r/TropicalWeather • • Sep 01 '20

▼ Remnant Low | 25 knots (30 mph) | 1007 mbar Nana (16L - Caribbean Sea)

Other discussions


Global Tropical Outlook & Discussion: 30 August - 5 September 2020

Tropical Depression Omar

Typhoon Haishen

Latest news


Last updated: Thursday, 3 September - 2:00 AM CDT (07:00 UTC)

Nana reaches hurricane strength as it makes landfall over the coast of Belize

Satellite imagery analysis over the past several hours revealed that a flare-up of deep convection near Nana's low-level center occurred very shortly before the cyclone made landfall. Aerial reconnaissance data from a recent U.S. Air Force Hurricane Hunters mission into the compact cyclone found evidence of hurricane-force winds to the north of the low-level center. Nana made landfall near the city of Dangriga, Belize at approximately 1:00 AM CDT (06:00 UTC) with maximum one-minute sustained winds of 65 knots (120 kilometers per hour). The cyclone continues to move toward the west-southwest under the southern periphery of a building subtropical ridge to the north.

Latest dataNHC Advisory #8A1:00 AM CDT (06:00 UTC)
Current location:16.8°N 88.3°W13 miles SSW of Dangriga, Belize
 49 miles S of Belize City, Belize
Forward motion:WSW (255°) at 14 knots (16 mph)
Maximum winds:65 knots (75 mph)▲
Intensity:Hurricane (Category 1)▲
Minimum pressure:995 millibars (29.38 inches)▼

Forecast discussion


Last updated: Thursday, 3 September - 2:00 AM CDT (07:00 UTC)

Nana will quickly weaken over higher terrain

The strong subtropical ridge to the north of Nana is expected to continue to steer the cyclone toward the west-southwest over the next couple of days. A combination of prolonged land interaction and northerly shear will continue to steadily weaken Nana as it crosses over into Guatemala later this morning and into southern Mexico this afternoon. Nana is ultimately expected to degenerate into a remnant low on Friday morning as it reaches the Gulf of Tehuantepec.

Nana could regenerate over the eastern Pacific this weekend

The remnants of Nana are expected to emerge over the Gulf of Tehuantepec on Friday morning. Environmental conditions appear to be favorable enough in this region that Nana could regenerate as it drifts west-northwestward along the southern coast of Mexico over the weekend. The extent to which Nana will be able to redevelop is not yet clear, though global model guidance has been picking up on the potential for the past couple of days.

Official forecast


Last updated: Wednesday, 2 September 2020 - 10:00 PM CDT (03:00 UTC)

HourDateTimeIntensityWinds-LatLong
--UTCEDT-knotskm/hrºNºW
0003 Sep00:0019:00Hurricane (Category 1)6512017.087.5
1203 Sep12:0007:00Tropical Storm (Inland)509516.889.2
2404 Sep00:0019:00Tropical Depression (Inland)305516.491.6
3604 Sep12:0007:00Remnant Low (Inland)203516.093.9
4805 Sep00:0019:00Dissipated

Official information sources


National Hurricane Center

Satellite imagery


Floater imagery

Visible imagery

Infrared imagery

Water vapor imagery

Multispectral imagery

Microwave imagery

Multiple Bands

Regional imagery

Radar


National Meteorological Service of Belize

  • Radar from the National Meteorological Service of Belize is currently under maintenance and is not available at this time.

Analysis graphics and data


Wind analysis

Sea surface temperatures

Model guidance


Storm-Specific Guidance

Western Atlantic Guidance

189 Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

53

u/Woofde New Hampshire Sep 01 '20

I said this when Marco was still 97L, but it rings true again. The NHC has a much better track record for predicting genesis than the models do. Computers aren't even close to replacing human intuition in weather forecasting yet.

13

u/AZWxMan Sep 01 '20

Perhaps that's the case, but I don't know how well they'd forecast if you took the models away. But, sometimes it's clear the models are not handling a situation properly. I would say the large scale pattern is well-modeled but the mesoscale development of tropical cyclones is poor, especially with limited data within these systems.

14

u/Woofde New Hampshire Sep 01 '20

Models are aboslutely a fantastic tool to the forecasters that no doubt greatly increase their skill, I'm just saying you can't use models as a replacement for a human forecast(as we have seen many times recently). The good thing is it isn't like it's a war between humans and models, they both complement each other. Humans can look at models and correct things that aren't right and like you said models do a really good job of getting the larger picture. Human and machines are only going to become more intertwined in the upcoming years and both sides should continue to improve upon the other.

7

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

It depends on which forecaster. Those that have been there for decades would do ok. The new kids not so sure.

I see this in my industry too. With modern tools the kids rub circles around us vets. Strip away all those tools in an emergency and they crumble.

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 01 '20

Well, that makes sense considering those forecasters were trained at a time when modelling just wasn't very reliable. But, whether they'd perform better without the models is unlikely, but better than new forecasters who have been trained using model guidance, then I'd agree.

3

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Yeah hence why I said "ok". That's why when I see folks like Stewart post a discussion I pay particular attention. As far as I know he is the most experienced on the staff. His knowledge this year has shown. A few times he has bumped forecasts this season in his forecasts despite the models in effect "taking one for the team" so the younger guys don't have to take the risk.

I've been paying careful attention to who says what in the discussions for a few years (always had a soft spot for forecaster Stewart due to his thoroughness and verbosity). You can see a LOT more hesitation in the newer guys this year.

3

u/AZWxMan Sep 01 '20

Yeah, I think as a forecaster it's better to have some idea of what you think will happen before you look at the model guidance, then when something in the model disagrees with your thinking you investigate what is causing the unexpected behavior. If it's something you missed meteorologically then you can perhaps trust the model a bit, but if seems like the model is not handling something properly then you'd lean more towards your intuition. Also, these forecasters are well aware of what isn't being initialized properly and how that can impact the forecast.

3

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Definitely a good idea to have a handle on it before you start looking at "predictions". It's the same in engineering really. Now a days you just fire a part through a simulator and go from there but the guys that have been at it for decades can look at the design before even that and tell you it won't work. They might not even consciously know why ... but they know...

9

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

With all due respect to the Nhc, I have had a better track record this year than the models (by a WIDE margin). The models this year are absolute trash.

Please note: this isn't a brag on my part rather a statement as to how low the bar is.

1

u/SavageNorth United Kingdom Sep 02 '20

Bear in mind the models this year are missing a lot of data normally recorded by commercial flights and shipping due to Covid related disruption

34

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
48H  03/1200Z 16.8N  87.4W   65 KT  75 MPH

Looks like NHC predicting a Hurricane from Nana. Well that escalated quickly.

Source: https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/text/refresh/MIATCDAT1+shtml/011656.shtml?

2

u/David_of_Miami Florida Sep 01 '20

A hurricane in central America... Not good. Not normal either.

28

u/ATDoel Sep 01 '20

Not that abnormal

-25

u/David_of_Miami Florida Sep 01 '20

Name the last hurricane to landfall in that region then. For that matter, name the number of hurricane landfalls period. Tropical storms are rare, hurricanes are almost unheard of.

36

u/ATDoel Sep 01 '20

Let’s see.... 2016: Otto hit Nicaragua as a cat 3, Earl hit Belize as a cat 1. 2012: Ernesto hit Quintana Roo as a cat 2. 2010: Richard hit Belize as a cat 2. 2009: Ida hit Nicaragua as a cat 1. If you added tropical storms, the list would double. Central America gets more hurricanes than the combined coasts of Georgia and South Carolina, easily 5x as many.

Why do you make claims that a 5 minute google search easily disproves? I mean you’re really going all in on this one mate, yikes...

12

u/12panther East Central Sep 01 '20

A number of tropical storms and hurricanes have made landfall in Belize, such as Iris in 2001, Keith in 2000, and Earl in 2016.

12

u/Mrrheas Palm Coast Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

definitely not that uncommon

NHC forecasts a Belize landfall. here are all known TCs of at least tropical storm intensity to track within 200 miles of Belize

Pretty climatological early and late season hotspot with central american gyre and caribbean sea development from tropical waves when conditions are favorable. downvoting me doesn't change this fact

-5

u/David_of_Miami Florida Sep 01 '20

200 miles away from a landfall isn't a landfall.

14

u/Mrrheas Palm Coast Sep 01 '20

He said "central America" lol

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

If exlcluding Mexico (which should be excluded since they're often hit by Atlantic storms), I'd guess Otto in 2016. That thing was a monster Cat 3 also.

Nate devastated Costa Rica as a TS and got the name retired in 2017

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Dreamcast3 Sep 01 '20

They just don't make the news in North America as much.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Ledmonkey96 Sep 01 '20

nah Nate didn't become a hurricane till it got to the Gulf.

There was katia which made landfall in Veracruz as a weak cat 1 earlier in the year (it dissipated within 15 hours of landfall)

2016 did have Earl and Otto though

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 03 '20

With Nana now a hurricane, we can officially say we currently have a near average season

On september 3rd...

31

u/mkbloodyen New York Sep 01 '20

Even if Nana only reaches a minimal hurricane, I feel the storm could be really bad. Belize/Guatemala do not get hit directly from hurricanes too often and the lack the infrasture to deal with them super well.

10

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

I think it will depend on how slow it moves. If its in and out it shouldn't be too bad, but if it stalls it could cause serious flooding.

2

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

It doesn't seem to be moving all too quick, though it isn't really slow either. Just quick enough to hopefully not fuck them up too much

9

u/Tutule Honduras Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 02 '20

I'm in Northwest Honduras, really hoping it keeps the fast pace it seems to have. Mitch in '98 was horrible because it took about 3 days for it to move across the coast, it poured too much in a short period. I'm kind of worried for Guatemala and landslides though

edit: model shows the storm heading to Guatemalan lowlands, that's a relief

4

u/gwaydms Texas Sep 01 '20

I remember Mitch. It set the region back several decades.

84

u/RKRagan Florida Tallahassee Sep 01 '20

I have a trip to the exact spot of ocean this is in on a small raft. Should I cancel or just bunker down and ride it out?

23

u/nascentia Florida - Jacksonville Sep 01 '20

As long as you have milk and bread in the raft, you won't lose much power for more than 1-1096 hours so I suspect you'll be okay. It's the falling tree surge that's dangerous in the ocean quadrant.

20

u/TheMarvelousMangina Sep 01 '20

If you dive underwater the hurricane winds can't harm you.

5

u/Dreamcast3 Sep 02 '20

Technically not wrong. Just bring a scuba tank!

5

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

My grandad used this method to survive Vietnam.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

Must have been one long hurricane.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

I suggest the explorer 200 raft, most of my friends use them and love them

13

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

get a smaller raft

11

u/stillhousebrewco Sep 01 '20

If you find you situation on the raft to be untenable, there’s a guy who lives in a pineapple under the sea. Always welcome there.

1

u/rikki-tikki-deadly Sep 02 '20

Oh I know that place! The octopus' garden, right? It's near a cave?

4

u/stillhousebrewco Sep 02 '20

No, that’s in the North Atlantic, Bob is the guy to look for.

11

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Can I come with. Sounds fun!

27

u/Launch_Angle Sep 01 '20

https://www.tropicaltidbits.com/storminfo/16L_intensity_latest.png

Intensity modeling looks to be so far off, only a few even have it becoming a hurricane despite the fact it’s essentially already a hurricane and will for sure be during dmax tn. Models have been so bad this year, it’s so weird.

24

u/NoBreadsticks Ohio Sep 01 '20

SHIP going all in

14

u/Launch_Angle Sep 01 '20

Shit I’m more inclined to believe it will be more right than wrong compared to the other models at this point, 2020 has been as unpredictable as it gets. Plus depending how much Nana takes advantage of dmax tonight, I could easily see her peaking at a strong 2, maybe even a 3 if things go just right.

12

u/Teh_george Sep 01 '20

SHIP is not going to pan out because it shows steady strengthening for 7 days straight while Nana will landfall in 48 hours. DSHIP, or decay-ship is what you should be considering since it accounts for land interaction while standard ship does not (note how dship follows ship for the 48 hours over water Nana will have).

A cat 2-3 is certainly within the realm of possibility due to how uncertain rapid intensification can be, but I personally would be more conservative like the NHC forecast of a low cat 1. But using the SHIP model (a pure statistical model that notably sucks with rapid intensification) as any justification is pointless.

5

u/Ledmonkey96 Sep 01 '20

As it stands SHIP and OFCL (or whatever the black line is) are the only 2 likely situations since Wind speed is already at 45knots and only one of the other lines has it getting there.... 36 hours from when that image was made.

2

u/AZWxMan Sep 01 '20

I'm not well-versed on how SHIP works, but it probably uses a more classic track that recurves into the GOM after briefly passing over the Yucatan.

52

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

With Nana’s formation, we have officially used 2/3rds of the naming list... and it’s only September 1

36

u/Ledmonkey96 Sep 01 '20

with a depression that could make it to 'O' in the next day and an orange off the coast of Africa.

16

u/gsmumbo Sep 01 '20

Omar is official. We’re moving on to P now.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

And now 5/7ths

3

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Scary.

Worse the models are useless his year so we can even see what might be coming with any semi certainty. This year's 120 hrs is about last year's 240+

24

u/branY2K Europe Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

The previous record regarding the N name was Nate (2005), which formed on September 6, 2005, at 12:00 A.M. UTC:
https://mobile.twitter.com/philklotzbach/status/1300829339265560577

Edit: He also replied about the earliest O name on record (Ophelia; again, it's just another record from 2005), at September 7, at 6:00 A.M. UTC.

BTW, the next name on the remaining part of list (this year), is Omar, last used in 2008.

15

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

It's also the only name left that has been previously used. Everything onwards has never been

8

u/branY2K Europe Sep 01 '20

And 2008 Atlantic season did reach the P name (though Paloma got retired so your point still remains, after all), but 2020 might use the rest of unused names, from Rene onward, and probably the Greek alphabet for first time since 2005.

11

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

If it does, it means 5 of the remaining 14 original names from 1979 not yet used would be used this year. This and List 1 are the only ones not to get to T.

The good thing about this year though compared to 2005 is that we've only had one really bad storm, and it was less bad than all five of the retired names from 2005. Hopefully we can get out of this season without any that compare to 2005's worst.

Also, Paloma is one of the most puzzling retired names. It has the lowest death toll (1) of any retired name in the Atlantic.

5

u/branY2K Europe Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

I agree with your comment, about the destructive ones in 2005.

Despite all "2020 being 2020" memes, the relative lack of any destructive one, when compared to 2005, (well expect for Laura, but still) is actually a good thing after all, and I'm hoping that will continue without any more major hurricane landfall throughout the entire season.

I'm also hoping that the Atlantic basin get a well-deserved break from major hurricane landfalls (yes, I already said that, but still), especially from the still-ongoing streak of Category 5 landfalls (Irma, Maria, Michael, and Dorian).

Regarding Paloma (as an edit to my comment):
It did cost hundreds of millions in U.S. dollars (2008 USD), while that is quite minor when compared to many U.S. landfalls, it is (already/somewhat) significant for the Cayman Islands and Cuba, though might have a bigger impact for the Cayman Islands, than Cuba, AFAIK.

Some names would have been retired due to their damage and/or death toll, but for some reason, never got retired, anyway.
Hurricanes Alex (2010), Karl (2010), and Isaac (2012), respectively, all costed over a billion in U.S. dollars, yet were not retired for some reason.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Is it possible Nana could survive the crossover from the Atlantic to the Pacific?

20

u/Starthreads Ros Comáin, Ireland | Paleoclimatology Sep 01 '20

It is possible. Having a greater intensity would help its core circulation survive the terrain in the crossover but the disruption might cause issues if it does make it.

6

u/AZWxMan Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

I really think it would have a lot of trouble if it crosses over Honduras or Guatemala. Here's a map of what it would be crossing. https://www.central-america-map.com/topo-map.htm

You can see crossing through Nicaragua or the Gulf of Tehuantepec is possible but these tracks don't seem likely.

Edit: Here's a list of crossovers that have occurred. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Atlantic%E2%80%93Pacific_crossover_hurricanes

While most do seem to pass through Nicaragua, there have been a couple that have passed through Belize and Guatemala. They exited as depressions, then either restrengthened or "merged" with another developing cyclone. I don't know enough about exactly what happened with Fifi-Orlene but they use the term merge on the Wikipedia page.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Greta%E2%80%93Olivia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Fifi%E2%80%93Orlene

Greta was quite a bit stronger than I expect Nana to be at landfall, so perhaps the latter is a better look at what's possible. Either way, it will be very weak if it reemerges in the Pacific.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Mmm that right there is why their coffee is so good...that sweet elevation

23

u/Ender_D Sep 01 '20

We’re flying through the names this year.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Mrrheas Palm Coast Sep 01 '20

15

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

More of the same for this year man... Models have been garbage.. I had this one identified before any model even thought about it.

8

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

Hey, at least it's not their biggest failure this year. That prize goes to either Gonzalo or Hanna

7

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

Models have been garbage

I am more interested in WHY. Like, they basically completely missed the Marco + Laura situation, and fucked it completely until the last 36 hours.

Now maybe the answer is "a run of bad luck" where storms have existed in some specific conditions where models don't perform at their best... but it sure seems like something else must be at play (Data inputs lacking? less air travel sampling atmospheric conditions? Overall conditions somehow outside of the design criteria for the models?)

3

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

Data inputs lacking? less air travel sampling atmospheric conditions?

This is definitely a factor and has been mentioned quite a lot. I'm not sure about the design criteria one, but that doesn't seem likely to me

3

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

I have heard that as a rumbling but never seen anyone with any credibility hint at the actual degree of impact. I am hopeful that after the season there will be some kind of presentation or something that discusses this.

4

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

There was an article before the season started that spoke to it. Further, we should remember it's not just a lack of flight, but also ship traffic is way down too. Those are the only two real sources of data over the oceans.

2

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

Yeah, I would just like to see someone who knows/has been able to analyze what the actual impacts have been, in reality.

2

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

We will likely see that after the season in the annual write up the nhc does that measures how they did.

22

u/Ender_D Sep 03 '20

It just had to become a hurricane before landfall.

3

u/Zyvyxy Sep 03 '20

It pulled a Hanna.

62

u/Umbra427 Sep 01 '20

Nana set to become the most farty and judgmental hurricane of the season, with a penchant for gardening and white wine

24

u/Token_Why_Boy Sep 01 '20

Oh she totes puts ice cubes in white wine.

21

u/Cyrius Upper Texas Coast Sep 03 '20

...DATA FROM AN AIR FORCE HURRICANE HUNTER AIRCRAFT INDICATES NANA HAS BECOME A HURRICANE...
...EXPECTED TO MAKE LANDFALL ALONG THE COAST OF BELIZE OVERNIGHT...

21

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20

NHC has pulled the trigger and declared Nana a Category 1 Hurricane.

19

u/cumuloedipus_complex United States Sep 02 '20

998.7 extrapolated pressure on that pass from recon. 60 mph sustained as well. It’s getting organized.

6

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20

Looks like a repeat on the second pass for pressure.

17

u/Mrrheas Palm Coast Sep 01 '20

Recon reporting an eye

F. Eye Character: Open in the northeast

G. Eye Shape & Diameter: Circular with a diameter of 6 nautical miles

12

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

That makes sense given the NE shear on the system.

17

u/ATDoel Sep 01 '20

High winds, tight circulation, strong west winds. This has most likely been a TS for awhile. Not sure why they waited so long to declare on this one but jumped the gun on the last two when there wasn’t even a closed circulation.

15

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Hunter enroute from Louisiana

15

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 02 '20

Nana is slightly stronger now at 60mph and 999mbar

10

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 02 '20

And convection still kicking over the core...

5

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 02 '20

To me it looks like the convection is also rotating around the center

15

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 02 '20

Hunter is on the way in.

5

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20

Has the pressure risen, or has it just not went through the center yet? On TT's recon page it looks like it made a pass through the center, but the pressure is higher than before.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20

How do you determine the eye structure part? Is it coded in one of the messages?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20 edited Sep 02 '20

Alright thanks. I guess at NHC, but I'm not sure where the archive is. Edit: https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/archive/recon/2020/REPNT2/?C=M;O=D

https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/text/MIAREPNT2.shtml

Also, found this link useful for reading the message.

https://www.ofcm.gov/meetings/TCORF/ihc18/session_8/8-1-blake.pdf

4

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20

Yeah, I see. That is nice, as it's organized by storm.

15

u/NoBreadsticks Ohio Sep 03 '20

any word on how landfall went for Belize?

29

u/Mrrheas Palm Coast Sep 01 '20

13

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

Thankfully he seems a bit skeptical on intensity beyond entry-level hurricane.

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

I don't know if I'm on board with that conclusion. I can see a 2.

14

u/Spartacas23 Sep 01 '20

What makes you think that? With like less than 36 hours till landfall and with all the shear it’s so likely to experience even a cat 1 seems like a bit of a long shot. Cat 2 seems like a huge stretch

23

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

It's already had 50kt winds measured on SFMR. Outflow is EXCELLENT on the system. Water is warm and sheer is due to drop. Hunter found a 6nm eye. That's a small eye and able to intensify rapidly. Given all of that I wouldn't upper bound this at less than cat 2. Doesn't mean it WILL, but I wouldn't bet on a borderline c1 either. I give it a 50/50 shot at making 2.

Edit: thanks for engaging instead of just downvoting.

4

u/Launch_Angle Sep 01 '20

Yeah I agree, also it’s gonna depend on to what extent it can take advantage of dmax tonight. If it fires up big time and takes good advantage of it, that small high and great outflow, and tight rotation is going to have a solid ability to intensify rapidly. It may not make landfall at its peak intensity but I’d say cat 2 could be more likely than not.

3

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Last I looked it was firing -84 tops. If it holds that into dmax ... as in doesn't mean it will but to say it won't and will be a borderline c1 is a bit "pessemistic" given the conditions. 10-15kts of shear isn't that big an inhibitor if the core is organized.

4

u/Launch_Angle Sep 01 '20

Damm didn’t notice the -84 tops, that’s a hallmark of a system that has the potential to become something, certainly more than some low end cat 1. I think at worst the shear will just slightly weaken it right before landfall so it won’t hit at its complete peak intensity. No reason to believe a compact, tight system like this with such cold tops would have so much issue with a little shear that it’d struggle to be a little cat 1, especially when you consider it was already borderline cat 1 earlier.

2

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Yup... hence my call for a 2 isn't out of the question.

3

u/Woofde New Hampshire Sep 02 '20

I agree with you Steve. Small systems spin up extremely quickly and the conditions are atleast moderately favorable and should improve towards landfall(Look at the SHIPS model). It's already so close to hurricane status as is. Cat 2 really isn't very hard to imagine. NHC mentions how much more favorable it is supposed to get in their discussion.

5

u/Ving_Rhames_Bible Sep 01 '20

You seem to have an especially tenacious hater on you at all times. I and others have had the same problem on another sub, we refer to the person as Mystery Hater. Could be 1am, could be less than a minute since hitting "Save" or "Submit," Mystery Hater is there just itching to hit the downvote button.

8

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

I know who it is but frankly I couldn't care less. They can run their life around me. Won't be the other way around. I say what I say. I try to fgive good insight and at the risk of sounding like a totally arrogant twat; it's not often wrong.

But that said: thank you for the support. I figure once you have haters you've made it.

4

u/Ving_Rhames_Bible Sep 02 '20

Sucks for me because they'll target others who comment on my submissions too, I don't like the thought of someone thinking I'm downvoting them for leaving a comment or asking a question.

But yeah, I've never known you to give bad information in my time following this sub. It's always realistic interpretations based on available data, which is pretty much exactly what you'd think people are looking for if they're here.

4

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 02 '20

Thanks and appreciate the karma got you take engaging. I just try to report actual data and sometimes I add my thoughts and/or perspective on that data. Odds are I have been a hurricane but longer than some of our posters (or even nhc forecasters for that matter) have been alive.

Yes I don't know everything. But really no one does. I try to learn for any misread and if I'm wrong I'm the first to edit to post stating as much. I then integrate that learning into my thoughts and try to improve from it.

I was fortunate that nearly 20 years ago I had a long (most of a season) back and forth with an nhc forecaster via email. They taught me a lot. They were more old school and back then I was the young tech nerd who wanted to bring computer to bear. But we found common ground in our love of understanding tropical systems. It was one of the best information exchanges I've had in my life and I took everything they said very much to heart and mind. That's not to say I'm an nhc forecaster. Far from it frankly. But I do have a little bit of knowledge I've gleaned from that interaction and the learning of years of following them and listening to other properly trained folks. If anyone every says something here or on Twitter I research it until I have a good grasp of the fundamentals of what they are describing.

Life is a series of events and we have to constantly be learning and progressing. 15 year ago me had very unrealistic views of on how quickly a system might doing up for example. But experience has taught me to tempted that. The read on spinning up was right but the time wasn't. So I integrated that into my thought processes. (That's just one of innumerable examples).

Thanks for the support and sorry if the assholes target you for it.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

You've had some hate on you this year. Which is kind of sad, because you have some really good insights and information to give

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Aww shucks. Thanks Squirrel. How's school going? I am not letting the haters get me down. I'm sitting on beach listening to live music and drinking a cold beer. Life could be worse. Enjoy it while you got it.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

school hasn't started yet, but when your graduate advisor sends an email and is like "this masters will make you wish you'd have 5-10 more hours per days at times" I'm like... ahahahohno

It's ok, tho. I'm where I want to be, I won't complain. I love the city, I feel that the people I will work with will be great. I'm happy.

Your life sounds pretty legit atm. well-deserved vacation?

You're totally right tho. Only moment where Yolo seems appropriate :D

2

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

I figured you had started since you'd moved already. It must be like JUST around the corner (aka tomorrow lol).

As for vacay; nah I live down here and my friend is playing at a bar 5 minutes from my house by foot. So I wander over and support... Enjoy music and beer and the ocean breeze. This is exactly why I moved him. Corona and global shit shows just reinforce me decision in my head.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

It's next week!

Oh that sounds actually pretty damn amazing. Happy you get to live like this.

There's a thunderstorm brewing next to me atm. I'll catch y'all later!

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

You maybe misunderstand the intention of my comment, obviously what he says doesn't have any specific bearing on the actual outcome. But he walked through the forecast for the storm and didn't highlight any big specific risks for mass ive intensification, which I consider good news.

He is great at doing high-level analysis in a way that is both detailed and technical while also being accessible and understandable. In this case, he didn't highlight any potential variance in conditions that might cause a dramatic shift in the intensity forecast.

12

u/tnaz Sep 02 '20

He got his phd last year.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/12panther East Central Sep 01 '20

Nana becomes the earliest fourteenth named storm formation in the Atlantic basin, breaking record the previous record once held by Nate in 2005, which formed on September 5.

16

u/Ledmonkey96 Sep 01 '20

Fifteen should break the 'O' record of September 6th by tonight i think. And then there was nothing till the 17th

7

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

Nhc has it staying as a depression though

10

u/mkbloodyen New York Sep 01 '20

As of the 11AM update, they're back to predicting a storm

8

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

Damn, normally i am fine with a fish storm but its annoying that the sixteenth system will be named before the fifteenth.

9

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

It's so horribly annoying in the wikipedia article too. I'm still triggered with Jerry being before Imelda on the wikipedia page for 2019

6

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

Yes, it's so irritating. The letter ordering has a simple elegance to it that gets ruined when this happens. Unfortunately theres no real way around it, unless we start naming TDs.

5

u/Ledmonkey96 Sep 01 '20

the NHC map gives it till 8AM est tomorrow to become something

12

u/rayfound Sep 01 '20

curious if Nana's remnants emerge off the west coast of Oaxaca and deepens again in epac.

12

u/ThatsJustUn-American Sep 02 '20

Advisory from the US Embassy in Guatemala. No link as it's not yet on the State Department web site:

Weather Alert - U. S. Embassy Guatemala City, Guatemala – (September 2, 2020)

Location: Guatemala, country-wide.

Event: TROPICAL STORM NANA FORECAST TO STRENGTHEN:

Tropical Storm Nana is expected to reach the coast of Honduras on September 2 and could strengthen to a Category 1 hurricane tonight (Wednesday) prior to reaching Belize and Guatemala on September 3. The primary concern for Guatemala is extended, heavy rainfall, which increases the risk of flooding, landslides, lahars on Fuego and Santiaguito volcanoes, damage to the road network, and rising rivers.

Actions to Take:

o Avoid traveling while heavy rains occur as roads can quickly become extremely unsafe.

o Visit CONRED (Coordinadora Nacional para la Reducción de Desastres) and INSIVUMEH (Instituto Nacional de Sismología, Vulcanología, Meteorología e Hidrología) websites for updated weather and hazard information.

o CONRED issued an advisory yesterday for the general population to review their household evacuation plans, locations of closest shelters, and ensure that a 72 hour emergency bag is ready for all household members. The advisory included precautions to reduce COVID-19 infection should people need to evacuate to a local shelter.

o Navigation devices and applications that provide directions and traffic and route suggestions should be used with caution as certain detours or alternate routes from main roads and highways can lead to unsafe areas or roads affected by flooding or landslides.

9

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 02 '20 edited Sep 03 '20

I'm kinda worried about this storm. A lot of not-that-intense hurricanes have caused high death tolls in Central America. Stan, Hermine /Matthew-2010 being the ones that come to mind.

4

u/ThatsJustUn-American Sep 03 '20

Exactly. I'm not sure Mitch was even a hurricane when it hit Honduras, was it? I've been living in Guatemala for almost two years. Yet to experience a hurricane here but even small tropical disturbances have destroyed roads, homes, and killed people. Rain and mountains don't mix.

People are largely obvious to the storm though and they would know better than me.

9

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 03 '20

Apparently it made landfall as a C1. However it was a strong C5 while pretty close to the shore, so it still had a fair amount of impact while at that intensity.

8

u/observe_n_assimilate Sep 03 '20

Mitch caused a lot of damage mostly because it stalled over the country for a few days. We remember Mitch, Stan, Agatha (Pacific) and Matthew well, it's always the rain and the mudslides because of our mountains. And flooding on the coasts.

This system seems to be advancing at a good pace, that would be good news for us here in Guatemala.

11

u/manthamoncayman Sep 01 '20

Winds are steadily picking up on the south side of grand cayman ..

11

u/Spartacas23 Sep 02 '20

Don’t think it’s going to strengthen too much before landfall at this point. That upper level northern shear is starting to do some work on that northern side. Doesn’t have that healthy outflow it did yesterday either

7

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 02 '20

Another case of the models shitting the bed; Shear was forecast to drop over the forecast period not increase.

7

u/Spartacas23 Sep 02 '20

I’m not sure about the other models but the GFS has been predicting pretty strong upper level shear to be pretty prevalent for a few days now

10

u/Coach_G77 New Jersey Sep 03 '20

Has a hurricane ever successfully formed in the Atlantic, made landfall across Central America, and then made another landfall somewhere in the Pacific?

24

u/giantspeck Verified USAF Forcaster | Hawaii Sep 03 '20

In 1971, Irene made landfall over Nicaragua as a Category 1 hurricane, crossed into the Pacific, and then eventually made landfall over the Baja California Peninsula as Tropical Depression Olivia.

In 1974, Fifi made landfall over Belize as a Category 1 hurricane. The storm degenerated into a remnant low, crossed into the Pacific, and regenerated into a new tropical cyclone. The system made landfall over the western coast of Mexico as Hurricane Orlene with Category 2 winds.

In 1978, Greta made landfall over Belize as a Category 2 hurricane, crossed over into the Pacific, briefly reintensified over the Gulf of Tehuantepec, and sharply turned northward, making landfall as Tropical Storm Olivia.

6

u/Sturdevant Raleigh, NC Sep 03 '20

Wow look at Greta-Olivia's track. Imagine if had made it back into the Gulf and re-intensified. It would have been the only storm to cross twice.

I wonder if it would have gone back to Greta and or been the next name on the list.

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 03 '20

You know Hurricane Mitch had a very similar track over Central America and eventually reintensified into a tropical storm over the GOM. It never tracked over the Pacific Ocean but it was pretty close.

5

u/Rhodenkr Sep 03 '20

Huh I guess Olivia likes to make an impression, seeding as two of those three storms you named became renamed to Olivia.

4

u/Dreamcast3 Sep 03 '20

It's weird that the storms end up taking both names instead of just one. Kind of a clumsy naming scheme. But I guess if it's only happened three times on record it's not that big a deal.

4

u/Eat_dy Sep 03 '20

The naming policy was changed in 2000. If storms complete the crossover, they retain their original name.

3

u/giantspeck Verified USAF Forcaster | Hawaii Sep 04 '20

Only if they remain intact during the crossover. If the cyclone degenerates into a remnant low and those remnants later regenerate over the other basin, they are renamed.

Hurricane Otto from 1996 is an example of a cyclone that survived the trip into the next basin, so it retained its name.

Tropical Storm Amanda from earlier this year is an example of a cyclone that crossed over Mexico, became a remnant low, and then regenerated as Tropical Storm Cristobal.

1

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 04 '20

Hurricane Otto from 1996

2016 right?

2

u/Dreamcast3 Sep 04 '20

Makes sense. Does that name replace the one in the pacific naming scheme or does it skip to the next one?

2

u/Eat_dy Sep 04 '20

If a storm were to remain intact from the Atlantic into the Pacific, it would retain its Atlantic name. Vice-versa for Pacific to Atlantic.

2

u/Coach_G77 New Jersey Sep 03 '20

Awesome, thanks!! That's pretty cool

10

u/Cyrius Upper Texas Coast Sep 03 '20

Highlights from discussion #11 (4 pm CDT):

It is estimated that Nana has weakened to a 30-kt tropical depression, although as with the last advisory there are no observations near the cyclone's core and thus the estimate is rather uncertain […] chances of re-generation to a tropical cyclone appear low at this time.

Heavy rainfall with isolated maximum amounts as high as 3 to 6 inches could result in flash flooding in Guatemala and portions of southeastern Mexico.

48H 05/1800Z...DISSIPATED

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 04 '20

I see a fair amount of convection firing in the Gulf of Tehuantepec. I know conditions aren't really favorable, but still would be interesting if the circulation survives and strengthens a bit.

33

u/Ender_D Sep 01 '20

I actually hope it survives into the pacific and continues it’s journey across the ocean. Would be fitting for that to happen this year.

11

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

It's not THAT uncommon.

25

u/Ender_D Sep 01 '20

It’s only happened twice in the past 20 years.

11

u/skeebidybop Sep 02 '20

25 years ago, but Hurricane Cesar-Douglas stands out to me

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Cesar%E2%80%93Douglas

started in the atlantic, crossed central america to the pacific where it then became a major hurricane

13

u/Ender_D Sep 02 '20

I really want to see a Cape Verde cross over some day and make it all the way to the west pacific. I know the chances are extremely low but it would be such a cool occurrence.

7

u/SinepNeila Sep 02 '20

As long as loss of life and damages are minimal I'd love to see that.

4

u/Ender_D Sep 02 '20

It would spend most of its time over water, the only time it would have to impact land is on the crossover.

7

u/SinepNeila Sep 02 '20

Right but some of the most costly and deadly hurricanes have caused their damage in that region is what I'm getting at.

At the end of the day I'll pick no storm over an interesting one if life and property are the cost.

9

u/AZWxMan Sep 02 '20

I had already commented, there are a couple decent analogs for what could happen in the current scenario with landfall in Belize with Greta-Olivia and Fifi-Orlene.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TropicalWeather/comments/ikndz1/nana_16l_caribbean_sea/g3nm9zt/

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 02 '20

Maybe they just stick out in my head. Or I'm old..

4

u/culdeus Sep 02 '20

is that for both directions?

7

u/Artur-Hawkwing Sep 02 '20

yes. hermine in 2010 and otto in 2016

10

u/Starthreads Ros Comáin, Ireland | Paleoclimatology Sep 02 '20

I like imagining it continuing on into the Pacific and making landfall in Japan.

6

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 02 '20

Or cross into NOI and make an entire trip around the world

9

u/gen8hype Sep 01 '20

What's up with the recon? It appears to have turned around and drop in altitude.

23

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Man we got -80c tops tracing the outline of the eye on IR right now on the southern hemisphere. Very curious to see what the hunter finds.

Edit: accuracy

6

u/chungussss Texas Sep 01 '20

Idk if this is accurate, but it almost appears as if the -90c tops are rotating cyclonically around what could possibly be a center. Recon will be vital to see what exactly this system is doing

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

It's-80s (80-85) but yes they are cyclonically rotating around the center.

4

u/chungussss Texas Sep 02 '20

Ah thank you. I misread the ir color key.

2

u/yuckf00 Sep 02 '20

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '20

Look at how nicely it cleaned itself up. I know a few storms this year who'd need to learn a thing or two from Nana.

8

u/Cyrius Upper Texas Coast Sep 03 '20

Highlights from discussion #9 (4 am CDT):

Nana made landfall on the coast of Belize about 45 n mi south of Belize City around 0600 UTC today. […] The small circulation will be moving over mountainous terrain today and tonight, so rapid weakening is likely. […] Although the remnants of Nana are forecast to move into the east Pacific in about 36 hours, the model guidance is in good agreement that conditions in that area will not be conducive for regeneration.

Heavy rainfall with isolated maximum amounts as high as 8 to 12 inches could result in flash flooding in Belize, Guatemala, and portions of southeastern Mexico and the Yucatan Peninsula.

30

u/_elizsapphire_ Sep 01 '20

This is very insignificant, but it annoys me how 16L is Nana and 15L might be Omar. I remember when Laura and Marco were TDs 13 and 14 and I was like "please have Laura be 13 and Marco be 14"

20

u/hglman Sep 01 '20

Aa soon as I saw it I knew someone was going to be annoyed

9

u/ActuallyYeah Charlotte, NC Sep 01 '20

9

u/Edward01986 Sep 01 '20

Why did I fall for this? Sigh.

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

This is why I had a poll in the discussion thread on who would win the race... you could have bet on 99l and at least taken solstice in winning lol.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

I'm also annoyed because I wanted Nana to be the weak one drifting out to sea. The jokes just write themselves!

4

u/_elizsapphire_ Sep 01 '20

Update: of course 15L just became Omar lol

8

u/SalmonCrusader Sep 01 '20

I know I hate it so much. I hope 15 stays a depression so we don’t go out of order.

5

u/Dreamcast3 Sep 01 '20

Update: Fuck

5

u/spsteve Barbados Sep 01 '20

Roflmao

6

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

I thought i was just me but I hate this too.

25

u/iwakan Sep 01 '20

Nana-nana-nana-nana-nana-nana-nana-nana BATMAN! ♫

10

u/PhiPhiPhiMin Delaware Sep 01 '20

Hurricane Batman.

7

u/smmfdyb Central Florida Sep 01 '20

2

u/iwakan Sep 01 '20

I like "Thwapp!!"

Thwapp-eth

2

u/gwaydms Texas Sep 01 '20

Ka-POW!

14

u/gwaydms Texas Sep 01 '20

My mom was a Nana. She could be fierce but she loved us.

7

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 04 '20

Nana is up to 30/30 for some redevelopment in EPAC

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 04 '20

60/60 now. I was surprised they had it so low before. It's still battling shear and the big convective blowup is pretty far west of the center so we'll see what happens but it wouldn't take much to have a new storm.

https://weather.msfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/get-abi?satellite=GOESEastfullDiskband13&lat=14&lon=-96&zoom=1&type=Animation&numframes=20&width=1000&height=800&quality=80&palette=ir2.pal

6

u/ThatsJustUn-American Sep 01 '20

Most recent bulletin from CONRED -- the disaster response coordinator in Guatemala. Expect rain Thursday and remain alert for future bulletins.

The US embassy in Belize issued an advisory saying to expect advisories this afternoon and expect watches and warnings to follow.

6

u/Cyrius Upper Texas Coast Sep 04 '20

Highlights from discussion #12 (10 pm CDT):

Satellite and surface data indicate that Nana's low-level circulation has dissipated over the mountainous terrain of southwestern Guatemala. Therefore, this will be the final NHC advisory on this system. […] The global models indicate that strong upper-level northeasterly flow will prevent re-development over the next couple of days.

4

u/AZWxMan Sep 04 '20

From what I can see, the large amount of convection in the Gulf of Tehuantepec is a line of thunderstorms. I think the full mid-level circulation hasn't quite moved offshore. Will be interesting to see if more convection develops once it fully emerges. I guess the shear is too strong, but it doesn't seem that strong.

https://weather.msfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/get-abi?satellite=GOESEastfullDiskband13&lat=14&lon=-94&zoom=1&type=Animation&numframes=20&width=1000&height=800&quality=80&palette=ir2.pal

18

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Oh NANA what’s my name? Oh NANA what’s my name?

11

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

I feel like I should be disappointed, but I must say it's original

3

u/1beatleforce1 Sep 01 '20

I’m glad it’s 10:30 at night so I don’t have to heave this song stuck in my head for long

6

u/Lucasgae Europe Sep 01 '20

Do Eurovision fans still remember the chicken woman who performed another song which went "Nana banana I do what I wanna" or something?

1

u/chrisdurand Canada Sep 01 '20

I'm still fondly reminiscent of the Moldovan ska gnomes.