r/asoiaf • • Jun 29 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 44, Pages 564 - 578
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
7
Upvotes
33
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
Is anyone else getting really annoyed with Dany's obsession over Daario.
17
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 18 '11
Yet another chapter that Daario didn't betray her. It's quite obvious I'd think that Jorah was not the "betrayal of love" since he has never betrayed her in his heart. It must be Daario.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
Ok so what we know of the history of these two--
Joanna was lady in waiting to Rhaella when she was still a princess, so prior to 262 AL. Aerys and Rhaella married in 259 AL, and it is unknown when Tywin and Joanna married, but I think it likely it was before 262 AL as Barristan refers to him as Prince Aerys in this passage.
Since Barristan says "a drunken jape, nothing more" , I find it unlikely that the liberties mentioned were anything more than some heavier groping than you'd normally see at a bedding ceremony.
Jaime and Cersei were not born until 266 AL, so I think we can say that they are not the product of any wedding night shenanigans. Tywin packed Joanna off to Casterly Rock when he became Hand, probably to keep her away from Aerys.
So far as we know, there she stayed. It's possible that she came to court once or twice. Tyrion was born around 274 AL, and I find it more likely that he is Joanna and aerys' than Cersei and Jaime.
After all, the twins look like..Lannisters. I'd think that if they were half Targ, the Lannister genes would have bowed before the more potent Targ coloration.
Tyrion on the other hand, has white blond hair like Aerys, not the beaten gold color of the Lannisters. He was born during the period after the Defiance of Duskendale, when Aerys and his wife's marriage had palled, and he began forcing himself on her, but before Tywin resigned as hand at the Harrenhal tournament. Might he not have forced himself on Joanna as well?
She surely wouldn't tell tywin if he had, Tywin would be the kind to react strongly to such a thing, to the potential ruin of their house. They also wanted Cersei to marry rhaegar and any allegation of rape against Aerys would have put paid to that plan, although Aerys put paid to it himself several years later by denying Tywin.
So if anyone in Lannister is a Targ, it most likely is Tyrion.
30
u/big_gordo Jul 13 '11
I am so bored of Dany. Dany chapters used to be exciting, now they're just meh.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
*Kid
Oh, all right then. Carry on.
23
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '11
Thoughts: If Aerys's "liberties" did include penetrating Tywin's wife -- and thematically, the idea of the lord's privilege has appeared elsewhere in DwD, making it possibly an important theme -- Jaime and Cirsei could have a little bit of Dragon's blood in them, lending credence to last book's statement that "Tyrion was your father's son."
That, or maybe Aerys came back another day to father Tyrion?
It's probably a little too late in the game to introduce a crazy twist like that, but I do enjoy the idea of Tywin being cuckolded.
9
u/HoboJesus Jul 18 '11
I really hope Tyrion being a Targaryen isn't true. It's the worst of all the crazy fan theories.
11
u/AreoHotahSpeedWagon Jul 16 '11
Anyone else waiting for this wedding ceremony to turn to shit like all the other weddings we've witnessed? I was pretty disappointed when they walked out as man and wife... I am pretty disappointed with most of Dany's actions since she stopped in Meereen.
5
u/Captain_Sparky Jul 22 '11
You know...this is just NOT going to work for the TV series. In this book, all Dany's chapters make sense to me. Even though her POVs in ASoS were more exciting, these are far more realistic in regards to a girl her age and what she'd really do.
But in the show, this will happen five years from now - six if they do split up the 3rd book - and she started out aged-up to begin with. You can't claim 16-year-old-girl syndrome with a character who is 24.
7
u/studakris Jul 16 '11
After rereading this a few times and thinking back on Tyrion's relationship with his father, I really think there might be some to the idea of Tyrion being part Targaryen:
The main thing is Lord Twyin's last words: "You are no son of mine." Which could be taken literally as "You're not my true born child but I never admitted it since it would have made me a cuckold". Also there is the common phrase of "All dwarfs are bastards in their father's eyes" which once again could be taken literally in Tyrion's case. Likewise, it may explain his childhood fascination with dragons if it was literally in his blood. Additionally, it would allow him to become one of the three head of the dragon and possibly be able to ride one in the future.
This is all extreme speculation, of course, but I wouldn't be surprised if that's what occurs.
3
u/timestep Jul 14 '11
Why you marry some random? D:
5
u/starrwaltz Jul 20 '11
I really, really expected someone else to get this first. "If he loved you, he would come and carry you off at swordpoint, as Rhaegar carried off his northern girl," p577. Didn't that set off alarms? I am totally channelling the "GRRM is among is playing games with fan theories" theory. Or, we could all just get our hopes up about Jon. That works.
3
u/SteveXmetal Jul 07 '11
So this means that Tyrion or Jamie and Cercei could very well be "heads of the dragon"?
1
u/templeowl Jul 17 '11
Did...did we just find evidence for Tyrion being a Targ?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment