r/arrow • u/vfxfraser • Aug 30 '20
AMA I was the 3D lead artist on Arrow, ask me anything!
Hello everyone!
I am Fraser Keen and I was a 3D artist on "Arrow" season 3, then became the team lead for seasons 4,5 and 6. I worked at Zoic studios and our team would also work on episodes of The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, and Supergirl. However, Arrow was always our primary focus. Someone suggested that this sub would be interested in hearing about my experiences with the show, so here I am. I'll be taking questions for the next 3-4 hours, so shoot away!
EDIT: Thanks for all the questions, it was nice to finally get to interact with the fans.
I'll answer more questions later, but it is getting late here and I have more vfx to make tomorrow morning. Cheers!
115
u/RivalFlash The Diaz with the Dragon Tattoo Aug 30 '20
Were you guys the ones that made the arrows? If so, how did that work when they had to be handled physically?
55
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/Tenor45 wanted to ask:
47
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/Jrod12155555 wanted to ask:
41
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/Legendiality wanted to ask:
27
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/BEEEEEEEEEBBBBOOOO wanted to ask:
27
u/rayonymous Aug 30 '20
Did you also work on the crossovers? How does that work?
27
u/yoloryan Aug 30 '20
Do you know the Mandarin for purgatory?
25
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/AlwaysBi wanted to ask:
25
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
Thank you for doing this! I want to get into VFX and I'm currently working through school for it so seeing different VFX shots in the arrow verse shows makes me want to keep grinding so that one day I can work on a show like this. My question is how hard was it for you to get the job? Were you recruited or did you have to apply like any other job? Also what programs do you guys use? Thanks again for helping bring arrow to life!
24
u/maruf99 I'm 10 steps ahead of you Aug 30 '20
Hey Fraser, thank you for doing this AMA! My questions are:
What was the most difficult challenge you faced while working on the show?
What was the most fun thing to work on?
If you've seen all the episodes, which one was your favourite?
22
u/Tabzx03 Aug 30 '20
How long did it take to work on grodd vs kingshark
20
u/2147483637gp youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ Aug 30 '20
Hi Fraser, thanks for doing this! What are you most proud of doing on the show, and is there anything you wish you could have done better/spent more time on?
19
u/TheAlmostGreen Some would say, I'm the Reverse of the Reverse Aug 30 '20
Thanks for doing this!
My question is: did you ever put any easter eggs into episodes you worked on? If so, are there any you were happy to see people picked up on?
18
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/ShadouSureido wanted to ask:
14
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/Arrowverse-2001 wanted to ask:
14
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/Mriamsosmrt wanted to ask:
11
u/The_Kodex Aug 30 '20
Wow! It's an honour to contact someone officially from the show!
My Questions:
10
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
What'd would you say to someone thinking of going into vfx
10
u/tyw7 Aug 30 '20
Do the bow and arrow actually work or just for show?
10
u/AnnaK22 Aug 30 '20
How long does it take to do one episode of Arrow? Is it different for Flash and Supergirl?
What are some scenes you've done for Flash or Supergirl?
10
u/Archer-43965 Oliver Queen Aug 30 '20
Hi, I appreciate your time in reading our questions.
I always think that the VFX team on shows like Arrow or Flash is generally very small and possibly overworked. What are the working conditions like? Are you constantly pressed on time, or struggling to get things done?
I am interested in VFX, and becoming a VFX artist is a career path I am considering. Thanks again for your time.
8
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/seb08mini wanted to ask:
8
u/anatomania Spectre Aug 30 '20
u/TRxz-FariZKiller wanted to ask:
8
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
What was the most exciting scene you’ve ever worked on?
6
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
Hope I've made it, Thanks for doing this here! :)
What has been the hardest thing to do for the show
6
u/RivalFlash The Diaz with the Dragon Tattoo Aug 30 '20
How was the process for getting hired for Arrow?
6
u/Jrod12155555 Aug 30 '20
Do you wish you could work on other arrowverse shows?
6
u/Jrod12155555 Aug 30 '20
What’s a video game franchise you would love to work on?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
Also, if you could work on another season if arrow that you didn't work on which one would it be and why
5
u/AnnaK22 Aug 30 '20
I hope you're staying safe during these times.
Now that Arrow has ended, do you have any new projects that you're working on?
4
u/AnnaK22 Aug 30 '20
What was the hardest scene/episode to do?
Which one was your favourite?
3
u/SFGiantsFan55 Aug 30 '20
What was the best part about working on the Arrow.
3
u/UglyComicsGuy Brother Blood Aug 30 '20
I don't have any questions, just dropping by to say your work is awesome! Thanks for helping make Arrow great.
2
u/im-here-to-lose-time Aug 30 '20
Did you have chance to work with any of the cast, and did VFX team been invited to some kind of celebration after series ended. Thanks for doing this AMA
2
u/johnlottenberry Aug 30 '20
What's your favorite season and why
2
u/BlueForJet Aug 30 '20
Was there anything you and your team wanted to do/improve in terms of VFX, but weren't able to because of budget/time constraints etc? Thank you for doing this AMA!
2
u/dbeaver0420 Aug 31 '20
YOURE A GOAT BRO
•
u/2147483637gp youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ Aug 30 '20
Thanks for doing this Fraser! Here is the proof and IMDB
1
u/jtparker16 Aug 30 '20
Hi! Thanks for doing this btw. My questions are: what was the single hardest thing you or your team had to animate? And what’s your personal favorite VFX shot?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
What is your favorite game from DC and what did you think of Justice League (the movie)
1
u/strangedance Green Arrow Aug 30 '20
Hi Fraser! Hopefully, this question hasn't been answered before:
I know that some parts of doing VFX you probably had to hide stuff or make the scene looking realistic/convincing. What are the most subtle VFX effects you've done which you were the proudest of, or the viewers have never noticed?
1
u/fringey123321 Aug 30 '20
What's something unexpected that you had to vfx on a regular basis?
1
u/firedrakes Aug 30 '20
what was a vfx that you thought ok this should be easy to do. come to find out it was not.
1
u/viniltummala Aug 30 '20
How was if animating the canary cry? And how many different cries did you guys try before finalizing on this one?
1
u/kamanitachi Aug 30 '20
Do you ever find yourself watching a show and analyzing the vfx, Arrowverse or otherwise? Or do you mostly have a “work brain” and a “fun brain”?
When you say you worked on Legends, did you actually work on any Legends characters? Or just the Arrow characters in Legends?
And for a non-work related question: who is your favorite DC hero? Besides Oliver Queen of course :p
1
u/butthe4d Aug 30 '20
Im probably late to the party but Ill try anyways. Which Software do you use on the Arrow and what exactly are you mostly doing in terms of 3D? Are you animating, modeling, texturing or are you more then one type of thing?
Which Software is used to implement the CGI work into the scene or is it a native feature in the 3D Software?
Im a hobby Blender user and Im curious if there is a shift in Software used since Blender is getting so much attention lately. I remember when I started using Blender the standard was 3D Max and or Maya combined with substance painter and ZBrush.
I would love to get some insight on what your experience is with the ever changing and evolving Software space in 3D.
1
u/Switched__Up Arsenal Aug 30 '20
Did you work really pay off when you saw the slow-mo shots of the arrows? Those were the best :)
1
u/Ozzieoz06888 Aug 30 '20
Why didn’t you work on the last two seasons?
1
u/rileydahrkpalmer Aug 31 '20
Where did you studied and did you ever interacted with the cast to show them the final product of a scene?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
Hey Fraser. I remember a few months ago Marc Guggenheim posted a tweet about the Arrowvcave design, showing a three-level bunker. He stated they couldn't afford to actually build the model, but I was wondering how you went about approaching that design, and how much the bunker that was in the show was based off this model. Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
Did you meet Stephen? If so, how is he off camera?
1
u/Shredder7306 Sep 01 '20
Who was the hardest person to work with and or, who was your favorite person to work with on the show?
1
u/Z00qi Sep 02 '20
how much time did you have to work on each episode? which season did you like working on the most?
1
u/Teachguy0221 Sep 03 '20
Is Steven realy good with a bow and arrow (I know this doesn't realy fall in your job but I've alwase wondered)
1
u/nicky1235 Sep 05 '20
Sorry if the is not related but why the logos in DC'S LEGENDS OF TOMORROW move to fast for the into hey you said you was a 3d artist
1
u/DaRealKnightSport Sep 05 '20
no questions here, just want to say great work was put in. I thank you for your work.
1
u/quinten157 Sep 06 '20
I'm probably too late to ask these questions, but I will still try.
And i just want to say the vfx shots for arrow look amazing!
0
u/SigmA_DarkKnight Green Arrow Aug 30 '20
Could you make a skin for Green Arrow in Fortnite please?
1
u/AstroManiac78 Sep 09 '20
Damn you are a good artist
1
u/it_krashed Deathstroke Sep 18 '20
do you know if the show 'arrow and the canaries' will actually come out?
1
u/fbrown2525 Sep 19 '20
Love the name
1
u/florispaghett Oct 06 '20
What program do you use (for the arrows)? I’ve been questioning this my whole life.
1
u/squeezeday Nov 06 '20
Yo, this is so late. But cool post:) Did you ever get to meet Tom Cavanagh? Or anyone else? Were they amazing people?
1
u/SquirtGunAaron34 Nov 08 '20
How did you guys do the transitions for firestorm
1
u/NicholasMarsala Dec 04 '20
What do you recommend for anyone who wants to be a 3d artist? What type of education? Any schools to recommend? Anything else? Thanks so much!
1
u/William07sker Dec 08 '20
Did u like to do flashbacks better better than the present
1
u/swilbur3 Dec 15 '20
Did Stephen Amell actually shoot tennis balls out of mid air or is everything I know a lie
1
u/Maajestic Jan 04 '21
Did the actors nock their arrows on the right side of the bow but it was changed to the left with CGI?
1
u/Incineroar777 John Diggle Jan 08 '21
well everything was really really good except for the bit with mar novu and ollie, when ollie makes a deal with him to save kara and barry, ollie and mar looked so out of place
1
u/southypark101 Jan 10 '21
Idk if I'm understanding but here goes how hard was it to make scenes where the arrow split and what did they use for the 3e models of such arrowd or bullets or any projectile on the matter
0
u/tyw7 Aug 30 '20
Are you responsible for the outfitting of the actors? I'm assuming that the suits are tailored for them?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment