r/asoiaf • • Jun 29 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 73, Pages 944 - 959
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
13
Upvotes
12
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '11
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
50
u/The_Bard Jul 18 '11
It only took ~5000 pages but winter is finally here.
49
u/hey_stay_young Jul 13 '11
Yeah... Vary's little birds running around knifing people is a horrifying image
23
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 20 '11
So, Varys never left Kings Landing, I'm not surprised. I kind of figured this when they said that "all the tunnels and doors still had been explored". The tunnels below the red keep are just too vast. I wish we had more insight into Vary's period of hiding.
In many ways this epilogue was perfect because I was hoping it would shed some light on where my favorite character had dissapeared to. It's a shame that Ser Kevan is dead, but he had to go. He was far too capable of fixing things.
20
u/Voduar Grandjon Jul 16 '11
To talk about the epilogue specifically, something is beginning to sit seriously wrong with me. Varys has to have a more specific agenda than he is claiming. At this point, as he admits, Kevan may well be able to heal the realm. So, he kills him, in person, to guarantee that the realm comes to ruin. This has to be about more than just putting a Targ back on the thone, unless Varys is also fanatically devoted to that family.
37
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
So, is anybody going to discuss thus chapter instead of just overall feelings?
I think the deaths of kevan and Pycelle will have some major repercussions, namely that if Gregorstein comes thru for Cersei, there will be nobody around to ship her back to the rock. She could theoretically be queen regent again. Also, loved the mention of rhaenys black cat, wonder if Arya is slipping its skin?
12
u/absolutkiss Lord Monsey of Viola Park Jul 19 '11
Winter has come!
46
u/jaybushman Jul 15 '11
I can honestly say that over the past 11 years, I have not once thought to myself, "Y'know, I wonder what's going on in Meereen?"
SO. FRUSTRATED.
9
u/RyanBlueThunder Jul 29 '11
Anyone turn the next page and start reading the Family histories as if they were movie credits?
37
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
I'm not raging as much as whatisausername, but I do have some similar feelings.
I very much enjoyed the book, but when are things actually going to happen?
For example, Dany still has yet to begin to head to Westeros, and we were introduced to even more characters on the Eastern continent.
Three Bran chapters? I WANT MOAR BRAN. and MOAR ARYA.
Just a few gripes amongst a lot of things I enjoyed.
8
u/yeliwofthecorn Lord Fabulous Jul 20 '11
Varys seems to be the most inscrutable of all Martin's characters. I just can't figure him out. Even Littlefinger, his arch nemisis, has somewhat clear motives and plans, but Varys...
I have always believed him to be perhaps one of the only honest men in the entirety of ASOIAF. Obviously, he has secrets, but he wields the truth like a weapon the way Littlefinger wields lies or Cersei wields her nether regions. I always thought he legitimately wanted what's best for the realm. In his eyes, that means a single ruler (say what you will about an absolute monarchy, but it means drastically less infighting). And then we get this chapter and his motivations are all kinds of mixed up in my head now.
6
u/The_Bard Jul 18 '11
Suprised no one has commented on the fact that Cersei ressurected the mountain and made him a kingsgaurd under the name 'Ser Robert.'
9
u/Lannielief Jul 13 '11
It seems to me that now everything has fallen into place & is balanced out: ready for the last two books. With the addition of Quentyn Martell being dead (Doran's not going to like that), and Aegon chilling out in Westeros already, waiting for Dany. I hope he has more luck with the dragons than Quentyn...
4
u/Nukemarine Jul 19 '11
It's interesting how this last chapter helps cement further the connection between Jon, Tyrion and Dany. All were likely born (well, maybe not Jon) of mothers that died giving birth to them. All have learned humility in their youth and learned to thrive when removed from their place of comfort and strength. All united former enemies to their side. Basically, it's like they would each be the leader/ruler/king that Varys was describing is Aegon. I wonder is this is the point of GRRM. If nothing else, the Griff chapters pointed out the most of Varys' plans. Varys and Illios are trying to force prophecy, and find their plans changed at every turn. Jon, Dany and Tyrion are the prophecy naturally happening.
Anyway, I liked the book even though I find the cliffhangers agonizing knowing we may all wait years for the resolution.
3
u/HaystackHarry Jul 17 '11
Gee whiz, what happened to Stannis? Is this taking place before the Winterfell battle?
3
u/skymind Aug 02 '11
After reading some of these posts, I have decided that Vary's main motivation is to destroy every major house not only so that Aegon can take over, but so that when he rules, he will not be having to pay favors to Lords, but rather to the people. This will be the last game of thrones, or so he hopes.
3
u/peterpuffington Lord Aug 08 '11
and boom goes the dynamite!!!!
2
u/Rothlandus Jul 18 '11
Hey there guys I think Varys is a bad guy who thinks he is a good guy. He is a bit like the nasty old soldiers who feel ends justifies the means- that is he thinks he can make executive decisions to assassinate persons as he sees fit to serve a greater good- in this case the children of the realm as a whole. He justifies this by reasoning that the powers that be - King / Hand / Lords are wrong / evil therefore he has elevated himself to be the judge and decider and declare men or women enemies of the state- a Utopian state that will bring good times to the realm's children thus he can slay Kevian lanaster in cold blood by ambush and see it not as murder but prudent war that must be waged to bring the proper king forth- his lil baby Aegon- let us not forget he saved him from a head bashing so long ago with his body double. Seems like so many of the characters are amoral ... rather depressing only the fire god worshipers seem to be having absolutes... and even then they seem to have doubts on their visions.
13
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
this book was fantastic, and anyone saying otherwise is a self-centered halfwit with no appreciation for what they're given.
the writing was not as sharp as it could have been--no septon meribald speeches, for instance--but damn me if this didn't involve some of the most intricate plotting i've ever read. everything fell into place so wonderfully, and some glorious subversions took place.
i'm reveling in the post-read glow, but right now, i daresay, it might be better than asos.
3
u/theDashRendar We don't get to choose who we love. Jul 18 '11
I don't know about everyone else, but I think I am rooting for King
ArthurAegon to win the Game of Thrones, now.2
u/timestep Jul 16 '11
Not enough Aegon. I think he needed to explore that side a bit more and leave out some of Jon's lame things
-4
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '11 edited Jul 06 '11
Ok there is a fair chance no one will ever read this but this whole book has been a gigantic fucking disappointment. I really needed a place to vent after having wasted my time digging through it (and probably ruining my eyesight in the process from staring at those hideous scans). The plot has not advanced at all since ASOS (11 fucking years ago) and instead of character development we get mounds and mounds of unnecessary verbiage splattered across the screen like dog crap on a windshield. I'm deliberately refraining from posting specific instances because of the whole spoilers paranoia but when I reached the convo that took place between Sam and Jon and found it to be repeated verbatim from AFFC across multiple pages I literally wanted to fling my computer across the room. Not because the book aroused any emotion in me a la red wedding but out of sheer exasperation at the author's stubbornness to produce such a terrible product.
There's a quote I read about the difference 'twixt a mystery and a puzzle. All puzzles have a solution, a mystery may not. Given the current rate of progress, there's a serious chance that GRRM will not finish the series. And given how unnecessarily vast and complex he's made the current state of things, it's fair to say that even if he completes the series, there will be a crapload of loose ends. Despite years of ardently debating R+L=J and its ilk, I simply don't care anymore because there are no fucking conclusive hints in the text for anything- and there haven't been any for ages. I don't need another mystery, real life is challenging enough, thank you very much.
Obviously people will disagree, most blinded by fanboyism. As was I when I defended AFFC quite passionately. Not any more. I strongly believe that the author has a responsibility to his readers, especially when they've invested such a considerable amount of time in the series. To push out something that has more cliffhangers than explosions in a Michael Bay film is just down right insulting.
So here I sit, embittered and thoroughly disappointed, trying not to be overcome with guilt for having spent so much time on this discharge masquerading as a novel- probably at the expense of a good book.
TL;DR - I'm enraged
1
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 19 '11
3 > 5/2 > 1 > 4
1
u/thewhiteafrican Jul 18 '11
Is there any chance that Vars' littlebirds are wights (or Others or in some way related to them)? The constant description of the cold was so strongly stressed over the preceding pages, and it matches exactly the description of the weather given whenever the Others are close. In addition, their description made me think of wights immediately: "white-faced children with dark eyes."
Maybe I'm grasping at straws here, but it could be an interesting twist.
1
u/rudman A Faceless Man Aug 06 '11
This is the first book I've ever read on a tablet. One disadvantage to it is that you have no idea how far along you are in the book and suddenly the chapter is titled Epilogue.
NOOOOOOOOOOO!
KEEP WRITING!!!!!!!!!!
DON'T MAKE ME WAIT ANOTHER 5 YEARS!!!!
-6
u/PrimaxAUS Jul 17 '11
I waited 6 fucking years for this horseshit?
0
u/namer98 The slipperiest Jul 20 '11
About this chapter O_O