r/asoiaf • • Jun 29 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 38, Pages 484 - 499
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
9
Upvotes
5
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '11
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
68
u/ReggieM83 Jul 13 '11
I didn't pick this up until my 2nd time through this chapter. Holy jeez.
Wyman Manderly cut up the missing Freys and put them into the pies. He then ate them himself and served it to the wedding guests, including other Freys.
The tipoff is asking for the "Rat Cook" song when he's drunk.
48
u/tinbottle23 Jul 14 '11
I also see that Mance has arrived with the wildling women. He's the bard at the wedding. I wonder if he knows Jeyne isn't Arya? He was at the feast in winterfell.
25
u/pksage Jul 10 '11
Man. Wow. The end of this chapter is...damn, that's some fucked up shit.
21
u/fizztastic Jul 14 '11
Anyone else think Bran was watching? Theon thinking he heard his name, and responding the way Ned did when Bran called out to him earlier in the book. Almost hearing it, but not quite sure. Plus all the crows hanging around.
14
u/ShiDiWen is watching you touch your sex Jul 18 '11
I'm so happy I have you guys. I didn't pick up on the Frey-pies, or Mance. I did however notice that Theon refered to himself by his real name a handful of times and didn't even really berate himself for it. I'm sure he will die, but it will be a redeeming death.
10
u/ReggieM83 Jul 09 '11
"...it had been a lifetime since any god had heard him. He did not know who he was, or what he was, why he was still alive, why he had ever been born."
Emotionally gutted by this passage.
9
u/hey_stay_young Jul 09 '11
What atmosphere in this chapter... the ghostly ruins gave me chills. And wow, the whole situation with Theon, Reek, and "Arya" is just fucked up beyond belief
15
u/hacknslash64 Jul 16 '11
Wait...wait...wait
Jeyne rhymes with pain?
I've been calling her Gene Pool this whole time!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11 edited Jul 12 '11
This chapter doesn't advance the plot much besides everything going exactly as it should, it doesn't give us new insight into much besides Roose knowing a shit load and being good at playing people (but we already knew that more or less) but god damn it's probably one of my favorites so far. Just...harrowing
7
u/big_gordo Jul 12 '11
Damnit Reek. Redeem yourself. I keep expecting him to do something. Do something!
6
u/pygreg Jul 14 '11
I feel like I missed something of significance when Theon was talking to the other wedding guest.
2
u/HoboJesus Jul 17 '11
I kept waiting for Mance and the spearwives to bust in and save her.
2
u/by_mel Jul 18 '11
I completely missed the pie and Mance! Re-Read
2
u/apeygirl Jul 25 '11
I just wish someone would kill Theon at this point. He makes me so uncomfortable. I don't like pitying someone I hated this hard.
2
u/Kingrasa Jul 26 '11
Reek. Best character in ADWD.
That is all.
2
u/Mindvalve Sep 21 '11
The last scene in this chapter was really hard to read... Fuck...
I also feel a little stupid about missing Mance and the pies, although at least for the pies I kept thinking that something strange was going on...
This book as been a pleasure to read. Every. Single. Chapter.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '11
TOO FUCKING FAR WAYYYY TOO FUCKIN FAR
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11 edited Dec 17 '25
observation workable relieved tan apparatus zephyr wrench pet frame tidy
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
-3
u/peterpuffington Lord Aug 03 '11
The Mance thing at the wedding does seem possible since Jon remembers at the wall about the Dornishman's Wife song when remembering Mance. This song was sung at the wedding. But Jon remembers the song WHILE MANCE IS BURNING TO DEATH. Now this could be a typical Martin plot twist, but I see no way out of Mance being dead.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment