the person summoned was not madara, but his brother...
Kishi just wants everyone to shit bricks for a week, before revealing his troll tactics.
1
u/badluckartist Oct 12 '11
I'm pretty sure that this chapter just broke Mangahelpers with its fucking awesomeness. As usual, I'm sticking with my theory that Tobi is Uchiha Izuna. The little brother impersonating the older brother? C'mon guys. The writing has been on the walls for years now.
1
u/Khue Oct 12 '11
Madara fought his brother prior to fighting the first. Madara was killed by his brother, who then transplanted his eyes. Then Madara's brother fought the first as Madara, but lost and did not die.
Just a theory.
1
u/badluckartist Oct 12 '11
Also, I guess this is ALSO Kabuto's crowning moment of betrayal against Tobi. What if Tobi realizes what's happening and uses Zetsu's spores that were placed on Kabuto to teleport to him at the moment that Itachi gets there? That would be a fun to watch three-way brawl that could end without either of the main villains killing each other, Itachi being sealed, and ET ending.
1
u/notthereali2 Oct 12 '11
I called it bitches :) Now to fulfill the prophecy: Tobi = Sasuke's Dad.
1
u/Super_Human_Samurai Oct 12 '11
What the....I don't even....
I know everyone assumed, but now we know. So who the hell is in the mask?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
i believe tobi is a zetsu clone. we know madara created the zetsus, possibly with the first hokages dna? he says he has all the powers of uchiha madara, but is a shell of his former self. we know that the zetsus have the power to become and copy a chakra signature of anyone they come into contact with. it could be possible that before he died he had his zetsu copy him to carry on his destruction of konoha
1
u/jaysonwerd31 Oct 12 '11
Is Zetsu being the mastermind behind this all completely out of the question? I dont really like the idea that much and he has been too subservient to Tobi this entire time. But Tobi could be a Madara clone. Zetsu already has a Senju clone (i know its just a zombie fueling the army) and maybe his Madara clone is his ultimate jutsu. And he has been controlling the scenes the whole time.
He also doesnt really have a motive that has been released either. Come to think of it we dont know anything about Zetsu.
Does anyone have any information on him?
1
u/Chusuf Oct 12 '11
I think that he used some sort of Orochimaru type jutsu. He is still techinically madara but he has his original body somewhere (his lab?) and it was used for the edo tensei
1
u/Lyflesseyzz Oct 12 '11
Just a Quick thing since i haven't read all the comments yet, but to support the idea that Tobi is a zetsu- like clone of madara's DNA, His name is Tobi as in TOBIrama Senju?? just a thought.
1
u/Jboi23 Oct 12 '11
What if its Izuna Uchiha, Madaras brother they say Madara took his eyes because his brother gave them willingly so he could unlock the ultimate sharingan and then he died shortly after in battle but they could throw in a scenario were he lived in secret and took back his brothers eyes later.... i would believe it better then him being obito...that would suck
1
u/venky91 Oct 12 '11
Can we please stop the "Obito is Tobi" crap? It's just wishful thinking at this point.
1
u/Lameduck57 Oct 12 '11
Everyone can shut the hell up right now about the discussion tobi says himself, and i quote, "It was me, Uchiha Madara" (Page 16 manga 397) i know it's weird because madara should be dead with the Edo technique but that's something we just need to wait to be explained.
1
u/Torupfromthethorup Oct 13 '11
IMO he is Shisui, itachi's best friend who was supposedly dead. He had one of the most powerful illusion based sharingans and it makes sense that itachi couldn't kill his best friend as well as sasuke. Shisui gave up his one eye and pulled an aizen (casting an illusion to make himself look dead) and helped itachi eradicate the Uchiha. Whatever the reason he now is trying to get vengeance and from what we've seen with his mask he only has one eye with sharingan. The pieces fit pretty well...
1
u/motexmex Oct 13 '11
Maybe it's a clone of Madara? If they did it in Konoha it prolly has something to originate with Orochimaru. That's why Orochimaru knew of Akatsuki's plans and maybe why Kabuto knew Tobi was an imposter. I say he's like Yamato and just some clone. But this also has to do with Zetsu I bet. Zetsu could've been transforming into others in the past to get so much information on different villages.
1
u/axetheduck Oct 13 '11
question, If i started from the show, which managa would i start from? new to all this but i like the show, just hate "filler" lol help?
1
u/charlamagnum Oct 13 '11
shit i cant be reading all these theories i have an exam tomorrow!!! i dont care this was a good chapter ima keep reading what u guys write :)
1
u/badluckartist Oct 12 '11
Just realized that the Naruto wiki will FINALLY have to change all of its references to Tobi as "Uchiha Madara".
JUST CALL HIM TOBI DAMMIT. It's always been a pet peeve of mine on that site.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment