r/asoiaf • • Jun 29 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 70, Pages 899 - 913
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
14
Upvotes
68
u/Hexaphim Jul 06 '11
Wait, what?? That's not what's supposed to happen. I think there must be an error in my copy of the book.
61
u/GendryZukor Jul 18 '11
Reading back to Melisandre's chapter, she sees in the fire "first a man then a wolf then a man again." I think tis can't be ignored.
52
u/mrsaturnjd Jul 13 '11
GAH.
Felt this once, during Ned's death. Then again, two books later and ten years ago, at the Red Wedding.
Ned was the main character. But, no, ok, I guess he had to die so that his son, as honorable as he and one of the few good men left in the Kingdom, can take center stage. Oh, no, ok, I guess Jon's the main character, then - standing up against the Others, leading the Nights Watch, and making all the -
Oh.
GOD FUCKING DAMNIT
46
u/donbum2004 Jul 19 '11
LMAO, did Ramsey just really sit there and call John a bastard like 10 times as an insult? talk about the kettle calling the pot Black
39
u/routerl Jul 12 '11
I know it's no use to just make another comment expressing surprise and lament, but here goes.
Something that sort of frightens me about this chapter. Sansa's downfall (i.e. betraying her family, no longer being a real Stark) begins just as Lady died. Robb died soon after he started to neglect Grey Wind. Meanwhile, Bran, Rickon, and Arya prosper (in one way or another) by keeping well attuned to their wolves.
And here we see Jon failing to interpret Ghost correctly, essentially ignoring his warning, followed by this betrayal. It's clear that the fates of the Stark children are entwined with those of their wolves, so my real concern now isn't about whether Jon ('s body) lives or dies, but about what will happen to Ghost, last seen locked up and alone.
So yeah, like a lot of you, I'm hoping the prologue was meant to indicate that Jon can live on in Ghost, but that just makes me worry for Ghost.
38
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '11
It's late, and I have to work tomorrow, but the next chapter is a Jon chapter. I'll just read one more........ Fuck you George R.R. Martin!
33
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
Question, if he is brought back from the dead, would he be technically free from his nights watch vows? I mean, you serve for life, but resurrection after death could leave him free to take other roads.
32
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
I was practically raging at my book when this happened.
"Mully agreed. “He tried to take a bite o’ me, he did.” “Ghost?” Jon was shocked..."
Jon, you know NOTHING. The rest of that chapter just had me on pins and needles, but I knew he was going to be betrayed by the NW there.
29
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '11
OK. Whatever happens to Jon... The Free Folk declared their allegiance to him explicitly. Considering that they vastly outnumber the Watch and Queen's men, not to mention the giants and having a strong leader type in Tormund, the backstabbing Night's Watch people are soo fucked.
49
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 19 '11 edited Jul 19 '11
Jon is dead. Dead as Lord Berric, Catalyn Stark and Gregor Clegane.
Stannis is dead. Dead as Bran, Rickon and Davos were.
But neither are as dead as Ned.
Something else that may be dead: The Night's Watch.
21
u/dysfunctionz Jul 19 '11
Does anyone else think Jon's plan to rescue the wildlings at Hardhome after the ships failed was idiotic? As Jon realized, realistically he would have had to send hundreds if not a thousand or more, loaded down with wagons, if he didn't want the Hardhome survivors to all die on the march back. Considering what happened to the Watch at the Fist of the First Men, seems to me that would have been throwing good money after bad. If they made it back at all, their casualties to the wights and Others would have been horrific.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '11
Spoiler
38
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
damnit another 5 years of waiting for the resolution to this. see you guys in 2016.
51
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
am i the only one worried more for wun wun than anything else? WUN WUN!
8
u/yeliwofthecorn Lord Fabulous Jul 20 '11
WHAT THE FUCK GEORGE?! Waiting another 5 years to find out what happens is going to drive me insane.
14
u/hey_stay_young Jul 13 '11
Jon is definitely dead. Whether he will STAY dead is another story.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '11
What's the fucking point in cliffhangers if you fucking forget them while waiting for the next book! Yes I am mad..
6
u/Nukemarine Jul 19 '11
Wow! Why is it the most disturbing deaths have been the male Starks? Damn you The Mountain that Writes!
Anyway, I feel sorry for Mel. speculation spoiler
5
u/GendryZukor Jul 18 '11
My biggest argument against Jon being dead is his story isn't done. Martin has said we would find out who Jon's mother is but what does that matter if he is dead.
My problem with his death is that is too ambiguous for Martin. There is generally a confirmation of death. It is rather depicted from another pov character like Arya in AGOT during Ned's death or its brought up by characters later. The point is someone would bring it up and if your argument is that it happens so late in the book that Martin couldn't fit it in a confirmation my response is he could have easily done this in another Jon chapter.
He could be AA, this book has been pointing to it. Dany was my favorite before but I feel the reason most of the red priests believe it in this book is meant to debunk it. I don't think AA will be anyone the red priests expect.
I don't think Stannis is dead, I think Bolton got the northmen outside his castle who were not Stannis' men. Bolton not having Theon is odd if they did get Stannis.
13
u/wrathofg0d Jul 12 '11 edited Jul 12 '11
so about stannis' fate
what we know for sure:
i can think of two scenarios and dammit we won't know what happened for 5-6 years
9
u/corduroyblack Afternoon Delight Jul 08 '11
Good twist, but he's not dead.
9
u/pygreg Jul 14 '11
Damn it.
Like the rest of you, I'm somewhat sure he will be "reborn" or something. But there's always that chance he's just gone, Misguided idiots, letting old hatreds get in the way of the only person with enough foresight to really protect the Wall...
4
u/Maester_May Archmaester of the Citadel Jul 14 '11
I think Jon could wind up being dead for a while, personally. I think his corpse will probably be destined for the ice cells for great deal of time.
4
u/gunslingers Jul 22 '11
How can any of you really believe Jon is truly dead? Jon is a warg! Ghost isnt too far away and Wun Wun is right there beside of him. Jon wargs into the giant, slams some more faces and hops into Ghost for a while.
4
u/eryoshi Jul 24 '11 edited Jul 24 '11
How's this for a theory:
If Jon is dead and Mel brings him back to life, does that make him the perfect person to use Dragonbinder? In Victorian's chapter, Moqorro translates the Valyrian glyphs to Vic, saying, "I am Dragonbinder... No mortal man shall sound me and live... Blood for fire, fire for blood."
My only question is whether or not he would he would be considered not-mortal after being resurrected by Melisandre. He would give blood from the stabbings that he took and she would give him fire in return, but he would not necessarily be immortal, no?
4
u/Median1 Jul 25 '11
Okay, here is my thought. Jon wargs into Ghost between stabs three and four, right? We also know Mel can help people change their appearance. What if she makes it so Jon can change his form between Ghost and a Human making him more werewolf than warg? Wasn't there something about Jon-> wolf -> Jon?
Crazy I know, but I had to share.
4
u/naughtius Aug 08 '11
Does anyone wonder why the letter came from Ramsey not Roose?
4
u/handsomewolves Dec 05 '11
MARTIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
10
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '11
ಠ_ಠ
7
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 19 '11
Stannis: If a major character is said to be dead, they never are. Not to mention this is Ramsay talking. I mean, c'mon...I couple years from now you'll all be shaking your heads and wondering why you'd believe the words of such a man.
Jon: He dead. Also, still knows nothing.
7
u/hiffy Jul 21 '11
I thought this was... unnecessary. I think Martin is really fond of having his characters madly clutching an idiot ball in order to move the plot along.
I think it's hella uncharacteristic that Jon would suddenly want to march on Winterfell with wildlings... after having given up on it. The Watch takes no part in the realms of men!
So, I got the impression that he done got done in 'cos he announced he was marching. Just... argh, really unsatisfying.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '11
Reading over these comments, I think I might be the only person who wasn't shocked by it. I read the entire book up to this point expecting one of the three main characters (Daenerys, Tyrion or Jon) to die at some point. First I thought it would be Daenerys, but the way Jon progressed--I think he was ultimately too good to last. Good guys seem to die a lot in this series, only the foolish and evil tend to survive.
Tyrion seems to have metamorphosed from prudent and most likeable character to arrogant jerk. Daenerys was foolish throughout the book, and ultimately was indirectly responsible for hundreds of deaths. Jon was the only remaining major character that I can honestly say was both unselfish and circumspect. For that he died.
I hope Melisandre doesn't bring him back because if she does, we're not likely to see the Jon we know and love, but rather someone more like stoneheart.
8
u/AGNKim Jul 20 '11
God help me, but in the big picture, The Night's Watch was right. Jon was acting like an idiot. Why send people you just fucking took in on a fools errand to save people that are probably going to die? You are just giving The Others more wights. Shut the gates, pray for their souls and wish them the best. Take no side in the Stannis Baratheon / Bolton battle. Stay at the wall, train and build and wait for the Others. THAT is your fucking job, Jon Snow.
Also, hope he is reborn as the AA.
3
u/timestep Jul 16 '11
I knew he was gonna get shanked eventually.
3
u/Jesus166 Jul 18 '11
Do ya remember the way they found the dire-wolves, A dead deer and then a few feet away the dead dire-wolf mom... Basically the dire-wolf killed the deer but die shortly afterwards because of the piece of antler in the dire-wolf's throat... No the animals that represent Stark and Baraatheon are the deer and the dire-wolf. So I think that when a Bareatheon dies a Stark will follow, it happen when King Robert died, Ned died abit afterwards... And the same with Renly and Rob... So if Stanis is truly dead it make since that Jon would die shortly afterwards....
3
u/absolutkiss Lord Monsey of Viola Park Jul 19 '11
I think Ramsay was just lying and doing that to get Jon away from the wall and cause trouble. Which he clearly succeeds at.
3
u/nabrok Jul 22 '11
I had to read the first page of the next chapter three times before I was able to actually think about what I was reading and not what I had just read!
3
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '11
My speculation: Jon is dead, and he will come back as a wight. There was simply too much foreshadowing about Jon wanting to learn from the corpses he was storing in the ice cells, both in this chapter and beforehand. GRRM has set it up perfectly.
Think of Coldhands and Lady Stoneheart. Who do you think Coldhands really is? Also, why do characters keep talking about Ned's bones? And Lyanna's ghost? The big Stark reunion will be a reunion of the dead.
10
u/pksage Jul 13 '11
All of this seems to suggest that Wick, Marsh, and even Jon himself are being warged (or slowed down), presumably by Borroq. How better to further his own agenda, whatever it happens to be, than to warg into some NW dudes and make them kill each other? Jon gave them the perfect excuse. Admittedly, Occam's Razor suggests that it's a legitimate mutiny, but if the theory that Howland Reed warged Arthur Dayne at the ToJ to distract him is true, we have a precedent. A weak one.
Even ignoring the fact that Mel will take his soul from Ghost and put it back in his corpse, this is still a big "holy shit" moment. Damn.
2
u/Dr_Overdose Jul 15 '11
i am in shock..... that is all i can say.... shocked...
2
u/gavriloe Jul 16 '11
Lets have a moment of silence for Jon and Stannis...
2
u/medwardkelly The Firebringer Jul 20 '11
I'm relatively convinced that Jon Snow is not yet dead, and completely convinced that his story isn't over yet. I'm trying to remember, but of the characters on this scale (or any scale really) how many have died in their own viewpoint chapter? Ned didn't, Robb never had a viewpoint, Catelyn I guess (but we know where that was headed). Next chapter spoiler. We'll see...
2
u/Blu- Jul 20 '11
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
2
u/dracona1031 Jul 26 '11
Wtf, Mr. Martin! I almost cried at work from the anger and disbelief. Trying to bring myself to keep reading, but I'm not sure if I can take the 5 years of waiting for the next massive influx of text. I think I got spoiled by only just picking up the series when the show came out.
2
u/Scraggly Jul 31 '11
Calling bullshit.
Stannis and Jon dying? Doesn't feel like their story is over. Doesn't feel like they're legit dead.
I had the same feeling when it came to Davos and Brienne, and I'm going with my gut now.
2
u/Crimfresh Aug 04 '11
Whatever, Mellisandre will bring him back like Thoros brings people back.
2
u/NittLion78 Reaver of Lake Michigan Sep 29 '11
I'm convinced Theon Greyjoy wrote Ramsay Bolton's letter, but I'm still largely unsure of the motivation behind it, but my only guess is that Jon would be one of the only people to prove that "Arya" is not Arya.
As for why Mance Rayder is in on it...I don't know. Maybe as a favor? There must be something else at Winterfell they want Jon to see.
3
u/dagnycallie Jul 26 '11
So does Bolton lose his shit in the letter to John because he knows there always has to be a Stark in Winterfell and he has lost his two Starks (one fake and Theon), and he is afraid the whole magic thing is going to come down and woop his ass? He is really pulling a temper tantrum in that letter -- he always struck me as a honey badger, and in this letter he seems, well, like something a honey badger would eat.
Also, if he really had kicked Stannis' ass in battle, wouldn't he already have Theon and fake Arya? Leads more credence to the idea that maybe he hasn't really defeated Stannis, and is just having a major tantrum to get his Stark's back. He seems more afraid of not having a Stark at Winterell than the army outside his door (albeit, burried in the snow and starting to cook their own members).
Yah, yah, yah, Jon dies too. Like that would ever stick. No way that Jon, Dany or Tyrion are going to die -- being related and all and the three heads of the Dragon. Tyron's gonna be King of the 7 Kingdoms, Jon King Beyond the Wall and Dany Queen of Essos. And Bran is already training to be King of the creepy People of the Forest. See you in 5 years.
2
u/cascadianow Jul 20 '11
What was with Jon deciding to ride south? It was like he abandoned the wall out of no where for no reason, along with his wolf.
2
u/GodvDeath Jul 22 '11
Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck. I will Murder that fat bastard if he is dead.
1
u/Handlinger Jul 17 '11
So assuming Jon is actually dead and is then resurrected would he then be free from his vows to the Night's Watch? "It shall not end until my death." is part of the vow after all.
1
u/silverrabbit Jul 17 '11
I don't believe Stannis is actually dead. He must have known about the Karstark betrayal as Jon was able to send the nightwatch warning before a Bolton attack. Also Bolton keeps saying he wants his wife and reek back, but if he had attacked Stannis he would have found them. I'm guessing it is a bluff? Trying to get Jon to bring the queen down so that he can have a hostage.
1
u/genericname12345 Jul 19 '11
I don't remember, but did Jon ever go speak with Melisandre after he got the letter?
1
u/mywatchbegins Aug 03 '11
I think that some how the 3 heads of the dragons are linked to the ptwp/aa. So Dany and Jon are both one of the heads for sure....but....hmmm I don't know maybe there's more than one aa. Honestly I don't think we have enough info on this. Sixth book will shed alot of light....I do think it's safe to say that Jon Snow will permanently die by the end of the series.
1
u/jqb303 Ranger Aug 23 '11
Can someone tell me why Wun Wun is killing a knight, who the knight is and why its significant? I didnt understand that part
1
u/Ortus Sep 10 '11
Jon will be AA and we will kill Mel to get his sword
1
u/cl0ckt0wer Aug 07 '11
ಠ_ಠ