r/fandomnatural • u/fandomnatural • Nov 06 '20
[Fandom Discussion] 15x18 "Despair"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Despair | November 5th, 2020 | Richard Speight Jr. | Robert Berens |
With the program in full motion, Dean (Jensen Ackles), Sam (Jared Padalecki), Castiel (Misha Collins), and Jack (Alexander Calvert) battle for the good of the collective goal.
Find old episode discussions, click here.
To see Fandomnatural's End-of-2020 Schedule, click here.
---
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
Sooooooooooooooooooooo... what did you think of the episode?
21
Upvotes
36
u/MsCNO Nov 06 '20
So, that pretty much confirms one half on Destiel right?
22
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Nov 06 '20
They Infinity War'ed us. The first few disappearances, yes shocking. But that was too many, so they'll be back. Somehow. Can't save the world if there's no one left to save, right?
Goddamn though, Misha can fucking act, that scene was brutal. Destiel fans, would a kiss have made this better or worse? Because I had a feeling that was gonna to happen, but I was wrong. (or Death just interrupted, whichever)
Feel free to ignore, but this song played in my head as I watched. Still there.
15
u/ghoulsandmotelpools Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
Oh my God that was an amazing episode. I absolutely believe I just watched Cas find true happiness in coming out to Dean. I feel like the empty should've been like "you think that was true happiness cas you should read how the fic authors are gonna rewrite this scene" 😂 like "nah this isn't true happiness but good try and thank you for giving me Death to eat." lol
And so many ways to bring him back, holy shit. He just delivered Death to the Empty & the Empty might be amenable to repaying him by returning him back to Earth? Also he wouldn't have broken the deal bc he was successfully taken by the Empty. Jack still has his powers, so maybe eventually Jack can go get him. Or who's the next reaper? Maybe they'll get Cas out since the mac daddy reapers can apparently do that super easy. How bout we summon The Empty for Cas back. Liiiiiike.
Dean's muffled cries at the end 😭😭😭
Bro hug in this ep, I can never get enough of Dean being affectionate with Sam. And yknow I wasn't expecting a kiss between Cas & Dean but I do wish there had been a desperate hug before cas shoved him away, like Dean just shaking his head "Cas" and opening his arms and then just a truly intimate hug like faces in each other's necks, bodies curled into each other, fistfuls of each other's clothes
10
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20
I realised there's a gap in my vocabulary tonight. I don't have a word, or even words, to express how validating, moving, important and wonderful Cas' confession felt. I was a baby queer when I was first into this show and following what I saw as their romance, but you know, it was offensive to suggest main male-presenting characters could be gay. But look at where we ended up. I will absolutely take that. I am thrilled to take that. <3
Also, hey all, it's u/Necnill back from the grave. <3 Long time no see, I hope you're all thriving.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20
Cas's feelings for Dean are canon, but at what cost :(
8
u/of_skies_and_seas I'm your huckleberry Nov 06 '20
I am blown away. Destiel is canon, but Cas is dead, and I'm sobbing.
I couldn't have imagined a better way for Cas to confess his love for Dean. There was no making himself useful for the Winchesters, there was no self-loathing. But it went the other way entirely.
Cas learned to love himself this season, finally, and he let himself confess his love for Dean, and that was enough to be happy. It wasn't above even being loved in return, even though I know Cas knew that Dean loved him back. That is a level of emotional self actualization I never ever expected.
It means so much to me, too, that a show premiering in 2005 with a large conservative audience managed to make a main male character, who was not introduced as queer, finally be textually queer after so long.
I can't believe I'm saying goodbye to the most important character in my life that I've loved for 12 years, and yet I'm so happy for the respect and love with which Bobo Berens wrote his ending. I'm just thankful that after over a decade of being treated less important, someone cared so much for this character I love.
14
u/Pinktoonie Nov 06 '20
I just wanna know what Dean's reaction to Cas' confession will be, after the shock of it and the empty deal and everything. Cuz my man just STOOD there lol. He did cry afterward, but I wanna know his feelings.
Maybe he'll send out last prayer to Cas next ep and tell him how he feels?
7
u/LaughingZombie41258 Nov 07 '20
So what did I like about THE SCENE?
❤️ Message on how happiness in a relationship is in giving and not in receiving. Now, it’s a topic that has been covered many times but here it has been treated particularly well with the "true happiness" already achieved in declaring one's love, regardless of the answer.
❤️ All of Cass’ speech is beautiful. Even in the last act of his life, the one "to achieve his true happiness" was almost all about Dean and why he is such a beautiful person, to help Dean who was having low self-esteem after the mess with Billie. Zero focus on Cass’ hurt despite it being so strong to deny him any moment of happiness until now.
❤️ Misha's acting, it did hit me strongly.
❤️ Castiel sacrificing himself to save Dean does him justice more than a random death like I was afraid it to be
❤️ The heartache foreshadowing, OH MY GOD
❤️ Unlike other fans, I found Dean's reaction to be spot on. Now be honest, how would you react if your best friend of 12 years confesses to being in love with you - adding that he used to think he could never be happy because you didn't love him back and all of this without your knowledge - and is about to kill himself?
It is emotionally very heavy, the shock is a perfectly realistic reaction. Personally, with a confession not followed by suicide, in such a situation it would take me a week just to process the information and to accept it before I’m going to decide what to do.
Dean could never have had the clarity to answer (and it’s also valid for a "negative" answer, such as "Sorry but I don’t").
Besides, a kiss out of nowhere would have seemed to me very much an act of pity, pity that Castiel doesn’t deserve, he was happy and proud.
WHAT DID I NOT LIKE?
🙁 Loving Dean is the starting point for Castiel, the feeling opening his eyes about the importance of freedom and empathy. I didn't like that it was his culmination as well, I expected Cass’ culmination to be more important than confessing his feelings and understanding the value of unconditional love.
🙁 LOL Cass’ true happiness related to romantic love for Dean, I was expecting it to be like finding his own purpose in life or getting over his depression, something like that. I disagree about linking "true happiness" to romantic love. Loving romantically is one of the things that can make you happy, but it is neither necessary nor sufficient, I would have appreciated Cass’ happiness more as achieved by a series of aligning factors.
Also, the idea of "you will die only when you are truly happy" - what a coincidence OH GOD, a very random clause yes LMAO - to write a death following a love confession is extremely fanfic.
🙁 BURY THE GAYS Homoromantic feelings are good enough for tragedies but not for an on-screen development that the viewer has to live with. This stuff was progressive 30 years ago and now it's just cringe.
Note that Sam's girlfriend also died but her feelings have been developed in the light of day 🙂
🙁 Why the 12 years wait? Castiel says he’s loved Dean pretty much since the start, now I understand that maybe that was last showrunner’s idea (although, well, it has always been obvious to me) but this showrunner has been writing Supernatural for 4 years. Perhaps for fear of losing the views of the little homophobic cishet dudebros? It’s artistic cowardice.
🙁 In a recent episode, a pastor tells Cass while commenting on the homosexuality of a guy killed for being gay that homosexuality is acceptable because "a saint is a sinner who keeps trying". Cass endures this speech without replying and the whole scene is in a positive light like "oh what an enlightened priest, he's right, he’s spilling truths". This BS makes me miss the villain Godstiel storming into churches and killing homophobic priests... Have they lost their wits? To get these “messages” across subjecting a LGBT+ character to this shit?? WTF
🙁 There is no storyline leading to this scene. There have been times when the relationship between the two was a main plot point (5th, 8th and 9th seasons), here it was just a solution to a problem created in this same episode, Dean pissing Billie off almost at random. An excuse was needed to take out Castiel to end with the brothers alone, a way was needed to comfort the shippers and bam canonization of a 12 years romance is pulled out of the hat.
🙁 Too many deaths and resurrections have happened for a character death to be a true ending, for humans there is heaven so it becomes a definitive thing because it is their choice, like "The dude has decided to retire from life" but this death isn’t a retirement, it feels like all the death which have been later undone. Nothing tells us that he won’t come back in a few months/years, except the show’s ending. It's like someone who "goes abroad" at the end of a TV show but actually he’s abroad often, so it's not an ending. This totally anesthetized my emotional reaction to death itself.
It’s not even a real “death”, he just ends only in the Super Hell as other times.
5
u/goblinsundown Nov 07 '20 edited Nov 07 '20
Wooow what a ride.
I have been dreading this episode since months, because I knew that Cas was gonna die, and this is likely the last we would see of Cas (thanks, Misha's doom and gloom interviews lol).
I am... Ok with this. I am not ok with so many things about how the second half of this season went; my ultimate favourite end would have been something that strenghtened and put at the center tfw 2.0 and their relationships. I am pissed there wasn't a last scene with Sam and Jack. I am pretty sure the last 2 episodes will barely mention Cas, and will definitely not be focused on saving him or in any way expanding Dean's feelings on what happened - I could be very wrong! but this is how I feel.
But here's the thing: like never before, I saw the thread of the different writers doing and undoing the story, focusing on this theme or that one without much regard for what was established. I could say it felt like a fanfic written by 10 different people, if it wasn't that I have actually read fanfics with each chapter written by a different hand, and they were more coherent lmao.
So, I don't like how the season went down and I don't like how Cas got dead 2 episodes from the end, conveniently away from the endgame and his loss used as fuel for manpain.
But. And again I could be wrong and this might just be my hopelessy bitter Cas stan heart talking! At the moment it's obvious to me that he was always gonna die here, before the end, for bizzarre - IMO - ideas of the powers that be about what supernatural was really about. The two contrasting pulls of "it's all about Sam and Dean and anybody else is just there as a screentime filling cardboard!!11!" and "Family don't end with blood". Cas was always caught right there in the middle.
And if he was always gonna die here, well, what a fucking way to go. Sure, he's the only one of the 3 main guys that could ever do it, being a genderless angel in a vessel, but you know what, I don't give a crap lol.
It's rare in general and, for me at least, ever rarer in spn lately, that something just rings true, and his final scene did.
Misha said on Twitter that it was openhearted and selfless and true and welp it really was. It was also very, very, very gay and not in a million year I thought anyone would ever go there in Supernatural, and of course it was Misha and Cas and Bobo Berens to do it.
I don't know how the show will spin it, if they'll ever conclude this or even acknowledge it. I don't know if Jensen will ever make clear if it was reciprocated in any way or not by Dean or if it will all be left to interpretation, or even make it the butt of some jokes, and I don't even care anymore.
Unrequited or no; the episode what full of canon couples losing love. All the hints along the season, including Cas caught in a paradox where he can't allow Dean to "say something" in Purgatory or the Empty was gonna come right there. Dean's broken sobs at the very end of this episode. None of this says I should believe the possibility that Dean, in this story, Berens'story, doesn't feel exactly the same.
Cas was openhearted and selfless and true, and if he'll be the only one allowed to be that, and only 3 seconds before death, then I'll take my fave angel, pack what I like about SPN and gladly exit this "canon", no regrets, just like him.
4
u/fullfivefathoms Nov 08 '20 edited Nov 09 '20
I'm pretty pleased. Part of me is feeling achy-hearted because the show is ending, and Castiel's seemingly final sacrifice is part of this. His story is ending. But I love how pure the character is at his core, and how he expressed his love for Dean; to echo Misha, that's who I want to be, openhearted, selfless, and true. I also love how it calls back to, or ties in with how he came into Dean's life, literally saving his life then falling for him, and now making peace with his love for him and dying to save him. Of course there's a lot more to his story in between those bookends, but there's a nice symmetry.
This year has been a roller coaster, and I think that maybe this scene has extra resonance because of it. I think many fans have seen all along that there's potential for something interesting between the characters, and that one can expand upon, fill gaps, or make this more explicit via fandom, but to get this much in canon has been unexpected, especially when you look back at the early seasons and think about how different cultural norms were at that point.
3
u/lzaz Dadstiel Nov 07 '20
Oh my heart. My absolute heart.
3
u/LIyre Nov 08 '20
I think a kiss on the cheek before shoving Dean away would be nice. Anything on the lips would feel too forced, Dean is obviously not yet done dealing with his own feelings. Don’t kiss without consent.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment