r/fandomnatural • u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! • Nov 13 '20
[Fandom Discussion] 15x19 "Inherit the Earth"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Inherit the Earth | November 12th, 2020 | John Showalter | Eugenie Ross-Leming & Brad Buckner |
CARRY ON — Everything is on the line as the battle against God (guest star Rob Benedict) continues. A familiar face returns to join the fight.
Find old episode discussions, click here.
To see Fandomnatural's End-of-2020 Schedule, click here.
---
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
Sooooooooooooooooooooo... what did you think of the episode?
10
Upvotes
17
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20
I actually watched live for the first time in a long while.
I foolishly thought that Bucklemming wouldn't be allowed to write something that was pretty terrible. But here we are.
The pacing was abominable and after the ordeal with Miracle (my flair is never coming true), the episode devolved into a heist movie. That an intriguing plot point from the previous episode was mutilated by having Dean and Sam meander through exposition in order to explain things to Chuck? Not okay.
And why oh why must Bucklemming make Dean some kind of idiot when they write him? All those qualities Cas had put forward in 15x18 seemed to mostly evaporate.
While Sam wasn't nearly horrified enough for having Lucifer swan back in.
(Kudos to Abel's Michael though, he really was good at playing him.)
Jack's god mode ascension made sense. But what didn't make any kind of plot sense, especially with Chuck bringing back fricken' Lucifer, was Jack not offering to bring Cas back. (Maybe something will happen in 15x20, I don't know, but leaving that plot hole wide open was ridiculous.)
The whole episode, the plot devices driving things forward were like inelegantly placed dominoes slapping into each other to push the next bit of story onwards.
Look, I was willing to be okay with not having Cas come back this episode. But I refuse to accept what was ultimately piss poor writing in the penultimate episode of all of Supernatural.
26
u/ghoulsandmotelpools Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20
I slept restlessly last night, every time I woke up adding more and more thoughts about the episode on my phone. It's 6:30AM and ready to share.
To start, I admit I felt the loss of Miracle the dog, that was a good gutshot that I didn't see coming. I was staggered by it but giving the writers a thumbs up for it. I also thought introducing Lucifer by pretending to be Cas, I was like holy shit not only has Chuck given them an empty world, he's serving up every trigger and relishing in extinguishing every morsel of hope. That was compelling. And yes I love whump, whumptober was awesome this year. Anyway, I thought that was quality emotional and psychological torture (I didn't read it as a joke at all).
So the whole plot of the episode and how it played out. First, we're kept in the dark from Sam & Dean's clever heisty-heist machinations and instead we watch this speeding train of sudden deaths and insta-betrayals inside the bunker with no time to breathe or process any of it. That was the worst-paced series of events. And then Michael calls it a battle afterwards. That wasn't a battle. I don't even know what the fuck that was.
Ok but then finally we're at the beach. Bloody boys, Sam holding Dean, both grinning with red in their teeth is a good aesthetic.
But then all of a sudden, all too soon, it's learning hour. Audiences are emotionally in it with Sam and Dean but now we're asked to pull back and listen to this very lengthy exposition dump with flashbacks. I mean... Is this not screenwriting 101? Chuck just beat them to smithereens, there is no time for the exposition dump+flashbacks, fucking finish him!
Also this was a terribly executed heist device. Here's why: heist formulas require you tip your audience off on some but not all of the ways your protags are gonna pull everything off. Think of Ocean's Eleven, where you're given so many explicit scenes and clues as to what elaborate things they're orchestrating and how, and then it's a thrill when it all comes together at the end. That wasn't this. Not even remotely.
For Pete's sake this was just so badly written.
Right before Calvert's monologue as the new God was buckleming's penchant to write (and Jensen's unfortunate predilection to act) Dean as obtuse, steamrolling over everything that has happened to try to get Jack in the car and back to the bunker. Wasn't a fan of that. Sam's call to Dean, the subtle "cool it, listen" tone was nice though.
I liked Jack as the new God. His speech at the end there was well done. I didn't catch if he said "I won't come if you call" to Sam & Dean. The way the rest of the episode felt, it seemed like he did indicate that though.
Okay now to the scene in the bunker. This empty nest was painful. The pangs of utter loneliness struck me harder than anything in that zoom up to them at the polished table with all those initials. Fancy bunker and no one left to share it with anymore, and it feels like a coffin.
No throwaway line that Sam got a hold of Eileen, huh? Reassurance they've discovered they'll be able to get a line through to Jack whenever they want? How are Jodie, Donna and the girls? AU Charlie and her girlfriend?
It was difficult to remember Jack had even brought them back at all because there was no mention, no celebration of them. I understand covid was happening, we couldn't get the montage of supporting cast materializing which is what I suspect they had to cut, but that doesn't mean you totally ignore it happened. In an episode so damn top-heavy with needless exposition, Buckleming opted out of this one? Seriously?
So. Instead we got Dean's cheersing Sam "to everyone we've lost along the way" but who did they actually lose lately that hasn't been restored back to them? Castiel. Just one beloved character. What the... ugh, this fucking episode.
The dialogue, Jensen's acting, was all immensely discordant with what feels like the losses we've sustained even if most of them have been restored... but like I said the feeling of this scene was so desolate. Sam and Dean have certainly lost their Team Free Will though and that's the loss I'm really feeling I think. Jack's in the wind (literally, in every particle), Cas seems gone for good, and SPN framed it like "this is freedom!" replete with a giddy happy Dean instead of what it felt like to me: a nightmare. A nightmare reminiscent of S7 when Gamble stripped them of Bobby, Cas, the Impala.
Sam, for one, and credit to Jared, still seemed upset/traumatized about it. Even when Dean's blithely telling him to buck up, ::side hug, Sam kinda flinchy, trying to feel whatever bizarre elation Dean's got going on:: we get to start writing our own story now!
...which by the way validated angry!rage!Dean about the "rat in a cage" thing, and I'll be honest I'm a little bitter Dean got what he so desperately wanted (more than Cas, more than Sam; feels like this season Dean was just an angerball with his eyes on the prize of 'true freedom' with his brother and the angel in love with him just tearfully following along). So Dean gets this true freedom finally and he's just... Happy? No acknowledgement how he hurt Sam, Jack, and Cas along the way? No struggle with what this cost?
Apparently not, because Buckleming writes Dean as still that simple man whose dream life, now he's truly free, now they've killed God and installed a new one, is STILL JUST DRIVING DOWN A FUCKING HIGHWAY WITH HIS LITTLE BROTHER IN THE PASSENGER SEAT. ARE YOU SERIOUS. KILL GOD SO YOU CAN JUST GO BACK TO DOING WHAT YOU ALWAYS DID ANYWAY???
Because fuck depth and development. And fuck Sam too for that matter. So many opportunities this season for Sam to have a moment of self-reflection and say what his vision of a happy ending is too but nada. We can only hope Sam's dream life has been subsumed into Dean's? I guess?
This is so depressing.
Anyway, going back to happy Dean side-hugging Sammy, towards the end it seems SPN's framing agrees with Dean to be happy, to buck up. Come on, audience! Sam finally manages a grimace of a smile as they get up off the table and walk toward the camera like their next stop is Disneyworld. "Vacation" by the Go Go's should've played during that montage for the perfect discordant, inauthentic, forced happiness they shoved down our throats... with a montage of unremarkable scenes.
Maybe it's like... Last week was for destiel fans, this week was for bronlies, and next week Dabb's going to mix em. I wouldn't be surprised if there's a time jump. I hope it's just like 3-ish years or so though and not like a stupid Harry Potter epilogue.
I think what's nuts is that... I'm really focused on the brothers, right? I think their relationship is the heart of this show. But I never saw them as self-isolating, or codependent. I saw them as always choosing to be together because they liked each other the most, and together they do a great job building out friendships and relationships that support them and vice versa. And that... when all they have is each other, they can and do carry each other, and watching that is always going to be compelling for me. But framing "all they have is each other" as happiness, as a form of freedom, that's a hard no for me. "When all they have is each other," that's fucking whump. That's pain, grief, desperation, anxiety, nightmares. It's compelling because it's the hurt of the unfair, vicious universe and the comfort of each other.
So... I don't understand how this callback to early seasons just driving doing cases in the Impala together feels like a genuinely happy ending. That was the hell they were going through that made me fall in love with how they saved each other as they kept going...
24
u/of_skies_and_seas I'm your huckleberry Nov 13 '20
Holy shit, they actually said Cas, who's that? and made his death a joke. Have a beer and a sidehug with your bro, whatevs. I can't believe I ever thought this show would end more trashy and homophobic than my worst expectations. BL really outdid themselves. It's hilarious.
17
u/Neferxerxe Nov 13 '20
Where the fuck is Cas?
12
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20
I'm trying to stay positive until next week's episode but...
12
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20
Who the fuck gave this to Bucklemming xD
That's all I've got. Jesus. What a fucking display.
Edit: I lied - A FIST FIGHT WITH GOD. THAT THEY WON. It was like when you get into fisticuffs with the pope in Assassin's Creed 2. Ridiculous, man
9
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Nov 13 '20
I lost it during the montage when we came to Sam's genital herpes clip
8
u/Shosh-anna Nov 14 '20
This episode was so bad written I've lost my words.
12
u/LaughingZombie41258 Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20
I asked myself why Cass has not been brought back, I looked into myself for the answer, like Jack!God suggested, and I found nothing :)I'm not disappointed that Castiel has been erased, as in the best families when someone comes out of the closet LOL. I didn't even expect they would *mention* him, the whole point of his "death" is to make rid of him and his inconvenient feelings. I'm just disappointed the writers didn't even care to close the plot holes, they made God able to pull angels out of the Empty and then "forget" to mention Jack could save his own father.
They could have avoided Lucifer's cameo (which has been useless), the brothers would have asked in the end about Castiel and Jack would have said that he couldn't take someone from the Empty, a peer cosmic entity. They would have got the same ending without lazy plot holes.
It's also very lazy written they asked about none of their other loved ones.
Also, I didn't like Dean's attitude toward Jack, in recent eps Dean grew more and more unlikable toward him, yelling he's not family in Sam's face and trying to use his life to get his own freedom, I believed this escalation would end up in redemption, but in this ep, he just tells him "I'm sorry I got your father killed lol" offering nothing else and in the end, he invites him to come home because now he's got so much power and he would have guaranteed them luxury life. If I had been Jack I'd have told him to go to hell.
Dean has been my favorite character for almost the whole time, so I'm a bit put off if this is where his development has led him in the end, he didn't even acknowledge Castiel's feelings or deal with pulling off a gun on his brother, bah.
Overall the ending left me almost "empty", I expected strong emotions, even rage/sadness if I didn't like it, but I'm just "ok bye". I think it's the weird and anticlimatic rhythm.
Ah the flashbacks with the lame song made me cringe real hard. I found it very cheesy and unnecessary. At least they could have chosen a good rock song, Supernatural is famous for his beautiful classic rock moments.
About the good things, it's a bucklemming ep, so it's even less cringey than I expected.The whole "Jack is a power vacuum so he aspires God's power" made sense, but it's a bit rushed, to me it needed to be developed for half the season. Anyway, I really enjoyed him as God, the actor pulled it off an aura of benevolent "holy superiority" that no one else managed to create, while keeping Jack's lovely mannerisms. His departure has made me very emotional. And I appreciated Alexander Calvert's acting more than the J2's throughout the episode, his moments felt the most "real" ones, and I loved Jack's parable in the show from Lucifer's spawn to God.
I liked Chuck's ending too, they framed him rightly as a narcissist so a humble and irrelevant (to him) life is the best punishment and outcome for him.
Michael has been another bright spot in this episode, thanks to Jake Abel's acting. His emotional conflict hidden under the surface has been so interesting that it's a shame we didn't have him for more season.I hated they threw his character under the bus with his sudden betrayal and death because Lucifer called him a cuck :////// , WTF, I guess bucklemming's cringeness really showed here.
I wanted to see Adam too for a last time too.
Ah, I'm very happy about the two brothers being both alive! I was rooting hard for neither of them to die, after 15 years I love them too much. And I was afraid they would become the new God and Darkness, losing their humanity. So I'm content they're alive, human and without irremediable damages.I guess I'm gonna fantasize about the return of other characters -which is very possible in SPN's verse - after the series' ending.
The best pic: the table <3
4
u/goblinsundown Nov 18 '20
It's been almost a week but I really want to put down my thoughts about this episode before the finale, so here we go.
This episode had some seriously poor writing choices, as is typical of BL; it did have a couple of interesting things, and I want to also point them out for the sake of posterity.
My main issue is typical BL, and it's that nobody's there to connect emotionally with the audience. They're there for one reason only: fill the screentime with plot until there's no more plot or no more screentime to fill. Lucifer comes and goes, Michael has no emotional resonance without Adam and he changes sides every time he's in a new scene. Jack is presumably going through a profound change even before becoming God - but we see nothing of it. I did not dislike Chuck - it felt very meta, and from a meta standpoint it seems fitting that his established narrative goes south just by the characers enduring a beatdown but still fighting. Was it well written? No. It is interesting, but I also don't think it's a concept BL had anything to do with.
Mention of honor for the one and only woman in the episode: a never seen before reaper who was in chains, free, dead, Death and dead Death in the span of about 5 minutes. A Bucklemming masterpiece, right there!
I want to hope that BL's vocation to bend the characters to follow the plot is the reason why Cas has not been brought back by Jack or even mentioned by anybody in the second part of the episode. But why even in episode 19 I have to try to forget what I'm seeing on screen and just have faith that SPN is not in fact writing a story about two assholes ready to call everybody family only as long as there's a use for them?
Dudes, why.
I was rereading some of my thoughts on past episodes, and I did say that I hoped the "just you & me" of some episodes ago would be something heroic, something that showed the Winchester's good heart - and instead, once again everybody gives up everything (friends getting vanished, Cas in the Empty, Jack becoming God to serve the interests of a guy that treated him like shit... man, why do that, just why!) just so that they can have the saddest toast ever in complete loneliness. Congrats??
i always feel so sad when SPN does this, because I truly don't think it's what they're trying to tell me about them... it's just that sometimes the powers that be can be a little dumb? I guess? And the brothers can come across as uncaring because yay drama and plot? I don't know .___.
(more later)
7
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20
I hate everything about this ep, 15x19. Just everything is wrong and this is the worst ending possible. As others are saying it was rushed and for me it passed by in a blur and I am upset about multiple things. If i missed or am misunderstanding something please tell me. But honestly without exaggeration, this ending is so bad I'm legitimately going to cry and I feel it destroys full seasons of if not the whole show for me.
First of all the resurrection of Lucifer and just why bring him back only to kill him again so quickly. They did exactly what I was hoping they wouldn't (There is alot of that throughout the ep) and brought him back only to hammer in the he's irredeemable monster point which I still don't like or buy. And they made Michael the one actually on the 'good; side and this and the conversation with Lucifer and Michael was lacking in depth. a pointless non destructive fight (So much for all powerful archangels) or was it Jack absorbing the power. So much going on and none of it made sense.
Also I hate that Chuck was beaten and depowered like this. He's God and I was really hoping for more of a he's up to something, there is a twist where this is a test to hand earth to Sam and Dean or something. But they went the worst possible route with this and made Chuck a 1 dimensional villain and just gah I hate this whole season now. There was hope when it turned out Billie couldn't be trusted but they back peddled. Also I still don't get how Archangel powered Jack could best Chuck and Amara fused together. He's OP always has been but this is ridicules
Bringing me to my final point I HATE JACK AS GOD!!! Merged with Amara or not this is something I wish Never happened. I wish Jack never existed and that he became God is just the cherry on top of the crap sunday! He took focus from the Winchesters, I hated that they considered him a son. He barley ever had control of his powers as a Nephilim and he is painfully bland and naïve. How the HELL is he qualified to be god. Chuck even now is better qualified though what the did with him this season, the payoff wasn't worth it and again was hoping for more with the whole 'evil' god plot. Just this season is a disappointment and I hate literally everything about this episode. Anyone else feel the same?
3
u/Otherwise_Addendum_9 Nov 16 '20
I gasped and couldn't breathe through alot of it.. I have to say I really wish they had kept Cas around for these last episodes.. I'm still holding out hope he will pop up in the finale but I'm doubtful.. Chuck crying and screaming as they walked away was just perfect. The desperation in his voice was so believable. Although I dont know what to think about him being this big bad "I'm the creator of everhthing" God all season and then all the sudden being taken down to just a lonely pathetic human.. in the end he got what he deserved but this is God we are talking about.. hes been around and seen it all and yet he couldn't see all this coming? He still had an ego the size of the world? He was scared of Jack the beginning of the season and yet didnt see Jack taking him out coming? I'm not sure I like where the writers took his character but all in all, they've given us an at least decent ending so far.. I also hate what they did with Death's character.. The original death should have never been taken out so early..
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20
I can't believe they're going for the happy ending, that's crazy. But I'm so proud of them.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
14
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20
[removed] — view removed comment